Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 53

The Third Tie

MR. VOSS: For the record, the Association objects to this entry in the strongest terms.

MR. WYNN: Noted. You may object from the porch, Mr. Voss. The warrant says the building.

The Pilot Station sits at the end of the Association pier, on the wrong side of a chain-link gate, where the land stops pretending to be land.

I have seen it from the water twice and from the road once. It is a long low shack of gray cypress, with a tin roof that has gone the color of an old penny and a stovepipe leaning out of it at the angle of a man trying to hear. There are three radio masts.

There is a sign, hand-lettered, that says HARBOR PILOTS’ ASSOCIATION, DISPATCH, and underneath it, in newer paint, a second sign that says PRIVATE PROPERTY, and under that, a third, smaller, in a very careful hand, that says PLEASE KNOCK.

It is five minutes past one on Friday, January the sixteenth. There are eleven of us on the pier and it is blowing hard enough off the water that Pru has put her briefcase between her feet.

“You will stand where I tell you,” says Wynn, to me, not unkindly. He has changed his tie. He has put on a pair of rubber-soled shoes and a canvas jacket that says STATE on the back in letters one inch high, and in the thin cold light he looks like a man on his way to inspect a dam.

“You will not go in until the sheriff’s team has cleared it and photographed it. You will touch nothing. You are here for one purpose, and it is to look at handwriting when I ask you to.

If I say go, you go. If Deputy Hale says go, you go. If Mr. Voss says anything at all, you do not answer.”

“I’m the one with the monitor, Mr. Wynn. I know how to stand still.”

“I have noticed.” He looks at me a moment. “You look like a woman who’s read a very long letter.”

“I’ve read a very short one,” I say. “It was the length that was the trouble.”

He nods, once, and goes up the pier.

---

Mr. Voss is a lean sixty with a tan he did not get in Louisiana, a camel coat, and the smile of a man who gets paid by the hour for being gracious. He is the Association’s counsel, and Gulfline’s, and for some years has been Lionel Cade’s. He has arrived in a black car with a younger lawyer who carries his papers, and a very large locksmith of his own, who stands on the planks with a toolbox and a worried air.

“The locks were changed Sunday,” he says, mildly, as the sheriff’s locksmith kneels at the door. “By authority of the Association’s board, for security, following an intrusion. I assume that will appear in your return.”

“It already does,” says Wynn. “Under the heading of things that happened after the sealed submission.”

“I resent the implication.”

“You may resent it from the porch.”

The lock gives with a dry click, like a knuckle. The sheriff’s man pulls the door, and a smell comes out onto the pier: coffee, wet wool, hot dust off a radiator, and something sweetish and ancient underneath it, as of a house that has kept a cat’s secrets for forty years.

Four deputies go in. The camera goes in, held on a long pole, with a small man behind it in a hairnet. For eleven minutes we stand on the planks while the wind goes through my coat and the water slaps the pilings below with the sound of a great many people clapping very slowly.

I count the pilings. It is a habit.

At sixteen past one, one of them comes out and nods to Wynn, and Wynn crooks a finger at me, and I put my hands in my pockets, for the discipline of it, and go in.

---

It is smaller than I expected, and neater.

There is one room. A long counter of scarred oak runs along the seaward window, and on it, in a row, stand a telephone console with sixteen brass jacks, a marine radio, a lamp with a green shade, and a mug with a hand-painted anchor that has been washed so many times the anchor has gone to a ghost. Behind the counter is a swivel chair with a cushion that has taken on the shape of one man.

There is a cot in the corner. There is a calendar from a ship chandler’s, turned to January, with the days crossed off in a firm pencil up to the eleventh.

On the wall, a shelf holds a row of black-spined ledgers, dated by year, each with a number on the spine. There are twenty-three of them. I look at that for a moment longer than I should. A man gave a quarter of his life, one book a year, to a shelf beside a window that looks out at the sea.

“Don’t touch,” says Wynn, at my shoulder. “I know. I’m saying it for the camera.”

