Walt Gerrity drives the way he negotiates, which is to say slowly, in the right lane, with a thermos between his knees and no opinion he is willing to share before the second hour.
It is twenty past four on Wednesday morning. We have left Paulding Falls behind us in the dark, with its sealed mill hall and its eleven stopped Lights and its Assembly that is forbidden by its own Master Article to adjourn, and the highway ahead of us is empty all the way to the sky. Dale is in the back seat in my union windbreaker, with his seat belt on twice, once across the chest and once, I think, across the mind.
I am in the front with a stack of index cards on my knee. I have a pencil and a rubber band and a violet stamp on my left palm that says RESTING, and I have no voice. Lou is on the mill-hall floor speaking for Local Nine in the voice she has borrowed and the voice she has kept. Wren is holding the Chair with her small gray hands. Somebody had to go to Worcester, and the somebody could not be anyone who had to be heard.
I write a card. I hold it up to the dash light.
WHAT TIME IS THE COMMITTEE?
“Nine,” says Walt. “Nine sharp. They sent it by courier and by email and by certified mail, which tells you the hospital’s lawyer is nervous or is billing by the envelope.” He drinks from the thermos. “I called a guy I know at the state nurses’ association. Priya isn’t in a bargaining unit. Burnside Regional is a non-union house. No Weingarten rep, no contract, no steward, nothing. At-will, and the hospital can ask her anything it likes.”
“Chief,” says Dale from the back, “that’s the worst thing anybody has ever said in a car.”
I write: SHE CAN BRING A WITNESS.
“If the bylaws say so. We’ll read them when we get there.” Walt glances at me. “You can’t speak in there, Odie. I know. Cards are cards, but a hospital committee isn’t a Local. If you hold up a card in front of a quality committee, Haas will call it an exhibit.”
I write: GOOD. THEN IT’S EVIDENCE.
He almost smiles. It is the first time in four days. Then he turns his eyes back to the road, and does not say whatever it was that he was going to say.
---
I try not to think about the page.
I think about it all the way to the Massachusetts line. The Pelham book is in my coat pocket, wrapped in a pillowcase, and I do not need to take it out to see the last page. BRANDT, P. WORCESTER. RN. ASKED. 4 MARCH. 9:00 A.M. WITNESS: VAIL, C. It is not a ripe date. It is a time, and a name, and a woman in a charcoal coat who has promised to attend as a courtesy.
Every entry in that book, going back to 1949, has the same shape. A person is asked. A person says a word. The word is written down. Then a thing comes to be ripe, and a day arrives, and someone who was asked turns out to have been counted. It does not take a week. It does not need a ghost. It needs a small, polite question, put at a moment when the person is tired, and a person raised to be agreeable.
My sister is the most agreeable person I know. She is also the most tired.
When we were girls our mother had a name for the thing she did with her mouth when a stranger asked a favor. She called it Priya’s yes. It was not a lie. It was a reflex, a little round automatic Okay that came out before the thought, like a knee under a doctor’s hammer. She said it to teachers. She said it to boys.
She said it, aged ten, to a man in a parking lot who asked if she would hold a door, and I had to walk over and take the door out of her hand.
I put the pencil down. I am aware that I am gripping it harder than a pencil requires.
“She’s going to say okay,” says Dale, softly, from the back. He is looking out of the window. “That’s all it is, isn’t it. She’s going to say okay, chief, and it’ll be written down.”
I do not answer. I cannot. But I have his meaning, and he has mine, and for a few miles neither of us says anything at all.
---
The sun comes up behind the Worcester water tower at ten past six. Burnside Regional is a long brown campus of five buildings and a parking structure on the north side of the city, with a helicopter pad on the roof of the newest wing and a flag at half mast for nobody I know. The ER entrance is lit like a stage.
There are ambulances at the bay, and a line of cars at the curb with their hazards on, and a security guard standing by the doors with his hand on his belt and his eyes on the lot.
Priya is waiting at the cafeteria door. She has been on shift since seven last night. She is in navy scrubs and white clogs and a cardigan I gave her four Christmases ago, with her hair in the knot she wears when she has stopped caring what the knot is doing. Her eyes are red. She has a badge on her chest that says P. BRANDT, RN, and below it, in smaller type, EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT, and in a pocket, I know, she has a folded copy of the notice.
She sees me and she does not say anything. She puts her arms around me, there in the doorway, and the badge digs into my collarbone, and she smells of hand sanitizer and old coffee and the cold, clean smell of the unit.
Then she steps back and looks at my face.
“You can’t talk,” she says.
I shake my head.
“Is it permanent?”
I hold up a card that I have been carrying since Paulding Falls. It says: NO. IT’S A PRICE. IT’S THE KIND THAT ENDS.
