Walt Gerrity says that every meeting in the history of labor has been won or lost in the fifteen minutes before it starts, and he has never said it so seriously.
It is eight-twenty. We are at the Harrow table with the cards spread out in front of us, and Lou on my left, and Walt on the bench behind, leaning forward with his elbows on his knees like a man at a ringside. The skylight has gone from bruise to pewter. The Stewards are coming to their places. I hear the scrape of folding chairs and the small cough of a century and a half of dead men clearing their throats.
“Here’s the problem,” says Walt, quietly. “Voss files the motion. It’s in order. Article Twenty-three says a voice may be lent. It doesn’t say the Steward has to agree. It says ‘chosen by the house.’ The house is the Association. Voss chooses Dale, Dale says ‘don’t mind if I do,’ and at nine o’clock the roll is called, and when they get to your name, a voice comes out of your mouth that you didn’t give.”
I write: WHAT DOES IT SAY?
“Anything. ‘Present.’ That’s all it has to say. The Article only needs a Steward at Rest to be heard on the floor. They don’t care what you say. They want the sound.”
I look at the card. It is the best piece of procedure I have heard all weekend, and it is the Owners’ procedure. It is clean, and legal, and kind. It would cost the Owners nothing at all. And it would cost Dale a voice, and he would give it, and say thank you.
“We can’t stop him offering,” says Walt. “He’s a member in good standing. He’s entitled to be heard.”
“We can stop it counting,” says Lou.
---
I had not heard her say it in that voice before. It is her own, the flat, level, Maine voice, but there is a grain in it that I have heard in a very different kind of person. It is the voice of someone who has made a decision and is about to be sick.
“Say it again,” says Walt.
“The Article says the voice has to be heard on the floor.” She is looking at Odalys’s table, not at us. “Not just made. Heard. By the Assembly. It’s a roll call. So the Recording Secretary has to hear it, and enter it. That’s his job.” She swallows. “What if he doesn’t have to?”
“The Secretary’s got no discretion,” says Walt. “It’s a duty.”
“No. Not that.” Lou’s hands have gone white on the edge of the table. “What if there’s a question that comes before the roll? What if, before you call the first name, someone moves a thing that has to be dealt with first? A matter of privilege. The Article about the Light’s own count. Odie said, Master Article Zero.” She says it carefully, like a girl reading a line that she has been taught. “’No head is entered that has not first been asked.’”
I know what she is going to say, and I would give almost anything to stop her.
“Seat Six,” says Lou. “She’s seated by courtesy. She’s never been called. She’s never been asked. The Association is voting with her chair, and she isn’t on any roll. Under Zero, it’s irregular.” She looks at me at last. “So we move to call her. Before the vote. Before the lent voice. We move that the roll of the Association’s Table be called, in full, and the Creditor be asked, by name, whether she is present.”
---
I write nothing for a time.
I know that it is good. It has the clean ring of a thing that works. It uses the Owners’ own table-plan against them. It takes Midge’s demand, name the lender, on the floor, in her own hand, and it turns it from a request into a point of order, and a point of order cannot be voted down by a majority. It must be ruled.
And I know that it is the only way, and I know what it costs.
She does not take. She asks. And if somebody calls her, if somebody says her name aloud before eleven Stewards and a Recording Secretary and a Roll, then that somebody has asked. Has put her on the record. Has done, in front of the whole coast, what that old woman has been doing for a hundred and thirty-seven years, in kitchens and on motel walks and across a table in the dark.
I take a card. I write it in the best hand that I have.
IT’S AN ASK. IT’LL BE CHARGED. TO THE ONE WHO ASKS.
“I know,” says Lou.
NOT YOU.
“I’m the Witness. I’m the only one who can say it. You can’t talk.” She gives a short, hard laugh. “Dale’s not allowed. Walt’s not on the roll. Wren’s eleven.” Her face crumples briefly, and is mended. “It’s okay, Odie. It’s my rule. I made the call.”
I have heard it before. It is the line she said on the night that she stayed dry. She has been standing behind it ever since, like a wall, and I think that it is the only wall she has.
I take the card, and I tear it in half. It does not help.
“There’s a rule for this,” says Walt, suddenly. He has gone quite quiet. He is looking at Lou with the expression of a man who has watched a great many people take a hit and has not, in thirty-one years, once found a way to like it. “Under every system I know, the one who moves the question carries it. You move, somebody seconds. If it carries, you’ve done what you set out to do. If it’s ruled out of order, you eat it.”
“Who seconds?” says Lou.
I look around the hall.
---
Ten of the eleven Stewards are within thirty feet of us. I know their faces now. I know what they are afraid of, and what they would give. But a second is a small, hard thing. It is a person in the middle of a roomful of strangers saying: I am with you. I am prepared to be counted next to this.
Maura Quill would, but Maura is across the hall in Local Three’s seat with her face turned to the stair. Dennis Halloran, in his chair, has his hand on his daughter’s shoulder. Wren is awake. She is looking at me over the rim of a paper cup, with her gray eyes narrow, and she has a pencil behind her ear, which is a thing she has caught from Walt.
