Jude
There is a particular kind of shame in hearing your own voice from a drunk-dial you don’t remember, and mine was worse, because I was sober, and I had been so careful.
“Wil,” said the man on the tape. “I don’t know if these are on.”
“They’re on,” said Birdie, very quietly, to nobody, from her bucket, and put her hand over her mouth.
I had expected to sound like a tragedy. I sounded like a man in a hallway at one in the morning looking for a light switch. Thirty-one years old, hoarse from a two-hour show, a little hollow behind the consonants. In the garage in Cloquet, a heated room full of a stranger’s weather, I sat on the concrete with my back against Willa’s knees and listened to myself walk across a stage.
You could hear the walk. Boots on plywood, a long slow echo off an empty arena, then the squeak of the riser. A pause. A soft, flat, thudding sound that I knew at once, because I have made it with my forehead against a tom-tom in my sleep ever since.
“Okay,” said the tape. “Okay. Floor tom. The sixteen.”
Willa’s hand tightened on my shoulder.
“You’re the one she hits when she’s mad,” said the Jude on the tape. “She doesn’t know that. She thinks she hits you the same as everything. She hits you about nine percent harder when she’s angry and she never notices, and I’ve never told her, because I thought it was the only honest thing about her.” A breath that was nearly a laugh. “Which is a hell of a thing to say about a woman who’s been lying to me for three weeks and doesn’t know I know.”
“Oh,” said Willa, very softly, beside my ear.
I had forgotten. I had actually forgotten this part. I had been so sure the tape was a twenty-two-minute confession that I had not remembered it was also twenty-two minutes of a man being tender about drums.
He went down the kit. I will say that for him, the man on the tape: he was thorough. He did the sixteen and the thirteen and the twelve. He did the snare, which he called “the witness.” He did the kick, which he said had a small flat spot at the center of the head where her beater lands and he’d been meaning to buy her a patch for six years.
He did the cymbals, one at a time, as if he were reading a roll call. He told the hi-hat he was sorry. He told the crash on the left, the one she lifts her hand for a quarter beat early, that he’d noticed.
“I noticed in March,” he said, to the crash. “In Denver, the second night. And I thought, she’s counting. And then I thought, she’s not counting. And I went and looked in her bag.” The voice cracked, just a little, on the word bag. “Four hours ago. In a corridor. Under an exit sign. I read it three times.”
Nobody in the garage moved. The tape hissed. A bar of gray light lay across the steel table and across the big slow wheels of the deck, turning, turning, and I could hear Willa’s breath, steady, in fours, a bar of four, a bar of four.
“Do you want me to stop it?” said Birdie.
“No,” said Willa.
“Do you want me to turn it up?”
“A little,” said Willa. “I can hear the room. I can’t hear him.”
Birdie touched a fader. The hiss came up, the big empty air, and I heard my own throat in the dark, thick and close.
“I’m going to practice,” said the tape. “Since you can’t hear me. I’ve got until the bus leaves, which is five. Seven hours. I’m going to say it to a drum, because a drum can’t hate me back.”
And then, God help me, I did.
I’m not going to repeat all of it. A man is entitled to the worst twenty minutes of his life, and some of it was only embarrassing.
I did the speech where I told her I’d gotten a solo offer, which was a lie, and graded it out loud like a diving judge: “Believable. Cruel. Stupid, because she’ll google.”
I did the one where I said I’d fallen out of love, and stopped in the middle of it and said, “No. She’d laugh. She’d say, for the record, Harlan, you’ve been in love with me since a basement in Superior, and you’d be the guy who’s been lying to a woman who can count.”
I did the one where I said I was bored, which I rated as the winner. “She’ll hate it,” said the tape, with sorrowful satisfaction. “It’s got no excuse in it. People can forgive a man who wants something. A man who’s scared they just lose.”
“You said that to me,” said Willa, “in Austin.”
“I know,” I said. My voice was a rag. “I think it’s the only line I had.”
“It’s a good line.”
“It was a terrible plan.”
“It was a very good line for a terrible plan,” said Willa, “and that’s the whole man.”
She wasn’t smiling. But her thumb moved over my collarbone, once, and I knew that I had not been condemned.
Around the ninth minute, the Jude on the tape stopped and I heard paper.
I knew what it was before he spoke. I had forgotten, until that second, that I’d taken a photograph of the letter in the corridor and printed it at a hotel business center at three in the morning and carried the printout out onto the stage, folded in my back pocket. I don’t know why. I think I wanted to say it to something with a face.
He read it out loud.
I would like to be able to tell you that it was dignified. It was a man in an empty room reading a medical letter in a voice that he’d cut out of cardboard. The letterhead, the date, the address of the clinic in Duluth.
