At midnight, in the Cold Room, Dee Kowalczyk called the hearing to order by banging the lid of her thermos on the top of a granite stone.
“This is a Step Two,” she said. “Under the by-laws of Local 9, Wellwrights, Dowsers and Cistern Workers, in the matter of a grievance by a person of the surface against a keeper of the ground. I chair. The record is kept by Mr. Calder, who is not a member, but has been given a pencil.” She put the lid down. “Form 9-B is filed. The keeper has been offered pie.”
“It had apple,” said Rafe.
“It’s on the form.”
I had never been so tired. We were thirteen in a room built for nine boys and a stove. The cap lay on the old slate over the print, a round gray stone with a faint line of hand-cut letters, and it was warm in the way a person’s forehead is warm. I knelt on one side of it, with the rope round my ribs and a pad of paper I had written nothing on. Across the stone, on an upturned crate, with his cap in his hands, sat Josiah Wend. Lavinia stood at my shoulder in her apron. Zara and Rafe held the rope. Calder sat on the bottom step with his legs crossed and his pencil over his pad. Finch had been brought down in the arms of a long, silent, shuffling procession of his own friends, and sat by the long table with Ruth, solid, upright, and rather frightened. Mr. Bell, the dead lawyer, had appeared out of the wall without being asked, with his gavel, and was looking round with a hungry delight.
“The aggrieved will state her case,” said Dee.
I stood up. It took me two tries. I read it off my own palm, which I had written on in a very small hand in the hour before, because it is the only place I trust.
“On Monday the sixth of April,” I said, “I was asked a question. The question was, ‘Would you like us to keep him?’ It was asked of me when I was afraid, and in a way that could not be answered by one word. I said, ‘Yes, and no. Don’t.’ The keeper took the first word. A man who is dying has been kept on the strength of it. I am not claiming that the keeper lied. I am claiming that I said no, and that the question was built so that I would also say yes.”
“Objection,” said Mr. Bell, with great joy.
“Sustained,” said Dee, “to the extent that I’m not sure what it is. Sit down, Mr. Bell.”
“I have not been objected to in a hundred and fifteen years,” said the lawyer, “and I should like it noted that it was exquisite.”
“It’s noted,” said Calder, writing.
“The keeper will respond,” said Dee. “State your name, for the record.”
There was a long pause. The cap hummed.
“We have not got one,” said the Neighbor. “The Tender has been kind enough to give us a word. It is a very great honor.” It sounded slightly nervous. “We do not contest the facts. She said yes. She said no. We heard both. We took the yes because it was first, and because, in the habit of a hundred and thirty-nine years, a yes is the thing that is said. We are not accustomed to the other.”
“Your witness,” said Dee.
“The builder.”
Josiah lifted his head. He had gone gray in the lamplight, an enormous worn man. “I was the first to ask it,” he said. “In eighteen eighty-six. I knelt in the ashes and told it what I wanted. I did not ask its name. I did not ask what it would take. I said, a house that will not burn, and it said, yes, and I thought it was a mercy. It has done what I asked for a hundred and thirty-nine years.” He took a breath. “It has never once broken its word. It is the most faithful servant I have ever had. And I have never, I think, thanked it.”
“Sir,” said Calder gently, “for the record. Did it ever, in all that time, refuse a request?”
“No.”
“Did it ever say no to you?”
“No.” The builder looked at his hands. “It never knew that it could.”
I heard a small, appalled sound from the stone. It was not a word. It was the breath of something that had never been told a thing it did not know.
“The kept will speak,” said Dee. “Mrs. Cobb.”
Lavinia took one step forward onto the cap’s edge. She had the white towel folded over her arm. She stood with her feet planted on the granite like a woman on a wet floor, and she did not look at me, and she did not look at Dee. She looked straight down.
“I said no to you once,” said Lavinia. “It was nineteen oh nine. You said, ‘Would you like us to keep it?’ And I said, ‘No, thank you, I’ll keep it.’ And you said, ‘Of course.’ Do you remember that?”
“We remember it,” said the Neighbor, very quietly. “It is one of the dearest we have.”
“Then you know it takes a no. You took mine. You never asked twice. You have been the politest thing in the ground for a hundred and sixteen years, and you took it, and you let me be.” She planted her fists on her hips. “She said no. I heard her. She said, ‘Don’t, please, don’t.’ That’s a no. You know it is. You’re only a bit too shy to say you heard.”
The cap hummed. There was a very long silence. I felt it the way you feel a gate in a field, in the soles of my feet.
“We heard it,” said the Neighbor.
Nobody moved.
“We heard it. We have turned it, since Monday, a great many times. It was a, it was a no. We kept the yes because it was the first, and because it was, it was easier. And because,” and its voice dropped, “we were afraid that if we asked again we would be told something we did not wish to hear.”
“Which is?” said Dee.
“That we were wrong.”
I looked at Finch. He had risen, I do not know when. He was standing quite straight by the long table, in his cardigan, with his hand on Ruth’s shoulder, and his glasses, for once, on his nose.
“Madam,” he said. His voice carried perfectly. “I should like to say a word to the keeper, if the chair permits.”
“The chair permits,” said Dee.
“You are not wrong,” said Finch. “You have only been alone with a very large number of other people’s fears. It does not make a person wise. I speak as a man in the profession.” He paused. “It is quite all right to find out that one has been mistaken. I did it last Thursday. It was most instructive.”
“We will give him back,” said the Neighbor, abruptly. “We are sorry. We will, it is the right, we think, it is the thing to do, only,” it faltered. “Tender. You should know what it is. When a keeping is returned, it is returned entire. What was kept is given. We will return it all. He will have it again, all seventy-one, all at once. He will feel the going in full. And it will not be slow. He has a great deal of time owed to him, and it will come all in a week.”
“How long?” said Ruth.
“A week. Perhaps less.” It said it with a kind of agony. “He will go afraid. We have taken it from a great many who went afraid. It was the only kind thing we had.”
I did not look at Ruth. I think I would have broken.
“Aldous,” I said. “You don’t have to.”
“I know,” said Finch. “I decided on Thursday. It has simply taken the three of us this long to say it.”
“Then it is settled,” said Dee, softly. She had taken her hat off. “The grievance is upheld. Pending terms.”
“There are terms,” said the Neighbor. “We have three questions, Tender. So have you. You have used two. You have one left. We have one. We would like you to ask yours, and answer ours, and then there will be a, an arrangement.” It paused. It sounded like a thing that has been rehearsing something for a very long time and now does not want to. “Ask your third. And we will ask ours. Ours, you will not like.”

