At 4:20 on Tuesday morning I bang on the bunk room door with a milk pail, and the man who answers is already dressed.
That is a problem. Hired men who are already dressed at 4:20 are hired men who plan to stay. The room behind him is the old hired man’s room above the milk house, one window, one cot, one space heater that smells like a wet sheepdog, and he has made the cot with corners. He is holding a small notebook and a pen.
“Day two, four-eleven a.m.,” he reads. “Goat, one. Me, nothing.”
“What’s that?”
“A record. I like to know how I’m doing.”
“You’re doing terribly. Boots.”
The parlor has six stalls, two strings of three, and thirty-one does currently in milk, with the rest of the herd waddling around the kidding barn like furry tents. I show him how to wipe, strip and clip. I show him it once, because I only have the patience for once.
Gladys, a Saanen with the temperament of a retired judge, steps into the bucket. A doe named Fig sits down on his foot. Senator Bernard stands in the doorway, where he is not allowed, offering commentary.
“They are not cooperating,” Anders says.
“They’re cooperating. You’re just not the one they’re cooperating with.”
By the second string, he stops asking permission for his questions and starts asking them like a man looking for the bolt in a machine. How many pulsations a minute. What the vacuum should read. Whether the pipeline runs level or on a pitch. I answer the first two out of habit and the third out of spite, and then he squats by the regulator with a butter knife borrowed from my kitchen.
“Can I ask a question? How long has your gauge read nine?”
I look at it. It should read twelve. It has said nine since the middle of January, and I have been blaming the pump, and the pump’s age, and the world.
“Since January,” I say.
He turns something under the cover. The needle climbs to twelve and settles, and every doe in the string lets out a long, satisfied bleat, as if someone had finally taken their hat off.
“The lock nut was backed off,” he says. “Not worn. Backed off. Somebody turned it.”
“Goats can’t turn a nut.”
“No.” He looks at the butter knife. “They really can’t.”
I would like the record to show that I added this to my list of reasons to dislike him. He is useful. Nothing is more annoying than a useful enemy.
At nine I put him behind the shop counter, which is a mean thing to do, and I know it. The shop is a former milk stall with a plank floor and a refrigerated case, and the whole of Larkin Notch files through it that morning to buy a quarter pound of Morning Chevre they do not need.
Mrs. Larrabee from the church asks if it’s true he’s building a robot barn. Two of the Hatch boys ask for a photo. A woman I’ve known my whole life asks whether the cheese is “as good as what he’s used to.”
“I don’t know yet,” he says seriously. “I’ve only tasted the one. But it’s the first thing I’ve eaten here that didn’t apologize for itself.”
They laugh. He sells two hundred and fourteen dollars of cheese before lunch, which is more than a good Tuesday, and I stand in the doorway of my own shop, outsold by the enemy.
The feed truck comes at ten. It always comes at ten, Tuesdays and Fridays, because Dewey Marchand has been delivering to Bell Hollow since before I could drive, and Dewey is the kind of man you can set a pot of coffee by. Fifty-eight, shoulders like a sofa, a bad left knee he blames on a Selectboard meeting in 2011.
He’s owned Marchand Feed & Hardware since his father’s stroke. He chairs the Selectboard because, as he says, it’s a job you get by being the only one who doesn’t leave the room.
“Morning, kiddo.” He swings down and gives me the hug he gives everybody. He smells like cold diesel and peppermints. “And this must be the fella.”
“Mr. Marchand.” Anders shakes his hand. “Can I ask a question? Is it always Tuesdays?”
“Tuesdays and Fridays since 1998. Ask the goats.” Dewey laughs, then drops his voice with a wink. “Word of advice. Don’t let him fix anything. They always bill you.”
“Anything breaks,” he tells me quieter, nodding at the barn, “you call me, hear? I’ll make a call.”
Dewey is a man who has made a call about everything I’ve ever needed. He stacks feed for half an hour, whistling through his teeth, the same four notes he whistles every Tuesday, the opening of the closing hymn, flat on the third. A green twist tie holds each bag shut, the way it has since the nineties.
Then he lets himself into the milk house to leave the udder sanitizer, and he doesn’t ask where the spare key is, because he has been fishing it out of the ceramic goat on the shop windowsill since I had braces.
At two, Pearl does something strange. She takes the key out of the ceramic goat, walks across the yard in her slippers, and drops it into the hollow of the old iron cheese-press weight in the make room, which nobody has used since before I was born. Then she goes back inside and starts crocheting a hat for a goat.
“Grandma, what was that?”
“What was what?”
“The key.”
“Dust,” says Pearl. “I was dusting.” She has never dusted anything in her life.
At three I find Anders in the make room, holding his phone over the clipboard where I keep the aging log. He photographs one page, flips it, photographs the next. He has done eleven by the time I clear my throat.
“Can I ask a question? Do you always keep records this well?”
“My father’s rule. If it isn’t written down, it didn’t happen.”
“Mine too,” he says, and lowers the phone. “That’s not what I wanted to have in common with you either.”
By Wednesday night, Anders has survived three days of manure, six milkings, and one doe who stood on his shoulder. He sits on the porch step with a bandaged blister and a plate of Pearl’s meatloaf, because the Ordinance lets the owner assign the food. I assigned him the leftover end piece. Pearl gave him a second slice anyway.
“Can I ask a question?” he says. “How many things have gone wrong at this farm since Christmas?”
I should say none. A good liar says none. But I’m tired, and the porch light is turning his tired face into something almost kind, and somewhere in the last forty-eight hours I stopped being able to lie to him.
“Eleven,” I say, because I’ve counted. “The gate latch, four times, counting Monday. The feed room lid, once. Two goats bloated, three hundred forty dollars from the vet. The shop freezer unplugged, once, three days before I noticed. The fence wire cut, twice. The truck battery, once, which I blamed on a dome light. A sap line, once, which I blamed on a squirrel with ambition. And yesterday morning’s regulator.”
He writes the number down. He underlines it twice.
“Josie, none of these are accidents. I don’t think you think so, either.”
“Here is what I think. I think the man whose company has been offering to buy me out since October is sitting on my porch step asking about my bad luck.” I take his plate before he can finish it. “You’re my chief suspect.”
“Fair,” he says, and he sounds almost pleased, like a man who’s been handed a job description. “Then can I ask the obvious question, so you can watch me ask it? Who else knows where you keep the spare key?”
“Everyone. It lives in a ceramic goat on the shop windowsill.” I stop. “Lived. Pearl moved it into the old cheese-press weight yesterday. Didn’t say why.”
Anders puts down his pen.
“Josie,” he says, very quietly, “your grandmother has kept that key in that goat for fifty years. She moved it the afternoon after I arrived.” He looks toward the lit kitchen window, where a small gray head bends over a crochet hook. “What does she know that you don’t?”

