Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 60

The Only Witness

THE COURT: Mr. Fenner, you have been advised that what you say now may be used against you. Do you understand that you may stop at any time?

MR. FENNER: Yes, Your Honor. I’ve never been any good at stopping. That’s been the trouble.

Division F convenes at half past one on Monday, and it is full to the doors.

I sit in the third row, on the aisle, with Colette on my left and Loretta Aldous on my right, her pocketbook on her knees. Otis is behind us. Pru is at the defense table in her gray suit, with her pen uncapped and a face like a closed door. Across the aisle, Wynn sits alone at the State’s table with the box of cover sheets beside him, in his gray cardigan, with the look of a man who has had no lunch and does not expect any.

It is the first time I have been in this room as nothing. Not the reporter. Not the defendant. I have no machine, and no oath, and no duty except to sit still. My hands do not know what to do. They find the hem of my coat and fold it, over and over.

Okonkwo is in the chair. She gives me one brief nod across the well, a young woman in a green blazer who has taken down more of my life than anyone, and puts her fingers on the keys.

The jury comes in. They look at the defendant, and away from him. They are the same twelve. I do not know their names, only that they have been told, since the twelfth, a great deal about a boat and a coat and a tin, and that tonight, perhaps, they will go home.

My father comes in last.

---

He has been given a suit. It is not a good suit. It belonged to someone smaller, and the cuffs show an inch of wrist, and the lapels have been pressed by a hand that did not care. He walks to the defense table with his shoulders down and his chin up and sits, and does not look at the gallery.

I know how he sits when he is afraid. I have known it for thirty years. He puts both hands flat on his knees.

“Mr. Fenner,” says Banks, from the bench. “You have told this Court through counsel that you wish to testify on your own behalf, against the advice of counsel, and in a manner that may waive certain rights. Is that correct?”

“It is, Your Honor.”

“You understand the State has not rested on the matter of the death of Mr. Prejean.”

“I understand it.” He swallows. “I want to say what happened. I want to say it before anybody says it for me.”

“Ms. Delacroix?”

“My client has been told, Your Honor.” Pru does not stand quite straight. She has the look of a young woman who has said the same sentence four times since Saturday and lost each time. “I have noted my objection. I remain at his elbow.”

“So noted. Mr. Fenner, to the stand.”

He rises. It takes him a moment. He is a large man, and the room has gone so quiet that I can hear the heavy scrape of his shoes on the boards. He raises his right hand. The clerk, a small woman in glasses, says the oath, and he says “I do,” in a voice that carries to the back of the gallery like a rope thrown across a gap.

Loretta’s hand finds mine on the pew. I realize I have been gripping the wood.

---

He tells it in forty minutes.

I will not give it all. It is on the record, and it will be read by people who have more right to it than I. I will give what he says, as he says it, and that is the best I can do.

He says that on the fourteenth of October, five years ago, he went down to the Number Nine slip at twenty to ten at night to meet Walter Prejean, because Prejean had written to the auditor and had begun to ask the Fund where a sum of money had gone. He says he took a half-inch wrench from the tool crib on the way, and that he will not pretend he took it by accident.

He says that Prejean stood at the end of the slip with his hands out, palms up, and said, Ray, we’ve been had. He says that what followed, Ray Fenner did.

“I hit him once,” he says. “On Friday I told a judge in chambers that I did not kill Walter Prejean. I said it to a jury, too. That was a lie, and it is the last one I mean to tell. He died of it. Cosmo Teague carried him to the lot, because I asked, and I let him say for five years that it was his own doing. I want all of that said in my voice.”

He does not look at the gallery when he says Teague’s name. I look at the floor.

“I didn’t do it for money. I did it because I was afraid of what he’d say, and because a man I trusted told me that a person like Prejean was a threat to the whole Association, to every family in it. I was told it was a form of protection.”

He says that the page in the bookkeeping room, the late fee that was no fee, was his idea and nobody else’s. He says he dictated it at three o’clock that afternoon to a girl who trusted him, so that there would be a name beside the dead man’s initials. He says it in the same level voice, and the only sign of what it costs him is that his hands, which have stayed flat on the rail, press down until the knuckles go pale.

“Who told you?” says Wynn. He has risen, very slowly, with one hand on the table.

“Mrs. Cade.”

There is a sound in the gallery like a sail filling.

“On what occasion?”

