The bulk-tank alarm sounds like a smoke detector having a nervous breakdown, and it goes off at 2:07 on Thursday morning, directly beneath Anders Lund’s cot.
By the time I cross the yard in my socks and my father’s barn coat, he is already standing in the milk house in a camel overcoat and pajama pants, notebook in hand. The tank display says forty-six degrees and climbing. The compressor is silent. The milk house has hummed since 1989, and the quiet in it is like a missing tooth.
“Can I ask a question? What happens at forty-five?”
“Over forty-five, milk stops being cheese and starts being regret.” I open the tank lid, and the cold off the milk is already weaker than it should be. “Sixty gallons. Two days of work, Saturday’s market, and the wholesale order for the shop in the ski town.”
“What’s the plan?”
“Moses Tillotson keeps a spare tank. Three miles down Notch Road.” I call him from the milk-house landline. It rings eleven times. “He sleeps with his hearing aid in a glass of water, I swear to you. We’re driving.”
We fill twelve five-gallon cans from the spigot. I hand them down, Anders carries them out, and each time he hugs the can to his chest like a man carrying a sleeping child, because the camel coat can’t be saved and he seems to understand this. When we heave the last one into the bed of the truck, I realize we have a passenger.
Senator Bernard is standing in the cab, front hooves on the dash, ears hanging to his chin.
“Get out,” I tell him.
He looks at me with the face of a man who has always been invited to the emergency.
“He’s fine,” Anders says. “Can I ask a question? Is it normal that I’m beginning to find that persuasive?”
My truck is a red three-quarter-ton with a passenger door that opens only from the outside, so I have to let the billionaire out of it later like a dog. For now he folds himself into the seat with a goat at his shoulder and a notebook on his knee, and I take Notch Road at a speed that would give Connie Duquette hives.
Mud season in Vermont is a simple trick. The top of the road thaws and the bottom stays frozen, so you’re driving on peanut butter spread over concrete. Moonlight turns the ruts into silver rails. The truck wants to go sideways at every corner, and I steer into it, the way my father taught me, and Anders braces his hand on the dash and says nothing, which I count as the second-most impressive thing he’s done all week.
“Is it always like this?” he asks.
“March. April is worse. May is black flies.”
“Why do you stay?”
“Where would I go? The goats are here.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“It’s the only one I have at two in the morning.” Bernard sighs, long and warm, into the cab. “Why do you want my land?”
“Can I answer that on Day thirty?”
“No.”
“Then I’ll answer it when I know.” He says it so plainly that I look over, and in the dash light he looks like he hasn’t slept in a year. “I used to think nobody still did this. Got up in the dark for something that can’t thank you.”
“Goats thank you. They do it by not killing you.”
The truck chooses that moment to sink to the axles at the culvert.
Here is what I learn about the man in the next four minutes. I let him out. He puts his shoulder against the tailgate with twelve cans of milk and a goat in the truck. He slips, goes down on both knees, and does not let go. When the wheels finally catch and the truck lurches free, he is the color of the road, and the coat that cost more than my transmission is now a very expensive rag.
“It was a three-thousand-dollar coat,” he says, climbing in.
“Mud’s good for leather.”
“It was wool.”
“Mud’s good for everybody.”
He laughs, a short, startled, rusty sound, as if it had been stored in a basement. I decide I did not hear it.
Moses’s barn is lit from end to end when we turn in. He is standing in the doorway in long underwear and his feed cap, with a flashlight and no hearing aid, and I roll down the window and shout, “TANK!” and he jerks a thumb over his shoulder.
The spare tank is already clean and cold. Its light is on. Its lid is open like a mouth.
“How did you know?” I yell.
Moses reaches up with great ceremony and switches his ear on. Click. “Pearl called Tuesday,” he says in a normal voice. “Said keep the spare cold. Said you might need it any night.”
“Pearl said what?”
Click. Ear off. “Eh?”
We pour all twelve cans through his strainer with the cows watching, and I do the thing I always do instead of saying thank you, which is to put a wheel of Ember in Moses’s hands. It’s twenty-two dollars at wholesale. Section nine says nothing about wholesale. Moses weighs it like a baby, and nods at the sky.
We drive home as the black behind the ridge goes the color of dishwater. Bernard has gone to sleep with his chin on Anders’s knee. Anders does not move that leg for three miles, though I can see him wincing.
At 5:15 I get on my knees in front of the compressor with a flashlight and take the cover off.
It is not worn. It isn’t frayed. The wire to the capacitor has been cut through with a clean, bright face, and the main breaker has been flipped down with the little red tag snapped over it, so that even if I had fixed the wire, the milk house would have sat there humming nothing at me until noon.
On the concrete next to the unit lies a green twist tie, the kind every feed bag in the county wears like a collar. I put it in my pocket, because Pearl did not raise a girl who leaves trash on a milk house floor.
Then I stand up, and I want a word with my chief suspect.
He said he would check on the does. The does are fine. Anders is not in the barn, or the parlor, or the bunk room, where the cot has been made again with corners.
I find him at last in the north pasture, a small dark figure at the top of the field, standing on the boulder we call the Bar. He has the phone to his ear. The sky behind him has gone pink, and I hear every sucking step of my own boots as I climb the slope, so I come in along the stone wall and stop thirty feet away where the wind carries his voice down to me.
“Nolan,” he says. “No. Don’t explain, answer. Tell me you didn’t.”
Nolan Pierce. The name at the bottom of all five offers.
“I said nobody touches that farm. I said it in writing.” A long pause. He rubs his face with a muddy hand and leaves a stripe. “Then whoever you have in town, call them off. If one more thing happens at Bell Hollow, I will know it was you.”
He lowers the phone. He stands there with his shoulders down, like a man carrying a can too heavy for him, and he does not turn around.
I slide back down the wall before he can see me. The twist tie is a hard little knot in my pocket. The cut wire is a bright line in my head, and what I keep seeing is the way he said it, like someone who had already been afraid of the answer.
Either Anders Lund is the best liar I have ever met, or he’s afraid of his own company. I can’t tell which would be worse for my farm.

