The Table had ninety-one minutes to finish a Sale that was meant to take a night, and Leopold Strand used the first six of them to remove her chair.
He did it beautifully. He rose at the foot of the long oak table in the noon light, with his big gloved hands folded on his cane and the careful, grieved expression of a man who dislikes to speak ill of a friend, and he said that the Table was in an unprecedented position. He said that he had every sympathy. He said that no one in the room, least of all himself, wished to say a word against Miss Whitlock's skill, which had been, he would be the first to admit, beyond reproach.
But Article Nine of the Registry's code required that the appraiser be neutral. And it was the Table's painful duty to ask whether a woman who had broken the Auctioneer's consent in front of thirty-eight witnesses, and who had been observed, in the same room, to tell him that she loved him, could be called neutral in any sense of the word that a court would recognize.
"I wasn't aware," said Dess, "that it was a court."
"Miss Whitlock, please."
"I'd just like it on the record that I don't take a retainer in kisses."
"Appraiser," said Marcus, from the sofa, in the voice of a man in pain. "Don't help."
"I move," said Strand, "that her certifications be sealed provisionally, for thirty days, and countersigned by an appraiser the Table accepts. If no such countersignature is given by the thirteenth of March, the lots lapse." He sat. "I do it with regret. I do it, if I may say so, for the Registry's sake."
"Second," said a thin voice from a telephone on the table.
It was Quill. He had been wheeled in front of a speakerphone in his house on Chandler Row, ninety-one years old and breathing from a green tank, and he said it with his usual old-fashioned courtesy, like a man seconding the minutes. Dess watched Elias hear it. Nothing moved in his face. He sat at the head of the table with the pale gavel beside his hand and the empty fireplace behind him, and when he spoke his voice was level.
"The Table will vote."
It was five to four. It was always five to four. Strand, Quill, Medina, Abara, Delacroix on the one side; Voss, Halvorsen, Okonkwo and Marcus on the other, with the old lady's cane rapping the floor like a woodpecker. Dess had counted it before the first hand went up. She had known which of them would raise it, and she watched them do it, and none of them would look at her.
"The motion carries," said Elias. "Thirty days. The Whitlock may attest, the Table will accept her marks provisionally, and someone else will have to say she was right." He lifted the gavel. "Miss Whitlock, if you please."
"Wait," said Mrs. Voss.
"Imogene."
"I wish it known that I think this is the sort of thing done by people who have lost their nerve." She did not look at Strand. She tapped the cane once. "I wish it known, Leopold, that your Letter is the fourth one, and you may sleep on that. Go on, child."
There was a very small silence. Then Dess opened the Registry Book, and Elias raised the gavel, and the knocking began.
It was not the Sale she had read about. In the old accounts, the ones in Ambrose's archive, the Sale had been a rite of three days and three nights, with a priest of the Registry reciting each lot and a clerk entering each knock in red ink, and the Table, in its wine-dark chairs, rising at each third stroke to murmur the old formula. They had not got three days. They had until Special Agent Cho walked through the front door, and Cho, who had said she would take her time, was at that moment, as Ambrose reported from the hall, standing in the portico in the cold, reading the Gavel Lane street signs with great attention.
So they did it fast.
"Lot 2," said Elias.
"Sound."
"One." The gavel fell. It was a small, hard, dry crack, and it went off in the room like a firecracker in a church. "Two. Three. Lot 3."
"Sound."
"One. Two. Three. Lot 4."
She did not look up. She had the Book open on the oak, with her pen in her left hand and her eyes on the lines, and the numbers went by her like fence posts from a train window. Sound, sound, sound. It was the most terrible and most beautiful thing she had ever done. Four hundred and twelve lots, each with its own small history, a child's tooth, a bishop's clock, a violin, a tuba, a girl's diary, a ring that had gone to a wedding in 1952 and never come back, and each of them was called by number and given its three knocks and sealed back in its drawer for another term of years, and for each of them, as it passed, she felt the tiny, specific shock of recognition, like a handshake. She knew them all. She had stood in front of every drawer. She had worn their dust.
"Lot 17," said Elias.
"Sound." Her voice caught, very faintly, on the vowel. "The Pruitt watch. Real. Certified."
"One. Two."
The third knock fell. Alison Pruitt, at the back of the room by the oak doors in her good navy suit, with her hands folded, did not move, and did not look away.
"Lot 33."
"Sound."
"Lot 54." Elias paused. "Sound?"
"Sound." Simon Lowe's knife lay in the drawer, a plain fisherman's folder with a bone handle, as true as the day it was made. She had tested it twice. "He was telling the truth about one thing."
Somewhere past a hundred a clerk of the Society of Boring Lawyers brought Elias a glass of water, and he drank it without looking and set it down without feeling for the table, which was the nearest thing to a lapse in coordination she had seen in him in a hundred days. Somewhere past two hundred the light changed in the long windows, and the green lamp seemed to burn brighter. Mrs. Voss had stopped tapping her cane. Captain Halvorsen had put his face in his hands. Behind her, Pip was sitting cross-legged on the floor against the wall with a clipboard, ticking each lot as it passed with a green pen, and not saying a word, which was how Dess knew the fear was real.
"Lot 88," said Elias.
"Sound."
Marcus did not look up. He sat in the corner of the sofa with his hands between his knees and his big shoulders folded forward, and she saw his lips move on the number, and heard, from somewhere on the other side of the oak, the small dry sound of a woman who had come in by the servants' door and did not want to be seen. Cordelia stood against the paneling, in gray silk, with her gloved hand on the frame of the open door. She was not a member of the Table. She was not the Registrar. She was a tall woman in a corridor watching her son's lot be knocked three times, and when the third knock fell she turned away and put the back of her wrist against her mouth.
