I had been saving the third question for a month without knowing it, and when the moment came I found that I had two of them and no time to decide.
The first was What is under the Roll. It was the big one. It was the one that had been sitting in my chest since Josiah told me about the stove, a cold lump with edges, and I knew that if I asked it, the cap would hum and the floor would open and I would be given an answer that I would carry for the rest of my life. The second was shorter. I had thought of it on Friday, on the sidewalk, with Ruth’s tea in me.
“Pencils down?” said Dee, softly. “Hon, take your time. It’s a long night.”
“I know what I want to ask,” I said.
It was a quarter past one on Sunday morning. The lamp on the long table had burned down to a small yellow bead. Behind me the Nine sat in a row on Josiah’s bed with a blanket over all their knees, and Amos had fallen asleep against Bart’s arm with his mouth open. Calder’s pencil had stopped. Finch stood by Ruth with his hands folded, and in the dim light I could not tell whether he was shaking.
I put my palm on the cap. It was warm, and quite still, like a held breath.
“What do you want?” I said.
I do not think it expected it. I felt the whole stone go silent under my hand, as a person goes silent who has been asked, for the first time in a hundred and thirty-nine years, a question that is not about someone else.
“We have not been asked that,” said the Neighbor.
“I know.”
“It is a very large one. We would like to answer it properly.” It was a long time. “We want to be told when it is morning.”
I did not understand. Behind me I heard a very small boy wake up.
“We have never seen it. We are in the ground. We keep what comes down to us, and what comes down is the worst hour, always, the night part. We have a great many nights.” It spoke quite slowly, like a child going carefully along a very high wall. “We have never had a morning. The boys, the little ones, upstairs. They wanted it. Their wanting came down to us for a hundred and thirty-nine years. We kept it, and we did not know what it was. We thought it was a very strange fear. We did not know it was a, a hope.”
I heard Amos say, sleepily, “Is it talking about us?”
“And we would like,” said the Neighbor, “to be visited. We would like someone to come and sit, and not ask us to keep anything. We would like a person who is not afraid of us to say, ‘It is Thursday, and nothing is wrong.’ We have been, Lavinia said it, we have been lonely. We did not know it was a thing that could be said.” It paused. “That is all. It is not very much. It is, we think, rather a lot.”
I took my hand off the cap. I did not know that I was crying until Zara put a handkerchief into my fist. It was one of Finch’s, I saw, a large square cotton thing with a monogram, and she had been carrying it, I think, for three days.
“That is your third,” said Dee, in a voice quite changed.
“It is,” said the Neighbor. “And now ours.” It drew itself up, as a child does at the start of a recitation. “Pippa Lowell. Tender. Will you come back?”
“That’s it?”
“We said you would not like it.” It was almost apologetic. “It must be true. It must be an honest answer, or it is spent. Will you come back? On Thursdays, at midnight, to this stone. For as long as you are Tender, and when you are not, will you find another who will? Will you sit with us, and not be afraid, or if you are afraid, will you say so? And will you bring, each time, someone who is not afraid of us at all?”
Nobody spoke. I could hear the stove ticking. I could hear, behind me, the Nine breathe.
“You would be the first,” said the Neighbor. “It is not like the builder. He would not say. It is not like the lady with the lattice. We should like it to be a promise, and not a transaction. We do not know the difference. We wish to learn.”
I thought about it. I want to be exact. It was the only honest answer I had given all week that cost me nothing in advance, and so I did what I always do, which was to list.
I was afraid of coming back. I was afraid I would run out of things to say. I was afraid that on some Thursday I would have a fever, or be in Cleveland, or be dead. I was afraid of the stair, and the cap, and the three questions, and the thing in the dark with its jars. I was afraid I had been taken in by a very kind voice, which is how people are taken in. I was afraid of what it would be like to say yes.
And I was afraid that if I said no, a thing that had never been loved would go on, for another hundred and thirty-nine years, being polite.
“Yes,” I said.
It was not loud. It did not feel like courage. It felt like putting down a very heavy bag and discovering, with some surprise, that I was still holding the handle.
“Yes, Thursdays,” I said. “And I’m scared. I’m going to be scared every time, I think, and I’ll say so. And you’re not to take it. I’d like to keep it.” I swallowed. “And I’ll bring someone who isn’t. Zara. Amos. Fee. Anyone. And if I can’t, I’ll send someone. And I’ll teach them to knock.”
“Will you,” said the Neighbor.
“Yes.”
“We will not take it.” It sounded awed. “We will, we will keep nothing that is not offered. Not from you. Not from the dead, unless they ask twice, in daylight, with a friend. We will keep the fire from the house, as we did, if you ask. We will not feed on the bound. We will, we will take the work, if you will give it. It is the third Courtesy. We have been reading.”
“And the boys,” said a thin voice from behind me.
I turned. Amos Dyer was standing on the bed in his nightshirt with the blanket round his shoulders, seven years old, with his hair on end and his chin up. He had gone very pale, and very fierce.
“I’ll tell you,” he said, to the stone. “When it’s morning. I’m up first. I’ll go on the roof and I’ll look, and I’ll come and tell you. Every day.” His voice cracked. “That’s my work.”
“Amos,” said Josiah.
“I want it, Mr. Wend,” said Amos. “I want to be the one. Let it be written.”
It was a very long time before the Neighbor spoke. When it did, it was in a whisper.
“We should like that,” it said, “more than anything.”
And then, because it was a thing that kept its word, it gave him back. I felt it go. It was a long, slow, gentle sigh, like the breath of a very tired man laying down a coat, and the slate cooled under my hand. I looked up. Across the room, in the lamplight, I saw Aldous Finch put both hands over his face.
“Oh,” he said, through them. “Oh. There you are.”
I saw it come. All of it, at once, seventy-one items, the elevator and the telephone and the brown paper bag in the closet, all returned to him in a single wave. His knees went. Ruth caught him. He held on to her, shaking, with his glasses crooked, and the old gray fear in his face, quite naked, and quite his own. And through his cardigan, faint and clear in the light of the lamp, I saw the brick of the wall.
“I’m afraid,” said Finch, to his sister. He sounded astonished. “Ruthie. I am so very afraid.”
“I know, love.”
“It is dreadful. It is quite wonderful.” He lifted his head. He was laughing and crying, and his face was wet. “Ms. Lowell, I wish to see the front door. At once. While I am still afraid enough to enjoy it.”

