Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 82

A Reminder Only Works on a Secret

"I'd like to make a proposal," said Dess, "and I'd like it noted that I've been awake for thirty hours and that Teddy has fed me a shortbread."

"Two," said Teddy.

"Two shortbreads."

It was nine in the morning on the seventeenth of January, in the Blue Room, and there were eight people in it. Dess counted them, because she always did. Ray, propped in the great carved bed in Gus's navy dressing gown, with his color a little better and his glasses on the end of his nose. Elias, in the window seat, in shirtsleeves, with a mug he had not drunk from. Teddy, cross-legged on the rug with a tin. Marcus in the armchair with his boots up, looking as though he had not slept since the funeral. Pip on the floor, laptop open, in her odd sneakers. Miss Whitcombe, in a wing chair brought up by Ambrose, with her clipboard and her tissues and her little bell. And Anders.

He lay on the chaise longue by the fire in a plaid blanket, thin and bearded and very pale, with a cup of broth on his chest and an expression of weak, determined, ironical interest. Dr. Rao had given him a week. He had been in the house for sixteen days, and had refused, politely and absolutely, to go home.

"Go on," said Ray.

"The Trust's whole lever is a reading." She stood at the foot of the bed with her hands behind her back, like a woman at a lectern. "That's what it's been since nineteen twenty-one. Thirty-one hammers, thirty-one Letters, and a man in a good suit saying, 'We do not threaten, we remind.' It works because of one thing. It works because the people on the Letters are afraid of it being said."

"That's what a secret is," said Marcus.

"That's all a secret is. It's a thing that's worth something only so long as no one's told it." She turned. "Mrs. Voss said it to me last night, in the library, with her coat on. A reminder only works on someone who's afraid. And you can't be afraid of a thing you've already said."

"No," said Ray, softly.

"So I'd like to take the thirty-one hammers away from the Trust." Her voice was steady. "Not by paying it. Not by burning anything. By asking every one of those people, one at a time, if they'd like to read their own Letter first. Aloud. In their own voice. To each other, in a room, on the thirty-first of January, before the Trust can read it in a ballroom on the first."

Nobody spoke.

"It would take away the only thing the Trust has," said Dess. "It wouldn't have a reminder. It would have a repeat."

"It's the most dangerous idea I've ever heard," said Elias.

He had not moved. He sat in the window seat with the mug between his hands and the pale winter light on his face, and he did not look at her. His voice was perfectly level. It was the voice she had heard in the Cabinet Room on the first night, saying, I didn't say it was kind. I said it was owed.

"It breaks the Registry."

"It breaks a Letter."

"They're the same thing. A Letter is a promise. The whole structure of the house, every drawer, every hammer, is built on the idea that what's written there is not read without consent. That a man can say, I did this terrible thing, and be forgiven for it, and be quiet." He looked up. "I've held that line for thirty-five years. My father held it for forty-six. My grandfather held it. If every one of those thirty-one people stands up in a room and reads a crime aloud, then what was it all for?"

"For the Trust," said Dess.

"What?"

"It was for the Trust. It was always for the Trust. The Registry was a house built to hold other people's secrets, and the person who owned the house was never a Draycott." She did not raise her voice. "I've been reading your family's book for nine weeks. And the more I read, the more I think the quiet wasn't mercy. It was a lease."

He was silent.

"I'm not asking you to read anything," said Dess. "I'm not asking the Table. I'm asking thirty-one people if they want to. If they say no, they say no. If they say yes, they're free of it. The Auctioneer hasn't called a hammer. He hasn't forced a thing. He's only opened a door."

"Article Eleven," said Miss Whitcombe.

Everyone turned. She had not looked up. She sat with her clipboard flat on her knee, and her glasses pushed up on her forehead, and was paging through a thick green volume that Dess had last seen in the Registrar's escritoire.

"I took the liberty of borrowing the Table's code. Ambrose was kind enough. I don't think the Registrar knows." She sniffed. "Article Eleven. 'A consignor may at any time disclose, in whole or part, the Letter upon his own lot, to such persons as he sees fit, and shall thereby be released from any obligation of silence to the Registry. The Auctioneer shall not hinder him.'" She looked over her spectacles. "It's four hundred words long. It has never been used. I believe it was written by a man who did not think anyone would be fool enough."

"My great-grandfather wrote that," said Elias, slowly.

"Silas, I think. In nineteen twenty-four."

"Why?"

"Because he was a very intelligent man," said Ray, from the bed, "who had been told on the fourteenth of March, nineteen twenty-one, that he was selling the one thing that nobody could sell. Silence. And he thought, privately, in a ship-chandler's office, that if he ever lost his nerve, there ought to be a door."

"You don't know that."

"I don't. I'm guessing." The old man's mouth twisted. "I'm guessing from a hundred and four years of the Whitlock family being told what an Auctioneer was thinking. It's a bad habit. It's been correct about half the time."

