Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 36

Section Eleven

Here is what a milking parlor is built for: six does at a time, on a raised platform, with their heads in a feed rail and their back ends politely at the height of a man’s belt.

Here is what it is not built for: a hundred and forty people in bathrobes, barn coats and one full set of choir robes, standing shoulder to shoulder on the wet concrete at ten minutes to six in the morning, holding mason jars.

“Does anyone know,” says Mrs. Larrabee, from the front, “if the Lord objects to a hymn being sung over a manure gutter?”

“The Lord was born in a manger, Edna,” says Pearl, from her lawn chair, which somebody has carried in and set up beside the bulk tank like a throne. “I believe He’s made his peace with it.”

“Then we’ll have the first verse.”

We have the first verse. It’s “Come, Thou Fount of Every Blessing,” and it is sung by a hundred and forty people who have had no water, no coffee and not much sleep, and I would like to report that it’s terrible, but it isn’t. It rises up into the rafters, and the does, who have never in their lives been sung to at that hour by anything but me, lift their heads out of the feed rail and listen.

Gladys, in the first stall, sets her jaw and goes on chewing, a judge who has heard worse testimony.

I stand against the wall by the vacuum pump with a cold thermos and a stack of paper, and I think: Ray would have hated this. Then I think: no, he’d have stood at the back with his arms folded and his ears red, and when it was over he’d have said, “Well. That’s the town,” as if it were a weather report.

It’s the first time in eight years I’ve thought of him in the past tense without it feeling like a hand on my throat. I don’t know what to do with that, so I put it in my pocket.

“The meeting of the Larkin Notch Water District,” says Connie, “is called to order.”

She has a gavel. It is not a gavel. It’s a wooden cheese iron with a rubber band around its handle, and when she raps it on the lid of the milk can she’s using as a lectern, the sound is a deep, dull thock, like a very small cannon. She’s changed out of the teapot nightgown into a gray suit, with her notary stamp on a lanyard. Her hair has been set. I don’t ask how.

“This is the first regular meeting, which is also the second special meeting, which is also, as a matter of record, an emergency,” she says. “Commissioners present. Ines Gallagher.”

“Present,” says Ines. She’s standing beside the cheese press with a flip chart she has brought from the bank, the kind with a stand, and on the top sheet in red marker it says DRY TAPS: WHAT WE KNOW.

“Gil Hatch.”

“Yup.”

“Edna Larrabee.”

“Present, and under protest at the lighting.”

“Noted.” Connie raps the milk can. “We have one item. We have until about three twenty this afternoon to do something about it. Before anything else I’d like to say, for the minutes, that the District has been in existence for thirteen hours and forty minutes, and in that time it has taken delivery of one fire tanker, a hundred and thirty-six people’s worth of drinking water from a neighbor’s well, and a goat as a member in good standing.”

She looks over her glasses. “I couldn’t be prouder. Josephine, you have the floor.”

I’d like to tell you I stride to the front. What actually happens is that I get shoved there by a Hatch boy.

My hands are cold. I look down at what I’m holding, which is not a speech. It’s four pages, photocopied at the Notch Store at five-fifteen this morning by Mr. Odell, who opened early, in his undershirt, and charged me nothing, and said, “I’m not doing it for the money, Josie. I’m doing it for the story.”

“Annex B,” I say. “Harriet Noyes read it to us last night, but she read it in the dark and she was crying, so I’d like to do it again where everybody can see me.”

There’s a murmur. Harriet, in the third row in a navy cardigan, with her bag clutched on her knees, looks at the floor.

“The Vail Land and Timber permit was filed on September twenty-seventh, 2018. It was approved on October second. The text of it is the part everyone remembers, which is three forestry monitoring wells. The annex is the part nobody read.”

I turn the page.

“Annex B, paragraph two. The operator may conduct yield trials of up to twenty-four hours’ duration, at rates not exceeding six hundred gallons per minute, no more often than quarterly, for a term of five years. Paragraph three. Trials may be conducted on consecutive days at the operator’s discretion.” I look up. “That’s the one. That’s the word that’s drinking our water. Consecutive. They don’t have to wait three months between tests. They can run four in a row.”