“Where’s the radio cabinet?”

“There.” He points. At the foot of the counter, set against the wall, a tall cabinet of dark varnished wood with a glass-fronted upper half, a row of knobs, and a speaker grille. “The drawer is on the right. Lower. It sticks.”

“Teague called it the dead-rail drawer.”

“Because it was a rail once, a drawer rail. It’s warped.” He looks at it. “Sheriff’s man opened it ten minutes ago. I want you to see it as it was.”

The drawer is out on a clean sheet of white paper. It is shallow and it is empty. There is a little dust in it, in the shape of something that was in it a very short time ago, a rectangle of cleaner wood, about the size of a thin account book.

“Gone,” I say.

“Gone since Sunday, I’d say. Gone since the day somebody changed the lock.” Wynn rubs his jaw. “He told you about it in the infirmary. He told you it was there.”

“He told me what he believed.” I bend, without touching, and study the rectangle. There is a faint blue line along the edge, as of carbon paper. “Somebody who knew exactly what they wanted took the pad. They didn’t search. They went to the drawer. Nobody told Teague’s visitors where it was but Teague.”

“Or his recorder,” says Wynn. “The warden’s son was holding it Thursday morning, when Teague talked.”

He does not say it as a question and I do not answer it as one. I look at the floor.

---

The floor is cypress, wide and gray, laid over joists. It is worn to a shine along the path from the door to the counter, a pale track, narrow as a ribbon, where the same pair of feet has crossed it at the same angle every night for twenty-three years.

I have been told that the Association, long ago, built the shack on the roadbed of the old tram line, and that the sleepers, great black creosoted ties, still lie under the floor like the ribs of a ship.

“Mr. Wynn,” I say. “Which wall is the door?”

“I beg your pardon?”

“The third tie from the door. Nell wrote it. Teague’s second book is under the third tie from the door.” I do not point. I stand in the middle of the room and turn, very slowly, and look at the planks, and count them with my eyes, as I might the lines in a transcript. “A tie is eight feet long. The boards run the other way. The third tie from the threshold will be about”

“Here,” says the small man in the hairnet. He has put the camera down and has gone, without being asked, to the left of the counter, where a rag rug lies against the wall. He turns it back with the toe of one boot. “There’s a seam. These two boards have been out and back, and the nails are bright.”

The room, very quietly, draws near.

“Don’t use a bar,” I say. I hear myself say it. “He said, don’t send a boy with a crowbar.”

“Who said that?”

“My father.” The word is strange in this room, among clean sheets of evidence paper, with a locksmith to my left. “Through a door, as they took him away.”

“I’ll be damned,” says Wynn, softly. “Right. Detective, a flat blade. And somebody photograph every nail.”

It takes four minutes. The nails come out with a faint shriek, one at a time, bright where the heads have been newly set and dark where the shanks have been in the wood for decades, and each goes into a small paper envelope marked with a time. Two boards lift, side by side, and underneath them, in a recess cut into the top of the black tie, there is a tin.

It is a flat, long, gray tin, of the sort that holds fishing line, with the paint worn to the metal at the corners. It is wrapped in oilcloth. It has been wrapped, I think, a hundred times, by the same careful hands, and it comes up out of the dark with a faint clinging breath of tar and old rain.

“Evidence bag,” says Wynn. “Camera on it. Ms. Fenner, you’ll open it. I’d rather it were you.”

“I’ve been told the chain,” I say.

“The Judge told me. I’m choosing to take it anyway, with a second reader behind you on Monday.” He does not smile. “Go on. Gloves.”

---

Inside the oilcloth, in the tin, there is a thick bundle of carbon sheets tied up in kitchen string, with a card tucked into the knot. A label on the top sheet, in a neat engineer’s hand, says: APRIL 7 to JUNE 30.

I untie it with a pair of tweezers. The card says, in pencil, not in the careful hand but in a hurried one, as of a man who has been interrupted:

For Miss Ada. If you are reading this I am either dead or have been brave. Either way I am sorry for the delay.

