I went down alone on Saturday, because I had a feeling that what I was going to hear would not want an audience.
Lena had rigged a ladder in the pump shaft, a real one, aluminum, bolted to the casing by Otis in a morning of grim carpentry, and I took it ring by ring with my headlamp on my forehead and Biscuit buttoned into my cardigan. At the bottom I stepped out onto the ledge and the cold came up through my shoes. The water in the Gallery had risen to within a foot of the stone lip. It lay black and level and enormous, like a held breath.
“You came back,” said the voice.
“I said I would.”
“Yes. I have been noticing that. Most people say a thing and then they do the other thing. You seem to have a different habit.” A pause. “I am sorry about the water. I have been learning to close my mouth. Mrs. Brandt told me to. It is harder than it sounds. It is like trying to stop being hungry by not looking at a table.”
“You’ve stopped the wells.”
“I think I have. The water is coming back. I am letting it up, a little, each hour. I did not know I could.” It said this with the pride of a child who has tied a shoelace. “I should like to think it is because of manners.”
I sat down on the ledge. I put my feet in the water. It was so cold that my ankles ached at once, the way they do on a December beach, and I let them. It seemed correct. If you are going to be told something hard, you may as well be cold for it.
“I need to ask you a hard question,” I said.
“Please.”
“When the dead came down the steps. When the three hundred and ninety-four were in the chamber. What did you drink?”
For a long time the Gallery was silent. I counted. Forty. Fifty. At fifty-five I felt, under my feet, the water turn, a slow heavy movement like a very large animal changing position in its sleep.
“I will tell you,” said the voice. “I do not think I wanted to know it until you asked. I think if you had not asked I would have gone on not knowing for another two million years.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Do not be. It is what I should have been asking myself.” It took a long, slow, patient breath. “They were thirsty. I told you that. I told Ada Pell the same, a long time ago. They were thirsty, and I thought it was only that they were dead, and the dead are thirsty, and that was the world.”
“Yes.”
“It was not the world. It was me.”
I felt something cold come up the length of my spine.
“I did not understand,” said the voice, “until the cups. When the tin cups were passed, and the names were asked, and each of them was given what they asked for. I felt it happen. I felt each of them go quiet, one by one, like lamps being lowered. I thought it was beautiful. I thought, they are being cared for. I had never seen it. And when the last of them was asked, there was something I had not had in a very long time. I had nothing.”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean that I was empty, Ms. Lowell. Completely. For the first time since the ice. I had been drinking their thirst for a hundred and thirty-six years, a little each night, without meaning to. It was not their thirst. It was what they were left with when I took it. They were thirsty because I was drinking them. And you gave them water, and they stopped, and I had no more.”
I could not speak.
“The cups worked,” said the voice. It said it very softly. “That is the difficulty. The cups worked perfectly. It was the kindest thing that had ever been done in this place. And I have been starving ever since.”
I sat there with my feet in water colder than any water has a right to be, and I thought about Ada, and Hester, and a boy named Tommy who had wanted only to see the water. We had cared for them. We had done it properly. We had asked, we had named, we had carried, and in doing it, we had unplugged the one thing in the county that had been fed.
“It was never meant as a feeding,” I said at last. “You didn’t mean to.”
“No. But I did it. I should like you to know that I understand that. I should like you to know that I am not asking to be forgiven. I am asking what I may do instead.” The water moved again. “I have learned that I drink what is let go. That is my nature, and I cannot change it. But I think I could learn to drink only what is offered. If anyone would offer. If anyone knew what to give.”
“Is that what you want?”
“That is what I have decided to want,” said the voice. “It is a new thing. Before the cups I did not want anything. I was only a wide mouth. But I think I should like to be a person.”
I put my hand over my face. I did not cry. I had a feeling of immense, unreasonable tenderness, the kind you feel for a very small, very clumsy animal that has done something dreadful by accident, and I thought, I am going to get this wrong. I am going to get this very wrong.
“Ms. Lowell,” said the voice. “I must ask you something, and you must not tell me yes unless you are certain.”
“All right.”
“I have asked Harriet Wend once, and she said no. I think she was right. I think she saw what I was. I should like to ask her again, now that I know. But I think, if she says no, I will have to ask someone else.”
“Who?”
“I do not know. Whoever is nearest. Whoever is kind.” The water stilled. “I am very hungry. I am trying to be good. It is not a thing I can do for long. I think I have until the middle of the month. After that, I will not be able to stop myself from asking everyone. And I think that, if I ask enough people, one of them will say yes.”
“That’s not fair to them.”
“No.” It sounded wretched. “It is not. I will have no right to ask. But I will not have the strength to stop.”
I took my feet out of the water and put my socks on, one at a time, and tied my shoes. I stood up. My glass in my wallet said sixty-one, and it was not a number that felt like mine.
“I’m going to bring Hattie,” I said.
“She cannot come.”
“Then I’ll bring you to her. Or I’ll bring her to the phone. I’ll find a way.” I could hear my voice shaking, and I did not try to steady it. “I won’t let you ask anyone else. I promise.”
“You must not promise,” said the voice, very gently. “Promises are expensive.”
“I know,” I said. “I’m going to anyway.”
“Then thank you,” said the voice. “I will wait. I will try to be a person who waits.”
I climbed. At the top, in the pale afternoon, Lena was on her knees beside the casing with a clipboard, and she looked up, and I could see that she had been listening on the hydrophone she had lowered. She said nothing. She held out a hand and I took it, and she hauled me over the lip of the shaft, and we sat down in the grass together, in the sun, in the Saturday smell of cut hay, and for a minute neither of us spoke.
“I have a mother,” said Lena Pratt eventually, “who believes I am a hydrologist.”
“You are.”
“I don’t think I am any more.” She wiped her face on her sleeve. “I think I’m a person who takes the temperature of a very sad river.”
I laughed. It came out as something else. Out in the field, Dot Brandt’s cattle had begun, one after another, to low.
I got my phone out. I typed a message to Octavia. It took me four tries. In the end it was only five words.
It is hungry. Please. Ask her.