“I can’t,” says Wren, in her small clear voice, not very loudly. “I’m not a Steward. I gave up the chair.”
“No,” says Walt. “That’s right.”
“But I can tell you who can,” says Wren.
I follow her gaze, and I think, at first, that she is looking at the Owners’ table.
She is. She is looking at Philippa Pelham-Ward.
---
It is the first time in my life that I have regretted a plan before I had finished having it.
Philippa is sitting in her place, in a gray silk blouse and no cardigan, with a fresh cup of tea at her elbow and her uncovered hand open on the cloth. She has her eyes on the glass. It is full again. It is full to the brim, and it has not gone down since a quarter to five, and she has not once looked away from it.
I cross the floor. I do it slowly, with Lou’s hand in my sleeve. I do not make a sound. I stop on the Harrow side of the cloth, three feet from the Chair of the Owners, and I put a card on the table, face up, between the pitcher and the glass.
SECOND LOU’S MOTION.
She reads it. She takes a very long time. She puts her bare hand flat over her mouth.
“Miss Brandt,” says Philippa, from behind it. “You are asking the Chair of the Association to second a motion that the Association’s own table be called.”
I nod.
“To call Seat Six. Before the vote. On the floor.” Her voice is shaking. “I should be breaking the one rule that I was given. My mother said it, the night that I was seated. Never call her. Never. Never ask.”
I write: DO YOU KNOW WHY?
“No.” She lowers the hand. She has been crying, I think, for some time, without any sound, as a woman cries who has been taught that it is rude. “I never knew. I only ever knew that it was not done.” She looks at the cushion. It is wet, and the print is there, narrow and neat. “And she has been so very patient.”
I wait.
I have been in a great many rooms with a great many people who were about to choose. I know that there is nothing you can do for them. You can ask your question. You can stop. You can not fill the silence.
“I should like it entered,” says Philippa Pelham-Ward, at last, very softly, “that I second the motion. And that I should have done it thirty years ago.”
---
At eight-forty the Chair brings the Assembly to order.
Bernadette Kuhn stands behind her table with her hair done up in its long gray plait and her sash across her chest, and strikes the board with an old wooden gavel. It sounds like a tree falling in another county. The Stewards rise. The doors, which have been sealed for two days, do not open, but a draught goes through the hall from somewhere, and the lamps lean.
Odalys reads the minutes of the night. He does it quickly. He reads out the roll of the Lights, which counted at three-twelve; he reads out the entry for Pruitt, W. He reads, without a tremor, the line for 213. He does not look at Dale. Dale, on his folding chair at the back with his cap on his knee, nods, politely, as to a greeting.
“There is one matter,” says Bernadette, “of business before the Chair. The Association has given notice of a procedural motion under Article Twenty-three of the Local Articles, and Master Article Twenty-six. Mr. Voss.”
Haldane Voss rises.
He has a manuscript, in his own hand, on an index card, and he reads it in a beautiful, even, reasonable voice. It takes him less than a minute.
He says that the Association, being anxious that no vote should be questioned afterwards for want of form, moves that the Assembly receive, for the purpose of Article Twenty-six, a lent voice for the Steward of Local Nine. He says that a member, Mr. Ferreira, has kindly offered. He says that this is an act of courtesy to the Steward, who would otherwise, he regrets, be silenced by a technicality.
He sits.
“Is there a second?” says Bernadette.
“The Chair of Local Eight seconds,” says the gray woman in the fish-market apron, without getting up.
“The motion is before the Assembly.” Bernadette looks down the table with her tired, honest, unhappy face. “The Chair will take discussion. Is there any...”
“Point of privilege,” says Lou.
---
I have said that it is a small voice. It is the first time I have heard it fill a room.
Lou Pruitt gets to her feet in her socks, in her father’s flannel, in the middle of the Harrow table. She is nineteen. She holds a single index card in her left hand, which she does not need, and her right hand is a fist at her side. She does not say anything for a moment. She breathes. I can hear it. I can hear her do the four, the in and the out, for me.
“Local Nine,” says Lou. “Witness. For Brandt, O.” She says it all in one, quite flat, and a little too fast. “A question of privilege. Before the motion, before the roll, a question touching the Assembly’s own roll.”
“The Chair recognizes the Witness,” says Bernadette. She has half risen. Her eyes have gone to Odalys’s table.
“Master Article Zero,” says Lou. “The Light counts only those who answer. No head is entered that has not first been asked.” She is reading it off the card now, in a thin even voice. “The Association’s Table is seated in six chairs. Five are called at each session.
The Sixth has never been called. She is, by the Association’s own plan, a Creditor. She holds the paper for the offer that the Assembly is asked to vote on, and she has never been asked, on this floor, whether she is present.”
“The Witness is out of order,” says Haldane Voss, politely, rising.
“The Witness is not,” says Odalys. His voice is a thread, but it cuts. “The question is a point of privilege, and it touches the validity of the proceeding. It must be put to the Chair.”
“It has a second,” says Philippa Pelham-Ward.
Everyone turns.
