Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 5

Quiet Deaths

On the fifth night I go back to work, because the one thing I know how to do is sit with the dying, and I want to find out what I have been doing wrong.

It is Thursday, the third of September. The Lamplighters are at home against a team from the other end of the lake, and the roar comes through the glass of the east wing every few minutes like weather. I have not resigned. The letter is still in my cardigan pocket, folded in thirds, going soft at the creases.

Neva Lindqvist-Amadi has not asked for it. She hands me the night roster on Monday without a word and I take it without one, and neither of us says what we both know, which is that I am only staying until the twenty-eighth.

I haven’t slept more than four hours in any night this week. I don’t seem to need to. The book sits in the bottom drawer of my desk in the chaplain’s office, under a hymnal, and it is cool and plain and does nothing, and I check it every hour like a man checking a sleeping child. Mari has not come back to the field.

I walked out to the chalk shed on Sunday and found the padlock on and a note taped to the door that said RULES OFFICE: GROUNDS CREW CLOSED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE, and under it, in pencil, in handwriting I did not know, a row of seven small tally marks.

It is hard to eat. I did not understand what Ruth’s Mostly would cost until I tried the cafeteria downstairs on Tuesday.

The woman who runs the steam table is sixty and tired and kind, and her minestrone tastes of cumin, and tomato, and a sentence she has been swallowing since a quarrel with her sister in 2011. I could not finish the bowl.

I have been living on dry crackers and tap water, which taste only of themselves. It is an astonishing relief. It is the closest thing to quiet I own.

At nine, Lonnie Mapes stops me in the hall outside Room Four.

“Mr. Abernathy’s asking for you,” he says. “Asking by name. He says the chaplain’s the only one who doesn’t talk to him like he’s a kindergarten class.”

“How is he?”

“Stable. He’s been stable for a week.” Lonnie lowers his voice. “Dana’s flying in tomorrow. His daughter. Phoenix. They’ve been going back and forth on the phone. I don’t think it’s gone well. I think he’s been waiting.”

He looks at me, a big gentle man in blue scrubs, and then past me at the window at the end of the hall, where the dark shape of the stadium sits against the sky. “You all right, Reverend? You’ve been looking at things funny since the weekend.”

“I’ve been eating at the cafeteria.”

“Oh,” he says, with deep sympathy. “That’ll do it.”

Walter Abernathy is seventy-nine and has been dying of congestive heart failure for fourteen months, with a patience that borders on spite. He taught shop at Port Ardent High for thirty-eight years and has the forearms to prove it, grown thin and corded now like old rope.

He has a bad temper and a worse tenor, and in the nine days he has been in Room Four he has sung the first verse of every hymn in the Methodist book at three in the morning to annoy the night aides.

He is propped on three pillows when I come in, with the window cracked open six inches to let the game in, and he looks me up and down with his sharp little black eyes and says, “You look like hell, Padre.”

“Sorry,” I say. “That’s just true.”

“Don’t apologize. It’s refreshing. Sit down. Lonnie won’t tell me the score.”

I sit. I put my hand on the bed rail, the way I have for nine years, and I let the taste come.

It comes whether I want it or not. It is no longer a thing I can turn off. I have, in a week, learned to find the doorway of it, the narrow threshold at the back of the tongue where a man’s unsaid sentences wait, and I stand there with my eyes half closed while the old man tells me about his night. Marmalade.

That is the first thing. Marmalade, bitter, with the thin sharp rind in it. Under it, burnt sugar. Under that, a very faint salt, like a handful of seawater, and I know what that is. It is a sentence that has been rehearsed so many times it has lost its edges.

Walter Abernathy has something he has not said. It is a large and particular thing, and it has been in him for years.

“It’s the daughter,” he says, as if I had spoken. “Everybody thinks I’m waiting on God. I’m waiting on a flight.” He gives a dry cough that turns into a long one, and I raise the cup of ice chips, and he takes one and holds it in his mouth. “She’ll be here tomorrow afternoon. I’ve got till then. The doctor says I might have a week, and I say, I don’t want a week. I want twenty hours and a clear head.”