"Lot 91," said Elias.
Dess drew a breath. "Lapsed."
She heard Cho's name in the silence. Not spoken. It was in the corridor outside, in the hush that had fallen there, like a hand laid on a table.
"The drawer holds a counterfeit," she said steadily. "The real tankard was removed before the Hundred began and cannot be produced. By the code of the Registry, a lot that cannot be produced at its first knock lapses. The debtor is free. The hammer is released." She turned the page. "Lot 91 was pledged in nineteen ninety-six by Joyce Okafor, who is dead. The debt is hers. It's over."
"One," said Elias.
The gavel fell.
"Two. Three."
When the third knock fell, someone in the doorway made a sound, and it was not a sob. It was smaller than that. It was the sound of a person who has been standing for a very long time and has been told, for the first time, that she may sit down.
They did forty-one of those. She never afterward remembered them separately. She remembered the sequence of rooms in her own head, like a house with the lights going out one by one, and each time the same little speech, The drawer holds a counterfeit, the debtor is free, and each time the same flat crack of the gavel, and each time, on the other side of the room, one or another of the families rising from their chairs with a hand over their faces.
Some of them wept. Some of them laughed out loud, in the high, cracked, appalled way of people let out of a long dark room. Whitcombe's lawyers moved among them with cardboard boxes and white gloves, wrapping each freed object in tissue, handing it into the hands of its owners, and sending them out through the kitchen door, past the pantry, into the garden, where, Dess knew, a line of cars stood waiting in the snow with their engines on.
"Eleven forty-one," said Pip, in a whisper, from the floor.
"I know."
"Cho's at the steps."
"I know."
"Lot 412," said Elias.
He had not raised his voice once. He stood now at the head of the table with the gavel in his hand and four hundred and eleven lots behind him, and the whole of the east wall rising to the cornice, with its tiers of plaques catching the noon light like the scales of some great sleeping fish. He did not look at Dess. He looked at the plain small drawer at the very bottom, with the brass tab that said LOT 412, and the padlock hanging open from its hasp.
"The drawer is empty," said Dess.
"Is it?"
"The box is in the Blue Room, with my father." It was nearly a whisper. "The cat has not been in the Cabinet Room since one o'clock this morning. I'd like that read into the record, with the hour."
"So noted," said Whitcombe, from the sofa, without looking up from the hymnal he was pretending to read.
"I cannot knock on an empty drawer," said Elias.
"Then reserve it."
"For whom?"
"For the Keeper." She said it to the room. She said it to the east wall, and the neat round hole in the oak by the fireplace where a lens had been, and the chair behind it that nobody sat in. "Lot 412 is reserved for the Keeper of the Cat. It can't be knocked without her. It can't be opened without her. It's the one lot in this house that nobody but she can bring to the table, and I'd like her to know we've kept her place."
For a moment she thought no one would answer. Then Elias lowered the gavel, very gently, and let it rest.
"Reserved," he said. "Without a knock."
The oak doors opened.
It was not an agent. It was Ambrose, in his black coat and white cuffs, with a face as expressionless as a cup, and behind him, a pace at his shoulder, Cho. She was alone. She wore her gray overcoat buttoned to the throat, with the snow still melting on its shoulders, and in her left hand she carried a thin folded paper, and in her right a small, flat, black, very ordinary pistol, held down along her thigh, pointing at the carpet.
"Agent Cho," said Elias.
"Mr. Draycott. I'm here to execute a warrant." Her voice was perfectly steady. "I'd like to inform the Table that a stay of that warrant was granted at eleven fifty-one by a federal magistrate of the District of Massachusetts, on the emergency motion of Mr. Whitcombe, pending a hearing. I was not served with it until about a minute ago. I'm afraid it takes some time to walk up a driveway."
"Eleven fifty-one," said Whitcombe.
"I have the paper." She held it up. "The Bureau will inventory. We will photograph. We will tape the doors. Nothing leaves this room." She looked around it, at the old people in their chairs and the clerks with their boxes and the long oak table with the forty-one empty gaps in the wall, and her eyes were very bright. "I understand that a number of items have been lawfully returned to their owners in the last two hours. I haven't seen them go. I am not wearing my glasses."
"You don't wear glasses," said Pip.
"I haven't for years," said Cho.
She came to the table. She stopped in front of the drawer that said LOT 91, which was empty and open, and stood for a while with her gun hand at her side, looking down at it. Then she put the pistol away. She did it quickly. Dess saw her hand shake.
"Thank you," said Cho, to no one in particular. It was almost inaudible.
"For what?" said Elias.
"For saying the number out loud."
It was twelve minutes past twelve. It was done. The Sale was over, and the Table of Ten rose from its chairs in the heavy silence like a jury that has delivered a verdict nobody wanted, and Dess closed the Registry Book on its black ribbon and put both her hands flat on the cover and could not feel them.
"Miss Whitlock."
Thorne stood at her elbow. She had forgotten he was in the house. He wore yesterday's navy suit and a day's growth of beard, and he looked as a man looks who has been fed a good breakfast against his will. He held in his hand a small cream-colored envelope with a seated cat embossed in the corner.
"It came at eleven," he said. "I wasn't to give it to you until the Sale was finished. It was left in the runner slot of the back door, by someone who did not ring." He swallowed. "I did not open it. I thought you ought to know that it was addressed in her hand, and that it wasn't the Trust's hand, and that I have never in sixteen years been so afraid of a piece of stationery."
She took it. It was thin. It held a single card, in the copperplate, in brown ink.
I am sorry for the warrant. It was not mine. Please do not tell the grand jury about the tail of the cat. I only know of it because someone in that room at nine o'clock told me. N.

