We reach the Bath at ten to eight on Wednesday evening, with the last of the sun on the ridge and the church clock telling anyone who cares that it’s five to eight, which it isn’t, and which it is.
I haven’t been down in five days. I’d forgotten the smell. It comes up the lowest stair like a breath from somebody sleeping: cold stone, wet lime, a faint warm sweetness that is the Kettle, and under it something I can’t name and don’t want to, a mineral, patient, very old smell, as of a cellar that has been waiting for a visitor since the Ice Age.
Thad Quill is sitting on the seventh rung from the top in his oatmeal cardigan, with a thermos between his knees and his straw hat on his lap. He rises when he sees me, with the care of a man whose hip has opinions.
“Ms. Bell.”
“Mr. Quill.”
“I’ve been here since noon, on the Judge’s order, as the Quill of record. I have not touched a thing.” He holds up his hands, clean and spotted, and I believe him. “It’s all in the log, in ink, with the times.”
“I believe you,” I say. “Odile?”
“Down here,” says her voice, from the dark.
---
There are sixty-one rungs, an iron ladder bolted into a shaft of dry-laid stone, and I count them, as I always do, because Ray counted them and Walt before him, and because counting is the only way I know to keep from thinking about the water.
At the bottom there’s a landing, a platform of oak planks that the District’s volunteers laid on Saturday, with a rope rail. It’s cold and bright and loud. Anders has put in two work lights on poles, and they throw our shadows a hundred feet up the walls, onto the tally marks of three men and a long dead century of arithmetic.
Odile’s at the rail with a flashlight in her teeth and a clipboard under her arm. She takes the flashlight out when she sees me.
“Look at the Lid,” she says.
I do. It’s there, floating in its great dark room, a plate of tiled lead the size of a church floor, lying on the water like a lily pad, with a long crack across it where the hole is. Since Friday it has risen a good eleven feet. It’s very close now to the quarry roof. When I put the light on it I can see a fine rain of grit coming down from the stone where its edge scrapes.
“It’s *breathing*,” says Anders, softly, at my shoulder.
It is. It rises a quarter of an inch, with a long slow groan, and holds, and settles. I think of Pearl asleep. I think of the Skeleton’s dead windows.
“Where’s the wheel?” I say.
---
The return wheel is on the north wall, behind a post, where I’d have missed it for years if Walt hadn’t painted it red. It’s an old iron valve wheel, two feet across, with six spokes, bolted to a pipe the width of my thigh that comes down out of the rock and goes into the water in a long cold curve.
On Friday morning, after the lock, I’d turned it a quarter-turn. A quarter. Odile had measured it with a ruler. Four gallons a minute, a trickle, enough to put the spring’s own overflow back where it came from, no more.
It’s open all the way.
I can tell before I touch it. The pipe’s humming. It’s a note I know from the barn, from a pump dragging on a half-full tank. And at the rim of the wheel, where it should have been stiff with a week of cold, a thumb of grease has smeared along the spoke, and caught the light.
“It was at one-quarter at seven this morning,” says Odile. “I logged it. I took a photograph.”
“Show me.”
She does. On the phone, in the work light, the little red wheel with its pointer at the quarter.
“So between seven and nine,” says Anders.
“Between seven and nine, someone came down sixty-one rungs, past a lock under a judge’s seal, turned this wheel the whole way,” says Odile, and her voice is shaking, now, with something that’s not entirely fear, “and put *this* in the spokes.”
Anders lays his palm flat on the pipe, as you’d feel a child’s forehead, and takes it away fast. “It’s cold,” he says. “But it’s shaking. There’s a lot of water going through this.”
“Eleven hours of it,” says Odile. “Ten and a half, if she turned it at nine and we count from the logger.”
There’s a pencil.
It’s jammed through two spokes, like a bolt through a gate, a thick flat carpenter’s pencil, red, with the end chewed, and a loop of green string tied round it. Hanging from the string, on a little manila tag with a reinforced eyelet, is a card I’d know in the dark.
I take it by the string. I turn it to the light.
*RETURN. FULL. 9 A.M. Wed.* *YOU WILL WANT TO UNDO THIS. DO NOT, UNTIL SUNDAY NIGHT.* *THE POND MUST BE EMPTY BEFORE THE QUIET IS FULL. THIS IS HOW YOU GET BOTH.* *—A FRIEND.*
---
Nobody speaks. Above us, in the dark, the Lid scrapes the stone and moans.
“It’s a very good argument,” says Thad, behind me. He’s come down, after all, one rung at a time, and he’s sitting on the bottom one now with his hat in his lap. “I’d like to be clear that I’m not saying it’s right. But it’s a good one.”
“Explain,” says Anders.
“The pond has to be empty to be a relief,” says Thad. “You’ve worked that out. I heard what you said in the conference room; Ms. Baptiste telephoned me. Now. The pond won’t be emptied by Saturday at five, because Birchwater will submit a plan that takes ten days. They’re lawyers. They’ll say it can be drained at forty gallons a minute, over three weeks, to protect a downstream trout.”
