At five in the morning, in the parlor, with a doe on the ramp and the compressor shuddering, I hand Anders the envelope without a word, and watch him read it with his hair still wet from the pump.
He reads it once. He reads it again. He turns it over, as if the back might apologize.
“Somebody knew,” he says.
“Somebody heard it on the porch, or was told. Or guessed.”
“Nobody guessed that I’d drive to Montpelier at eleven. I didn’t know it myself till Delphine’s file came at two in the morning.” He gives the note back, very carefully, holding it by the edges as one holds a thing that might be evidence and might be a love letter. “Josie, do you want me to go?”
“What?”
“This says the State will pull the permit at five. It says to *say yes to it.* I have to ask. If I don’t go, there’s nothing for them to pull.” He leans on the stall rail. “I could wait. I could let Delphine write it up properly, send it on Friday, let the lawyers have a week to be lawyers.”
“The Quiet doesn’t have a week.”
“I know.”
“And you’d know, every morning, that you had a signature on a lie and a reason not to say so.” I hang the teat cups on the next doe, and she sighs. “You’d be sleeping in the bunk room, looking at the ceiling, with a very good reason.”
“I’m doing that anyway.”
“Then you may as well do it in a clean shirt,” I say. “Go to Montpelier. I’m coming.”
He looks at me for a long moment with the face I remember from the first week, when he stood in my barn lot in a suit that cost more than the truck. He’d said *I’d like to ask a question.* I’d said *no.*
“Can I ask a question?” says Anders.
“Yes.”
“Why is it that every time I decide to do the right thing, it costs me the one person I’d like to have do it with?”
“It doesn’t,” I say. “It costs you a tie. Wear the green one.”
---
It’s a hundred and ten miles to Montpelier by the back roads, two hours and ten minutes if you don’t stop for pie, and we stop for pie.
I don’t say so to anyone. It’s a diner in Greensboro, with a counter and a cow clock, and the woman who pours the coffee puts down two forks without asking, and Anders eats a whole slice of rhubarb at nine-forty in the morning with the look of a man at a last supper, and says, “It’s extremely good.”
“It’s from a goat farm,” says the woman. “The rhubarb. Up your way, as a matter of fact. Little place. They’ve got a billy that’s been in the paper.”
Anders puts down his fork. I study the cow clock.
“I’m sorry?” he says.
“Bernard,” says the woman. “Big white fella with a, well. I don’t like to say. A *bearing.*” She tops off my cup. “My nephew sent me the clipping. You’re not from there, are you, hon? You’ve got the wrong shoes.”
“I’m learning,” says Anders.
“Well, you’ll never learn it from a book,” says the woman, and goes to bring us the check, and Anders looks at me across the pie plate with his whole face going soft, and I think: *I’d walk a good deal further than Montpelier for that man.* I don’t say it. I say, “She’s right about the shoes.”
“I’ve got boots in the truck.”
“You wear them like a man in a play.”
“I’m a man in a play,” says Anders happily. “I’ve been in a play for a hundred and eighty-one days.”
He’s counted. I put my hand on the table beside his, not on it, just beside. It’s the best I can do at the diner counter, with a woman looking.
---
The Agency of Natural Resources is a long brick building in a parking lot, with a lobby that smells of floor wax and a security guard who looks as though he’s been told to be pleasant by someone he’s afraid of. We’re met at the elevator by a young man with a lanyard who says, “Mr. Lund, Ms. Bell, they’re expecting you in Conference B,” in a voice of such total neutrality that I know exactly how many people have already talked about us.
Conference B has a long table, a pitcher of water, and a screen on which, when we sit, there appears a face I’ve only ever seen in two inches of phone.
“Anders,” says Delphine Roux, from New Orleans. She’s fifty, and silver-haired, and wearing the expression of a woman who’s been awake since Sunday and is about to be proven right. “You’re on time. I’d hoped you’d be late. It shows more character.”
“I’m hours early,” says Anders.
“Then you’ve got a *lot* of character, and I bill by the hour.” She smiles at me. “Ms. Bell. We haven’t met. I’m told you’re the reason my client has stopped wearing socks with his loafers. Thank you.”
“It’s the boots,” I say.
“I’m sure it is.”
Across the table there are two people: Dr. Wendell Achterberg, whom I last saw on the Bath stair in a hard hat, now in a tie with small sheep on it, which I suspect was a gift; and a woman named Ruth Baptiste, who’s the Agency’s assistant counsel and has a legal pad, a fountain pen, and a face like the first page of a very good contract.
“Mr. Lund,” she says. “Before we begin, I’m obliged to tell you that anything you say today is voluntary, that you’re entitled to counsel, which I see you have, and that the Agency’s enforcement section will receive a copy of whatever transcript is prepared. Do you understand?”
“Yes,” says Anders.
“Do you wish to proceed?”
“I’d like,” he says, and stops, and starts again. “I’d like to read something.”