“What’s the five years?” says Gil. “It’s been eight.”

“It says five. It was renewed in 2023 on a form that Harriet’s successor signed without the annex attached. I have the form.” I hold it up. “Which means that the permit that’s running this pump now is, as far as I can tell, legally the same permit with a different date on it, and nobody on this town’s board has laid eyes on a page of the thing in seven years.”

“That’s my fault,” says Dewey, from the back wall.

Heads turn. He’s standing under the calendar from Marchand Feed & Hardware, in the clean, wrong-buttoned shirt, with his cap in both fists, and he’s gray around the mouth, not the gray of a man who’s slept badly. The gray of a man who’s decided what he’s going to say.

“I was the chair in 2023,” he says. “I signed the renewal. I saw the permit number, I saw the date, I saw the box said monitoring, I checked it, and I went to lunch.” He swallows. “It’s on me. I’d like it in the minutes.”

“Dewey,” says Connie, gently, “this isn’t the Halfway Hearing.”

“It’s the closest thing I’ve got to one.”

“It’s noted,” says Connie. She writes it down. In ink. I watch her do it, and I watch Dewey watch her, and he nods once, at his own boots.

“Thank you,” I say, and I mean it, and I’m startled at how it sounds.

“All right.” Ines flips her chart. “Here are my numbers. The District serves thirty-one households and a school, about a hundred and thirty-six people. At fifty gallons a day for drinking, washing and the necessary, that’s a little under seven thousand gallons. We have the Barton tanker at four thousand. We have Moses’s well, which, thank you, Moses, is not a bottomless thing, and a tank trailer. We can hold until Wednesday if nobody takes a bath.”

“I don’t take baths,” says Mr. Odell, unexpectedly, from the door. “I take showers.”

“Then you’re ahead,” says Ines. “Everybody else, a sponge.” She turns the page. “The part I like less. In thirty-nine hours, if the pump runs the whole of Annex B’s four trials, the level at the cave, according to Josie’s father’s ruler, goes from five inches to zero. And according to Mr. Lund, the Kettle then doesn’t recover in days. It recovers in months, if it recovers. It’s an old reservoir. It fills slowly.”

“Weeks,” says Anders. He’s standing by the door, in Mrs. Larrabee’s late husband’s coat, and the room goes quiet when he talks, which is a thing I’d rather it didn’t do. “Possibly a year. I’d want a hydrologist to say so. But I’ve watched the figures, and the spring’s been dropping for fifteen hours on a curve I don’t like.” He shifts. “I’m sorry. I’m just telling you what the numbers say.”

“Thank you, Mr. Lund.”

“Please, Anders.”

“Thank you, Mr. Lund,” says Connie.

It’s not a dig. It’s the highest rank in her gift. Anders understands that, and he takes it.

There’s a movement at the back, near the milk-house door. A man in a tweed jacket over striped pajamas, with a plastic bucket upside down at his feet and a thermos in his lap, has sat down on the bucket, in the corner, as far from everyone as the walls permit. His white hair has been combed. His brown shoes have been shined, by someone, at some point after four a.m., and I’d like to know who and with what.

A hundred and forty people have turned to look.

He doesn’t say anything. He just nods, once, to the room, like a man at a funeral who’s been told where to stand.

“Mr. Vail,” says Connie, “is attending as an observer. He is not a party, he is not a witness, and he is not to be heckled.” She looks around. “That’s Section 3. I just made it up. It’s good.”

“We’d like you to call your sister,” says a voice, and it’s Mrs. Larrabee, rising from her folding chair with the hymnal held to her chest like a shield. “We’d like you to call her now. In front of us. I’d like to hear what a person says when she’s turned off a woman’s water on a Sunday.”

“She won’t pick up for me, Mrs. Larrabee.”

“Then she’ll pick up for the hymnal.” She opens it. “Dewey, bring the machine.”

It takes a minute. A cell phone has been unplugged, from a charger on the parlor wall, and set down on the lid of the milk can. A Hatch boy has turned the volume up all the way. There’s a hum, then the sound of a number dialing, a long way off, and four rings, and then a click, and a voice I’ve heard once.

