I’d like to say I have a good answer ready.
What I have is a hundred and forty neighbors at my back, a goat standing in a stranger’s path, and a woman in cream-colored wool holding something small against her chest, in a gravel lane at six-forty in the morning, with the rotors of a helicopter winding down behind her like a sigh.
“What my father tiled,” I say.
“Yes.”
“Mrs. Ames, I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“I think that’s true.” She says it with a kind of wonder, and then, as if she’d caught herself being human, she tucks it away. “It’s why I came in person. Mr. Brandt’s camera found it last night. He sent me the footage at one in the morning, and I watched it six times in my kitchen, and then I flew north before dawn, because I thought, she doesn’t know. Whoever’s living on top of it doesn’t know.” She lifts her chin.
“I’m not accustomed to being the one who knows something. I’d like to see what it feels like.”
“Margo,” says Calloway, behind me. His voice is a husk. “What footage?”
“Oh, Callie.” She doesn’t turn her head. “You were always going to find out last.”
I should say no. It’s what I came into this world to say. But the man in the gray suit has set down his briefcase in the road, and the Hatch boys are staring, and I can feel the town behind me leaning in with that terrible, patient attention of people who have decided to be present for a thing.
“Not in the road,” I say. “And not in front of the goats. You’ll come into the parlor. You’ll sit down. You’ll tell all of us what you know, in front of the District, and then we’ll decide whether to show you anything.”
“That’s an unusual procedure.”
“It’s Section Three,” says Connie, from somewhere near my elbow. “I made it up an hour ago. It’s already precedent.”
Marguerite Vail Ames looks at the cheese iron in Connie’s fist, and then, for the first time, a corner of her mouth moves. It isn’t a smile. It’s the place where a smile used to be before somebody taught it manners.
“Very well,” she says.
The parlor has been rearranged. Someone, probably Gil, has dragged the second lawn chair beside Pearl’s, and set it a polite distance from the bulk tank. Marguerite sits in it with her white coat arranged, her boots together, and her bag on her knees, directly across the platform from Gladys. Gladys looks at her. Marguerite looks at Gladys. I’d put money on neither of them blinking.
Her lawyer, whose name is Thaddeus Pruitt and who has the pinkish, weary air of a man who bills by the quarter hour and has not been asked to enjoy it, stands behind her and doesn’t sit, because there’s nothing for him to sit on but a milk can.
Calloway hasn’t moved from his bucket in the corner. The hundred and forty have settled back into their places, with a creaking and a shuffling, and Mrs. Larrabee has taken her hymnal off the cheese press and set it on her knees like a woman with a weapon.
“Mrs. Ames,” says Connie, “you have the floor. Please keep it to five minutes.”
“I’ll need ten.”
“You may have eight.”
“Seven,” says Marguerite, mildly. “I’ve never been one to bargain upward.”
She opens her bag. What she takes out is a square of white card the size of a coaster, held at the edges between a gloved thumb and finger, and she carries it across the platform, past a doe who sniffs at her glove, and holds it out to me.
I take it.
It’s a Polaroid. I haven’t held one in years, and it’s the real kind, with a wide white margin at the bottom, and the colors have gone the way those colors go, lemon and rust and a green like the inside of a pond. In the middle of it, in a room I have never seen, two men are standing waist-deep in steaming water, with their arms around one another’s shoulders, laughing.
I know one of them at once. I’d know those ears anywhere. He’s about forty, thinner than I remember from the pictures in the hall, with a wet cap pushed back, and he’s laughing so hard his eyes have vanished.
“That’s my grandfather,” I say.
“I thought so,” says Marguerite. “The other is mine.”
The other man is large and fair and ruddy, with a jaw you could use to open crates. He is about the same age. He has his head thrown back, and in the photograph his face is wide open, like a window with the sash up. I try to find Calloway in it, and I can’t. I find Marguerite instead, in the cut of the mouth. I find the pale eyes.
Behind them, behind the steam and the two grinning men, is a wall of tile. Dark green and white, in a pattern of interlocking scallops. Above it, in the corner of the frame, a curve of vaulted ceiling, tiled in the same green, going up into shadow.
“Turn it over,” says Marguerite.
I do. On the back, in blue ballpoint, in a hand I don’t know, a man has written:
E. + W. Jan 21, 1978. Opening day. (Nobody came.)
“Opening day,” I say.