“Okay,” says Priya. She stops. She presses her lips together. “That is the thing. Isn’t it. I’ve been hearing myself say it all night. I said it to a charge nurse at two. I said it to a man with a laceration. I said it to Dr. Anand about the stapler. It’s like a tic.” She laughs, a short, thin, tired laugh. “I think I’ve been saying it my whole life, and I never once heard it.”
I write: EAT FIRST. THEN WE’LL TALK ABOUT IT.
She reads the card. She puts her hand over her mouth, and for a second I think she is going to cry.
“Okay,” she says, behind her fingers. “But that one’s yours.”
---
We eat in a corner of the cafeteria, under a poster about hand hygiene, with a tray of eggs and toast and weak tea and a banana that nobody asked for. Walt buys. Dale eats two breakfasts and does not say a word about either. Priya eats the way nurses eat, in sixty-second bites between thoughts, with her eyes on the clock over the register.
She gives me the packet.
It is thirty-one pages, stapled, in a manila folder with a red tab. It has a cover sheet from the Medical Staff Quality Committee of Burnside Regional Hospital, signed by someone named Haas in the lawyer’s blue ink that looks like a threat. It has thirty-one chart excerpts, one per page, with the patient names blacked out and the notes left clear.
I read them in order.
They are ordinary. That is what makes my stomach turn. A woman with chest pain, triaged correctly. A boy with a broken wrist, splinted in eleven minutes. A man brought in from a fishing boat at three in the morning with a cold, white, wrinkled hand, and a note in Priya’s tight upright print: Pt states “it’s the Light.” Pt states “somebody has to count.” Pt calm, oriented x3. Pt discharged AMA.
In thirty-one pages, the word Light appears forty-four times. It is in the chief complaints. It is in the family statements. Twice it is in my sister’s own handwriting, in quotation marks, as a thing the patient said. Once, on the nineteenth page, in a margin, in blue ballpoint, it is in a hand I know. Someone has written, very small: counts them. It is not Priya’s. It is not mine. It has a crack in the capital C.
I hold the page up so Priya can see it.
She stares at it for a long, flat second.
“I didn’t write that,” she says. “I’ve never written that. I’ve been telling Haas that since Monday.”
Walt takes the page, and reads it, and puts it down very carefully, as if it were hot.
“Somebody’s putting words in her chart,” he says. “Hospital counsel’s going to say the nurse wrote it. It’s a retaliation setup, Odie. It’s textbook. They call it an investigation of the charting. You’re not being fired. You’re being asked about your documentation.”
I write, on a fresh card: WHAT DOES THE COMMITTEE DECIDE?
“Whether to refer her to the state board,” says Priya. Her voice is very flat. “Whether to restrict my privileges. Whether to file a report with the licensing board that says I’ve been charting delusions.” She looks at the eggs. “Odie. It would end it. It wouldn’t be a firing. It would be a flag, in a database, for the rest of my life. I’d never work in an ER again.”
---
I find the bylaws at ten to eight.
Priya has them on her phone, in a PDF the size of a phone book: Medical Staff Bylaws, Burnside Regional Hospital, revised 2019, with an appendix of forms. I read them on the cafeteria bench the way I read every Article since December, which is to say like a contract, with a pencil, from the back.
The back is where they hide it. Article IV is Committees. Section 4.7 is Peer Review Proceedings. Subsection (c) is Rights of the Practitioner. It is four lines long.
(c) A practitioner under review shall be notified in writing. A practitioner may be accompanied by one support person of her choosing, who is not an attorney and who may not address the committee. No finding shall be entered against a practitioner who has not first been asked, on the record, whether she consents to its entry.
I read it twice.
I read the last sentence a third time, and the pencil stops in my hand.
No finding shall be entered against a practitioner who has not first been asked whether she consents.
It is the oldest rule in the world. It is the Pelham book in a hospital’s good typeface. Somebody, a long time ago, sat down with a drafting committee in this building and wrote a courtesy into a procedure. Be fair, they thought. Ask her. And somebody else, who was not on the committee, and was not wearing a lanyard, and has a lantern, saw the courtesy and understood it for what it was.
Priya has been reading over my arm.
“That’s in all of them,” she says slowly. “That’s in every hospital’s. It’s a due process thing. The accused has to consent to the record.”
I write: THAT’S NOT WHAT IT SAYS.
“What does it say?”
I write, and I underline it twice: IT SAYS “ASK HER.” IT DOESN’T SAY “AND IF SHE REFUSES.” There’s nothing here about no. Nothing. If she says okay, the finding goes in. If she says no, the rule is silent. A rule that’s silent on a no is a rule that doesn’t know what a no is.
Walt reads it upside down. He nods slowly. He has been a union man for thirty-eight years, and I watch him recognize it the way I did, not as a trap, but as a gap.
