My father’s door is warm, and nobody in my kitchen will let me open it before coffee.
“It has been shut for eight years,” says my grandmother, in her bathrobe and her barn boots, with her thermos held in front of her like a lantern. “It can survive twenty minutes more.”
“Pearl.”
“I’m eighty-four, Josephine. If I’m going to see what my son left behind a wall, I would like to be properly caffeinated for it.”
It is ten past five on Sunday morning. The yard is gray and wet. Behind her on the cave steps, Bernard stands with his ears at half-mast, looking like a bishop who has been woken for a fire. I didn’t go to bed. Neither did Anders.
We sat on the top step of the cave from half past midnight until the sky went the color of dishwater, with the door down below us shut and the tin of pennies between our feet, and neither of us said what we were both thinking, which was that if we went to sleep the ticking might stop.
It hadn’t. I went down at three, and at four, and at a quarter to five. Tick. Tick. Tick. I stood in front of the oak rack we’d rolled aside and put my palm flat on the wax, and it was still warm, and I came back up and told Anders I was fine.
“You’re not fine,” he said.
“I’m fine like a bulk tank is fine. Cold on the outside.”
He’d nodded and not argued, which is the thing about him that I still haven’t made peace with.
Now Pearl pours coffee into the thermos lid and hands it to me, and I drink it standing up, scalding, and it is the worst coffee in Vermont and I would trade my left kidney for another cup.
“I called Connie,” Pearl says.
“It’s five in the morning.”
“She’s been up since four. She says it’s how you can tell a retired librarian from a fresh one.” Pearl looks at the cave door. “It’s the town’s door, Josephine. Your father put it in writing. When the town asks, you open it. I would like a representative of the town present, with her stamp. If I’m going to be a sentimental old woman about it, I intend to be a documented one.”
“Section fourteen,” says Anders, softly.
“Section fourteen,” says Pearl. “Thank you, dear. You are learning.”
Connie Duquette’s Buick comes down the lane at five fourteen with its parking lights on. She gets out in a raincoat over a nightgown with a pattern of small blue teapots, carrying her fountain pen, her minutes book, and a rubber stamp in a sandwich bag. She does not say good morning. She says, “Show me the wax.”
We all go down.
The cave at dawn is the same as the cave at any hour. A bulb, a humidifier muttering, four hundred and some wheels on their racks, the cold coming up through my boots. It smells like limestone and rain. It has smelled like that since before I was born, and I still can’t say for sure whether it was my father’s doing or the hill’s.
We have left Anders’s oak rack rolled back against the side wall. Behind it, under the little bulb, is the low arch of pale stone, and the hemlock door, and the ring wired shut, and my father’s square capitals across the planks.
JO. NOT UNTIL THE TOWN ASKS.
Connie reads it with her glasses pushed up on her forehead. Then she takes them down and reads it again, and then she opens her minutes book on top of a cheese-brine tub and uncaps the pen.
“For the record,” she says, “it is five-nineteen a.m., Sunday, the twenty-eighth of June. Present, Constance Duquette, notary and, as of last evening, clerk pro tem to the Larkin Notch Water District, because Opal says she won’t be conscripted before noon.” She writes it down. “Pearl Bell, co-owner of the parcel. Josephine Bell, co-owner and daughter of the author of the inscription. Anders Lund, a, a person.”
“Hired man,” says Anders.
“Hired man. Mr. Lund, was the door sealed in your presence by you or any person known to you?”
“No, ma’am.”
“Was it sealed by Ray Bell?”
“I believe so.”
“You don’t believe it,” Pearl says. “I know it. That wax is from the stick he kept in the shop for the cheese-box flaps. I could pick the smell out of a church.”
Connie writes, Wax identified by P. Bell, and underlines it. Then she looks up, over her pen, at me.
“The inscription says not until the town asks,” she says. “Yesterday, in open meeting, four hundred and eleven residents voted to form a water district, to accept this parcel, and to ask the question that your grandfather’s tape put to them. Did the town ask?”
“It asked,” I say. My voice cracks on the second word, and I let it. “I think it asked.”
“I’m not asking what you think. I am asking whether you, Josephine Bell, as the person named, accept that it was asked.”
I think about it for a long moment. I think about Mrs. Larrabee’s hundred pennies going hand to hand. I think about Gil Hatch, standing at the back of the barn, saying My tap was green and nothing else.
“Yes,” I say. “Yes, I accept it.”
“Then I have the ring,” says Connie, “and you have the wrench.”
I have the wrench. I’ve had it all night. It’s my father’s eleven-sixteenths, the one with the taped handle. I take a step toward the door, and my knees do a thing I don’t approve of.
“I can do it,” says Anders, so quietly that Connie has to lean in.
“No,” I say.
“I know. I’m just saying I can.”
“I’m the one he left it to.” I wipe my palms on my jeans. “Stand here.”