“She said it in her office, in the back, with a pot of tea. She said that Walter had been talking to a reporter. She said she’d see I was looked after.” His hands are flat on the rail of the stand. “And she was. Twenty-five thousand dollars, in a green envelope, delivered by a man in a gray van. I never counted it. I put it in a tobacco tin and I let my daughter think it was the roof.”

I do not look at anyone. I look at the back of my father’s head, at the gray hair thinning above his collar, and I think of a kitchen table and a pencil and the letter A.

---

Voss objects four times, and four times Banks says “Overruled” in a voice that grows quieter each time.

“Mr. Fenner,” says Wynn, “you have said that you were handed a tin on Wednesday the seventh of April.”

“Noon. In the Association hall. Mrs. Cade gave it to me herself. She said it was for a long week.”

“Did you know what was in it?”

“No, sir.”

“What did you do with it?”

“I put it on the seat of Nell’s car in the Blue Heron lot, that evening, with the window cracked.” He stops. For a moment I think that he will not go on. “I did it because I was told to. I did it because I’d been told that Nell had been unwell, and that the Association was looking after her. I did not think about it, Mr. Wynn. I want that understood. I have thought of nothing else since. But I did not think about it then.”

“And the next day?”

“I carried an envelope. Green, like the other. I went to the house at five to eight. She let me in. She gave me a glass of water.” His voice thins. “She told me on the porch that somebody was going to hurt her. And I said she was being a fool.”

He is looking at Loretta.

I feel her go still beside me, with her mouth shut and her chin lifted, in the exact posture of a woman receiving a verdict.

“I said that to your sister, ma’am,” says my father, across the courtroom, to a stranger in a navy dress. “I’m sorry. I’d give a good deal to take it back.”

“Mr. Fenner,” says Banks, quietly. “Address the Court.”

“Yes, Your Honor.” He turns his head. “I’m sorry.”

Loretta Aldous looks at him for a long, long time. She does not nod. She does not look away.

It is, I think, the only form of absolution that she has to give, and the only one that he can bear.

---

It is ten minutes to three when Mr. Voss rises and says that he has no questions, and Wynn says that he has none, and Pru says that she would like to be excused for a moment, because her voice is not at present her own.

My father steps down. The bailiff takes his arm. He does not look at me as he passes. He walks the length of the well with his big hands hanging, and as he reaches the rail there is a small stir at the back of the gallery, and a light, clear, courteous voice says:

“Your Honor. May I be heard?”

Every head in the room turns.

She is standing in the last row by the door, in a gray wool coat and a hat with a short brim, a small straight woman with a handbag over her arm. She has put on her rose lipstick. She has the quiet, ordinary dignity of a person who has come to church late and means to apologize to no one.

“Mrs. Cade,” says Banks, after a pause.

“I have been at liberty since Thursday, Your Honor. I understand my husband was taken from a boatyard gate this morning. I understand there is not yet a warrant for me, which I take as a courtesy.” She walks forward down the aisle, past Colette, past me, past Loretta, with her shoes making a clean dry tapping on the boards, and does not look at any of us. “I should like to make a statement. I should like to be sworn.”

“Mrs. Cade, you are not on the witness list.”

“I am aware, sir. But I find I am the only witness in this room who has all of it.”

“Your Honor,” says Voss, on his feet, with his white face working, “I represent the Association and, as of this morning, Mr. Lionel Cade. I have not been retained by this lady. I advise the Court that she is under medical care, that her statements—”

“Mr. Voss.” She does not raise her voice. “You will sit down.”

It is the voice of thirty-one years of weddings. It is not loud. It is a voice that has never had to be.

Voss sits.

---

She takes the oath with her gloved hand upright, and sits in the stand where my father sat, and arranges her bag at her feet with a little precise shuffle, and folds her hands.

I have been wrong, I think. I thought I knew what the porch was. I thought it was a plea for cover, a carefully drafted shield to put round a husband. It is something else. It is a woman choosing her moment, in the one room in the county where the record is kept, to tell it in her own voice, before her husband’s lawyer, before her son’s, before the town.

“Mrs. Cade,” says Wynn. He is on his feet. His voice has an odd, unwilling gentleness. “You have the right to counsel. You have the right to remain silent.”

“I’ve known it for years. I took the minutes.”

“You may be charged on the basis of whatever you say.”

“I would be very surprised if not.” She smiles, faintly. “Ask me, Mr. Wynn. Ask me what you like. I’ll save you the time. I shall tell it plainly, and then I should like it read back.”

She tells it plainly.

I have never heard a person confess so well. She does not weep. She does not raise her voice. She sits in the witness box with her gloved hands folded and tells the room that she, Imogene Teague Cade, has been Acting Secretary of the Members’ Relief Fund for twenty-two years.

