Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 10

For the Record

THE COURT: Madam Reporter, do you understand that anything you say now, you say as a witness and not as the court’s officer?

THE REPORTER: I do, Your Honor.

THE COURT: Then please raise your right hand.

Roark has laid the photograph on Judge Lyle’s desk like a winning card. It is the same eight-by-ten. A courier left it at his office at seven this morning, in a plain envelope, with no note.

“Your Honor, the defense has compromised the court’s own reporter,” he says. His voice is smooth. “I move to revoke Mr. Marchand’s bond, strike the reporter, and sanction defense counsel.”

Marguerite Doss, standing in the doorway with her glasses in her hand, looks at the picture and then at me. She says nothing at all, which is the loudest thing I have ever heard her do.

Judge Lyle takes off her own glasses. “Ms. Aldous. Is that you?”

I look at my hands in the photograph. At his closed eyes.

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Do you wish to consult counsel?”

“No, Judge. I wish to be heard, on the record, in open court.” I breathe. “I can’t do it from the reporter’s chair. If the court will bring in another reporter, I’ll take the stand.”

For a very long moment the judge studies me over the tips of her fingers.

“Deputy Hale,” she says at last. “Fetch Mr. Tate from Division B. And find Mr. Raymond Fenner, wherever he’s sitting, and bring him in. Mr. Roark, I suggest you sit down.”

At 9:40 the jury has been excused and the gallery is full. A substitute reporter I’ve never met sits in my chair with his hands over the keys. I stand in the witness box with my palm up, and I have never in my life felt so thoroughly in the wrong place or so much at home.

“State your name for the record,” says Judge Lyle.

“Ada Marie Fenner.”

The room lets out one long breath.

“I’ve been sitting here as Nell Aldous,” I say. “Nell Aldous died of an aneurysm in Tupelo, Mississippi, six months before I ran. She was my friend. I used her license. It was fraud, and I’ll answer for it.” My voice is level. It is the reporter’s voice, and for once I let it be mine. “I am Raymond Fenner’s niece. I kept his books.”

In the back of the room, a door opens. My uncle comes in between Deputy Hale and a bailiff, with his coat over his arm and a faint, puzzled smile. He sees me in the box. The smile stays where it is, and nothing behind it moves.

“The line on Exhibit Fourteen is in my handwriting,” I say. “I wrote it on October fourteenth at three in the afternoon, because my uncle told me to. He said it was a late fee. It was never a payment. Jude Marchand paid twenty thousand a quarter. He never paid forty.”

“Objection,” says Roark. “Your Honor, this woman is a self-confessed fraud.”

“Overruled. Sit.”

“At twenty minutes to ten that night,” I say, “I was in the records room above the Number Nine slip, with the lights off. I watched Raymond Fenner hit Walter Prejean with a wrench. Cosmo Teague put him in the trunk of his own sedan. The slip floodlight had been broken since August. I filed the work order.” I find Evangeline Prejean in the second row. Her needles have stopped. “I’m sorry, Mrs. Prejean. I should have said it five years ago.”

She does not answer. She does not look away. She nods, once.

“And,” I say, “the ledger I handed my uncle on that ferry has four years of payments in it. Five thousand dollars on the first of every month, to initials A.R. In my handwriting, under the heading county counsel liaison.”

The courtroom goes dead still.

“Your Honor,” says Roark, pale to the lips. “That is slander.”

“It’s a question, Mr. Roark,” says Judge Lyle mildly. “You’ll have a chance to answer it under oath.”

I reach into my coat and take out the little recorder. It looks absurdly small in that high room.

“Last night on the 6:10 ferry,” I say, “Raymond Fenner admitted what he did. I recorded it on the court’s own audio backup, which I removed from the building without permission. That was a violation, and I’ll answer for that too. I’d ask the court to hear it.”

“Mr. Roark?” says Judge Lyle.

“I object, Your Honor, to the introduction of a recording obtained by a person who was involved with the defendant.”

It is out in the open air, then. I feel every head turn. I keep mine up.

“I kissed Jude Marchand on Tuesday night,” I say. “In his yard. I chose to. He told me not to. Anything else the State wants to ask about that, it can ask me at a hearing. I’m asking this court to listen to the tape.”

Behind the rail, a man I have not looked at once in twenty minutes has gone as white as the wall.

“Play it,” says the judge.

The clerk takes the recorder to the bench. A click. A hiss of static, the throb of an engine, and then my uncle’s voice, warm and fatherly, filling the room to the rafters.

“I hit Walter Prejean once. With a half-inch wrench from the Number Nine tool crib. I’d do it tomorrow.”

Nobody breathes.

“Cosmo carried him. I picked the harbor lot because Marchand’s tow has the contract.”

“Stop it, please,” says the judge. The clerk stops it.

For the first time in my life, I watch my uncle’s face with nothing to hide behind. His eyes find mine across the whole length of the room. He doesn’t look angry. He looks almost proud, and then like nothing at all.

Judge Lyle puts on her glasses.

“The testimony of Raymond Fenner is stricken from the record in its entirety,” she says. “Deputy, take Mr. Fenner into custody as a material witness. The Attorney General’s office will be notified within the hour. Mr. Roark, you are disqualified from this prosecution pending an inquiry that will not be conducted by your office. I suggest you find a lawyer.” She doesn’t raise her voice. “Mr. Marchand’s bond continues. The court declares a mistrial on its own motion, to be resolved at a later date.”

The room explodes. Ms. Doss has her hand on Jude’s sleeve, holding him down. Roark is gripping the rail. And somewhere behind it all, quietly, I hear a pair of aluminum needles begin again.

“Ms. Fenner,” says Judge Lyle.

I turn.

“You have confessed under oath to practicing under a false certification and to unauthorized use of the court’s property. You understand I am obliged to act.”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“I’m not unsympathetic. I’m not permitted to be.” She takes off her glasses again. “Deputy Hale.”

He is at my elbow before I know it. He doesn’t touch me. He holds out a paper sleeve of peppermints, and I take one, and I walk with him toward the side door.

“Ada.”

He has stood up. Doss has given up trying to stop him. Jude Marchand stands at the defense table, in front of fifty strangers and a judge, with his hands open at his sides and no clever thing to say.

“It isn’t safe yet,” I say.

“I don’t care.” He says it quietly. “I said I’d say it again.”

“It’s a continuance.”

He closes his eyes. That is all. It is enough.

The holding corridor beneath Division C is cinder block and fluorescent tubes. Deputy Hale puts me in a plain room with a plain bench and says he’ll be back with paperwork. I sit and let my hands shake.

The door opens at the end of an hour. It is not Otis.

Cosmo Teague stands in the doorway with his raincoat folded over one arm and a deputy hovering behind him. He has not shaved. He looks like a man who has just put down something very heavy and is not yet sure he can stand without it.

“Miss Ada. They’ll give me five minutes. I told them I’d talk to the AG.” He doesn’t come in. “I’m the one who drove that car, and he’ll tell them it was all me. He’s got a way of doing that.”

“Cosmo.”

“Listen. You’ve got his first book. There’s a second.” His eyes are wet. “He keeps it in the safe at the Number Nine office. Black cover. Nobody knows. The last page is not in his handwriting.”

“Whose?”

“Yours,” says Teague.

The fluorescent tube hums.

“It’s a confession, Miss Ada. Dated the fifteenth of October. Signed with your name. It says you killed Walter Prejean.” He swallows. “He had you sign blank pages for years, remember? Payroll. Tax forms.”

“No,” I say.

“He’s had it ready for five years.” His voice breaks, softly. “It’s in your handwriting. Every word.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!