“There’s no trout,” says Odile.
“There’s always a trout,” says Thad. “It’s the most reliable fish in Vermont.” He sighs. “So you’d have a full pond and a full lake and the Lid at the roof and nowhere to put a drop. Whoever wrote this means to *force* the matter. Fill the Quiet quickly, so that when it’s nearly full, the Agency has to step in with the key, and the pond’s emptied under an emergency order in two days instead of three weeks.”
“It’s blackmail,” says Anders.
“It’s a clock,” says Thad. “It’s a very frightening, very clever clock, that someone’s set to run faster than a man in a good coat can lie.”
“And if it’s wrong?”
“Then the Lid lifts,” says Odile, “and the Bath’s gone, and Mr. Quill’s Covenant’s breached by a person unknown, and nobody’s ever going to know the Quiet again.”
I look at the wheel, and the pencil, and the little tag in my palm. It’s such a neat, kind, deadly little note. It has a *please* in it, I swear, though the word’s not there.
“Odile,” I say. “What happens if I turn it back?”
---
She does it on the clipboard, on her knee, in the light of the poles, with her tongue between her teeth and a rain of grit falling round her like a benediction.
“Wheel at a quarter,” she says. “Four gallons a minute. The Quiet’s rising at one point four feet a day, if nothing else has changed. Full pool in sixteen days. Friday the twenty-fourth. If the pond’s submitted plan takes three weeks, it’s empty on the second of August, and the Lid’s lifted ten days before. You’d need the key, and you’d need the gate, and you’d need it in a fortnight.”
“And with the wheel wide open?”
“Monday the thirteenth, early.” She wipes her face. “At the day’s average. If the last eight hours’ pace holds, I’d rather not say.”
She checks the figure twice before she goes on. “The Agency’s order gives Birchwater till Saturday at five. Then the Agency steps in, if they refuse. If the gate’s opened on Sunday, you’d have a whole empty pond by Monday morning, if the outlet’s big enough. It just about works. On the *arithmetic.* If every single thing goes the way somebody’s planned.”
“Every single thing.”
“Josie,” says Odile. “It depends on a man who’s lied to the State for seven years telling the truth by Saturday.”
“It depends,” says Anders, “on somebody we’ve never met.”
“And on a key we haven’t seen.”
“And on a gate we don’t know.”
“And on the Lid,” says Thad Quill, very quietly, to his hat, “being as strong on Monday as Edmund Vail told my father it would be.”
I put the little tag in the breast pocket of my father’s coat. I take the wheel in both hands. It’s stiff, and cold, and slippery with somebody’s grease.
“Respectfully,” I say, to the dark, to a stranger who isn’t there, “no.”
---
It takes both Anders and me to turn it. Odile counts. At every full revolution we say the number out loud, as Walt must have, and Ray, and in the groaning, dripping dark the sound of it is almost a prayer: *one, two, three, four.* The pipe’s hum slows, and drops, and slides at last into a low contented burr, and I feel the whole hill let out a breath.
At nine and a quarter turns, I stop. Odile checks the pointer against the ruler.
“A quarter,” she says. “Where it started.”
“It’s where it *should* be,” I say. “I’m not going to run a bet on my father’s lake.”
Odile writes the time on the clipboard: 8:21 p.m., wheel at one quarter, hand-turned, two witnesses and a Quill. She underlines the *two witnesses* and, after a moment, the *Quill*, which makes Thad go pink under his hat.
“Josie.” Thad’s face is very pale in the light. “The note says Sunday.”
“The note says a lot of things. I can’t read the person behind it. I can read a flume.” I lean on the wheel, and I feel, for the first time since the Bath, absolutely calm. “I’ll go with the one I can count.”
“And the Lid?”
“We’ll have two weeks. Two weeks and a half. That’s long enough to find a key.”
“You hope.”
“I hope, and I count,” I say. “It’s the family business.”
No one argues. The Lid groans once more, and settles a half-inch, and I put my hand against the cold stone beside the wheel, where Walt’s tally marks begin, and I say, under my breath, to a man I never knew as a man, only as a smell of pipe tobacco and a pair of big, careful hands: *I’m sorry. I’m doing it by your book.*
---
How did they get in?
It’s Anders who asks it, as we stand on the landing and the poles hum. “The lock was sealed,” he says. “The Judge’s tape was on the riser at six. I took the photograph. There’s no one in the valley but Thad and Odile and me with a key to that stair.”
“And me,” says Thad. “I gave mine to Josie.”
“And me,” I say. “Which I wear round my neck.”
“Then it’s not the stair,” says Odile.
She puts the flashlight against the ceiling. Her voice is small and clear in the dripping dark. “The 1890s survey. There’s a second throat. The quarry shaft goes up and up and has a second mouth, the one the pump sits on, in the Skeleton.”
She swings the beam along the north wall, past the tally marks, to a place where the rock sweeps up into a dome. “There. That’s the foot of the shaft. It’s been a hundred and thirty feet of open air, with a water pump on top.”