“I told you, Callie,” says Marguerite Vail Ames. “Not before nine.”

It’s amazing, what a hundred and forty people can do with a silence. They don’t breathe. They don’t even shift their feet.

“Mrs. Ames,” says Connie, “this is Constance Duquette, moderator of the Larkin Notch Water District. You are on speaker in a public meeting, in the presence of the District’s commissioners and the community. Please state that you consent to being recorded, or please hang up.”

A pause. “Who is this?”

“The moderator.”

“I’m sure you’re very good at it.” The voice is clipped and cool, and it comes out of that cell phone, in that barn, among the does, like an ice cube dropped into a pail of warm milk. “I haven’t consented to a meeting. I’ve consented to a telephone call. You may record the call. I would remind you that I am a trustee of a duly constituted trust acting within an instrument signed by your own Selectboard chair.

I haven’t done a thing I wasn’t permitted to do.”

“Mrs. Ames,” says Ines, “there are thirty-one households here without water.”

“I’m very sorry for the inconvenience.”

It’s the word that does it. It goes through the room the way a draft goes under a door. Inconvenience. A hundred and forty people in bathrobes look at one another, and somewhere to my right Mrs. Larrabee closes her hymnal with a sound like a door.

“Inconvenience,” says Mrs. Larrabee. “Dear. I’m eighty-six. I have run a tap in the same kitchen every morning since 1961 and this morning I stood in front of it for a full minute while it did nothing. I’d like to know what you call that where you live.”

There’s a short silence.

“I’d call it,” says Marguerite Vail Ames, in a voice that, to its credit, has dropped about four degrees, “unfortunate. And temporary.”

“Until Wednesday.”

“Until Wednesday. After which the village’s supply will, according to our consultants, normalize.”

“Your consultants,” I say, from the front, “have never read a ledger kept by a man who stood in a room every night for eleven years with a ruler.”

“Miss Bell.” A pause. I picture her: I find I’ve pictured her already, a woman in a pale coat on a leather sofa, in a room with no clutter. “I’m told you have a flair for the dramatic. I’m told you hosted a vote in a cheese barn at which a goat received eleven ballots. I’d ask you not to treat a hydrological program as a stage.”

“It’s not a stage. It’s my kitchen.”

“And I’m sure it’s a lovely one.” The voice thins. “I don’t intend to debate the law with a dairy farmer in a conference call at six in the morning. The annex is in the file. The trial continues. If your District has a legitimate grievance, I would encourage you to retain counsel, and my attorneys would be delighted to receive a letter. In, I’d estimate, nine to fourteen weeks.”

“Respectfully,” I say.

“Yes?”

“No.”

It’s out before I can stop it. And what happens next is that a hundred and forty people say, not loudly, not together, but one after another, in the voices of grandmothers, Hatch boys, a retired choir director and a fire chief in his sleeping undershirt, the same thing.

“No.”

“No.”

“Respectfully, no.”

I don’t know who starts it. I think it’s Gil. It runs around the room like a spark in dry hay, and Bernard, who has been lying on the parlor platform among the does’ feet, gets up, shakes himself, and says it too, in the only way he can. It’s a long, rude, brassy bleat.

Marguerite Vail Ames doesn’t say anything for a while.

“Is that,” she says at last, “a goat?”

“It’s the Senator,” says Anders.

“I see.” A very long pause. “Mr. Lund. I wasn’t aware you were there.”

“I’m here.”

“I’ve followed your work. I’m sorry to see it come to this.”

“To what?”

“Whatever this is.” The voice has something in it that wasn’t there before, and I can’t read it. It could be contempt. It could be something older and worse. “You built a company out of knowing the difference between a thing that can be bought and a thing that can’t. I’d have thought you’d be the last person in the world to confuse the two.”

“I haven’t confused anything,” says Anders. “I know exactly what you’re doing, Mrs. Ames. It’s why I’d like you to stop.”

“Callie,” says Marguerite. “Are you there?”

On the bucket, in the corner, her brother looks up.

“I’m here, Margo.”

“You’ve been very quiet.”

