Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 62

The Bad Seed Bin

I drive up to the Skeleton at eleven at night with the high beams on and my father’s barn coat buttoned to the chin, and I rehearse, the whole way, the first sentence I’m going to say to Dewey Marchand.

It’s a good sentence. It has the word *respectfully* in it. By the time I reach the cattle guard, I’ve changed it four times, and by the time I turn into the caretaker’s lane I’ve thrown it out altogether and I’m just driving, with my jaw tight, past the dark shape of the lodge on its ledge, with its three hundred dead windows and its long porch full of leaves.

Anders offered to come. Pearl, in her kitchen, offered nothing; she only lifted her chin at the door like a woman sending a hen out to find the egg. So I came alone, with Bernard asleep in the footwell, because he won’t be left, and because he’s the one creature in the valley who has never lied to me about anything.

The cottage is at the end of the lane, a little shingled box with a stovepipe and a porch light the color of weak tea. There’s a truck in front, nose-in, with a feed-store sticker on the bumper. There’s a figure sitting on the porch step in the dark with a mug in his hands, as if he’d been told I was coming.

“Evening, Jo-Jo,” says Dewey.

---

He doesn’t get up. His knee’s the size of a cantaloupe under his work pants, and he’s propped it on an upturned bucket, and the sight of it undoes a good half of what I came to say.

“You’re sitting out here in the dark,” I say.

“It’s cooler.”

“You’re cold in July, Wanda says.”

“Wanda Cobb,” says Dewey, with a sigh that takes a minute to come out, “has the best eyes in Vermont and the worst sense of when to use them. Sit down. Bernard, you too. I’ve got a bowl of pellets for you somewhere.”

I don’t sit. Bernard does, directly on Dewey’s good foot, with a groan.

“Eighty-eight envelopes,” I say. “In the bank. In the dog-license kind. Dewey, I’ve got you on camera.”

“I know you do.”

“You *know*.”

“Tibbetts called me at ten past noon, after you left,” says Dewey. “He’s a worried man. He said, *Dewey, I’ve a duty,* and I said, *Tibbs, you do.* I’ve been waiting here since three. I thought you’d come at five, with the sheriff.” He takes a sip of whatever’s in his mug. It smells like Postum, which no one has bought since 1994. “I didn’t think you’d come alone.”

“Why am I looking at a gray cap on a night-drop at twenty to six in the morning?”

“Because I put it there.”

“Dewey.”

“I mean the envelope,” says Dewey. “I put the envelope there. I’ve put it in on the second of every month since March of 2019. Pretty near eighty-eight times, if Wanda says. I’m sorry. I should’ve told you the first time. I should’ve told you the second. I told myself I’d tell you next month, and it got to be a habit, like the knee.”

I stand there with my hands in my pockets. I’ve rehearsed a good many things, but I haven’t rehearsed *this*, which is a big, tired man on a step saying yes, in a very small voice, to the thing I’d have given a year of my life for him to deny.

“Who gives it to you?” I say.

“I don’t know.”

---

“I don’t *know*,” says Dewey, a second time, because I’m looking at him the way I look at a doe who’s eaten the feed bag and says she’s been asleep. “Jo, I swear on Walt’s grave and on every bag of pellets I ever sold. You can ask me with the Bible and the sheriff and your grandmother in the room. I don’t know.”

“You carried my savings money for seven years.”

“I carried an envelope.”

“From *who*.”

He sets down the mug. He gets, with some difficulty, a folded paper out of his shirt pocket, and holds it out in the porch light. The paper’s soft as cloth. It’s been folded and unfolded so many times that the creases have gone white.

“March the second, 2019,” he says. “It was a Saturday. I was in the shop, I’d just done the inventory. It was a month after the crate went missing, if you want to count, and I hadn’t slept for it. I went to the bad seed bin.”

“The *what*?”