“A no is a grievance,” he says. “You don’t say no to the finding. You say, ‘I received it. I don’t agree.’ You sign for receipt, not for consent. We tell a hundred people a year. Don’t sign the write-up. Sign that you got it.” He looks at Priya. “There’s a form. There’s always a form.”
“Appendix C,” says Priya. She is already scrolling. “Form QC-9. Acknowledgment and Consent.” She stops. She reads aloud. “Practitioner acknowledges receipt of the finding and consents to its entry in the record. Check one: consents. Does not consent. Check one.” She glances up. “There’s a box. There’s a second box.”
“Then there’s a no,” says Walt. “It’s just not in the rule. It’s in the form.”
I write: SHE CAN USE THE BOX. BUT THE BOX ISN’T ENOUGH. SHE’S GOING TO BE ASKED OUT LOUD, WITH A PERSON PRESENT WHO ISN’T IN THE ROOM.
And as I write it, I know why I am afraid. It is not the committee. It is not the form. It is that the Light has never in its history been fooled by a box. It listens to the mouth. It listens to the first word, the quick word, the one that comes before the thought. And my sister’s first word is a round, kind, tired Okay that has been in her mouth for thirty-one years.
---
Haas meets us at the committee suite on the fourth floor at ten to nine.
She is a small, brisk woman of about fifty, with iron-gray bobbed hair and a navy suit and a lanyard with six keys on it, and she carries a leather folio under her arm like a shield. She has the look of someone who has never lost an argument in a room with a conference table.
She shakes Walt’s hand, and Dale’s, and mine, and she looks at my face a half second longer than she should, and then at my left hand, which I have turned over in my lap so the violet stamp does not show.
“Ms. Brandt,” she says to Priya. “And a guest, I see.”
“My sister,” says Priya. “Under Section 4.7(c). My support person.”
Haas’s pen hesitates over her folio.
“That’s permitted,” she says, slowly. “She may not address the committee. She may not take notes for the record. She may sit.” A very small pause. “I understand she is, at present, unable to speak in any case. I was told that, by someone. I couldn’t tell you who.” She frowns, briefly, as though at a word on the tip of her tongue. “It is a condition that suits the rule, I suppose.”
I look at her.
She looks at the folio.
“The gentlemen will wait in the corridor,” she says. “There are chairs. We will begin at nine. It will be an hour, perhaps a little less.”
Walt sits. Dale sits. The chairs are standard hospital chairs, gray vinyl, bolted in a row along the wall. I watch Dale lower himself into one, and wait, and not feel the cold come up through the seat. I am looking very hard at the other chairs in the row. They are dry.
All of them.
Then Haas opens the door and holds it for us, and I follow my sister into the room.
---
It is a long, plain room with no windows. There is an oak veneer table that seats twelve and is set for six. There is a pitcher of ice water in the middle, sweating onto a paper coaster, and there are six glasses, and a legal pad at each place, and a name card in a plastic holder. The overhead lights are fluorescent. A wall clock reads eight fifty-six.
A court reporter’s machine sits in the corner under a small dust cover, which a young man in a gray cardigan is removing as I come in.
I read the name cards because I cannot help it.
DR. RENATA BOYLE, CHAIR. JOAN TIERNEY, RN, VP NURSING. DR. SAMIR ANAND, EMERGENCY MEDICINE. MS. HAAS, COUNSEL. MR. PELL, RECORDER.
There is a sixth place. The chair is at the foot of the table, a little apart. It is not the same as the others. It is an old oak armchair with a leather seat, the kind that comes out of a trustees’ room, not a conference supply. It has no name card. There is a glass in front of it, filled to the brim.
And in front of the glass there is a pad of ruled paper, and a pencil, and a fountain pen.
I stand very still in the doorway.
“That’s the chair for the trustees’ observer,” says Haas, behind me. She says it a shade too easily. “The Board asks that a member of the Pemberton Trust be present at reviews involving a licensed practitioner. A courtesy. It’s in the endowment agreement.” She comes around me and sits. “I’m told she’ll be a few minutes late.”
I do not look at Priya. If I look at Priya, my face will say something I have no way to take back.
I take the chair beside her, along the wall, where the support person sits. It is a folding chair. I put my cards on my knee and my pencil in my hand. I sit with my back straight, the way I sit at a first house visit, so that every person I look at knows I am looking.
And I count the glasses, though the count will not come.
Five poured and a sixth poured to the brim.
The clock reads eight fifty-nine.
On the other side of the door, in the corridor, I hear Dale clear his throat.
“Chief,” he says to somebody, politely. “Is this seat taken?”
And a woman’s voice, a dry, even, well-bred voice I have heard twice, in two different cities, says, “Not at all, Mr. Ferreira. It is quite all right. I am only passing through.”
The door opens. The charcoal coat comes in with the cold on it. It is nine o’clock.
Mr. Pell, the recorder, takes his hands off the machine and says, in a clear, high, careful voice, “The committee will ask one question.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!