---
He’s written it on the back of a Notch Store receipt. It’s the only paper he’d had in the truck. He puts his glasses on, which he doesn’t need except when he’s nervous, and he reads it aloud in a voice that begins steady and gets steadier as it goes.
He says that in September of 2019 a document called Lund Fieldworks Siting Study Number Seven was submitted to the State of Vermont, bearing his signature. He says he never saw it. He says that in March of that year, as chief executive of Lund Asset, he’d signed a blanket delegation of his authority to a vice president for Land and Power, together with an electronic signature rider, because he was in Lisbon, and thought it was a routine thing, and didn’t read the rider.
He says the vice president was Nolan Pierce.
He says the Study states that the Ridge Pond is fed by a perennial surface source. He says that’s false. He says that, from what he’s since learned, the pond is fed by a pump on the quarry shaft, and the water comes from an underground reservoir that is not a source anyone has any right to take from, and that the Study, which was presented to the State as the foundation for the Pond Permit, was a lie. He says he’s sorry.
He says it quite plainly. I’ve known him since the first of April, and I’ve never heard him say so much in so few words.
“I authorized the template,” he says. “It was my company. I’m not asking the Agency to excuse me. I’m asking you to pull the permit, because it was granted on a false statement over my name, and I want my name off it.”
The room’s so quiet I can hear the pitcher sweat.
Ruth Baptiste has written nothing. She’s set her pen down on the pad, at an exact right angle, and she’s looking at Anders over her glasses as if he’d spoken in a language she studied at school and never expected to hear.
“Mr. Lund,” she says, “in eleven years at this Agency, I have received four hundred and two requests to revoke a permit. They were all from neighbors.” She picks up the pen. “You are the first applicant who’s ever asked to be penalized.”
“I’m not asking for a penalty,” says Anders.
“I know,” says Ruth Baptiste. “That’s why it’s going to be so expensive.”
---
It takes four hours.
It’s not cruel. I want to say that, because I’d been bracing for cruelty. It’s only patient, and exact. Dr. Achterberg, in his sheep tie, brings out Odile’s data on a laptop, her three weeks of gauge readings in a column that goes down the screen like a rain, and says, softly, “This young woman should be offered a position.”
Ruth Baptiste takes a statement from Delphine, and then another, from Anders, in question and answer, with a stenographer who has a gift for typing *um* as if it were a word in the dictionary.
Nobody offers us sandwiches.
A person in a lanyard brings us, at one, a plate of cut cantaloupe and a pitcher of lemonade, and we eat it like children at a church supper.
At a quarter to three, Ruth Baptiste says, “Dr. Achterberg?”
“I’ve no hesitation,” says the hydrologist. He takes off his glasses and rubs the bridge of his nose. “Permit 19-0441 was issued on a source finding that I can say, after yesterday’s examination, is materially incorrect. A perennial source would not have an intake pipe. I’d like to recommend suspension, with immediate effect.”
“And the pond?”
“It’s an unpermitted impoundment from the moment of suspension. It cannot receive discharge, and it cannot be maintained as a source-fed basin. The owner has to submit a dewatering plan.”
“Dewatering,” I say.
They all look at me. I’ve not spoken since the lemonade.
“Meaning *emptying*,” I say. “They have to empty it.”
“Within seventy-two hours of the order they submit a plan,” says Dr. Achterberg, gently. “To drain the pond at a controlled rate to a lawful outlet. If they fail, or refuse, the Agency can step in under the emergency provision and do it itself, with notice to the District.”
“With the *key*.”
“With whatever’s needed,” says Ruth Baptiste. “Ms. Bell, may I ask what you’re thinking?”
I’m thinking of a note on a barrel. *SAY YES TO IT. THEN COME FOR THE KEY.* I’m thinking of a pond that was a dry catch basin, built to take the overflow of a lake on the day the lake was too high, and a man in a good coat who filled it to the brim and fenced it.
“I’m thinking,” I say, “that a pond has to be empty to be a relief.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“Nothing. Yes,” I say. “I’d like to say yes.”
“To what, exactly?”
“To the suspension,” I say, and I look at Anders, and Anders is looking at me, and I think, for the first time all day, that his face is the face of a man who’s just found out that the thing he’s done at such cost might also be the thing that opens a door.
“It’s a good order,” says Dr. Achterberg. “It’s the only one I can sign.”
---
It’s signed at four fifty-eight, in the hallway, on the back of a clipboard, because the conference room’s been taken for a hearing about a landfill, and the document’s one page, with two sentences in the middle that I read over his shoulder:
*The Agency hereby suspends Pond Permit 19-0441, effective 5:00 p.m., July 8. The permittee shall submit a dewatering plan within seventy-two hours.*
“Three days,” I say.
“Until Saturday at five.”
“And if Birchwater submits a plan?”
“Then they’ll drain it to a lawful outlet, at a rate we approve, with an inspector present,” says Ruth Baptiste. “And the gate’s opened in the presence of the Agency.”
“And if they don’t?”