“Dear Ms. Mercer. As discussed at your appointment, your audiogram shows a bilateral sensorineural loss consistent with noise exposure, markedly asymmetric, left greater than right. The loss in the high frequencies in the left ear is in the range of forty to forty-five decibels, and I am concerned about further progression. I strongly advise that you discontinue exposure to amplified sound at the earliest opportunity.”
“Dr. Sjoberg,” said Willa, under her breath.
“I further advise,” said the tape, “that you bring a family member or friend to your follow-up appointment, as these conversations are difficult to take in alone.”
Willa made a sound.
It was not a big sound. It was the sound a person makes when she finds the missing screw under the workbench six months later. It was the smallest, driest, most private noise, a kind of click in the throat, and it went into my spine and sat there.
“I never took anyone,” she said.
“I know.”
“I read that line forty times. And I thought, ‘family member or friend,’ and I thought, ‘I have a father who can’t hear a smoke detector, and a boyfriend who writes songs about me and calls himself a lighthouse, and a band.’ And I thought, ‘which one of them do I put in a chair, and make hear it.’” She laughed. It was a bad laugh. “And I put no one in the chair. For three years.”
“Wil.”
“I’m listening,” she said. “Let me listen.”
I let her listen.
On the tape the paper rustled, was folded, was put away. There was a long quiet. The vent fan in Philadelphia, a thousand miles and three years off, hummed in the big dark. And then the man on the tape said, in a voice that was not rehearsed at all:
“She’s never going to ask anybody. That’s the thing. She’d rather lose the ear than ask.” Another pause, very long. “And I’m exactly the same. We’re the same person, Wil. I’m doing it to you because I’d do it to me.”
I heard Birdie sniff. I heard something shift in the corner by the door. Len, I thought, back from his tree, standing in the cold with his hat in his hands, and I did not turn around.
“So I’m going to leave,” said the Jude on the tape. “I’m going to do it at dawn. I’ll tell Rafe, because somebody has to know where I am, and I’ll text you the stupidest thing I can think of, and you’ll hate me, and in a year you’ll be mad enough to play louder, and I’ll hear it on the radio.”
A short laugh. “Which will be the best revenge you could possibly have. And the worst thing I could possibly arrange for you.” A breath. “But you’ll be alive. And you’ll be somewhere with ears. You’ll have time.”
“No,” whispered Willa. “No, no. That’s not time. That’s a lock.”
“I’d do it again,” said the tape.
It said it so evenly that, for a moment, I could not feel anything. That was the line I had remembered. That was the one I’d carried for three years in the drawer I check at night, the sentence at the bottom of the reel, the thing I’d thought of as the end.
Willa’s hand went still on my shoulder.
I did not look up. I could not. I sat with my back to her knees and my eyes on the long gray wheels of Len’s deck, turning, and I waited for her to take her hand away.
She didn’t.
“There’s more,” said Birdie, in a very small voice. “There’s another minute on the counter.”
“I know,” said Willa. “Keep playing.”
The Jude on the tape was quiet for ten seconds. Eleven. I counted them in fours, which I never do, and I have no idea why I did. The hush of the empty hall filled the speakers. Somewhere a pipe knocked. And then he said, in a voice so low that Birdie leaned forward on her bucket and turned up the fader with two fingers, a man reciting something to the dark:
“No.”
“No, that’s — that’s what I’m going to tell Rafe. That’s the line. That’s the one I can say out loud.” He swallowed. “Wil, I wouldn’t. I’m lying to a drum. I’d do it the first time because I didn’t know there was another way, and if I had to do it again, I’d know there was one, and I’d be so — I’d be so goddamn scared of finding out what it was.”
“Oh, Jude,” said Willa.
“I’d want to ask you,” said the tape. “I want to ask you so bad it’s like a hand on my throat. And I’m not going to. Because if I ask you, you’ll say you’re fine. And if you say you’re fine, I’ll believe you. And I know that’s not the thing, I know it’s not, I know —” His breath hitched. “I don’t know how to ask a person who’s never asked. I don’t know where you begin.”
The hall was so still I heard him wipe his face with his sleeve.
“I’m sorry,” said the man on the tape. “I’m so sorry, Wil. Whatever it is. Whenever you find out. I wasn’t brave. I was just fast.”
The garage was silent. The deck turned. A white light lay across the steel table, and the wheels went around, and around.
I do not remember saying that.
I would like to be clear on this point, because I have thought about it every night since. I had no memory, none, not a flicker, of that minute and a half. In the three years I’d spent saying “I’d do it again” in the dark, I had literally never once heard the rest. I had put a sentence in the drawer and locked the drawer on the part of me that had already taken it back.
“You told me you would,” said Willa. Her voice was thick and bewildered, and she was looking down at the top of my head. “In my father’s kitchen. You said you’d do it again. You told me before I could hear it. You told me the worst thing you had.”
“I thought it was the worst thing.”
“It wasn’t the last thing.”
“I didn’t know.”
