“You invited the man who wants to buy us,” I say.
“I invited the man who signs the checks,” says Pearl. “The man who signs the checks is the only one who can stop them.”
Connie has the decency to look at her tea. Pearl does not. She pulls a sheet from the nearest folder and reads me the letter she mailed him in February, in her own small, hard hand, as calmly as a woman reading the church bulletin.
“Dear Mr. Lund. As co-owner of Bell Hollow Farm, I consent to Neighbor Review and request your attendance in person under Section Six. Someone has been taking my granddaughter’s farm apart a piece at a time since the week after your first offer. I would like to look the man who benefits in the eye. Bring boots.”
“Bad luck keeps no schedule,” Connie adds. “Somebody does.”
“And you didn’t tell me because?”
“You would have said no.”
“I would have—”
“Respectfully,” says Pearl. “And no is the one word that would have left you alone in this.”
That lands somewhere under my ribs. “If he’s the one doing it?”
“Then you’ll have him inside shouting distance for thirty days.” She picks up her hook. “And if he’s not, we’ll learn who is, because the person doing it will have to work around a man who watches everything and writes it down.”
I want to throw the tea. Instead I ask the question I came in with. “You said that was the letter. Is there more?”
For the first time in my life I see my grandmother hesitate.
“There’s a postscript,” she says. “Go look at row fourteen.”
The shop closes at five, but it never really closes. The north wall is where Pearl pins every note a customer ever left us, index cards, napkins, postcards, children’s drawings, a crayoned goat with five legs, layered like shingles from the baseboard to the rafters, fifty-odd years of strangers saying thank you. She keeps an index in a binder. Row fourteen, upper left. I find the card with a flashlight and my heart beating in my ears.
It’s a lined card in blue ballpoint, with a goat sketched in the corner. The goat is eating a map.
Best day of the whole trip. A goat ate our map, the cave smells like rain, and the baby kicked twice. Thank you. L. Lund, Wisconsin, July 1989.
I read the word baby three times.
“Can I ask a question?” says the doorway behind me. “Does it still say baby?”
He’s standing there in the dark, in his ruined coat, as if he’d been waiting for the shop to say something first. I don’t turn around.
“Your mother.”
“Lise. She died the winter I turned seventeen.” He comes in slowly. “She called it the goat farm with the cave that smells like rain. She never knew the name. She lost the map, apparently to a goat.” He stops beside me, and the flashlight makes his face look younger. “She used to tell me I’d been there before I was born. I thought it was a bedtime story. Your grandmother’s letter had a postscript.”
“Is that why you came?”
“It’s half of it. The other half is I’d rather find out who’s wrecking your farm than be the man who profits.” He’s honest enough not to say the rest. “I’m still the man who wants to buy it, Josie. I won’t pretend I’m not.”
“Your mother’s card doesn’t get you the farm.”
“I know.” He looks at the goat eating the map. “I’d like to stay anyway.”
I don’t answer, which I count as the most generous thing I’ve done in a week.
The next nine days I do not speak to Pearl about the letter, and the man in the bunk room does not speak to me about the card. We talk about chores. Compressor. Wash line. Hoof trimming, at which he’s mediocre, and a doe named Tulip who has taken against him. Bernard sleeps outside the milk house door like a very small, very smug bodyguard. Nothing else breaks. I have never been so scared of a quiet week in my life.
Then it’s Day 15, the Halfway Hearing, and the cheese barn is full.
Larkin Notch has not had a Town Hall since the roof lay down in February like an old dog, so every meeting happens here, on the event floor, where we push the wheel racks back and set up two hundred folding chairs. They’re nearly all full. Pearl sits in the front row with her handbag in her lap like a bomb.
The Committee has a long table. Connie, a gavel I know she bought at the church sale. Moses, ear off. Dewey in the middle, in his good flannel, because he’s Selectboard chair, and the chair is the one who reads out the findings.
“Order, order,” says Dewey, with a smile for the room. “Friends, I hate this. I surely do. But I found something this morning I have to show you.”
He lifts a feed sack onto the table, reaches in, and holds up a pair of bolt cutters. Red handles. An orange sticker on one jaw, in print so small I have to squint. LUND FIELDWORKS ASSET 0447.
“Hay shed,” says Dewey. “Behind the third bale. I stopped in this morning to get out of the drizzle.”
The barn makes a noise like a hive being kicked.
“Run him out!” someone shouts from the back, and a voice that sounds like Mrs. Larrabee’s says, “Now, Phil, hush.”
Connie raps the gavel. “Section twelve. For cause, the Committee may remove the applicant. The owner may waive removal. The applicant may withdraw at any time, with no penalty beyond the ten-year bar.” She turns. “Mr. Lund, you may address the room.”
Anders stands. He doesn’t go to the lectern. He just stands in the aisle with his hands open, in a borrowed flannel shirt, the best-dressed man there by default and the worst-dressed by choice.
“I didn’t put those in the hay shed,” he says. “I can’t prove it. I can’t even say who did.” A pause. “I could withdraw this afternoon. Josie’s farm would be safe from my company for a decade, and I suspect nobody in this room would be sorry. That’s exactly why I’m not going to.”
Someone coughs.
“Whoever’s doing this wins the moment I leave. They try again under a different name, and you won’t have a man in the bunk room to watch them. I’d like to stay and find out who.”
Dewey spreads his hands. “Kiddo,” he says, gently, to me. “Nobody’d blame you. Say the word.”
Two hundred faces turn my way. I can feel the whole mud-colored, loyal, tired town of them, who would like very much for this to be over. I can feel the weight of the envelope in my desk drawer. If I say the word, he goes. The cutters, the cave, the card, all of it leaves with him. It would be so easy.
“I waive removal,” I say.
“Josie,” Dewey says, softer. “Why?”
“Because if he’s the one doing it, I’d rather he do it where I can see him.”
Laughter, relief, a few boos. Connie stamps the log. Anders’s eyes find mine, over all those folding chairs, and what’s in them is not triumph. It’s something worse: gratitude. I look away first.
Afterward, at the coffee urn, Connie fills two cups and does not hand me either.
“I walk every shed on my rounds,” she says. “I walked the hay shed at nine this morning. It was empty.”
“Dewey said he found them at ten-forty.”
“So between nine and ten-forty, someone put them there.” Her fountain pen taps the lid of the urn. “That’s a short list. You. Anders. Pearl. Moses, who came for his tank. Dewey, who was delivering flyers for tonight.”
“Dewey held my hand at my father’s funeral,” I say.
“Section fourteen,” says Connie, “prohibits me from accusing anyone without evidence. I’m very good at sections.” She hands me a cup.
I walk out into the wet dark afterward and tell myself I waived removal for strategy. Keep him close, watch him work. It’s a good lie. It’s the first one I’ve told all month that I actually believe.

