Priya calls at ten past six on Tuesday morning, and I cannot answer, so Lou does it for me.
We are back at Paulding Falls. We came in after midnight, in Maura’s pickup, with Dennis riding in the bed under the tarp and Wren asleep against my shoulder, and the mill hall received us the way a ship’s galley receives a boat that has come in late, with a cup of something hot and no questions.
I have had three hours on a bench in the pay room with my coat over my face. Lou has had none. She sits across from me now, gray under the eyes, with the phone on speaker in the middle of the table between two paper cups, and she is listening, I can see, to two sounds at once.
“Okay,” says Priya’s voice, small and brisk from the speaker. “Is she awake? Lou, tell her I can hear her not talking.”
“She’s awake,” says Lou. “She’s listening.”
“Good. I’ve got eleven minutes before rounds, and I have to tell her something dull.” There is a clink, a spoon in a cup. My sister sounds like a woman who has been standing since yesterday and has decided that standing is a form of rest. “I got a letter. It’s from the hospital’s legal office, and it’s a notice to appear. Wednesday, nine a.m., before the Medical Staff Quality Committee. It’s about a series of chart notes.”
I write the word on a card and hold it up to nobody. WHICH?
“Which what? Oh. Mine. Years ago, in my intake notes, I put the thing about the wet pillowcases. I wrote the Harrow thing as a social history. I thought it was a joke, Odie. I put ‘family history of nocturnal dampness.’”
She laughs, and it is short and dry and not at all amused. “And now they’ve pulled every chart where I used the word ‘Light’ with a capital L, which turns out to be thirty-one, and there is a woman from risk management who would like to know whether I believe it. I told her I believe in hand hygiene.”
“Believe what?” says Lou.
“That something counts them,” says Priya. “She said, ‘counts them.’ She didn’t use the word ‘Light.’ She says the committee would like to understand a pattern.” The spoon stops. “Odie, nobody told her that phrase. I never wrote “counts” anywhere. Not once.”
I look at Lou. Lou looks at me.
I write: WHO SIGNED THE NOTICE?
“A Ms. Haas. In-house. It’s all very civil.” Priya takes a breath, and I hear her pull herself straight. “I’ll go. I’ll tell them the truth in the dullest terms I can think of. I’ll say I’m a nurse and my family has an odd town. I’m not scared, you hear? I’m only telling you because you’d want the time and the place.” She is quiet. “How’s the not-talking?”
I tap two fingers on the table. Two, and a pause.
“She says it’s fine,” says Lou.
“She says nothing of the kind,” says Priya. “Okay. Eat something, both of you. I love you. I have to go and tell a man his father is going to be fine.”
She hangs up. I put my forehead down on the cold table, on the grain of the old wood, and I stay there for the whole length of Lou’s breath.
It is a long breath. It is the breath of someone who has not slept in two days and is making it last. When I lift my head, Lou has put a paper cup of coffee at my elbow, and a wrapped slice of Mrs. Aguilar’s bread, and she is not looking at either.
“Eat something,” she says, in a fair copy of my sister’s voice. “It’s a rule. It’s Article Nothing. I just made it.”
---
Edmund Pelham IV arrives at ten.
I have never seen him come into a room like this. In every earlier room, at the Tidewell office, at the Hall, on a bench in the back, he has walked in as a man walks into a thing that belongs to him, in a good gray topcoat with the collar turned up.
He comes into the mill hall at Paulding Falls in the same coat. But it is buttoned wrong, and it has a splash of mud up one side, and he has not shaved.
He stops inside the door. He looks at the great loom floor, and the columns, and the long table with its eleven chairs. He looks at the empty Owners’ chair, with its cushion still dark. And then he walks down the length of the hall alone, between the benches, with every Steward’s head turning to follow him, and comes to a stop in front of the Harrow table.
“Miss Brandt,” he says.
He has something in his right hand. I know what it is before I see it, from the dull weight in the way he carries it. It is the smokehouse bolt. It is a foot of black iron, hand-forged, and it has been the paperweight on his desk since the day he signed the agreement.
“My plant is closed,” says Edmund Pelham. “I closed it at four o’clock yesterday. The lift truck went over on the north dock, and at nine last night a woman on the packing line put her hand in a belt. She is going to keep it.
Everyone is going to keep what they have, I am told, by the grace of God and a very quick ambulance.” He lifts his head. “There was a time when I would have said that it was covered.”
