Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 54

Show Cause

JUDGE BANKS: Mr. Voss, you have filed a report of violation against a woman who, as of eleven o’clock this morning, was the sole custodian of the most important piece of evidence in this courthouse. I would like you to tell me what you hoped to accomplish.

MR. VOSS: Compliance, Your Honor.

JUDGE BANKS: That is what the sheep said to the wolf.

Judge Banks holds the four o’clock in the small courtroom on the second floor, because the large one is being mopped.

It smells of floor soap and wet wool. The overhead lights have a faint buzz in them, like a bee in a jar. There are twelve people in the gallery, eight of whom I know. The Judge’s bench is lower than in the big room, and from my chair at the table beside Pru I can see the gray stubble on his jaw and a small smear of what looks like toast on his cuff. It makes me like him more than I want to.

Mr. Voss has the State’s old table, with a young lawyer and an air of long-suffering. Beside him sits Warden Cade Jr., in a pressed uniform shirt with the Gulfline patch on the sleeve, his hands folded and his face as untroubled as a plate. He does not look at me. I have the odd, cool impression that he has been told not to.

“Report of violation,” says Banks. “Mr. Voss, you may proceed, and you may be brief.”

---

Mr. Voss is not brief. He is thorough, which is worse.

He takes forty minutes. He reads the two conditions of my release and the two paragraphs of the travel order, and he reads, with the evident enjoyment of a man tasting a sauce, the words not to enter the building. He calls the warden, who testifies in a low, regretful, well-schooled voice that I walked through his gate at nine on Thursday, and was admitted to Processing, and remained in a secure area until eleven thirty-six.

“Ms. Delacroix?” says the Judge, when it is done.

Pru rises. She is a long, thin, tired woman in a gray suit with a pen still stuck behind one ear, and she does not look at all like a person who is about to do what she does.

“Your Honor, the order says my client was not to enter the building. It says nothing of the gate. It says nothing of the Warden’s own hand on the gate. At nine fifty-two on Thursday, the Warden’s staff opened the door, took her by the elbow, and put her into a holding room, where she was kept for nearly two hours against a clock and a monitor that the vendor has since admitted was triggered by an echo.”

She draws breath. “We will not say my client did not walk through that gate. She did. We say she walked into a trap that was set on a Monday, in a system hosted by the same vendor that runs the Warden’s logs.”

“Objection,” says Voss. “That is argument.”

“It is argument,” says Pru, “that I am glad to put in evidence.”

“Sustained as to form,” says the Judge. “Overruled as to substance. Go on.”

“It’s nearly done, Judge. The State’s own witness is going to say that she was given a waiver, in a room, with a form prepared by the Office of the Secretary, and that she struck out the second paragraph and kept a copy. If there was a violation of the access order, it was not hers alone.” She sits.

“Mr. Wynn?”

Wynn gets up. He looks, in the cheap light, thinner than he did at nine. He has got a fleck of creosote on one trouser leg.

“The State takes no position on the technical question,” he says. “The State takes a position on what was done with the findings.

“The Court’s order of twenty past eleven yesterday seized the medical records at Birch Landing. The Warden’s report of violation was drafted, signed and filed at 2:14 this afternoon, about three hours after the search warrant for the Pilot Station was approved. I would simply note, for the record, that a report filed within three hours of a warrant is a report filed within three hours of a fright.”

“Mr. Wynn, I’d like to keep this to the evidence.”

“That is the evidence, Judge.”

There is a very small silence, in which a bee buzzes in a jar.

---

“Ms. Fenner,” says the Judge. “Stand.”

I stand. The monitor ticks against my ankle.

“I am going to say what I think happened, and I’d like you to tell me if I am wrong. On Thursday, my order permitted you to travel to Birch Landing, in the company of a deputy, for the purpose of seeing a man who had asked to see you. My order told you not to go inside. You went inside.”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Why?”

“Because he was afraid,” I say. “Mr. Teague had said nothing to anyone for twenty-three years, and he had said he would say it to me, and if I had waited on the gravel for a form to be processed, he would not have said it, or he would have been moved, or he would not have been there.”

“You might have asked leave.”

“I might have, Your Honor. There was not a minute. I want the record to say I thought of it, and I decided, and I own the decision.”