“The returns bin. By the back door. It’s a barrel, it’s been there since my father’s day. If you buy a bag of seed that won’t sprout, or feed that’s gone over, you put it in the barrel and I give you your money back, no questions. Nobody’s ever once used it for anything but bad seed.” He puts the paper in my hand. “There was an envelope on the lid. Dog-license kind. With that on top.”

I unfold it by the porch light.

It’s a single sheet torn from a feed-store receipt pad, the carbon kind, with *MARCHAND FEED & HARDWARE* across the top, and on the blank side, in pencil, in neat block capitals, six lines.

*DEWEY. YOU OWE RAY ONE CRATE. HERE IS HOW YOU PAY.* *TAKE THIS TO THE NOTCH VALLEY NIGHT-DROP, SECOND OF EACH MONTH, BEFORE SIX.* *DO NOT OPEN IT. DO NOT FOLLOW. DO NOT ASK.* *IT IS FOR JOSIE.* *IF YOU TELL HER NOW SHE WILL BE HURT. WHEN THE QUIET IS LEVEL, TELL HER.* *—A FRIEND OF THE BELLS.*

I read it twice. Then I fold it up again, along its own white creases, because I can’t bear to see it open.

“*When the Quiet is level,*” I say.

“Yes.”

“In March of 2019, you were told about the Quiet.”

“I wasn’t told what it was,” says Dewey. “I thought it was a thing about the Bath. About the lake in the barn. I thought it was Walt’s, and Ray’s, and I didn’t ask. I never knew it was a *name.* I thought it was a way of saying *when things are calm.*”

He looks down at Bernard’s head. “And then Friday night, when you threw that breaker. You said it up at the pool house. *The Quiet.* And I thought, oh Lord. That’s the thing. That’s the thing I’ve been carrying.”

---

It takes me some time. I sit down, in the end, on the second porch step, with my knees up and my back against the post, because the dark’s come in round me like water and I want something solid.

“Tell me about the envelope,” I say. “Exactly. As if I were Connie and you were under oath.”

He tells me. He’s a precise man when he’s ashamed, and he starts at the barrel. Every month, on the first, he opens the feed store at seven, and on the first, or on the thirty-first, depending, there’s a dog-license envelope on the lid of the bad seed bin. He doesn’t see it come. He never has.

Once he sat up all night in the storeroom with a thermos, in the spring of 2021, and nothing came; and at six in the morning, when he went to the toilet for two minutes, it was there.

“Two minutes,” I say.

“It’s the only two minutes I was away,” says Dewey, in a voice of awful wonder. “Whoever it is knows my business better than I do.”

“What was in it?”

“Cash, and a note about the amount. I never opened them. I want you to know that. I never once counted. But the flaps weren’t sealed; I could feel it, I could see the green of the bills, and the figure was on the outside. I just carried them.” He rubs his face.

“It was Pearl who figured it. She saw me, you know. From the pantry window. At the church corner. She never said, and I never said, and every second of the month I walked past her house at twenty to six, in the dark, and I thought, *she’ll come out, she’ll say my name.* She never did. Seven years.”

“She said it to me tonight.”

“I thought she might.”

“She said you carry it.”

“That’s all I do,” says Dewey Marchand. “I’m the cart.”

I ask what he did that first morning, because it seems to me that the first one is where a man shows what he is.

“I sat in the truck outside the bank for forty minutes,” says Dewey. “It was March, it was twelve degrees, and the heater in that truck had been dead since Easter. I held that envelope on my knee like a hot dish. I kept thinking, *it’s a trick, it’s Birchwater, and if I post it I’m in it forever.* And then I thought about Ray. And I thought about the crate. And I thought, well, Dewey, you lost it. Whatever it is, you lost it.”

“So you posted it.”

“At twenty to six, with my glove on, and I dropped it in the slush and had to fish it out with a pencil.” He gives a short, cracked laugh. “It’s been a good deal smoother since. But I’ve never once got to the slot without my heart going like a hen’s.”