C. Teague

I read it twice. I read it aloud for the camera, in the plain voice. Then I put it on the sheet and I do not look at it again, because the next thing I have to do is read April the eighth.

“Which is it?” says Wynn. “The desk book, or the carbon?”

“The carbon. The desk book is the one on the shelf, the one the Association reads, and it has been changed whenever he was told.” I turn the tin so that the camera can see. “The second copy is made as he writes, with the sheet beneath, and it is the one he kept.” I breathe. “He didn’t tell me it was here. He said the dead-rail drawer.”

“A decoy.”

“A courtesy,” I say. “To himself. If someone came for the drawer, he would know someone had been told.”

---

I find the page by the dates. The paper is soft, with a faint tooth to it, and the pencil has gone silver with the years. Teague writes with a carpenter’s pencil in a hand a very little larger than one expects of him, and with a habit that I know from the black book, of setting a short dash after each time.

I do not need the camera to tell me that his hand is a different hand from the hand that traced Marie Marchand. It is clumsy and warm and a little slanted, a hand that has never in its life been in a hurry.

APR. 8. THURS.

6:00 p.m. On.

6:40 Radio check Margaret Anne. Clear.

7:15 Mr. Fenner at the gate, did not come in. Spoke to him through the fence. He had a green envelope. Said it was for “the Aldous woman.” I said I was not the post office.

8:40 Mrs. C. telephoned, a call from the clinic office. Asked if Dr. H. was on the Association roll as available “tonight, or at his Florida number.” I said I did not know. She said, “I will need the form for N.A. wanted by morning, and Dr. H.’s stamp. It is to be a heart.” I said, a form, ma’am? She said “Log it as a form.”

9:52 Mrs. Aldous on the line. 4 mins 10 secs. She was frightened.

I read it, and I hear, for a moment, the sound my own pulse makes.

“Say that again,” says Wynn. His voice is entirely different. “Slowly, Ms. Fenner. And say the time.”

“Eight-forty p.m. Mrs. Cade telephoned the dispatcher from the clinic office. She asked for a form. For N.A. For a heart. She asked for it wanted by morning, and for the doctor’s stamp.” I stop.

“Nell did not telephone until nine fifty-two. Nell was alive at eight-forty. She was well enough to have said goodnight to my father at the door at a quarter past eight and to have sat down afterward to write twelve numbered matters on a roll of tape. And at eight-forty Imogene Cade was already ordering the certificate.”

“Premeditation,” says someone, near the door. I think it is the younger of Voss’s lawyers, who has gone green.

“Objection,” says Voss, mildly, from the sill. “To the characterization.”

“Mr. Voss, you may not object. You are not a party. You are in the doorway.”

“I am the Association’s counsel.”

“The Association’s counsel is standing on a piece of evidence,” says Wynn pleasantly, “and I will have him moved before it is a second piece.”

---

It is the reel that finds us. It is not in the carbon, or the book, and it does not turn up for another forty minutes, while the team goes through the cabinet and the counter, and Otis finds the old tape recorder.

It is built into the radio cabinet, behind a panel at the back that opens with a thumbscrew: a reel-to-reel machine of the sort that ships used to carry, with two spools, one of them a good deal fuller than the other. A small brass plate on the front is stamped INSURER REQUIRED, A.P. 1998.

“It’s connected to the switchboard,” says Otis, crouching, with his hat on the floor beside him. “Every line in and out of this building. The insurer made them put it in. Anything that’s said to a pilot on a boat, anything the night man says to a captain. It runs when the console’s lit.”

“Does it run now?”

“It’s got a tape in it, Ada. It’s got a tape, and it’s, hold on.” He lowers a pair of reading glasses from his forehead. “The take-up’s been fed through by hand. The leader’s new. Somebody’s threaded this in the last day, not the last year. And the label on the reel’s” He stops.

“Read it.”

“APR. 5 to APR. 12. In Cosmo’s writing.”