“That is not an apology.”

“No, Your Honor. It is a statement of fact. I find it is the only kind I can be trusted with.”

Judge Banks regards me over the tops of his glasses.

“I find,” he says, “that Ms. Fenner violated the letter of my order on January the fifteenth. I do not find it willful in the sense of the statute, since the evidence shows she was admitted by the Warden’s own staff and held by them in a room from which, I note, she could not have left. I decline to revoke. I decline to modify her plea.

“I decline to refer her to the Board.” He takes off his glasses. “And I will impose a sanction, because a rule that is broken and costs nothing is not a rule. The curfew will be moved from nine o’clock to seven for thirty days. She is excluded from the grounds of Birch Landing, and from the premises of the Harbor Pilots’ Association, except when under a warrant or in this Court’s presence. If that is a hardship, Ms. Delacroix may file.”

“It is not a hardship, Judge,” I say. I mean it. “It is a price.”

“I thought you might see it so.” He puts the glasses on again. “Mr. Voss. I have granted nothing you sought, and I have denied nothing you can appeal, so you may go home and tell your client it was a draw. I should add, as a courtesy, that the Court regards your timing with the same attention as Mr. Wynn.”

“The Court is, as always, perceptive,” says Voss, in a voice of oiled silk, and sits.

I sit. Pru has put her hand briefly on the back of my chair. I have been fined, in hours, a third of the light of every winter evening for a month, and for a very small moment I feel as free as I have ever felt.

---

“Next matter,” says the Judge. “The State’s motion to designate another facility. I took it under advisement for forty-eight hours, and I find that I do not need forty-eight. Bring in Mr. Marchand.”

The side door opens.

I had told myself, on the pier, with the tanker going by, that I would be ready. I have been ready for things before. I was ready for a dead woman’s tube and a living father’s orange suit.

I am, evidently, not ready for the plain fact of a man in a belly chain and wrist irons coming through a door with a deputy at each elbow, and walking quite slowly, because the chain permits it, and looking for me, among twelve people in a gallery, before he looks at anything else in the world.

His lip is split. It is on the left, a small clean cut with a crust of dried blood, and under his eye there is a bruise the color of a plum. He has lost something in a day and a half that no scale would show. He is still Jude. The shoulders are the same. The way he holds his head is the same, tilted a little, as though he were listening to something under the floor.

His eyes find me. They hold. And I see his mouth do the thing that it did in the yard, on the first morning, the corner of it, a half inch, a rueful quirk, as if to say: yes, I know, it’s a continuance.

“Mr. Marchand,” says the Judge. “You are bruised.”

“A man in the shower line walked into my face, Judge.”

“Did he?”

“It’s what the sergeant wrote. I did not contradict him.” He pauses. “It is a long line.”

“I’m sure it is. Mr. Wynn, the State’s motion.”

Wynn’s motion lasts four minutes. It is a short, flat, ugly recitation of the roster, the cell number, the date of a warden’s complaint about Jude’s behavior, and the quantity of ice in a man’s lip. At the end of it, Voss rises and begins to say, in an aggrieved voice, that Gulfline’s records show an unrelated altercation, and Banks says, “Mr. Voss, if you say ‘unrelated’ again, I will have it etched on your table.”

The order, when it comes, is brief. The defendant Jude Marchand is to be transferred forthwith to the custody of the Sheriff, at the county main jail, in general population, until further order, on the ground that the Court is no longer satisfied that Birch Landing can assure his safety. His visitors are to be set by the Sheriff. His restitution payments are to continue.

“That is not a punishment, Mr. Marchand,” says the Judge. “It’s a change of address.”

“Thank you, Judge.”

“I advise you not to thank me. I have not finished.” He looks past Jude, at the second row of the gallery. “Ms. Marchand?”

---

Colette has been sitting two seats from the end in her father’s coat. She stands. She is so pale in the poor light that the shadows under her eyes look drawn on.

“Yes, Judge.”

“You have something to hand up?”