“What do you need to tell her?”

“Ha.” He looks at the window. “That’s the question, isn’t it. They teach you that in seminary? Cut right to it?”

“Not exactly. I’m Methodist. We mostly offer tea.”

He laughs, a real one. “Dana was twenty-six. She got married in a church in Scottsdale. Beautiful church. I can’t even tell you what I told her. I told her I had a job I couldn’t leave, which was a lie. I told her my back was bad. I told her the church was too far. And I stayed home and drank a beer in the garage and watched a game on the radio.”

His voice has gone very dry. “Twenty-six years ago. She’s fifty-two. She has three kids, and the oldest is almost the age she was when I didn’t show. She calls me every Sunday, and I say hello, and we talk about the weather, and she says, Dad, are you okay, and I say, sure. And I hang up and sit in the dark.”

Marmalade. Burnt sugar. A mouthful of seawater.

“Why didn’t you go?”

“Because I’d have had to look at her,” he says. “That’s the answer. I thought, if I go, she’ll see me. She’ll see what kind of man I am. She’ll look at me in a suit with a tie on, and I’ll have to stand up in a church and be proud of her, and I wasn’t. That’s the thing, Padre. I wasn’t proud of her. I was jealous. She got out.

“I’d been in that shop for thirty-eight years, with the same bench and the same radio and the same sixteen-year-old boys breaking the same drill bits, and she got on a plane to Arizona and never looked back. And I said to myself, good for her, and I stayed in the garage.” His eyes are wet and furious. “I was proud and ashamed. And then I was only ashamed.”

I put my hand over his on the rail.

I do not know how long it has been since I said anything real to a dying man. I think of Ruth in the pale light of Room Nine, with the rosary in her hand, saying, you’ve never once said anything to the people attached to them. I think of the letter in my pocket. And I take my hand off his, and I take out my phone.

“Walter,” I say. “What time is it in Phoenix?”

“What?”

“Phoenix is three hours behind us. It’s not even six o’clock there. Does Dana have her phone on?”

“You’re not going to.”

“Is she at the airport? She said she was flying tomorrow.”

“She’s at the gate in Dallas,” says Abernathy, slowly. “She’s got a layover tonight. She texted me. She’s coming in a day early.” He is looking at the phone as if it has produced a snake. “I’m not ready.”

“You’ve been ready for twenty-six years.”

I do not know where it comes from. It is my voice, my own, in a flat dry Midwestern register, and it does not shake. I say, for the record, I think you should call her now, and I hold out the phone. He stares at it for a long time.

I can taste the sentence under his tongue gathering itself, the marmalade going dark and sweet and strong, until it fills the room. He puts out a hand and takes the phone. He taps the screen with a thick finger. He lifts it to his ear.

It rings four times. I hear it ring, small and tinny, in the hush of the room.

“Dad?” says a woman’s voice, far away. She sounds frightened. “Dad, are you okay? Is it—”

“I’m fine,” says Walter. His voice is rough. “I’m fine, Dana. Where are you?”

“Gate B22. They’re boarding in an hour.” A pause. “Dad, you called me. You never call.”

“I know.”

“Is something wrong?”

“No. I’ve got something I want to say.” He closes his eyes. “It’s about your wedding, honey. I’ve got something to say about it, and I need to say it now, while I’ve got the nerve.”

It is very quiet. The window is open six inches, and through it comes the sound of a bat meeting a ball, a ragged cheer, the organ somewhere behind a wall of dark. I hold my breath and I look at the clock on the wall. 8:36.

“I didn’t come,” he says. “I told you I couldn’t. That was a lie. I could have. I—”

And through the window, very faintly, I hear a man start to hum.

It is not loud. It is only a thread of sound, thin and flat and slightly out of tune, coming over the parking lot from the direction of the ballpark on the warm evening air, the first six notes of a song everyone in America knows. I go cold. I know the sound the way you know the sound of a key in your own front door.