She says that she wrote the Rule, that she devised the arrangement by which a member who wavered was looked after. She says that she supplied the tins. She says that sixty-one members and their families, over twenty-two years, died of a thing she gave them, in the belief that it was a mercy.

She says: “I killed Nell Aldous.”

A sound goes through the courtroom like a long breath out. Loretta’s nails are in my palm.

“I gave her the capsules myself, on the thirty-first of March, in a vitamin bottle. I did it because she had begun to say things. I did it because I couldn’t bear that she should say them.” She turns her head, very slightly, toward the gallery, toward Loretta. “I am sorry. I cannot make it a better thing than it was.”

“And your husband?” says Wynn.

“My husband knew nothing.”

“You are sure of that?”

“He is a man of the most perfect rectitude, Mr. Wynn. I made it my business that he should never be troubled.” Her voice does not shake. “He did what he was told by the Rules. The Rules were mine.”

---

I am looking at her hands.

It is a habit I have, and I cannot break it. A voice can be taught. A face can be taught. A hand, in a stress that has gone on long enough, will do the thing it has always done. Imogene Cade, in the box, in her gray gloves, with her fingers laced, is moving the thumb of her right hand against the knuckle of her left, in a small, slow, regular stroke, like a woman worrying a rosary.

It is a tell. I do not yet know what it is a tell of, and I put it away to read later.

“Mrs. Cade,” says Banks. “You said you would like it read back.”

“I should, Your Honor. I should like it read back and I should like to sign it. In front of this court. In my own hand.” She opens her bag, and takes out a long cream envelope, and I know the paper from the porch. “I have a prepared statement. It’s the one I gave to Ms. Fenner on Saturday evening. I’d like it entered. I’d like it signed under oath. And I would like Ms. Fenner to tell the Court whether it is my hand.”

“I’m not the reporter, Your Honor,” I say, and I am on my feet before I know it, in the third row, with my voice sounding thin as a wire.

“Ms. Fenner.” Banks regards me over his glasses. “Mrs. Cade is aware of that. She has identified you by name for a purpose. I will permit a limited examination. Mr. Wynn?”

“No objection,” says Wynn, in a voice I cannot read.

“Mr. Voss?”

Voss has put his head in his hands.

---

They swear me at the clerk’s desk. I stand in the well, with the whole room behind me and a bright white lamp above, and the clerk puts the statement in front of me in a plastic sleeve, and a clean sheet of paper, and a pen.

“Mrs. Cade,” says Banks. “You’ll sign again, here, for comparison.”

She comes down from the box. She does not hurry. She takes the pen in her gloved fingers and signs her name on the clean sheet, beneath the last line, as I watch, in a flowing, steady, rounded hand, an old convent hand, with a long tail to the g. Imogene Teague Cade. It is a beautiful signature. It is the signature on four hundred marriage licenses. It is the one I have seen all my life.

“Now the other,” says Banks.

I look at the statement.

I look at it for a long time. The courtroom, behind me, is a held breath. I read the four typed pages again, with the heavy capitals and the filled-in e’s, and I turn to the last, and look at the signature at the foot of it, in blue.

It says Imogene Teague Cade. It is round, and steady, and flowing, with a long tail to the g.

It is perfect.

It is too perfect. That is the thing. A person’s own signature is never quite perfect. It varies. It tires. It rushes at the end of the name. I lay the clean sheet beside it under the lamp and I look at them both, and I see it, as one sees a face in a crowd, all at once.

Under the long loop of the C, in the statement, there is a blot.

There is another under the g. There is a third, smaller, after the last e, where the pen has paused.

Three, as there were three on a Release signed in a plaster cast. Three, as there were on the daughter’s signature in a tin. The same man, a careful man, a frightened man, who learned to do it slowly, and who cannot help setting the pen down in the same three places.

My mouth has gone dry. I look up. Mrs. Cade is watching me with that warm, level, courteous attention, with her hands folded at her waist.

“Ms. Fenner,” says Judge Banks. “Is it her hand?”

“No, Your Honor.”

It is a very small sound in a very large room. I hear Voss’s head come up. I hear Wynn put down his pen.

“The signature she has just given the Court is hers,” I say. “The one on the statement is a tracing. It has the same three marks as the Marchand release and the tin. It was made by the hand that signed those, and that hand was not Mrs. Cade’s.” I breathe. “She did not sign her own confession, Your Honor. Someone wrote it first.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!