“It came at three.” Her voice, level, is her brother’s. “It’s from the Commission. It’s a notice. They’ve suspended the yard’s license, effective Monday, nine a.m., pending a hearing in March, for, it says, ‘irregularities in the matter of the Marchand note.’ “ She holds out a folded sheet, and a bailiff carries it to the bench. “I do not know what irregularity. The note was paid. The Fund paid it. They are suspending me for being paid.”

The Judge reads. His brows go up, a little, and then down.

“The Commission is a state body,” he says, “and I have no authority over its licenses. I can say that the timing is remarkable. I can say that I will not forget it. I cannot say that it will not take effect.”

“No, Judge.”

“Mr. Marchand?”

Jude has turned his head. He is looking at his sister, in the second row, over the bailiff’s shoulder, and I have never seen his face do what it does then. It is not anger. It is a kind of stripped, quiet, tender fury, like a man who has watched somebody carry a heavy thing up a long stair for him.

“It’s a yard, Coll,” he says. “It’s boards and a tin roof.”

“It’s Daddy’s.”

“It’s boards.” He swallows. “We’ll make another.”

“The Court,” says the Judge, to nobody, “will pretend it did not hear that.” He taps the bench, once, with a pencil. “Four minutes in the holding room, Ms. Fenner, with your counsel present, before the transfer. By order of the Sheriff and with the leave of this Court. It is not a visit. It is an administrative interview, for the purposes of the Marchand restitution and the matter of the Association’s ledgers. I expect it to be dull.”

“I will do my best, Your Honor.”

“I’m sure you will,” says Banks, “and I’m sure you will fail.”

---

The holding room is a closet with a bench, painted the green that all government paint is, and lit by a bulb in a cage. It has a table, bolted down. It has a door with a window, in which a deputy’s shoulder, at an angle, is visible. Pru stands in the corner, studying the ceiling with the unnatural attention of a woman who has been told she is a piece of furniture.

Jude sits. The irons clink. He sets his hands on the table, one over the other, in the way he sets his hands when he is thinking, and I see that his knuckles have been scraped raw.

“You brought the weather,” he says.

“I brought a continuance.”

“I’ll take it.” He looks at my face. “You’re thinner. You’ve got a mark on your cheek where the pillow was. Did you sleep at all?”

“At nine this morning I read a woman’s last words off a strip of tape. It was a good deal like sleeping.”

“I heard,” he says. “The deputy at the door told the other one. It went through the courthouse by noon. Nell’s roll. I’m so sorry, Ada.”

“It isn’t yours to be sorry for.”

“It’s mine to be sorry about. It isn’t the same.” The corner of his mouth turns. “It’s the sixteenth.”

It takes me a second.

“It’s the sixteenth,” I say.

“I said you could ask me again.”

“I did not know you were still keeping it.”

“I’ve had a good deal of time.” He turns one hand over, palm up, on the steel. “Go on. You’ve got three minutes and some.”

I look at the hand. I look at the green wall, and the cage-lit bulb, and Pru’s inspired contemplation of the corner.

“Is it a continuance?” I say.

He laughs. It is a low, cracked, astonished sound, and it hurts his lip, and he does it anyway.

“It’s a continuance,” says Jude Marchand. “Granted, over objection. To a date to be set by the court, at the convenience of the parties and the weather.” He closes his hand on nothing. “Don’t look at me like that, I’m not going to cry in front of your lawyer.”

“I’m not looking at you like anything.”

“You are, though. You’ve got the face you get when you’re writing it down.” He leans a very little closer. “I didn’t tell you in the courtroom. I’m trying to keep my voice down. I’ve got something.”

I do not move. I am a person who does not move when someone says that.

“Cell twenty-two,” he says. “It’s Teague’s. They put me in it Thursday night, after you left. The sheet had him on it and they hadn’t scrubbed it.

“I didn’t sleep. I lay on the bottom bunk and looked at the springs of the one above, and there was a thing scratched in the underside of the frame. With a nail, maybe. It’s in a corner you wouldn’t see unless you were flat on your back.” His voice has gone very low. “Nine marks. In three rows. Each one with a date and two letters, R.H.”

“R.H.”

“I thought it was initials. I thought it was a man’s name.” Jude shuts his eyes and says it as I say a read-back, line by line, with the flat plain care of someone who has had a good deal of time to learn a thing by heart. “The oldest is in the corner. March, twenty-two years back. November, nineteen. April, sixteen. October, fourteen. March, eleven.

