I used to think grief was a room you went into and, eventually, came out of. Nobody warned me it could also be a room you find behind another room, with the lamp still on.
We carry the ledgers up into the daylight in two trips, Anders and I, wrapped in feed sacks because the damp is already getting into the covers. Connie writes each number into her minutes book as it goes by, one through eleven, and stamps the inside of the sack with her rubber stamp, which says RECEIVED, LARKIN NOTCH, and is meant for library fines.
The sun is up. It’s a perfectly ordinary Sunday. The goats are yelling about breakfast. Somewhere down the lane the Larrabee church bell starts, thin and sweet and a quarter-tone flat, and I stand on the cave steps with my father’s last entry in my head and feel the whole morning go on without me.
“Sit,” says Pearl.
“I’m fine.”
“You’re a woman who’s about to fall down a staircase. Sit.”
I sit. She sits next to me, which takes a while, and sets her thermos between her feet, and for a long minute neither of us says anything. Bernard lies across the step below us like a speed bump with opinions.
“He stopped sleeping that fall,” Pearl says.
I turn my head.
“I’d wake up at three and the bed would be cold. I thought it was the farm. The milk price had gone to the dogs again, and the bank had written, and I thought, well, he’s out walking it off.” She looks at her hands. “I never looked for him. I thought a man should be allowed one thing he doesn’t explain to his mother.”
“Pearl.”
“I’m not asking you to say it wasn’t my fault, dear. I’m saying it so it’s said. Eight years I’ve told myself he died of his heart, and he did. But he was awake the whole night before and frightened, and I was asleep forty feet away.” Her chin is perfectly steady. “That’s all. Thank you for letting me.”
I take her hand. It’s very light, like a bundle of sticks in a glove. “It was in pencil,” I say, stupidly.
“Yes.”
“He wrote down that he was going to call the geology man at eight. At eight. He thought he had until eight.”
“He had the whole day planned,” Pearl says. “He had you coming home for Thanksgiving.” She gives my hand one hard squeeze, the kind she used to give me in church to mean stop swinging your feet, and lets go. “So. We’ll do the day he had planned. We’ll find out who was drawing on the hill.”
“We,” says Anders, from the top step, behind us. He has been standing there the whole time with a feed sack in his arms, not interrupting, which is a skill I’m starting to think is the thing I actually fell for. “If that’s all right.”
“You live in my bunk room,” I say. “It’s a little late to ask.”
“I’m asking anyway.”
“Fair,” I say, and hear it come out of my own mouth, and he looks at me for a moment with an expression I don’t have a name for, and puts the sack down very carefully on the step.
I call Lorraine from the kitchen at half past six, on the harvest-gold phone, with the cord stretched out to the pantry door the way it has been stretched since 1974.
It’s the same-hour rule. It’s not the only reason. I stand in the pantry with the receiver against my ear and the shelves of Pearl’s pickled beets glowing around me like stained glass, and when Mrs. Larrabee’s spare-room phone rings eleven times and then picks up, I say, “It’s me. Josie,” and there is a silence, and I realize I have never said that sentence to my mother in my life, I mean not as a grown woman, and it sounds exactly like a twelve-year-old.
“I’m here,” says Lorraine. Her voice is thick with sleep and fear. “Is it Pearl?”
“No. It’s Dad.”
I don’t explain. I say, “Dad’s door. Come now. Wear boots.”
She’s there in nine minutes. She comes down the lane on foot, running, in the leather boots she bought at the Notch Store in May and has not yet learned to run in, with her cardigan buttoned wrong and her hair in a clip. She stops at the foot of the cave steps and stands there with her hand on her chest, and I think, oh, she’s afraid of what I’m going to say.
I don’t say anything. I hand her ledger number 1.
She opens it in the sun. She reads the first page, the way I did, with her lips moving a little at the dates. I watch her get to the second page and the third. At the sixth page she makes a small sound and sits down on the bottom step, in the wet, with Bernard’s chin on her boot.
“Twelve,” she says.
“What?”
“The winter after your grandfather died. I was thirty-eight.” She turns the book so I can see a line near the bottom, in pencil: Jan 19. 4:50 AM. 42 F. Spring steady. Lo asleep when I left. Looked in on Jo. “He didn’t come to bed. For four months, I told you that. I told you, in the barn. I thought—” She laughs, and it breaks in the middle. “Oh, God, Josie. I thought there was somebody.
“I thought he’d found somebody, and he was too polite to say. I stood at the window at four in the morning and watched the light go down the hill and into the ground, and I thought, there’s a woman in that hill, he’s going to her.” She presses the back of her wrist to her mouth. “I was waiting for him to say it. I waited four months. Then I got on a bus.”
I don’t know what to do with my face.
“It was a hole in a hill,” I say. “And a ledger.”
“It was a spring,” she says. “It was just a spring.”
