Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 67

Life, Without Parole

MRS. PREJEAN: My husband wrote a kind thing. I would like it said in this room, once, in his own words, before anyone says what was done to it.

The courtroom is fuller at two o’clock than it was for the verdict, and quieter.

I have the third row again, on the aisle, with Colette and Loretta Aldous beside me and Otis one pew behind, his hat on his knee and the long gray look of a man in the last week of a thirty-year job. Pru is at the defense table with Ray, because Mr. Kessler has withdrawn and the court has appointed her to stand with him for the sentence. She has put on a clean blouse. It does not help. She looks like a woman holding up a wall.

Ray sits in county orange with his hands flat on the table. He has been shaved, badly. There is a small nick under his jaw where the razor was dull, and a thread of dried blood on his collar that nobody has thought to tell him about. I watch it for a while. I cannot decide whether I want to go and wipe it.

Ruth Okonkwo takes the steno chair at five to two, in her green blazer, and sets her machine on its tripod. She does not look at me. She has not looked at me since the closet this morning, when she said that the list had five addresses and she had typed four. I think she is waiting to learn whether I believe her, and I think I do, and I have not yet found a way to tell her that does not sound like an accusation.

The bailiff calls the room to order. Judge Banks comes in with his bow tie and a single sheet of paper, and sits.

“This is the time set for sentencing in the matter of the State against Raymond James Fenner,” he says. “Before I impose the sentence the law requires, I will hear from the family of the deceased. Mr. Fenner has asked that Mrs. Prejean be heard first and that no one speak after her until she is finished. The Court grants that request. Mrs. Prejean.”

---

She comes to the lectern with her knitting bag over her arm, in the same good coat, and does not put the bag down.

It is a heavy canvas thing with wooden handles. I have seen it on her lap in four courtrooms. I realize, watching her settle it against her hip like a purse, that she has brought the work with her, whatever it is, in case this takes long, and that it is the bravest piece of planning I have seen in this building.

“Your Honor,” she says. “I am sixty-eight years old. I was married to Walter Prejean for forty-one years. I would like to read something, if I may. It is not mine.”

“You may.”

From the bag she takes not knitting but a clear plastic sleeve, and in the sleeve a sheet of yellowed ruled paper, folded in three, with a pencil’s soft gray handwriting on both sides. It is the page that was in Harlan Rudd’s Bible. Wynn photographed it Monday night in the sergeant’s presence, and the clerk released a certified copy to her at noon. She does not read from it at first. She holds it a moment in both hands, as I saw Colette hold the seal.

“Walter gave the harbor thirty-four years,” she says. “He walked its docks before light in all weathers, and he kept its books honest until the day somebody told him they were not his to keep. I never once heard him say he was afraid. He drafted this on the seventeenth of October, twenty-one years ago, at our kitchen table, on a legal pad, and I made him a sandwich while he did it.

“I thought it was the sort of thing a man writes when he has been asked to be sensible.”

She puts on her glasses.

“This is the first paragraph of the Rule of the Members’ Relief Fund. It is Walter’s. I’ll read it as he wrote it.”

---

*”Upon the death of any member, or the spouse or the minor child of any member, in the line of the service, the Fund shall pay to the survivors the sum of twenty-five thousand dollars, without condition, without inquiry, and without any paper to be signed in return, so that no widow of this Association shall be made to stand at a desk in her black dress and prove that she is poor.”*

Nobody in the courtroom moves. Okonkwo’s hands are going, very softly, on the keys, and I can hear them the way I would hear rain.

“That is all it says,” says Mrs. Prejean. “That is the whole of his idea. He was thinking about the widow of a man named Alcide Roy, who had been three months at the county office filling in forms. He thought that a Fund ought to be a kindness. And he went to bed that night, and he slept well, I remember. He snored.”

She turns the page over.

“The second paragraph is not in his hand. It is in a typewriter’s. It was added, according to Mr. Rudd, the next day, and it says that the Fund may also pay, at the discretion of the Secretary, in any case where a death *may expose the Association to claim*, on condition of a release signed by the survivor.”

She puts the paper down very carefully on the lectern. “I want to tell the Court what that did. It took a gift and made it into a price. And it took a man who had put down a kind thing and gave him, for the rest of his life, a thing he had written to carry.”

“Mrs. Prejean,” says Banks, quite gently. “Take the time you need.”

“I don’t need more. I have had a great deal of it.”

---

She does not cry. I would have thought she would, and I find that I am almost angry at myself for having thought so.

“My husband went up to Mr. Cade’s office on the twelfth of October, five years ago. He had a letter to the auditor in his pocket, which Miss Fenner has seen, and which I put in his hand myself, since he had trouble with his buttons. He said to me, ‘Vangie, if I’m late, don’t wait supper.’ He was never late in forty-one years.