He puts the bolt on the Harrow table, between my cards and the cold coffee. It makes a small, flat, final sound.
“I have been a member of your Local since the fifteenth of December,” he says. “I hold line sixty-four. I am in good standing. Under your Article Twelve, a member in good standing may be heard.” His mouth moves. “I believe I may be heard. I would like to be, if it is all the same.”
“Chair?” says Walt, behind me, very softly, and Bernadette Kuhn, at the head of the table, who has been awake for thirty hours, takes off her glasses and rubs her eyes.
“The Chair recognizes,” she says, “Mr. Pelham, of Local Nine. Briefly.”
---
He does not make a speech. For ten minutes, in the high gray light of the skylight, before eleven Stewards and the Recording Secretary and the Owners’ table with its empty chair, Edmund Pelham IV stands with both hands on the back of a folding chair, like a man who is leaning on a pew, and tells them where the Pelham money came from.
“We are a family of wharves and plants,” he says. “My great-great-grandfather had the smokehouse. He did not lose sixty-three men. The Light did that. He is said to have been on the Neck the night, and to have sat at the Hall until dawn, and to have been asked, by a person who was very kind, whether he would mind.
I do not know what he said. I know that my family kept a book.” His eyes go to Philippa, across the floor. She does not look up. “I know that she has kept it, my cousin. And I know that I did not read it, because I was told it was about money.”
Nobody in the hall breathes. It is the plain truth, and it is a small one: a man can go through his whole life with the book in the next room because nobody ever asked him to look. I know that kind of ignorance. I lived in it myself until a line appeared in a book in my own handwriting.
“What is in it?” says Bernadette.
“Names,” says Edmund. “Every person we ever introduced. The inspector. The nurse. A man from the state. A woman who audited the plant in 1994, and a dozen more before her, and I think a dozen who came after, whom I did not meet, and whom I have just read about in my own cousin’s hand.”
He has a leather case at his feet, a brown thing like a doctor’s bag. He lifts it, and sets it on the table, and opens it. “I did not want to give it to the Owners. I do not know to whom else I should give it. I understand that there is a Recording Secretary.”
Odalys has come round the table. He stands looking at the bag with a hand pressed flat against his coat, a boy asked to carry something very large across a street.
“Mr. Pelham,” he says, “you understand that this will be entered in the book.”
“I understand.”
“You understand that you will be struck from the Association’s table. That you will be a plain member of Local Nine and nothing besides. That whatever the family holds - “
Philippa has lifted her head at last. She looks at her cousin across the whole width of the floor, and I wait for the Pelham-Ward face to close like a door. It does not. She gives him one small, exact nod, the nod of a woman who has been waiting thirty years for someone else to carry the bag.
“I understand,” says Edmund Pelham, and for the first time in the whole length of our acquaintance he looks at me, and not at the bolt, or my card, or the wall behind me. “I would like it entered that I was told, once, a very long time ago, by someone who is no longer alive, that everyone was covered. I should like it entered that it was not true.”
---
The Pelham book is a thin oblong ledger in black cloth, with a red spine, and it is the neatest and most terrible object that I have ever been asked to read.
We read it in the pay room, at the long table, with the door open: Odalys, Walt, Mrs. Aguilar with a pad, Lou with her head on her fist, and I. Edmund sits on the far bench with his hands between his knees and does not speak. Each page is ruled in six columns. NAME. PLACE. THE ASKING. RIPE. ANSWER. WITNESS.
It begins in 1949.
I will not copy it out. I have copied enough in my life. It is a small, steady record in a dozen hands over seventy-seven years, and what it tells us, in a hundred and sixty-three entries, is the exact plain method of the Second Hand. Every person on it is a person who was asked. Each was asked in a public place, in the open, at a bus shelter or a diner or a ferry slip, by a gray-coated old woman with a lantern.
Each, in every case, said some courteous version of yes. And every one, on the date given in the RIPE column, in the hour given there, was found, sitting down, as Gus Terhune was found. The Pelham family did not do it. The Pelham family, it seems, only kept the page.
“The house held the door,” says Walt, in a hoarse voice, turning leaves. “That’s all they did. They kept the books for her. They’d show her to the place and keep the tally.”
“Kept it for what?” says Mrs. Aguilar.
“I don’t know,” says Walt. “A fee, I’d say. Two points of the plant.”
Mrs. Aguilar has been ticking the pad as he talks. She turns it around to show us: a column of decades, and next to each a row of small neat strokes in fives. Forty years of it come out thin, a handful a decade. Then the strokes crowd up. “Nineteen eighty-five on,” she says. “It’s picking up. Someone was in a hurry, or someone got bolder.”