“And he told nobody. Not you. Not me.”
“He told the book.” Lorraine looks at the page for a long moment. “He always did tell the book.”
I’d like to say I forgave her right there, on the step, with the sun coming up over the north ridge and Anders pretending to tie his boot forty feet away. I don’t.
What I do is sit down one step above her and put my hand on the back of her neck, the way you’d steady a nervous doe, and she goes absolutely still, and neither of us says a word. After a minute she reaches up and puts her hand over mine and holds it there, very lightly, and does not say thank you.
It’s the best I’ve got. It’s a lot.
By ten the kitchen table has become a war room.
Pearl’s oilcloth is covered in ledgers, open, spine to spine. Anders has found a pad and a pencil and is writing a column of dates in his small neat hand, with the corner of the page squared to the table. Connie sits at the head with her minutes book. Moses Tillotson has arrived in his Sunday suit, with his hearing aid in and his hat on his knee, saying only “Heard there was a thing,” and nobody asked him how.
Lorraine is at the sink, scrubbing a blue enamel pot that is not dirty, with her back to us and her ears on stalks.
“All right,” says Anders. “Here’s what I’m looking for. Your father logged six readings a day, before milking and after, and every night at ten. Dial, water temperature, air temperature, and what he called Remarks. Most of the remarks are weather and goats.”
“Goats are weather,” Moses says.
“Fair.” Anders turns a page. “But sometimes the remarks say something else. Look at ledger six, the spring of year six. March fourth. Remarks: Noise from ridge, 2 hrs, like a sewing machine in a bucket. March seventh: Same. March ninth: Sawmill? Not sawmill.”
“That’s a drill,” Moses says. “Rotary rig. You hear it down the valley when the air’s heavy. My cousin drilled wells in Barton. That’s a drill, and it’s three miles away.”
“Did your father ever mention it?” Anders says.
“No,” I say. “He never—” and I stop, because I’m remembering something. I was eighteen. I was home for a weekend that spring. I remember him standing in the barn door with his head tilted, listening, and I said, what, and he said, Nothing. Thought I heard a sewing machine. And I laughed.
I laughed at my father. And he laughed back, and went and did the milking.
“Here’s the pattern,” says Anders. His voice is very even. “It’s not constant. Over eleven years there are thirty-eight nights where the noise is logged. Every one of them is followed, within two to five days, by a drop in the dial rate. Not the total. The rate. The paddle wheel slows. As if somebody’s drawing off the hill upstream of the spring, and there’s less coming down.”
He taps the pencil. “The effect is small. Four, five percent. Your father put a little triangle next to those rows. By year nine the triangles are in clusters.”
“Year nine,” says Pearl.
“Year eleven, the last year, there are nineteen of them,” says Anders. “Eleven in September. And then October eleventh.”
Nobody moves. The clock on the wall, the Sunbeam with the missing second hand, ticks along the way it has for fifty years.
“Down four inches since supper,” I say. “Four inches of what?”
“Water level in the flume. Which means he put a ruler in it.” Anders turns the book toward me. “Look. A strip of masking tape on the north wall with ink marks. He measured the level. Josie, four inches in a night is not drought. A drought’s a slow thing. Somebody switched on a pump.”
“Whose pump?” says Connie.
“That’s what I don’t know.”
“Section fourteen,” says Connie, grimly, writing it down.
“Evidence,” says everyone at the table. Moses says it too. His hearing aid whistles.
“The rig’s the thing,” Moses says. “A rig leaves paper. You can’t drill on a hillside in this state without a permit, and a permit goes to the town. Opal keeps the permits.” He puts on his hat. “It’s Sunday. She’ll be in her garden. She does her tomatoes after church.”
“I’ll drive,” says Lorraine, from the sink.
We all turn. She has dried her hands. She has taken off her apron, Ray’s blue one, and hung it carefully on its hook, and she is holding up the keys to her rental car.
“I mean,” she says, “if anyone wants a driver. I have a full tank. I have, I don’t know, nothing else to do this morning but be useful.” She tries to smile. “I’m told I’m good at being asked.”
“Respectfully,” I say. “Yes.”
Opal Strand lives in a gray bungalow on Church Street, behind a fence made of scrap shutters, and she is on her knees in a tomato bed when we pull up in a rental sedan with a goat in the back seat. Bernard insists. He has not been consulted about a lot of things in his life, but he will not be left.
She looks up. She’s wearing glasses on a beaded chain and a church dress and a pair of rubber gardening gloves, bright yellow, up to the elbow.
“June twenty-eighth,” says Opal. “Sunday. Eleven forty. I do not take town business on Sunday.”
“Opal,” I say. “My father’s door’s open.”
She sits back on her heels. She takes off one glove, finger by finger.
“October 2018,” she says. “That’s what you want. Isn’t it.”