“Two nights later he was killed at the Number Nine slip, with the tide going out, by people who were told by his own superiors that a person’s death is a matter of paperwork, and that the paperwork had been prepared.”

Her voice does not rise. It becomes, if anything, softer, and I understand that it is costing her something terrible to keep it level.

“I will not forgive Raymond Fenner. I said so in a corridor to his daughter, and I will say it here, because the court should know I am not a woman who says one thing in a corridor and another in a room. But I would like it understood that the kindness in this affair was Walter’s.

“It was one paragraph, and he wrote it. Everything else that has been done in that Association’s name for twenty-one years was done by other people, in a machine’s typeface, and they will answer for it as they are able. I am done, Your Honor.”

She puts the sleeve back into the bag, among the wool. She turns and walks, with her coat buttoned to the chin, across the well and down the aisle and out, and I find, to my surprise, that I am standing, and that so is every person in the room.

Banks does not tell us to sit. He waits, with his hands folded, until we do it ourselves.

---

“Mr. Fenner,” he says. “You have the right to address the Court before sentence. You may speak or not. Ms. Delacroix has advised you, I think, that it will not alter the sentence.”

“She has, Your Honor.” Ray rises. He takes his hands out of his pockets, where he has hidden them, and sets them at his sides, in county orange, in the rough shoes. “I don’t want to say a lot. I’d like to say a thing about a page.”

“Go on.”

“The page Mrs. Prejean read. I’d like to say that I’ve never seen it, until just now, and I knew what it said.” He swallows. “I’ve known for twenty-one years that the first line was a kind one. Walter told me in the parking lot of the chandlery, the afternoon he drafted it. He said it like it was a good joke.

“I was the one who told him that a man with sense wouldn’t write a thing like that without a lawyer. And I went and told Lionel Cade he’d written it. That’s how it got a second paragraph. I didn’t write it. I carried it up the stairs.”

He draws breath. The cut on his jaw has opened a little.

“I told a man who was thinking of saving a widow some trouble that it was dangerous to be kind, and I told it to the one man in the harbor who’d make him pay for it. That’s what I did, Your Honor. The rest is in the record. I’ve said it all, and I’ll say it again if somebody wants it read. I want to say that I did it, and that I knew, and that I’d like it kept.”

“Kept?”

“Kept in the record. I know there’s some that want it struck, now that his lawyer’s gone and the wife’s a witness. I’d as soon have it left.” He looks at Okonkwo. “Miss, if you’d leave it.”

“I’ll leave it, Mr. Fenner,” says Okonkwo, without turning round, and her voice is not what I expected. It is quiet and clear and utterly without relish. I think she has decided something, in the last few hours, about what her work is.

Ray nods once and sits.

---

The sentence takes less than a minute, because the law has already made it.

“Raymond James Fenner, on the count of murder in the first degree, you are sentenced to life imprisonment in the custody of the Department of Corrections, without the possibility of parole, probation, or suspension of sentence. On the count of conspiracy, thirty years. On the count of tampering with evidence, ten years. The latter two run concurrently.”

Banks lays down his pen. “You will be transported to the Department’s reception center. I will say plainly that this Court has no discretion, and that if it had any, it would still have to be exercised in a manner that this courtroom has just seen described by a better person than I am.”

He looks at Ray with the long, level, unhurried regard I have seen him give a hundred defendants, and which I realize I have never before seen applied to a man I could call my father.

“You are remanded. The Court is in recess.”

I do not hear the gavel. I have stopped listening for it. Two bailiffs stand beside Ray, and one takes his elbow, and Ray rises, and then, as he did on Tuesday, turns at the rail.

He does not look at me this time. He looks at Colette.

“Miss Marchand,” he says. “Your father would’ve been sixty-three this March.”

“I know,” says Colette. Her voice is not steady.

“He was a better man than I was. I’d like you to know I thought so then.” He looks at the floor. “That’s all.”

They take him through the side door, the one prisoners use, and it shuts with a quiet click, and the courtroom empties around me in a slow, murmuring flood.

---

Wynn finds me in the corridor outside the clerk’s office, where I have gone to stand against a cool wall and not be looked at.

He has a thin yellow slip in his hand, the kind the Chancery clerk uses for rulings by telephone, and he holds it with two fingers, as if it were damp.

“Chancellor Mayhew,” he says. “Pru called him at a quarter past one. He heard her for three minutes. He says that Judge Banks’s remark about Friday is a remark, and that a trustee’s sale noticed on the fourteenth is a creature of the deed, and that he will not enjoin a foreclosure on a lien until someone has filed a pleading that says so in the proper form.”

“Then she files.”