“Then it’s a pleasure to act,” she says, with the first smile I’ve seen on her, narrow as a pen-nib. “I’ve been waiting a long time to act. Mr. Lund, you’ve done something remarkable. I’m aware it didn’t feel like it.”
“It felt like being sick,” says Anders.
“That,” says Ruth Baptiste, “is what remarkable feels like, in my experience. Good afternoon.”
---
Nolan Pierce is waiting by the elevator when we come out of Conference B.
He’s alone. The woman in the navy dress isn’t with him, and he’s taken off his jacket, and he’s standing with one shoulder against the wall and his phone dark in his hand, like a man who has been told something on the stairs and hasn’t decided to believe it. He doesn’t look sixty today. He looks about his own age, which is worse.
“Chief,” he says.
“Nolan.”
“I heard you were here. The Agency copies Birchwater’s counsel on everything, as a courtesy. It’s a very fast courtesy.” He turns the phone over. “Ellory’s going to file an appeal tonight. She’ll say your statement was made under duress, that the delegation was valid, that the Study was reviewed by a licensed engineer.”
“Was it?”
“It was reviewed by me,” says Nolan, “and I’m not an engineer.”
Anders says nothing. He’s learned, in the last hundred and eighty days, that the quickest way to hear a thing is to let a man finish it.
“I want you to know I didn’t know about the pond,” says Nolan, and his voice has lost the team in it, the hi-vis cheer; it’s a thin, tired, ordinary voice, a man’s alone in a corridor. “Not what it was for. I signed what Hale sent. He said it was a retention basin, for fire suppression, for the Notch North lodge. I thought, a pond. That’s not a thing you lose sleep over.”
“You’re losing it now,” I say.
“I haven’t slept since Monday.” He looks at me, properly, for the first time. “Ms. Bell, the death certificate. I’d like to say something about the death certificate, and I can’t, because there’s a lawyer, and she’d have my license. But I wanted you to know I’m not the one who drew it up.”
“Who did?”
The elevator opens. A woman with a cart of files gets out and looks at the three of us and, wisely, goes the other way. Nolan watches her go.
“Ask the Clerk,” he says, “who stamped the first page.”
The doors close on him before I can say a word.
---
We’re in the truck on Route 2 by a quarter past, with the window down and the whole warm green length of the state rolling past, when my phone goes.
It’s Odile. I put her on speaker and she’s breathing as though she’s run up a stair.
“Josie. Josie, where are you?”
“A hundred miles out. Odile, what is it?”
“It’s the Quiet.” Her voice cracks. “I read the logger at four. And again at five, from the Bath, by hand. It was one eighty-seven point one at six last night. It’s one ninety-one point three.”
I do the arithmetic, and don’t like it.
“That’s four feet.”
“Four point two feet in twenty-three hours. Not one point four a day, Josie. It’s three times what I said, and that’s only the average.” She’s whispering now, as though the Quiet might hear. “I’ve the logger trace. It crawled at the old rate until nine this morning, and then it went up like a hockey stick. It’s as if something shut.”
“Shut where?”
“I don’t know.” She’s crying. “I don’t know. There was nothing I could see. I walked every pipe in the Bath, and the valve room, and the gauge wall. Josie, I did the full-pool arithmetic again. Even at just the day’s average it’s two-fourteen in five and a half days.”
“Five and a half.”
“Monday the thirteenth. Early, before breakfast, if the last eight hours are the pace and not just the mean.” I hear a door open, and the sound of the Bath, hollow and wet. “The Lid’s already creaking. Thad’s sitting on the stair with a thermos. He says it’s making a noise like his father’s knees.”
“We’re coming,” says Anders.
“Don’t hurry. It won’t help.” Her voice steadies, a little, like a girl who’s remembered that she’s a scientist. “I wanted to ask you one thing. *Where was the note?*”
“What note?”
“Dewey called me at six this morning. He told me about the barrel. *The Quiet is rising faster than her numbers.* Josie, I only worked out the faster rate at four o’clock this afternoon. It was in the note you got at *midnight.*”
I turn my head and look at Anders. He’s very white. The road goes under us in a long unbroken line.
“Then it’s not a guess,” says Anders.
“No,” I say. “It’s not.”
“Somebody told us, seventeen hours before the water did, what it was going to do.”
“Odile,” I say. “How fast does a thing have to be shut to do this?”
“By hand, in one go,” says Odile. “Josie, it’s not a leak. It’s *deliberate.*” A silence, a long one, on the speaker. “Someone has closed something, this morning, at nine. And they’d written to you that they’d known.”
The speedometer needle trembles against the line. I think, with great clarity, of a quiet figure in a dark rain jacket, a pencil, a bin, and a promise, and a dead man’s list of three. Somewhere in the hills someone has turned a wheel, and written me a warning about it first.
I don’t know yet whether that makes them a friend. I understand, with a cold bright lurch like a stair that isn’t there, that they wanted me to be watching.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!