The organ is a half-beat slow. The crowd is rising to its feet. The roar is leaning, patient and soft and entirely without malice, across the lot and up the brick wall of a two-story building toward a window that has been opened six inches to let the game in.

“Walter,” I say. “Walter, close the—”

“I was ashamed,” says Walter Abernathy into the phone, and he stops.

I taste it go.

I have never tasted anything like it, and I hope I never taste it again. The marmalade thins. It does not vanish; it goes out of him like a thread being drawn through cloth, the whole long thick rope of it, the burnt sugar and the salt and the rind, pulled up out of his chest and his throat in one long unhurried motion toward the window. It is not violent.

It is the gentlest thing I have ever felt. It is like watching a tide go out of a sleeping child’s body. I stand up. I grab the window sash, and I try to pull it down, and it won’t move, because I am holding a hand-sized hole in the world with my bare palm and it does not matter.

“Walter!”

“Hm?” he says.

He is smiling. His face has smoothed. All the lines that fourteen months of fury and pain had cut around his mouth have gone soft and slack, as if somebody had run a warm iron over the sheet of him. He holds the phone loosely against his chest and turns his head on the pillow to look at me, with his sharp black eyes gone mild, and says, in a pleasant, faraway voice, “What was I saying?”

“Walter, you were telling her—”

“Oh, never mind,” he says. “It’s all right. It doesn’t matter. It’s all right, honey.” He lifts the phone. “Dana. It’s all right. I’m just glad you’re coming. I’ll see you in the morning.”

“Dad?” says the voice, very small. “Dad, you sound—”

“I feel fine,” he says. “I feel wonderful. I love you.”

It is the first time in twenty-six years he has said it. He says it easily, in an empty, sweet, perfectly lovely voice, with nothing behind it at all. I know what the words are made of. I can taste them. They taste like water.

“Oh, thank God,” says Dana Abernathy, crying. “Oh, Dad. You sound so peaceful.”

He dies at 8:52.

It is exactly the same minute that the scorebook had meant for me, and I cannot stop thinking it. He closes his eyes and lets the phone slide against his chest, and the daughter in Dallas goes on saying his name into the speaker until I take it and tell her, in my gentlest and most practiced voice, that he has gone. I do it well. That is the worst of it.

I have done it eleven hundred times and I do it perfectly. I tell her he was comfortable and not in pain, and that his last words to her were I love you, and every sentence I say is true. Nobody dies hard at St. Odile’s. I say it to a woman in an airport and she thanks me.

I put the phone down on the nightstand. I look at the face on the pillow, a face smoothed like a pebble, with a faint, pretty smile. I put my hand on the old man’s chest, and taste what is left.

There is nothing in him. Nothing at all. It is not even the empty-plate taste of Gideon Wray, which is the taste of something that has been wiped. This is cleaner.

It is a vessel that has been rinsed in a river and set out to dry, and it is the last place in the world a lie could live.

Walter Abernathy came into the world with a lifetime of sentences, and the last twenty hours of them he spent trying to say one, and a man in an usher’s vest took them all in the time it takes to hum six notes.

Outside, through the cracked window, I hear the stadium cheer.

I do not remember walking to Neva’s office. It is on the first floor, at the end of the corridor behind the nurses’ station, and the door is open. She is at her desk with her reading glasses pushed up in her gray braid and a pile of grant forms in front of her, and she looks up and sees my face and puts the pen down very carefully.

“Mr. Abernathy,” she says. “Lonnie called me.”

“He didn’t finish a sentence.”

“Friend—”

“He was trying to say sorry to his daughter. He’d been waiting twenty-six years. He had it in his mouth, and a man in the stands hummed a song, and he forgot what he was saying.” My voice is still flat and dry, and my hands are not shaking, and I am a little frightened of how calm I am. “She thinks he was at peace. She’ll tell her kids that. She’ll tell them he was at peace.”

“Sit down, Ansel.”

“I’d rather not.”