“You could climb it,” says Anders.
“Only if you’d done it before,” says Thad Quill.
---
We come up, in the end, by the sixty-one rungs, and the sun’s already off the ridge. Anders drives, because I’ve been shaking for a quarter of an hour without knowing it, and Odile sits in the back with the clipboard, and we go up the Skeleton drive with the lights off, past the lodge and the tennis court and the long, empty porch, to the pool house.
It’s Dewey who meets us at the door, in his slippers and his gray cap, with a flashlight, and the knee, and Bernard standing at his heel like a black-and-white shadow with a beard.
“I heard the truck,” he says. “I didn’t sleep.”
“Show us the pump,” I say.
The pool room is a long bare chamber with a dry blue pool in the middle and a smell of chlorine so old it’s turned to dust. At the far end, over a rail, the big gray pump sits on its steel frame, over a hole in the floor, a black, round, cold hole, five feet across, with the Corliss pipe going down into it like a tongue.
I put the light into it, and the beam goes down, and down, and doesn’t come back.
“Don’t lean,” says Dewey, behind me, and puts his hand in the back of my coat.
There’s a rope.
It’s a new one, white, braided, as thick as my thumb, and it’s tied to the pump’s steel frame with a round-turn and two half-hitches, a good knot, a sailor’s knot, a knot I can’t tie myself. It runs over the lip of the hole and down into the dark. There’s a smear of grease on the rail, where a hand’s been put. In the dust, beside the frame, are the prints of a pair of boots, in a lug sole I know: Vibram, a size or two under mine.
“It’s a woman’s boot,” says Odile, softly.
“Or a small man’s.”
“Or a boy’s,” says Anders. “Or Moses’s, I suppose.”
“Moses wouldn’t put a rope on a thing without ten minutes of conversation,” I say.
“Dewey.” The big man doesn’t move. “Did you see anybody come?”
“I didn’t see a soul.”
“Did you hear?”
“I heard the dog,” says Dewey.
I look at Bernard.
He’s sitting at the lip of the hole, looking down, with his head on one side. He isn’t afraid. He doesn’t sniff. He looks, as I’ve seen him look at Pearl on a bad day, at Lorraine in the cheese room, at Anders, once, in the first week, when he stopped being a stranger. He looks, in the beam of the flashlight, with a long, dry, entirely accustomed face, at a rope he knows.
“He didn’t bark,” says Dewey.
“No.”
“He barks at *everyone,*” says Dewey. “He barked at the *bishop.*”
“I know.”
“Jo.” Dewey takes off his cap, and turns it round in his big spotted hands. “That’s not a stranger’s rope.”
---
I go home at midnight with my mind going round like a wheel on a pencil.
The farmhouse is dark but for the kitchen lamp. Pearl’s at the table, in her robe, with a cup of tea gone cold in front of her, and she doesn’t look up when I come in. There’s a small plate beside the cup with two gingersnaps on it. She’s made them for me.
I sit down. I take one. We eat, in the lamp’s small yellow circle, without a word.
“Gram,” I say, at last.
“Yes.”
“Who’s been told about Montpelier?”
“Nobody,” says Pearl. “I didn’t even tell the hens.”
“Somebody knew.”
“Somebody’s always known,” says my grandmother, with her old, level, unrepentant face, and I look at her, hard, for the first time since the vault, and I see, in her eyes, under the steel, a thing I’ve never seen there before. It’s fear, and it isn’t for herself.
“I’ve thought for seven years it was a person I knew. And I’ve been afraid, Josephine, every day, that if I once found out which, I’d have to say thank you, and I’d have to say sorry, and I don’t know that I could do either.”
“Do you think it’s one person?”
“I think,” says Pearl, “that it’s somebody who isn’t finished.”
My phone buzzes on the oilcloth.
It’s Thad’s paralegal, Priya, a text, at twelve-eleven in the morning, with a photograph attached. I open it with one thumb. It’s a scanned page, gray, official, with a state seal in the corner and the words CERTIFICATE OF DEATH across the top in a heavy black type.
*Name of decedent: Hale, Francis A.* *Date of death: October 3, 2021.* *Place of death: Larkin Notch, Vermont.* *Informant: Pierce, Nolan R. Relationship: business associate.* *Disposition: Cremation. Remains to informant.*
Underneath, Priya has typed:
*Nolan told us Hale died “on vacation.” The certificate says here. Is there a record in your Town Clerk’s book?*
I turn the phone to Pearl, and she reads it, and I watch her put down her cup.
“Hale,” she says. “The man in the good coat.”
“Francis A.,” I say. I look at the line. *Larkin Notch.* “Gram. Somebody died in my town, in 2021, and Opal Strand never wrote it in her book.”
“Or nobody died,” says Pearl, “and somebody wrote down that they did.”
The kitchen clock ticks. Up on the ridge, a long way off, the pond lies brim-full and black in the starlight, and under the Skeleton a rope hangs down a hole in the dark, and my father’s Quiet rises, a little less than an inch an hour, toward a line he drew.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!