“She is filing now. He will hear it Thursday at four.” He looks at the slip. “It is not a ruling that a man makes who is afraid of something. I would almost prefer it. Mayhew simply follows the book. He has followed it for thirty years, and the book has a great many places in it where a sale can go forward on the day it says.”

“Four o’clock Thursday. And the sale is Friday at ten.”

“Which leaves eighteen hours, Ms. Fenner, in which the other side must lose its nerve, or someone must find that the assignment to Tall Tide was made on a day when the Fund had no Secretary.” He turns the slip over and puts it in his pocket. “I wish that I could tell you I think it likely.”

“Mr. Wynn.” I say it before I have decided to. “Why did you let Mrs. Prejean read Walter’s page?”

“I did not let her. I gave her the copy at noon, because it was hers.” His mouth moves, a small dry tuck at one corner. “I confess I did not know she would read it. I thought she might fold it into her bag with the wool and look at it on a bus. A great many people who are bereaved wish to hold a thing. She wished, I think, to be heard in a particular voice.”

“It’s the only time anyone’s said what it was supposed to be.”

“Yes.” He glances down the corridor, where the pilots are leaving in ones and twos with their hats in their hands. “And I would note that no one in that room who wore a ship’s wheel on his lapel did so today. I counted. It is a small thing, and I distrust small things that happen all at once.”

“What does it mean?”

“It means,” says Wynn, “that someone has told them to take the pins off. And I should very much like to know whom.”

---

Jude is brought up from the county jail for the sentence, and stands in the holding box at the back of Division F with a deputy on each side, in his orange and his shower shoes, with the Bible in his hands.

It is the first time I have seen him since Monday. I stop at the foot of the stairs, and Otis stops with me, and then he does a thing I will remember when the rest of this blurs, which is that he puts his hat on and walks away three paces and stands with his back to us, looking at a fire notice.

“Ada.”

He speaks the way a man speaks who has been told that his voice will cost him something and has decided to pay. It is hoarse, and low, and very exact.

“You came.”

“I’ve been in the room since two.”

“I know. I counted heads.” He tries to smile. The lip is healing, with a ridge of pink along the seam, and the smile breaks across it and gives up. “You took the third row. You always take the third. Why?”

“Because the record never starts in the third row. Nobody’s looking at me.”

“I’m looking at you.”

“I know.”

The deputy on his left, a young man with enormous ears, studies the ceiling.

“Rudd told me something,” says Jude, very low. “Monday night, after you left. About the Friday line. He said the transfers aren’t ever done on a Friday, because Fridays the Warden’s out. He said they do it at the minute the contract turns over. Twelve-oh-one.” He looks at my face. “Does that mean anything to you?”

“It means the contract renews at midnight on Thursday.”

“Then they’ll come at midnight.” He says it simply, as a man might say that the tide would turn at seven. “I wanted you to know I’m not afraid of it. I’d like to say I’m not. I’m not afraid of a van. It’s the room at the end.”

“What room?”

“Unit B. Rudd says it’s got no window.” He shifts the Bible to one hand. “I don’t mind a room. I mind a room where nobody has to write down what’s done in it.”

I understand him. I understand it more exactly than I can say.

---

At five-oh-two, in Pru’s borrowed office on the third floor, with a sandwich nobody has eaten, the telephone rings.

It is Deloach, and she is out of breath. I can tell because I have learned the way the Sergeant breathes when she has run, which is through her nose, with a small, furious whistle.

“Put Wynn on.”

“He’s here.”

“I’m at the county main. I’m standing at the records window. I’d like somebody to come and look at what’s on my screen, because I’ve been a desk sergeant nineteen years, and I don’t believe I’m reading it.”

Wynn takes the receiver. I stand at his elbow and I hear her, tinny and small, over the line.

“Housing roster, Mr. Wynn. Jude Marchand, booking number whatever. Cell Twenty-Two, Old Block, until four fifty-eight this afternoon. Then it changes.” She breathes. “Status, *Unit B, Pending.* Entered by SECR. Nobody typed it. I had my hand on the mouse. And his Thursday visiting slot, the one you had Banks order for him at one o’clock, with Ms. Fenner, is gone. It’s grayed out. It says *Not Available.*”

“The order was signed.”

“The order is on paper. The roster’s in the machine.” There is a pause, and I hear her swallow. “Mr. Wynn, I’ve got a jail full of men who go where the screen says. Not a one of them, nor a deputy on this floor, was ever trained to do otherwise. I can put a man on Jude’s door myself. I can’t put a man on the machine.”

Wynn looks at me over the top of the telephone. He has his glasses off, and it makes his face look unfinished.

“Sergeant,” he says. “How long to the next change?”

“There’s not a next change. It’s tomorrow at six. And tomorrow at six, it runs again.”

“And Thursday night?”

“Thursday night,” says Deloach, “is the night they’ve been counting to.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!