“I’ve been told I’m not to be heckled.”

“I don’t know what that means. Turn the phone off. Go back to Greenwich. We’ll talk when you’ve slept.”

“I don’t think I’ll sleep,” says Calloway, “until the pump is off.”

There’s a click. Dead air. The phone sits on the milk can with its screen dark, and in the quiet, Pearl, from her lawn chair, says conversationally, “Well. She’s very well brought up. Nobody’s been that rude to me in forty years without putting a cardigan on first.”

A laugh goes round the room, thin and surprised. And then I hear the sound.

It isn’t loud at first. It’s a flutter, like a moth against a screen. I feel it in my sternum before I hear it, and I see Gil Hatch’s head come up, and then Connie’s, and then every head in the parlor swivels toward the east window, where the sky has gone the color of weak tea. The flutter becomes a chop. The chop becomes a roar. The does throw up their heads in the feed rail.

The wooden window frame starts to hum, and Mrs. Larrabee’s hymnal, which she has laid on the cheese press, begins to slide.

“That,” says Gil Hatch, slowly, “is a helicopter.”

“It cannot be,” says Connie. She has gone the color of paper. “It’s Section Eleven.”

“It’s what, Connie?”

“Section Eleven of Ordinance Twelve.” She lifts her cheese iron. “No helicopters. Adopted in 1994, after the Johnson Brothers’ wedding party landed in your father’s hayfield, Gilbert, and the bride’s veil took out a tractor.”

“I remember,” says Gil, hoarsely. “My dad cried.”

We go out. All of us. A hundred and forty people and a fire chief and a goat pour out of the milking parlor into the gray light of a Monday morning, and the wind knocks us sideways. Over the Hatch hayfield, a quarter mile down the road, a white-and-silver machine the size of a delivery van hangs for a moment above the wet grass, nose down, like a dragonfly that’s lost its nerve.

Then it sets itself down, so gently that the grass lies back in a ring around it, and the rotors begin to slow.

“That’s a four-hundred-thousand-dollar machine in a seventy-dollar hayfield,” says Gil, in a voice of pure grief.

“Twenty-five dollars,” says Connie. She’s already writing it down. “Per rotor. Section Eleven. The fine’s never been raised.”

The door opens. A man in a gray suit climbs down with a briefcase, and turns, and gives his hand to a woman, who steps out onto the Hatch hayfield in a white wool coat, a pair of gleaming, ankle-high leather boots that have never before touched anything softer than a runway, and a scarf the color of cream.

She’s small. That’s what I see first. I’d built her in my head as a tall woman, a pillar, and she’s five foot three, with her father’s jaw and her brother’s white hair cut short as a boy’s. She doesn’t hurry. She stands at the edge of that hayfield and she looks, not at the barn, not at us, but at the ridge behind it, with the ribs of the Skeleton against the sky, as if she’s keeping an appointment.

Calloway has come out behind me. I hear him make a small noise. It isn’t a word.

“Margo,” he says.

She starts to walk. It takes her four minutes to cross that field. The man in the gray suit trails her with the briefcase, and a Hatch boy runs to open the gate, and Bernard, who respects an entrance, trots out to meet her and plants himself in the road, with his bell, in the middle of her path.

She stops. She looks at him. He looks at her.

“I’m told,” says Marguerite Vail Ames, “that this is the Senator.”

“He is,” I say.

“He has very dreadful manners.”

“You haven’t seen the half of it.”

“No.” She raises her eyes to mine, and they are her father’s eyes too, and her brother’s, a pale and clouded gray. “Miss Bell. I’m sorry about the helicopter. I’d read the ordinance. I’d thought it might be worth twenty-five dollars to be on time.” She takes a breath. “Before you tell me to leave. Before we have a meeting, or an argument, or whatever the next stage of this is. May I ask you one thing?”

“You can ask,” I say.

She doesn’t look at Anders. She doesn’t look at her brother. She looks at me, with that clouded, steady gaze, and in her gloved hand, which isn’t quite steady, there’s something small and square and faded, held against her chest like a hymnal.

“Before I ask you for anything,” she says, “I’d like to see what my father tiled.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!