“Then it goes up the frame. November, nine years back. April, seven. October, six. And the last one is April the eighth, five years ago. I counted twice.” He opens his eyes. “There’s a line under the last row. A short scratch. And a word. I couldn’t make it out for a long time. I think it’s ‘stamp.’ “

I have stopped breathing, and I did not notice.

“Nine,” I say.

“Nine. I told one of the guards I’d dropped a tooth and needed a flashlight, and I looked at it for two hours with a pen light, and I could not make myself believe it was anything but what I thought it was.”

“What do you think it is?”

“That he counted,” says Jude. “That he sat there Monday, and Tuesday, and Wednesday, and took a nail and counted. The Fund has sixty-one entries on that shelf. You told me. Sixty-one. He did not scratch sixty-one. He scratched the nine where the name on the paper was a doctor’s.” He looks at me. “That’s what R.H. stands for, isn’t it?”

“R. Haskell,” I say.

“I thought so.”

“The stamp. On the certificate.” I hear my own voice, small and level. “Nine, of sixty-one. Nell was one of nine.”

“Ada,” says Pru, from the corner, in a voice that is not entirely hers. “Write it down.”

“I haven’t got a pencil.”

“I have,” says Pru, and brings one, and a legal pad, and sets them on the table, and goes back to the ceiling.

I write the nine dates. I write them in the plain hand, one under another, the way I write a name, and my hand does not shake, which is the one great absurdity of my trade. Jude watches me. He watches the pencil go, and I see him, all at once, settle, like a man who has put down a very heavy bag at the foot of a stair.

“Time,” says the deputy, at the door. “Two minutes.”

“We said four.”

“Two’s the number I’ve got, ma’am.”

I rise. Jude rises too, with the clink of the irons, and stands in front of me, and does not put out a hand, because he cannot, and does not step nearer, because I am a woman with a monitor and he is a man with a sergeant at his shoulder.

“Don’t bring me the weather again,” he says, low. “You’ll get a longer curfew.”

“It’s seven o’clock.”

“I know.” The corner of his mouth moves. “I can count, too.”

---

Outside the courthouse the light has gone to the thin yellow of a winter evening, and there is a wind coming up Pelican Street with something in it that smells of rain. Otis has the car running at the curb. The Sheriff’s van is pulling out of the sally port at the back of the building, I can hear its diesel, and I do not turn my head to watch it, because Jude has asked me not to.

Colette is on the courthouse steps, alone, with her hands in her father’s pockets.

“They’ll shut the yard on Monday,” she says. “Nine o’clock. They’ll put a chain across the gate. I know the man who’ll come.”

“Colette.”

“It’s all right. I want to say it before I stop being able to.” She turns to me, and her face, in the failing light, is white and set and entirely her own.

“Mr. Voss called me on the telephone at noon. Before the notice. He said that if I would sign the blank, the one in the plea, the thing Mr. Cade keeps calling my ‘pending,’ they would withdraw the Commission matter. And the Fund would take over the Marchand note again. And Jude would go back to the quiet unit, and not the general.” Her mouth works. “He said it as though he were reading me a menu.”

“What did you say?”

“I said I’d think about it.” She takes a long breath. “And then I thought about it. All afternoon. In a courtroom, on a hard bench. And I’m going to tell you what I’m going to say on Monday morning when he calls me again.”

“Tell me.”

“Read it back,” says Colette Marchand.

She is smiling. It is a small, terrible, entirely genuine smile, the smile of a woman who has come to the end of a rope and found, to her surprise, a floor.

“I’ll read it back,” I say. “Every word.”

“I know you will.” She takes her hand out of her father’s pocket, and she is holding something, and she gives it to me. It is the small flat silver key, with the letters P.A. and the number 9, and the day scratched on it by someone’s hand. “I want you to keep that. I think it’s going to be a long weekend. And I think somebody’s going to come to Otis’s house tomorrow with another tin.”

I close my fingers on it. The metal is warm from her pocket.

“Why tomorrow?”

“Because it’s what they do,” says Colette. “When a thing is lost, they come with a tin.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!