Nobody says a word. Every person on the pier has come to the door, and every one is breathing as quietly as a man in a church.

“Does it work?” says Wynn.

“They built them to outlast the insurer,” says Otis. “They don’t die.”

“Then I will have it carried to the Sheriff’s lab, under guard, by two officers, with Ms. Fenner and Mr. Voss and Mr. Voss’s locksmith watching it go.” Wynn straightens his canvas jacket. “And I should say, for the benefit of everyone present, that I have been a prosecutor for twenty-six years. I have been told many times that a thing could not be found. I’ve found nearly all of them. I have never once found one that was recorded.”

“There may be nothing on it,” says Voss. He has lost the smile; he has retained the manner. “It may be a week of weather and pilot boat calls.”

“There may,” says Wynn. “I look forward to hearing the weather.”

---

I am at the rail of the pier, with the wind at my back, at twenty minutes to three, when I am served.

I do not see it coming. I am looking at the sea. It is a slate-gray water, with a long pale line of sandbar to the south, and a single tanker, enormous, red-hulled, being hauled in toward the channel by two tugs the size of toys. I have been thinking of nothing. I have been thinking of the faint blue line on the clean wood and the pin-pricks in the tape, and of a woman at a kitchen counter who did not take the lid off a tin.

“Ms. Fenner?”

It is the younger of Mr. Voss’s lawyers. He has gone from green to the color of dishwater, and in his hand there is a thin, clean, folded paper.

“I’m required to give you this. It’s a copy. It’s been filed with the Court and with your probation officer.” He holds it out as one holds out a thing in a shop one hopes the owner will not look at. “I’m sorry. I’m told I am to say that nothing in it is personal.”

I take it. It is two pages. At the head, in capitals, it says: REPORT OF VIOLATION AND REQUEST FOR HEARING. At the foot it is signed, in blue ink, by a man whose name I have seen on a roster, upside down, in a cannery, in a different life.

L. CADE JR., WARDEN, FOR GULFLINE DETENTION SERVICES, AS COMPLAINANT.

It alleges, in the stiff, polite, bloodless language of a lawyer’s drafting, that on January the fifteenth Ada Marie Fenner, a person on supervised release under conditions of a monitored curfew and with a restriction against entering any correctional facility without leave of Court, did knowingly enter the Birch Landing Annex in disregard of an access order, did remain therein for two hours and forty-two minutes.

It alleges further that she did, on January the sixteenth, enter the premises of the Harbor Pilots’ Association, private property, without the consent of the owner, in the company of State agents and under color of a warrant, that she is reasonably believed to have obtained by misrepresentation.

I read it twice. I read the word misrepresentation a third time, as one touches a bruise.

“Is there something I can say?” says the young lawyer, miserably.

“Yes,” I say. “You can tell your employer that the warrant was signed by a judge, and the building was entered by a sheriff, and the only thing I carried in was a pair of eyes.”

“I’ll say that.”

“You can also tell him that I am obliged to him. Very few people have ever been so exact about the hour.” I fold the paper into thirds, as I have seen Imogene Cade do, and I put it in my coat. “Two hours and forty-two minutes. It is a number I will remember.”

He goes away, quickly. Down the pier the Sheriff’s men are carrying the old reel out between them in a padded case, as one carries something asleep, with Wynn beside them and Voss behind, and the long white line of the wake in the harbor behind everyone.

The Judge’s hearing is at four, I know. In an hour and twenty minutes there will be Jude in a room, in a chain, and a Gulfline lawyer, and a monitor ticking quietly on my ankle, and all the polite little ways a building can find to put a person out of her chair.

Otis is at my elbow. “It’s a threat in the form of a motion,” he says. “It’s the same thing the Judge said.”

“I know.” I look at the tanker. It has crossed the bar and is sliding, a mile of red steel, into the lane. “It’s a very good motion. It says exactly what I did.”

“And what did you do?”

“I read a page,” I say, “that somebody had worked very hard to keep from being read.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!