I don’t know whether to laugh or kick the post. “And the dog-license envelopes at the town office?”

“That’s me, too.”

“*Dewey.*”

“There was a key on a nail,” says Dewey. “For the fire department. I took it down in 1998, and nobody ever asked for it back. In March 2019, when the first note came, there was a second line on the back, I’d almost forgotten. *The town basket needs filling on the last night. You have the key.*”

He lifts his hands, helpless. “I’m a *volunteer* fireman, Jo. I have the key to *everything.* So I filled the basket, on the last night of each month, with a hundred envelopes, out of a carton that was left for me on the porch of the feed store.”

“Why?”

“To keep the thing going,” says Dewey. “So they’d never run out. So nobody’d notice a gap.” His voice cracks, slightly, on the last word. “And I never *asked.*”

---

It’s very quiet. A whip-poor-will starts up, somewhere off in the ferns, and stops.

I should be furious. It would be easy. I’ve got eighty-eight envelopes and a camera and my grandfather’s friend on a step, and I know exactly how to make a man wish he’d never been born, because I did it to my grandmother in the vault.

What I feel, instead, is tired.

It’s a different thing from anger. It’s older, and it sits lower. I think, *this is how it was for her. Eight years.* She sat in the kitchen, with the thing in her hands, a good thing done the wrong way, a dead son’s tags and a stranger’s money and a farm saved at the cost of a lake, and she couldn’t make it anything else.

“You thought it was Pearl,” I say. “Paying.”

“I did, for a while.”

“And then?”

“And then I thought it was Birchwater, trying to buy you,” says Dewey. “And then I thought it was a thing from your father, a kind of, a *bequest,* that he’d set up, and then the crate. You see, Jo, if I’d known it was his pump, the one I’d lost, if I’d known that was what I was paying *for,* I’d have told you the first night. I swear. I’d have told the Pope.”

He looks at the dark lodge. “I thought I was paying off a crate of scrap.”

“Dewey.”

“It was a good *pump*, Jo,” says Dewey, very low. “It was a *good* one.”

I put my hand on his big, stiff, knuckled one, on the bucket-lid, and neither of us says anything for quite a while.

Bernard sighs, and rolls over, and puts his chin on my boot.

---

I look at my watch, in the end. It’s ten to midnight, and I’ve a milking at five, and there’s a creature in the dark hills with a better knowledge of our days than any of us have of it.

“Left-handed,” I say. “On the tape. The one who lifted the flap was left-handed, with a limp.”

“That was me.”

“You’re left-handed.”

“Always have been.”

“With a bad knee. Since when?”

“Since the cow stepped on it in ’98,” says Dewey. “And I won’t say I’m not proud of the way I limp. It’s been improving for years.” He heaves a sigh. “Go on. You’ve got a question you haven’t asked.”

“What are you not telling me?”

“Nothing.”

“Dewey Marchand.”

“Nothing that’s mine,” says Dewey, with dignity.

“Whose?”

He turns his face away. The porch light lies along his cheek, and I see, in his profile, what I’ve not once, in thirty years, looked for in him: a stubborn, grieving, deeply honest man who has been handed one more promise than he can carry, and is carrying it anyway.

“There was a second note,” he says. “In 2020. After the first Christmas of the pandemic. It said, *You have been very good. Thank you. I know what it costs. If you ever wish to stop, leave the bin empty on the second, and the thing will end. No one will blame you.*”

“And you didn’t stop.”

“I left the bin empty on the second of January, 2021,” says Dewey. “The envelope was on the lid at six. With a note. It said, *Please.*”

I don’t say anything.

“Just that,” says Dewey. “And so I carried it. I don’t know who writes that word the way they write it. But I’ve said it to myself in the dark every month since.” He looks at me at last. “I didn’t want to tell you, Jo-Jo, because I was frightened that it wasn’t Birchwater, and it wasn’t Pearl, and it wasn’t anyone I’d ever want to be found out.”