She takes off her glasses. She looks at me for what seems like a very long time, a stout, tired, brilliant woman of fifty-two who has never in her life lost an argument with a state inspector, and who is now, visibly, losing one with herself. “How long have you known?” she says.

“Since Saturday.”

“Known who?”

“An usher. Gideon Wray. Section 112.” I put both hands on the back of the chair. “How many, Neva?”

She says nothing.

“How many quiet deaths in nine years?”

“I don’t know the number.” Her voice is very low. “That’s the truth. I stopped counting around the fourth year. It’s not that I didn’t care. It was that I did.” She spreads her hands on the desk. “I’ll tell you what I know. It isn’t much. I came here twelve years ago from the university hospital as medical lead.

“I had a reputation for being hard on administrators. Three years later the board offered me the directorship, and they offered me something else, a grant from the St. Odile’s Foundation, which has its offices in a building in Cleveland I have never seen, and has been very, very generous. One point four million a year. For an eleven-bed hospice.”

“What was it for?”

“Comfort,” she says, with a laugh that is not a laugh. “It was for the patients’ comfort. A tidy sum in return for a few conditions. The east wing, rooms one through eight, to be kept in what the language calls an acoustic comfort configuration. Sashes that open. No soundproofing.

“A standing agreement with the Lamplighters about the use of the right-field parking lot. A requirement that our chaplains attend the home games, which Ruth always refused, and which I told the Foundation was a religious accommodation.” She looks down at her hands.

“I thought it was an odd bequest. I thought the founder had been a baseball fan. And then the deaths started. Not the dying. I’m a doctor. I know dying. These were different. They were easy. People who should have taken three days to go took three hours. People who should have been frightened were smiling. Nobody screamed. Nobody had a bad death. And the families wrote me thank-you letters.”

“You never asked.”

“I asked Ruth.” She smiles, the thin hard smile of a woman who is not going to cry in front of a subordinate. “The first year. She said, ‘Don’t, Neva.’ Just that. And she looked at me the way she used to look at the families, and I thought, there’s a thing here I would rather not know. And I took the money.”

“And the nine years after that?”

“I signed the grants.” She says it flatly. “Every spring. Nine years. And every spring I told myself I would stop, and every spring we were short, and a woman would come through the door with a husband who was going to die screaming on a county ward, and I would say, I can offer you peace. Friend, I have never in my life told a lie that I could not defend.” Her voice cracks. “Until this one.”

I look at her. The only sound is a clock on the wall, ticking, and through the thin window of her office, the muffled cheer of a crowd on its feet.

“Did you let her lock Room Nine?” I say.

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“Because it was the one room nobody ever died in the way the others did.” She wipes her face with the heel of her hand, quickly, like a woman killing a fly. “In all the years anyone can tell me about. Nobody ever took anything from that room. I thought it was a kind of superstition.

“And then I saw her carry that green book out of the safe in her closet three weeks ago, and I saw her face. And I understood that the hospice is not a hospice. It’s a barn, and she was the only one in the building who knew what was in it.” A long breath. “I’m a doctor, Ansel. I’m supposed to know what a death is.”

I think about Walter Abernathy’s smooth face, lying peaceful on the pillow, a tidy sheet. I think of eleven hundred and six. I think about how many of them said the thing, and how many of them said it into a window that was open six inches.

“I need the key,” I say.

“I know.” She opens the top drawer of her desk. She takes out a small brass key on a loop of red yarn, which I have seen on Ruth’s own neck, and holds it out across the blotter. Her hand does not shake either.

We are two calm people in a very quiet room. “She told me to give it to you after. She told me not to give it to you sooner. I told her I thought that was a stupid rule, and she said, “Mm.”

“What’s in Room Nine?”

“I don’t know.” She presses the key into my palm and closes my fingers over it, and her hand is warm and dry and very strong. “Friend, I’ve been the director of this place for nine years, and I’m telling you honestly, I have never once opened that door. The only room in the building they never came through is the one you’re about to open.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!