“My father kept it in his desk until he died. I found it in the drawer under his cuff links, in a card that said For Margo, when I’m gone. That’s the entirety of the message. I was fifty-four years old. I’d been told, my entire life, that my father had been defeated in Vermont by a bad ordinance and an unfriendly village, and had come home and never spoken of it.
And I sat on the floor of his study with a cuff-link box in my lap, and I understood that he’d lied.”
“To you,” says Calloway, hoarsely.
“To everyone. For forty years.” She says it to the room.
“I’ll tell you what I know, and I’d like you to hold me to it. It isn’t much. In January 1976 my father drilled a well from the ridge to supply a lodge kitchen, and it came up warm. He told Callie, and not me, because I was twelve and it was a boy’s afternoon.
“Two years later there’s a photograph. The room in it isn’t on the ridge. It’s under it. It’s tiled and vaulted and filled with water from two sources, one hot and one cold, and there’s your grandfather standing in it. In January. With my father’s arm around his neck.”
She looks at Pearl.
“Mrs. Bell. You’ll forgive me. I’d hoped you could tell me what it was.”
Every head in the barn turns to Pearl, who has put her crochet in her lap.
“I’d like to say I can,” says Pearl. She says it slowly, and a little hoarsely, and I realize with a start that I’ve never in my life heard my grandmother take two seconds to answer anything. “I’d like to. Walt kept a good many things from me. Edmund Vail was one. When I asked, he said, he’s a man who made a promise, and so did I.”
“A promise to do what?” says Marguerite.
“I’m eighty-four, dear. I’ve had forty-eight years to wonder.” Pearl’s mouth goes thin.
“I never knew about a room. I knew about a Thursday. Every Thursday, from the fall of 1977, my husband went to the cave after supper, for two or three hours, and came home smelling of wet stone and, God help me, of a man’s soap.
“I thought he had a lady. I thought it for four months. I followed him once, to the cave door. I stood in the dark with my hand on the ring, and I heard two men’s voices in there, laughing, and I went home and made a pie.”
Somebody in the third row makes a noise, half a laugh. It isn’t unkind.
“In January of ‘78 he came home white,” says Pearl. “He sat on the edge of the bed with his boots on. He said, it’s over. I said, what is. He said, the water. And then he got up in the morning and carried two hundred pounds of fieldstone to the north wall, and he didn’t ask for help, and I didn’t offer. That’s all I know. That’s the truth, and it’s a poor sort of truth, but you may have it.”
“Thank you,” says Marguerite. She says it as if it cost her a coin. “That’s more than I’ve had in my life.”
“Then ask me the rest,” says Pearl.
“I beg your pardon?”
“The rest of it. What you want.” Pearl’s gray eyes are on her. “You didn’t fly a helicopter into the Hatch hayfield for a photograph. Say it plain, Marguerite. You’re in my granddaughter’s barn.”
It’s the first time anyone’s used her first name in that room. I watch it land.
“I’d like to open the room,” says Marguerite Vail Ames.
Nobody says anything.
“My brother has told you, I’m sure, that I’m a woman of money. It’s true. I’ve run a trust for thirty years, and the Notch North project is, I’ll admit, a good one. But I don’t want your water, Miss Bell. I want the room.
“I want to stand in it. My father built a thing here with his own hands and his own money, in the last year he was a happy man, and then he walled it up and said nothing and went home and became the man I knew.”
She’s speaking quickly now, in a low, level voice, with her hands locked.
“I’d like to find out what it was. And if the only way to find out is to dig it out from above, with a drill and a camera and a pump, because a village won’t let me in the front door, then I’ll do it that way. I’ll do it for as long as I can. I’m sorry for your taps. I truly am. I’d drink a thousand gallons of your water myself and pay for each one.
But I won’t be told that a room my father paid for is off-limits to his daughter because of a farmer’s feelings.”
It’s very quiet.
“That,” says Connie, at last, “was eight minutes.”
“I said seven.”
“You went over. I allowed it.”
“Thank you.”
I find that I’m standing in the middle of the milking platform with the Polaroid in my hand and my heart going. There’s an idea trying to form, and I don’t like it, and I’ll tell you why. It’s that I understand her.
I’ve stood in a room that was my father’s, and I’ve wanted to be the only one who got to open it. I’ve sat on a floor with a book in my lap that nobody else could read. If somebody had come to the Bell Hollow gate in a helicopter and told me there was a thing of Ray’s behind a wall, I’d have thrown a shovel at them.
I’d have thrown it hard.