“How did you—”
“It’s what everybody wants,” says Opal, “after something happens in October. I’ve been waiting eight years. I did not want to be the one to bring it up. Come on.”
The fire hall back room on a Sunday is dim and smells of wet hose and floor wax. The gray steel cabinet stands where it stood in April, and Opal opens the third drawer from the top without looking, and takes out a green folder that has been handled, I notice, a good deal more than the others. Its edges are soft. She sets it on the table. We stand around it in a ring, six people, and a goat in the doorway.
APPLICATIONS, MISC., 2018, says the tab, in Opal’s round hand.
Inside, on top, there’s a single sheet of heavy cream paper, and I know the paper before I read a word.
“Vail Land and Timber Company,” Opal reads. She doesn’t need her glasses. “Application for permission to drill three forestry monitoring wells, for the purposes of soil and groundwater observation, on the Vail ridge parcel, Larkin Notch. Filed September 27, 2018. Reviewed by the Selectboard at its regular meeting, October 2. Approved without conditions. Recorded the same day.”
“Without conditions,” says Connie. Her fountain pen has stopped.
“It looked ordinary,” Opal says. “Forestry monitoring. The Vails had been paying property tax on that ridge since 1978 and never given us one minute of trouble. Mrs. Dube had a scheme with a pond that year. We did four permits that night.” She turns the page. “It was nine days before Ray died.”
I don’t feel anything. It’s very odd. It’s the cold at the center of a thing.
“Nine days,” says Pearl quietly from the doorway. She came in behind us on Moses’s arm. “The second, and then the eleventh. I counted it on the way here.”
My father was sitting at the kitchen table’s twin that October with a ruler and a masking-tape gauge, and a rig had been drilling on the hill for nine days by permission of the town. The same town.
“Who signed?” says Anders.
Opal turns the cream page over. At the bottom, in a column of three signatures, there are two ordinary ones and one very round, firm, upright hand that I have seen on every school nurse note of my childhood, and on the Selectboard minutes in May, and on a motion to table a roof.
“Harriet Noyes,” says Connie. “Chair.”
Nobody says anything else for a very long time. In the doorway, Bernard sneezes.
“She pulled a splinter out of me in 1999,” I say. “She gave me a lollipop. It was purple.”
“It was grape,” says Pearl. “She buys them in bulk.”
“She’s tabled everything since May. She tabled her own motion. She doesn’t explain.” I find I’m holding the edge of the table. “Anders, I rated her a four. I gave Harriet four goats.”
“I’d have given her five,” says Anders. “On what I’ve seen.”
“Respectfully,” I say, and stop, because for once I can’t think what comes next, and Lorraine, behind me, puts a very light hand on my back.
“You don’t have to decide anything today,” she says. “You only have to decide the next hour.”
“That’s what Dad used to say.”
“No,” says Lorraine. “That was me. He just wrote it down.”
I laugh, once, against my will. Opal slides the green folder into a plastic sleeve and hands it to Connie, who stamps the sleeve. Moses puts a hand on my shoulder as he goes by, big and dry as a feed scoop, and says nothing, and I’m grateful.
On the drive back Anders sits beside me in the back seat with the legal pad on his knee and Bernard’s head in his lap.
“Can I ask a question?”
“Yes.”
“Do you want me to say what I think?”
“I want you to say what you can prove.”
“Then I can prove a signature,” he says. “That’s all. I can prove she signed a form nine days before. I can’t prove she knew what the form was for. People sign forms.”
“She’s a nurse. Nurses read everything.”
“Then she’ll tell you what she read.” He looks at me sideways. “You’re already angry at her.”
“I’m angry at the whole town,” I say. “I’m angry at a Tuesday in 2018.” I look out of the window at the hay going gold in the Hatch field, and my own voice sounds strange to me. “I’m angry that I’m not angrier.”
It’s a little after one when we come back up the lane, in the rental, in silence. Moses’s truck is behind us, Opal beside him with the folder on her knees. Nobody has said a word since the fire hall. The sky has turned that white-gold of a hot afternoon, and the north pasture shimmers, and every one of my sixty-odd goats has gone to the shade.
There’s a car parked across the cattle guard.
It’s an old tan Buick, the kind with a vinyl roof, and it’s parked square in the middle of the lane, so that nobody can get past without asking. A woman is sitting on the hood. She’s seventy, with short white hair, a gray cardigan with a lump in one pocket, and glasses on a cord. On her knees she holds a covered casserole dish, wrapped in a dish towel, in both hands, like a person at a christening.
She doesn’t get down when we stop. She looks at me through the windshield for a long time, and I look at her.
Then Harriet Noyes slides off the hood, stiffly, and stands in the lane with her dish, and says, so loudly that I hear it with the windows up:
“Josephine. I’d like to tell you before you ask me.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!