He stands there. Not behind me, not in front. Beside me, a little to the left, where he stood on the night the compressor died. I remember that because I’d once rated him on the goat scale and he went from one and a half to three on a night of rotten milk, and now I don’t have the numbers anymore, he’s just the place beside me where a person fits.
The wire on the ring is a twist of baling wire, doubled, with the ends tucked. I snip it with my father’s pliers from my back pocket. It comes away in two pieces, bright as a new dime inside where the rust hasn’t reached, and a long, gray, narrow breath of air comes out of the seam around the planks.
It’s warm. It smells of wet iron and hot stone and something like the inside of a kettle that’s been on a low flame.
“Oh,” says Pearl, and sits down, gently, on a brine tub.
The wax is the last thing. I run the blade of my father’s jackknife down the seam, the way you’d slice a cheese, and it goes through like warm butter, curling off in a thick brown ribbon, and the door sighs. It doesn’t creak. Somebody has been oiling these hinges, and then I remember there’s nobody who could have been, and the hair rises up my arms.
“Bernard,” says Pearl sharply. “Out of the way.”
But Bernard has already gone through the gap.
I follow him, because there is nothing else in the world I could do.
It isn’t a big room. About twelve feet by twelve, with a floor of flat stone and a ceiling of the same dry-laid arch, so low that Anders ducks. The walls are dripping. The air is thick and warm, like the room above a bakery, and there’s a haze at head height where it meets the cold from the cave. There’s a lamp on a nail, an old kerosene hurricane lamp with a blackened chimney, and it’s lit.
It’s lit.
“Josie,” says Anders.
“I see it.”
“It’s not—”
“It’s a battery lantern,” I say, because I can’t afford the other kind of thought. It’s a little yellow work light, the kind from Marchand’s, with a clamp on the back, and it has been turned on to its lowest setting.
The glow it makes is the size of a dinner plate. I think of eight years of batteries. Then I see the cord, thin and gray, running from the clamp across the ceiling to a small brass dynamo bolted to the wall, with a belt that goes down into the floor.
Down into the floor, into the water.
The water is the middle of the room.
There’s a trough cut in the stone, two feet wide and as long as a coffin, and the spring runs along it, clear and quick and cold as anything on earth, and I know it for what it is the second I see it, because I’ve knelt at the other end of it every Sunday of my life. It’s Bell Spring.
It’s the same water. It comes in through a square hole in the north wall, runs along the trough under a flat wooden paddle wheel no wider than a bicycle wheel, turns it with a small steady clack, and leaves through a second hole in the south wall, and out, and under the hill, and down, to thirty-one kitchens.
On the wall above the paddle wheel there’s a brass box, the size of a loaf of bread, with a glass face. The face has six white dials in a row, like the odometer in a very old truck. The needles are moving. Not fast. One click at a time.
Tick.
“It’s a meter,” I say. “It’s counting.”
“It’s a totalizer,” says Anders. He’s standing right at my shoulder with his head bent under the arch and his hand not quite touching the glass. “A flow register. Paddle wheel drives a gear train, gear train drives the dials. The little dynamo off the same wheel keeps the lamp lit. Josie, nobody wound this. It runs on the water. It’s been running on the water the whole time.”
“Counting what?”
He leans in. In the thin light I watch his lips move as he reads from right to left. Then he reads it again, and I see the exact moment he understands, because his face does the thing it does when he’s seeing a number he won’t be able to unlearn.
“Gallons,” he says. “It’s counting every gallon that’s come out of the spring since the day it was set. Josie, the first dial is units of a thousand. The last is, I think, millions.” He swallows. “It’s on a hundred and eighty-six million, four hundred and twelve thousand.”
“I don’t know what that means.”
“Neither do I,” says Anders. “Not yet. But your father did.”
There’s a shelf on the east wall, a plank on two iron brackets. On it, in a row, leaning together like old men outside a hardware store, are a lot of black hardbound ledgers. The kind you buy at the stationer’s, with red corners and a cloth spine. They’re numbered on the spines in white paint, and the paint is Ray’s, I know that hand: 1 through 11.
I take the nearest down. It’s number 11. It’s heavy and a little damp, and when I open it, a smell comes up out of the pages that stops me where I stand. Pencil lead and wet stone and cheap cigars, the ones he swore he’d quit, the ones I used to find his wrapper from in the truck. It’s my father’s smell. I haven’t smelled it in eight years.
The page is ruled in his hand, columns drawn with a carpenter’s straightedge. Date. Time. Dial reading. Water temp. Air temp. Remarks. Down the page, one row after another, in his small square capitals, in pencil.
Jan 3. 6:15 AM. 162,990,330. 42 F. 51 F. Bitter cold. Spring is steady. Goats cranky.
Jan 4. 6:10 AM. 162,997,512. 42 F. 49 F. Steady.
Jan 5. Snow. Steady. Lost the dog’s ball in the flume. Got it back.
I laugh. It comes out wet and ugly and I put my hand over my mouth. Behind me I can hear Pearl on her brine tub saying, “Oh, Raymond,” in a voice I have never heard from her, a small voice, a girl’s.