“Mrs. Ames,” I say. “You didn’t ask. You drilled.”
“I asked in 2018. I sent a letter to the Bell family. It was returned.”
“Returned how?”
“Marked refused. In pencil.”
I look at Pearl. Pearl looks at her crochet.
“I did not refuse a letter,” Pearl says, to the yarn, “from a Mrs. Marguerite Ames. I refused a letter from a Vail. It was the week after we buried my son. I’m sorry for it now.”
“I see,” says Marguerite. She doesn’t say anything else. I think it’s the first thing in the whole morning that has taken the wind out of her, and I watch her fold it up, carefully, and put it away.
“Then here’s an offer.” Thaddeus Pruitt has come forward with a leather folder, the way a man comes to a table with a dessert nobody ordered. “On behalf of the Harbor Ridge Trust. It is open for the District’s consideration for the next six hours. Mrs. Ames will personally authorize it.”
“Go ahead, Thad,” says Marguerite.
“In exchange for a recorded easement permitting access to the north wall of the aging cave, for a period of ninety days, for the purposes of examining and documenting the chamber, the trust will: one, cease the present trial series at the conclusion of the current day’s trial.” A murmur ripples through the barn. “Two, provide at its own expense a potable water supply to every household in the District, by tanker, until the District’s source recovers.
Three, fund the construction of a municipal water main from the Barton line to the village green, of a capacity to be agreed, at no cost to the town.”
“A main,” says Gil, in the voice of a man being offered a woman he’s loved for forty years.
“Four, a payment to the Bell Hollow Dairy, in compensation for disruption and in consideration of the easement, of four million dollars.” He closes the folder. “Cash, within thirty days.”
There’s a sound in the barn I can’t describe. It’s not a gasp. It’s the sound of a hundred and forty people doing arithmetic.
Ines says, “That’s a lot of money for a wall.”
“It’s a lot of money for a wall that is, if I’m right, a ninety-day license to look at a room.” Anders has come in from the door. His face is carefully blank, which is the face he wears when he’s about to be useful. “Mr. Pruitt. Does the easement say what happens after ninety days?”
“It lapses.”
“And the Phase Two program?”
“Is not mentioned.”
“Of course it isn’t,” says Anders. “Because it’s a separate instrument. She’d have the room, and the water, and a main, and a check. And on day ninety-one she’d come back with a permit for the injection that had been sitting in a drawer the whole time, and the District would’ve signed away the one thing it had, which was the argument.” He looks at Marguerite. “That’s very good work. I’d have done the same.”
“Mr. Lund,” says Pruitt.
“I’m not insulting you, Thad. I’m saying I recognize the shape.”
“I’m in the room,” says Marguerite, dryly.
“I know. I’d like you to hear it from someone who used to be you.”
I didn’t expect that. Neither, I think, did she. For a second, in the gray light from the east window, a flicker crosses that carefully kept face, and I’d call it recognition, if I thought she’d let me.
“Four million dollars,” says Mrs. Larrabee, slowly. She is standing, and the hymnal is shaking in her hands. “Josephine. I’m eighty-six. I buried a husband and two sisters in that churchyard, and not one of them ever got a bill for the water. I’d drink out of a ditch before I’d see this town sell what Walter Bell wouldn’t. But it’s not my money, and it’s not my farm. So I’d like to hear you say it.”
“It’s not just my farm,” I say.
“No,” says Mrs. Larrabee, with great dignity. “That’s what I’m saying.”
I look around. A hundred and forty faces, in the light of the east window, tired, hopeful, wet-eyed, a little foolish in their bathrobes. Mr. Odell, from the Notch Store, with his arms crossed. Lorraine, in Ray’s apron, with the clipboard held to her chest. Harriet Noyes in her cardigan. Dewey against the back wall, grey as ash. Anders, whose face I can read as if it were a sign, and what it says is: Your call. I’ll back it.
And Bernard, in the middle of the platform, planted like a small, white, immovable idea, with the Polaroid’s reflection sliding across his yellow eye.
Four million dollars. A main, laid with someone else’s money, so that no Larrabee ever stands at a dry tap again. A cave door opened for ninety days. I think of the note in my desk drawer. I think of the balloon payment, and what Ray went through to dig that cave.
I think: it’s a good offer. That’s the awful part. It’s a good offer, made in good faith, by a woman who wants to see where her father was happy.
And then I think of a pencil triangle. Thirty-eight of them. Nineteen in the last year. A man standing in a hole at four a.m. with a ruler, writing what nobody asked.