I go through the pages for my own name before I can stop myself. I go through the whole autumn of 1998 twice, with my thumb, as if a name could hide between leaves. It is not there. It should be a relief, and it is not, because the absence has a shape. It is the shape of a person who has been written down somewhere else.
I put my finger on the last column.
WITNESS.
It is a short entry on every line: a single signature, in a kind of firm, slanting, genteel hand, in the same black ink all the way down. I read it on the first page, in 1949, and the second, and on the page for 1974. I read it on the line for a man named Anton Kuhn, whom the Resting Roll holds, and on a woman from Fenwick Cordage, and on the last of the old entries, the autumn of 1998.
VAIL, H.
I do not have to look at the next page. I turn it, and it begins in 1999, in the same black ink, in a hand that has softened and shortened and been taught, I think, by the first one.
VAIL, C.
Lou says nothing at all. I lay the pencil down on the table. I see in my head a woman in a charcoal coat in a harbormaster’s office on Cutter Point, with her umbrella furled, saying very civilly that she has never in her life been asked to enter the gate. A woman whose mother sat in that same room in 1995 and watched my own mother write in a roll.
They are not the Second Hand. They are something I have no word for. They are the ones who stand by.
---
The telegram comes at eleven fifty-two.
It is real. It is a flimsy yellow telegram, delivered by a boy in a cap who says he has been told that the Association still takes them, and Voss opens it at the Owners’ table, standing, with a very pale and exact face. He reads it once to himself. And then, which I did not expect, he walks the length of the hall, and puts it into Edmund Pelham’s hand.
“Your insurer,” says Haldane Voss. “Tidewell Seafoods. Cancelled with effect from noon. They cite ‘an instruction of the Association, communicated by telephone.’” He does not smile. It is the first time I have ever seen him look as if he does not want to be there. “I did not send it, Mr. Pelham. I want that understood. I would not have used a telegram.”
“Who did?” says Edmund.
“I do not know,” says Voss. “It is on our paper. It is signed with a lantern.”
He stands there a moment longer than he needs to, with his hands empty. I think he is waiting to be told that he is forgiven, and I think he knows he will not be.
I find that I do not have it in me to be cruel to a man who has just been robbed of his own letterhead. I write him a card: THEN SOMEONE ELSE HAS YOUR PEN. LOOK FOR IT. He reads it, nods once, and goes back up the hall to his table like a clerk who has been given a task and is grateful for it.
Edmund Pelham IV reads the thing, front and back. He folds it in four. He puts it in the pocket of the muddy coat with the care of a man filing a receipt, and I watch every job in his plant go into that pocket, and a pension, and a bronze wall with sixty-three names that he has not yet had cast.
“Well,” he says, very quietly. “I am a plain member.”
And he sits on the bench beside Dale, who moves up for him. Dale puts a hand on his arm and says nothing. They sit side by side, the two men who said yes, with their caps and their cold coffee.
---
Priya’s last text comes in at a quarter to ten at night.
I am lying on the pay-room bench with my eyes open and the ledger under my head for a pillow, because I do not trust it out of my reach. The mill is dim and breathing. Somewhere Dale is whispering, in the dark, with Walt coaching him, I mind. I mind. He has gotten as far as I mi. He has been at it for six hours.
My phone lights the ceiling. It is a photograph. The picture is of a floor. It is a plain brown doormat outside an apartment door in Worcester, and on the mat, square in the middle, squared up by someone with a very careful eye, is a cream card with a watermark of an anchor.
PRIYA: It was under my door when I got home. No one rang. I looked in the hall camera. It just appears, Odie, at 9:12, there’s no one in the frame.
A second photograph follows. It is the same card, turned over.
It is a single line, in the black, slanting, courteous hand that I have learned to dread. It does not say a threat. It does not say a charge. It says, very civilly, in the voice of a woman writing to a friend of the family:
Dear Miss Brandt, I shall be present at tomorrow’s committee as a courtesy to the hospital. We have so much to discuss. Do give your sister my warmest regards. C. Vail.
I read it three times. I do not wake Lou. I sit up on the bench, and I put my bare feet on the cold floor of the mill, and I say, silently, into the dark, the only word that I have left: Who else?
No one answers. But in the pay room, very far off, behind the grille, a woman’s quill begins to scratch on a page.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!