“Eleven years,” Anders says. “He went down every morning.”
“Six-fifteen,” I say. “He was in the parlor at six-thirty. I always thought he was in the make room, doing the aging log, I thought—”
“He was here.”
“He was here every day for eleven years, and he didn’t say a word.” I shut the ledger on my thumb. “He told me the cave was a hole in a hill. He told me a hole was just a hole. He let me think—”
“Josie.” Anders has his hand on my elbow. “Look at the nail.”
I look.
There’s a second nail, above the shelf. On it hangs a plain white envelope, soft with damp and gone a bit yellow at the corners. Written across the front in the same grease pencil as the door:
JO.
The room has gone very quiet except for the paddle wheel. Clack, clack, clack.
I take the envelope down. It isn’t sealed. The flap is just tucked in, the way you’d tuck a thing you meant to come back to. There’s one sheet inside, a page torn from the back of a ledger, folded in thirds.
“Read it,” says Pearl, from the doorway. She has stood up. She’s holding on to Connie’s arm with both hands, and her face is wet and perfectly steady. “Out loud. I’d like to hear it in your voice, not his. His I’ve got.”
So I read it.
“Jo,” I read. “If you’re reading this the town asked, which means somebody got up in a meeting and said it out loud, and I’m proud of whoever it was. I hope it was you. I hope you stood up. I know you won’t have wanted to.
“This is the Kettle. That’s what your grandfather called it, because the wall’s warm and he said that’s the only warm thing in the hill. I’ve never found out why. I’ve been down here eleven years trying, and all I know is the water in this room comes up forty-two degrees, and the wall behind that north hole is fifty-eight, and it’s been fifty-eight since the day Walt put the first stone in, in all weathers. I’m a dairy man. I’m not a geologist. Don’t you go looking for a geologist till you’ve asked the town.
“The spring isn’t ours. Your grandfather gave it away and he didn’t tell your grandmother because he knew she’d say no, and she’d have been right to, and he’d have done it anyway. The deed’s his business. The water is the whole valley’s business. I counted it for him after he died. Somebody should. A thing nobody counts is a thing somebody takes.
“Don’t open this for yourself. That’s why the sign. I know you. You’d have come down here the day after the funeral, to find out what I was hiding, and you’d have been angry at me, and you’d have missed the point, which is that it was never mine to hide, and it isn’t yours to keep. It’s everybody’s. It’s a thing you hold.
“I wish I’d told you to your face. I’m not good at it. You know that. I’m going to say it here, where nobody’s listening, in pencil: you’re the best thing I ever made, and I never said so, and I let you leave in tears when you were eighteen because I thought a man was supposed to stay quiet and let a kid find out for herself. I was wrong about that. I’m wrong about a lot. The cheese is right.
“Don’t leave the cave door open. I meant this one.”
“Dad.”
I get to the last word and stop, because I’ve run out of voice.
Nobody says anything. Connie’s pen has stopped moving. Anders is standing a foot behind me, not touching, with his hands open at his sides, and I realize I’m crying so hard I can’t see the paper, and that my grandmother has come across the room, in her barn boots, with her thermos still in her hand, and has put her free arm around me.
“Well,” says Pearl. She says it into my hair. “He did say it was wrong of him. I’d have liked it in the other order. But there you are.”
I lean on her. I have never in my life leaned on her. She is the size of a coat rack, and she holds my entire weight like a barn wall.
“He wrote it in pencil,” I say. “In case it got wet.”
“Yes, dear. Pencil lasts.”
We stay that way for a while. I don’t know how long. The paddle wheel turns. Bernard, who has gone to inspect the north hole, comes back and stands against my leg and sighs, long and loud, and lies down on the wet stone with his chin on my boot.
“Josie.”
It’s Anders. He is crouched at the shelf with ledger number 1 in his hands, and he’s very still.
“Can I ask a question?”
“Yes.”
“When did your grandfather die?”
“I was twelve.” I wipe my face on my sleeve. “Nineteen years ago this winter.”
“And your father died eight years ago.” He turns the ledger so I can see the first page. The first entry is dated the January after Walt’s funeral. “That’s eleven years of ledgers, one a year, one through eleven. He started the winter he lost his father. He kept going until the day he died.”
I open ledger number 11 again, to the last page with any writing on it.
I know the date before I read it. It’s the one I’ve never been able to write on a form without my hand shaking. Below a column of ordinary mornings, in my father’s small square capitals, is the last entry he ever made, and it says:
Oct 11. 3:10 AM. Down 4 inches since supper. Not drought, brook is full. Somebody is drawing on the hill. Can’t tell Pearl till I know. Call the geology man at 8. Ask Jo home for Thanksgiving.
Pearl called me at nine that morning. I got home at midnight. He’d been gone since six.
He was down here at three a.m. on the last night of his life, frightened, and writing down my name.
The tick behind me goes on, and on, and on.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!