“Respectfully,” I say.
“Oh, dear,” says Pearl, with satisfaction.
“No.”
Marguerite doesn’t flinch. She doesn’t look away, either. She looks at me with that clouded, patient gaze, and she says, very quietly, “May I ask why?”
“Because you’d be buying the cave with the thing you’re taking from it,” I say. “And my father didn’t write down a number for what the water was worth. He wrote down the number for what it was.”
“I can’t make a number mean anything to a man who’s dead, Miss Bell.”
“No. But I can decide what it means to me.” My voice is shaking. I let it. “I’ll tell you what I’ll do. I’ll show you your father’s room. I’ll take you there myself. But not in exchange for anything, and not while your pump’s running, and not until the town asks me to. It’s the rule. It was written on the door.”
“Then I have nothing more to say to you.”
“You do, though. You’ve got until three-twenty.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“That’s when trial two starts,” I say. “You’ve got until then to find a reason to stop it, because I’m going to find one to make you.” I hold up the Polaroid. “May I keep this until then?”
It’s the cheekiest thing I’ve ever done. Marguerite Vail Ames looks at the small square of card in my hand, and at the two men in the steam, and something moves in her face I don’t have a name for.
“Yes,” she says.
“Thank you.”
“I’d like it back.”
“You’ll have it.”
“Mrs. Ames.” That’s Connie. She has risen, and the cheese iron has gone into her sleeve like a baton. “For the minutes. The District declines the Trust’s offer. The vote is not required, because Miss Bell has declined as owner of record.” She looks at Ines, and Gil, and Mrs. Larrabee. “I’d like a motion to adjourn until we have something to do.”
“So moved,” says Gil.
“Seconded,” says Mrs. Larrabee. “With a hymn.”
“No hymn,” says Connie.
“A short one.”
The meeting breaks up the way a snowbank does, from the edges. People go out into the yard with their jars and their anxiety. Marguerite doesn’t leave. She sits on her folding chair, with her white coat arranged around her and her hands folded on her bag, watching the does, and I realize no one has offered her a thing to drink. It is, on principle, the hospitality of a town without water.
So I do the thing I’d never have done last week. I go over to the hydrant by the milk house, where Lorraine has set up Moses’s tank trailer, and fill a mason jar from the spigot, and I carry it across the barn and hold it out.
She looks at it. “Thank you.”
“It’s Moses Tillotson’s,” I say. “It’s the second-best water in town.”
“What’s the best?”
“The one that’s missing.”
She takes the jar, and for a moment she holds it, in both hands, and then she does something I can’t forgive her for, and I can’t stop thinking about. She drinks it slowly, with her eyes closed, the way you drink at a funeral.
“It’s very good,” says Marguerite Vail Ames.
“I know,” I say.
I’ve got the Polaroid in my pocket, and a pencil, and fifteen minutes before the meeting breaks up for good, and Anders is at my elbow. He’s gotten that look. I know it by now. He’s put his hands in the pockets of a dead man’s coat and he’s studying the ceiling.
“Josie,” he says, under his breath. “Can I ask a question?”
“It’s six fifty-two in the morning, and I’ve just turned down four million dollars.”
“I know. It was magnificent.” He says it solemnly. “I’m going to ask about something worse.”
“Go ahead.”
“What was the date on the ledger’s last page?” he says. “The twelfth one. The one you wrote in last night.”
“I wrote last night’s date.”
“No. I mean, what’s the first date in Ray’s ledger one?” He tips his head. “The one he started the winter your grandfather died. Because Pearl said Walt walled up the north wall in January 1978. And your father started the ledgers nineteen years ago, which is twenty-nine years after that.” He stops. “He wasn’t recording a spring. He was recording a wall.”
I stand very still.
“There’s a wall in that cave,” says Anders, “that’s been sweating for forty-eight years. And the only man who ever watched it was your father, at four in the morning, with a ruler. What if the question isn’t who’s drawing on the hill?”
“What?”
“What if it’s, what was Ray afraid would come out?”
And across the barn, on the lid of a milk can, a cell phone starts to ring. It isn’t Marguerite’s. It’s the Hatch boy’s, the one with the volume turned all the way up, and the voice that comes out of it is Brandt’s, hoarse and breathless, and it says:
“Ma’am? Anybody? It’s the foreman. It’s eleven past seven. Something’s changed on the gauge. The middle bore’s taking in water.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!