“Jude.” Her hand slid from my shoulder to the side of my face, and turned it up, and I looked at her. She was crying. She was crying the way she does everything, upright, wasting nothing, with her chin level and her eyes wide. “You already knew. You knew that night. You knew it in the first twenty minutes. You just couldn’t hear yourself.”
“I couldn’t hear myself,” I said stupidly.
“I can hear it for you,” said Willa. “I’d like to. If you let me.”
I had nothing to say to that. I put my face down into her palm, in front of Birdie and a thousand reels of weather, and for some while, I couldn’t talk at all.
The tape went on.
There were two minutes left, and I’d have missed them, I think, if I’d been alone. I had stopped listening. It was Willa who tilted her head and said, “Wait.”
“What?”
“There’s someone else.”
I hadn’t heard it. Under the hiss, from a long way off in the dark, a door swung open on a hinge that needed oil. A pair of small quick shoes crossed concrete. They stopped, a long way from the mic.
“Sir?” said a voice. A girl’s voice, young and thin and nervous, from far back in the house. “Hi. Sorry. Sorry, sir. I’m supposed to lock the dock.”
There was a silence. Then, from the stage, the Jude on the tape said hoarsely: “Sure. Yeah. Sorry. Give me one second.”
“Are you okay?”
“I’m fine.”
“Okay.” Footsteps, a few. They stopped. “My mom says that’s what everybody says.”
I heard myself laugh. It wasn’t a good laugh. It was the laugh of a man who has been hit softly with something.
“Your mom’s right,” said the Jude on the tape. “Tell her I said so.”
“Do you need somebody? I can get somebody. There’s a guy in the —”
“No. Thank you. What’s your name?”
“Tasha.” A beat. “Tasha Greer. I’m on the load-out. It’s my first tour, I mean, my first week. I’m nineteen.”
“Tasha Greer,” said the tape slowly, as if filing it, as if there were a drawer somewhere for the name of every stranger who had been kind to him at one in the morning. “You’re good at this. You didn’t have to ask me.”
“I didn’t hear anything,” said the girl quickly. “I swear. I’m sorry. I just — I didn’t want to lock a person in.”
“That’s the right instinct,” said the tape. “Don’t lose it.”
“Okay.”
“Tasha.”
“Yes, sir?”
“If somebody tells you they’re fine,” said the Jude on the tape, and I could hear how tired he was, “ask again.”
A long pause.
“Okay,” said Tasha Greer, very seriously, nineteen years old, in an empty arena in Philadelphia.
Footsteps. A heavy door. A bolt thrown. The big hush of the hall closed over everything, and for about forty seconds the reel played nothing at all, a clean, dark, enormous room, until the tape ran out of music and ran out of hiss and clicked, and flapped on its hub.
Birdie let it flap for a moment. Then she stopped the machine.
The silence in the garage was complete. A weight had come off the room. I heard the hum of a space heater, and the tick of the old Swedish deck cooling, and, out in the yard, at a great distance, a crow.
“Twenty-two minutes,” said Birdie, hoarsely. She was staring at the counter. “Four seconds.”
“It was empty hall,” said Willa, slowly.
“Yes.”
“Nobody was in it.”
“Nobody who wasn’t him.” Birdie wiped her face with a cotton glove, and left a gray streak, and did not seem to know it. “And a kid with a key.”
“I don’t remember her,” I said. “Any of that. I don’t remember her at all.”
“I know,” said Willa. She was looking at the reel the way you’d look at a very old photograph of someone you used to be. “I think there’s a lot of that night you don’t remember. I think that’s why it’s called a night.”
“What do I do with it?” I said. “It’s mine. It’s ours. I don’t know what to do.”
“Ask me,” said Willa.
I turned around and looked at her.
“What do you want to do with it, Wil?”
She opened her mouth.
The side door banged. I don’t know if I have ever been so glad to see someone be rude. Len came in on a gust of cold air with snow on his earflaps, and with a very strange expression, and behind him, white as paper, her phone in her hand and her thumb on the screen, came Dot, in her puffy purple coat, with a cinnamon toothpick hanging out of her mouth and her glasses gone crooked on her nose.
“I’m sorry,” said Dot. “I don’t say that often. I’m sorry, my loves, I’ve had Rule Fifteen on my mind for three hours and I just found out why.”
“Dot,” said Willa.
“Birdie,” said Dot. “Show them.”
Birdie, who hadn’t moved from her bucket, held out her phone. She had been holding it the whole time, I realized, face down, in her lap, under the meter, and I had taken it for an accident. The screen was lit. It showed a small gray rectangle of video with a woman’s hand on a play button, and under it, in red, a headline in a font made to be seen from across a street:
THE TAPE CHEAP GOLD DOESN’T WANT YOU TO HEAR: “I’D DO IT AGAIN.”
“Not my circus,” said Birdie, and her voice broke clean in half. “But somebody posted forty seconds of this twenty minutes ago.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!