“Why?”

“Because it’s someone who’s sorry,” says Dewey Marchand. “And I know what it looks like.”

---

We go down to the feed store at midnight, because it’s on the way home and because Dewey, who can’t drive with the knee, says he’d like to see the barrel once more before the sun comes up and spoils it.

I drive him. I don’t like to. He sits on the passenger side with his hands on his knees and Bernard across his lap, and when we pull in, at ten past twelve, under the single yellow lamp on the loading dock, nobody on the street.

The store’s dark, with its green door, and its old wooden letters: MARCHAND. Round the back there’s a gravel lot, a dumpster, and the barrel, a big one, a blue plastic drum, with the lid on, under a little tin awning that’s been there since he was a boy.

“It’s not the second,” I say. “Not for another twenty-five days.”

“It’s the eighth.”

“Then there’s nothing to see.”

“No,” says Dewey. “But I like to look.”

He gets out of the truck, laboriously. I help him. We go round, in the dim, between the shelves of fence posts and the pallets of salt, and I smell the whole of my childhood: sweet feed and rubber boots and the hot-metal smell of a hardware store at the end of summer. He puts his hand on the barrel lid. He stops.

“Oh,” he says.

There’s a dog-license envelope on top of the barrel.

It’s lying flat, weighted with a small gray stone, in the exact center of the lid.

“That’s not my brick,” says Dewey, very low. “I’ve held that lid down with a brick for twenty years, against the wind. Somebody took my brick and left me a stone.”

It’s as if the person wished him to know that they’d been close enough to touch his things, and had chosen to be polite about it.

The envelope is brown, and five inches by three, and it’s got a little pencil mark in the corner, in a hand I’ve seen eighty-eight times today.

It wasn’t there at three. Dewey says so, in a whisper; he checked it himself, on the way up to the cottage. It isn’t the second. It isn’t the first. It’s the eighth of July, at twelve-nineteen in the morning, and no one in the world was ever meant to be here.

“Don’t touch it,” I say.

“It’s got your name.”

It does. In block capitals, on the front, in the middle: *JOSIE.* Not *J. BELL.* Not *CUSTODIAL.* Just *JOSIE*, and underlined once, hard, by a hand that was shaking.

“Dewey,” I say. “Did you tell anyone? That I’d come tonight?”

“I told nobody a thing in seven years,” says Dewey. “I told Tibbetts I’d be home.”

“Then how did they know?”

“I don’t know,” says Dewey, in a voice worn thin as a dime. “I swear to you. I’d give anything to know.”

I pick up the stone. I take the envelope. The flap’s not sealed.

There’s a single slip inside, folded once. The pencil’s dark, as if the point were pressed so hard it nearly went through. It says, in capitals, five lines.

*JOSIE. THE QUIET IS RISING FASTER THAN HER NUMBERS.* *DO NOT LET THEM HAVE THE POND.* *TOMORROW AT FIVE THE STATE WILL PULL THE PERMIT.* *SAY YES TO IT. THEN COME FOR THE KEY.* *I AM SORRY ABOUT YOUR GRANDMOTHER. I AM SORRIER ABOUT THE REST.*

I read it by the loading-dock lamp, and I read it again, and my hands don’t shake, because I won’t let them.

“Tomorrow at five,” I say.

“What happens tomorrow at five?” says Dewey.

“Anders drives to the Agency,” I say, very slowly, “at eleven. To confess about the Study. We didn’t tell a soul but the people on the porch. Pearl and Odile, and Nolan, and a lawyer in a navy dress.” I look up, at the rim of the roof, at the black ridge beyond it, where the pond is brim-full under the stars and the Quiet’s rising, most of an inch an hour, to a line my father drew. “And whoever else was listening.”

Bernard, in the crook of Dewey’s arm, lifts his head and looks, for a long moment, up the hill.

He doesn’t bleat. It’s the only thing about the night that frightens me.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!