"Gus tried this," said Marcus.

They turned.

"In eighty-seven. I heard it from my mother." He took his boots off the table. "He'd been Auctioneer eight years. He called an open session of the Table, in this house, and he stood up with a Letter in his hand. His own. The one on the Registry's first lot after his father's death. He said, 'I'd like to read it to you.' And they voted him down. Seven to two."

"Why?" said Dess.

"Because they were afraid. Because the quiet was the thing they paid for." He smiled, crookedly. "And because my mother stood up and said that if he read it, she'd walk out, and take every key. And he put it back in the envelope."

"I never knew that," said Elias.

"I only know it because she told me last week. In the boathouse. With a thermos." Marcus rubbed his eyes. "She said it was the cowardliest thing she ever did, and she did it for the best of reasons, and that she had spent thirty-eight years finding out that those are the same thing."

A long silence fell. Outside the window a shovel scraped on a path, and somewhere in the garden Ambrose's voice, low and cross, said something about salt.

"I'd read it," said Anders.

They turned again.

He had pushed himself up on one elbow, with his hair on end and the broth spilling a little over his blanket. His blue eyes were very bright. "I mean, I haven't got one. I'm not a consignor. But I'd go. I'd stand at the back. I've spent my whole life in a family that thought the best use of a secret was to keep it in a drawer and wait for somebody to be afraid. I've watched my father do it to a hundred people. If somebody's going to show them what it looks like with the lights on, I'd like a seat."

"Your father will try to stop it," said Pip.

"My father will try to stop everything. It's his gift." Anders lay back. "He'll call every hammer he's got. He'll put a picket on the front steps and a cop on the back, and he'll tell every one of those thirty-one people that the first one to speak will be ruined. And he'll be wrong. I think. I'd like to find out."

"Elias," said Dess.

He did not answer at once. He sat in the window seat with his big pale hands round a cold mug, looking out at the garden, at the dead roses and the snow, and she saw him do what he always did when he was very afraid. He counted. His thumb moved against his fingers. One. Two. Three. She wanted to cross the room and take his hand. She did not.

"If I say yes," he said, "and it fails. If I say yes and a man is ruined, or a woman loses a post, or a watchman's widow reads a thing in a newspaper that she was never meant to know. It's mine. It's on me. I'd like that understood."

"It's on all of us."

"It's on the Auctioneer." His voice was quiet. "I took the gavel in November. I said I'd hold what the Registry held. I'm going to be the man who stood in this room and said, 'Let's open the drawers.' I don't know that I can do it."

"Then say it in the form of a question," said Ray.

"I beg your pardon?"

"Don't say, 'I order it.' Don't say, 'I command.' You'll never get thirty-one people to move on a command. Say, 'I've been told it's allowed. Would you like to?'" The thin face was gentle. "It's what Gus would have done. It's what he did with me. He never ordered me to do a thing in thirty years. He only ever asked if I minded."

Elias looked at him for a long moment.

"Ask them," he said.

"Elias?"

"Ask them. Not me. You. Dess, Marcus, the Whitlock family." He laid down the mug. "Go to every door. Tell them what it is, and what it isn't. Tell them they've got until the thirty-first, and not a minute more. Whitcombe will provide counsel. Pip will make a list. And I'll stand in whatever room you pick, with the gavel in my hand, and I'll be the Auctioneer who didn't call a hammer."

"That's all?"

"It's the only thing I've never done." He gave a small, odd, shaky smile. "I find, as it happens, that I'd like to see what it's like."

The room let out a breath. It was a small breath, and it had in it, Dess thought, the whole of a long, cold January. Teddy put down her tin. Marcus gave a slow, slightly unsteady whoop. Pip was already typing, with her tongue between her teeth and her glasses sliding, saying "Thirty-one, thirty-one, thirty-one," like a person reciting a spell.

The telephone rang.

It was the old black one on the bedside table, the house line, with its cord and its heavy handset. Nobody moved. Ingrid, from the door, said in her calm, low, lighthouse voice, "I'll get it," and Dess found, to her own surprise, that she had already crossed the carpet and lifted the receiver.

"Number Nine."

"Miss Whitlock." The voice was heavy, tired, careful, and it came from a long way off, through a crackle, as if from the bottom of a well. "I beg your pardon. I'd not meant to disturb the household. I find I don't know how to say this."

"Mr. Pratt."

"I heard, from a friend of a friend, that there was a meeting." A long pause. "I am in a motel. It is in Vermont. It has a very bad carpet, and I have been looking at it for twenty-three days. I have, in the interval, read the Lot 118 Letter. I had a copy. It was in a drawer in my office, and I took it with me, which I should not have done."

"Mr. Pratt, what—"

"I should like to be first," said Gideon Pratt. "If there is to be a first. I should like to be the one who stands up, and says it, and sits down. I think I should find it easier if it were me."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!