She has not stood. She has her hands folded on the cloth, and her face is white, and she speaks in the small, clear, dutiful voice of a girl at a recital. “The Chair of the Association seconds the Witness’s motion. And asks that the minutes show that she does so of her own free will.”
---
The silence that follows is not a quiet. It is a thing with edges.
I watch Haldane Voss. He has smiled for two days, and now he does not. He turns his head, slowly, as though on a pivot, and looks at the Chair of the Owners, and I see that he has never in his life seen her do this. It is not anger. It is what a man’s face does when a familiar wall in his own house is found to have a door.
“Madam Chair,” says Voss, gently. “I submit that the Association’s table is not the Assembly’s business.”
“It is,” says Bernadette Kuhn.
She says it in a voice I have not heard. It is not tired. It is the old, level, iron voice of a woman who has run a house full of other people’s husbands and never once let one leave without paying. She sets her hands on the table. “The Association has laid a tender before this Assembly.
It has asked us to take it on a Creditor’s paper. By the Master Articles, a party that asks the Assembly for assent is a party before the Assembly. I will not put a motion on the lent voice until I have put the privilege.” She turns. “Mr. Recording Secretary. The question.”
Odalys stands.
“The motion is that the Roll of the Association’s Table be called, in full, before any further business, and that the Creditor of Seat Six be asked whether she is present.” He swallows. “It is moved by the Witness for Local Nine, seconded by the Chair of the Association. It is a point of privilege, and the Chair has ruled it in order. It does not require a vote. It requires only a caller.”
“Who is the caller?” says Bernadette.
“The mover,” says Odalys, quite gently. “It is customary.”
Lou looks at me.
I think that I will remember it for the rest of my life.
She is standing in the lamplight with her face shut like a door, and her hand on the table, and she is looking at me with the exact expression that she wore on the night she chose to stay dry, when she decided something because nobody else would and found that her whole life had been altered by a single sentence. She does not look afraid. She looks like a person who has finished being afraid, and is now only tired.
I nod.
I cannot say go. I cannot say don’t. I have no count and no voice and no right, and the only thing that is mine to give her is the nod, and I give it, and I hate it for being so small.
---
The roll of the Association’s Table is called at eight fifty-eight.
It is, as Walt says afterwards, the longest two minutes of procedure that he has ever sat through, and he has been to a Teamsters convention. Odalys reads the entries from the plan in a clear, even voice, and each name rings in the iron hall.
“Seat One. Chair. Pelham-Ward, P.”
“Present,” says Philippa, in a whisper.
“Seat Two. Proxy. Voss, H.”
“Present.”
“Seat Three. Proxy.”
There is a silence. Then, from the dark behind the Association’s table, where no chair stands, a tick, a small scratch, like a nib on paper. The minute book writes by itself. PRESENT, BY PROXY. I see Walt cross himself, which I had not known he did.
“Seat Four. Proxy.”
Tick.
“Seat Five. Proxy.”
Tick.
There are five. It takes a long time. And then Odalys stops, and looks down at the sheet, and I see him straighten his shoulders, like a boy at a spelling bee who has been given a word in a language he does not speak.
“Seat Six,” he says. “Creditor. Seated by courtesy.”
He stops. He looks at Lou.
She has to do it herself. It is the rule. The caller asks.
Lou puts her fist against her breastbone. She takes a long breath. She looks across the hall at the empty chair, at the wet cushion, at the glass, which is full to the brim and beaded with cold, and I see her lips shape the four. In, two, three, four. Out, two, three, four.
“Seat Six,” says Lou Pruitt, in the flat clear voice of a girl from the end of the Neck. “Creditor. The Assembly asks whether you are present. Would you mind very much, ma’am, if we put your name down?”
---
Nothing happens. I count it. I cannot, I have no number, and so I do it in the old way, by the beating of my own heart.
It beats nine times.
Then the glass moves.
It does not tip or tremble. It slides, a quarter of an inch across the cloth, toward the edge of the table, toward Lou, with a small dry sound, like a chair being drawn out for somebody to sit.
And the water in it goes down.
It goes down all at once, not sipped, not drunk, but gone, in a single downward breath, as if a hand had passed over it and taken the whole glass back into the pitcher. The cushion creaks. The wet print in it deepens. And in the stillness I hear, quite distinctly, from the wrong side of the room, the click of a ballpoint pen.
It is a blue Bic. I have heard that click all my life. It is the sound of a woman capping a pen on the other side of a bedroom door.
On the minute book, which lies open on the Secretary’s table, a line is being written in the margin under the Harrow call, in blue, and under the blue, quite slowly, in copper, another.
Odalys reads it. He reads it aloud, because it is his office, and I watch his face go gray.
“Entered at eight fifty-nine,” says Odalys Brandt. “Pruitt, L. Witness. Asked.” He draws a breath. “Date of entry, blank. Next.”
Lou does not move. She is still standing with her fist on her breastbone and her eyes on the empty glass. She does not seem to have heard.
“And on the Association’s Table,” says Odalys, in a thread, “Seat Six. Creditor. Present.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!