Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 33

Forty Seconds

Willa

“Play it,” I said, and Dot said, “Honey, you don’t have to,” and I said, “Willa Mercer is not a person who has to,” which did not make sense, and Birdie played it anyway.

It was forty-one seconds. I know because the counter in the corner of the little gray rectangle said 0:41, and because I counted it in fours, ten bars and a pickup, with my aids in and my hand flat on Len’s steel table.

The picture was a still. A black-and-white frame from our own Milwaukee show, Jude in profile with his mouth open, a shot some fan had taken from the balcony and a thousand blogs had used. The sound came up over it, thin and tinny through a phone speaker, and I knew every breath of it.

“I’m doing it to you because I’d do it to me,” said the Jude on the tape. “So I’m going to leave. I’m going to do it at dawn. You’ll hate me, and in a year you’ll be mad enough to play louder, and I’ll hear it on the radio. Which will be the best revenge you could possibly have.” A pause. “I’d do it again.”

Then a cut, and the tinny hush of a stranger’s phone, and white letters on the black:

HE KNEW. HE DID IT ON PURPOSE. AND HE’D DO IT AGAIN.

“Four hundred and ten thousand views,” said Birdie, very flatly. “It went up at twelve-thirty-one Central. It’s been up for thirty-six minutes.”

“It stops before the end,” I said.

“It stops at the line.”

“It cuts the ‘no.’”

“It cuts everything after.” Birdie scrolled with a gloved thumb. “It’s not a bad edit. That’s what’s bad. It’s a good one. Whoever made it listened to the whole thing and knew exactly where to cut.”

I had been angry in my life. I had been angry at a snare I couldn’t tune and a boy who left me a text. I had been angry at a man in a camel coat who thought he was being generous. This was a new one. It started low in my stomach and rose slowly and quietly like water in a basement, and when it got to my throat, it came out as a very calm voice that I did not know I owned.

“Dot,” I said. “What does it say under the video?”

“Honey.”

“Please.”

Dot looked at her phone, then at Jude, then at me. She took the toothpick out. “It says, ‘Cheap Gold’s Jude Harlan, recorded alone onstage in Philadelphia hours before he walked out on the band. Audio obtained exclusively from the new documentary Nothing Left to Say. In theaters never, on a streamer soon.’ And there’s a link.”

“A documentary,” said Jude. It was the first thing he’d said since Birdie turned the phone around, and his voice had no air in it at all.

“Apparently,” said Dot.

“There’s no documentary.”

“Apparently there’s been one for fourteen months,” said Dot, “and no one told the subjects. Which, given I’ve been the subjects’ manager for fourteen years and I read the fine print for fun, is a feat. I’d admire it if I didn’t want to bite it.”

I looked at Jude. He was sitting on the concrete with his back against my stool and his arms around his knees, and he was staring at the little gray rectangle with the face of a man watching his own house burn from a very long way away. The color had gone out of his lips.

I knew that face. I had last seen it on a stage in Philadelphia at one in the afternoon three years ago when I thought he was tired.

“Jude,” I said.

“It’s fine,” he said.

“It’s not.”

“It’s accurate.” He still had not looked up. “Everything in it is accurate. I said it. I said all of it. If they want to hate me for a thing I really said, that’s — it’s fair. It’s a fair edit.” He took a breath.

“Let it run. It makes me the villain. That’s what I was supposed to be. It’s what I wanted. You come out clean, you’re the drummer who was left, and I’m the guy who did it on purpose, and I’d do it again. It’s the plan. It’s the original plan, it just —” He laughed, awfully. “It took three years to work.”

The garage was very quiet.

I want to say that what I did next was patient. It wasn’t. I took one step, and I crouched on the cold concrete in front of him in my father’s flannel robe, which I was still wearing, I realized, under my coat, and I put my hand under his chin and lifted his face until he had to look at me.

“That,” I said, “is the exact sentence on the tape.”

“What is?”

“‘You come out clean, and I’m the villain.’ You said it at one in the morning to a drum. It’s the plan, Jude. It’s the plan with the ‘no’ cut out of it.” I did not raise my voice. I never do. “You just did it again. You just took the part where you’d changed your mind, and cut it, and said, ‘Let it run.’”

He opened his mouth. He closed it.

“You’re doing it right now,” I said. “To me. In a garage. After a whole tape of you saying you wouldn’t.”

“Oh,” said Jude.

“Yes.”

“Oh, no.”

“Yes.”

“I was —” He put the heel of his hand against one eye. “God. Wil, I was literally doing it. I was doing it in my head while you were looking at me.”

“I know. I could see you pick the clean sentence. It’s like watching someone choose a shirt.” I let go of his chin. “Ask me.”

“Ask you what?”

“What I want. You asked me before we pressed play. You said, ‘What do you want to do with it.’ You didn’t get to hear an answer. I’d like you to ask again.”

He looked at me for a moment, with his hand still over one eye, and then he took it down and sat up straight.

“Wil,” said Jude, hoarsely. “What do you want to do?”

“I don’t know yet,” I said. “I want to know who did it. I want to know what they’ve got. I want to hear what they said, to us, before they said it to four hundred thousand strangers. And I want you not to flinch.” I thought a moment. “And I’d like Rafe. And I’d like my father. And I’d like to eat something.”

“That’s six things.”

“It’s the right number,” I said. “It’s the number I have.”

“Rule Sixteen,” said Dot, quietly, from the door.

“We have a Sixteen,” said Birdie. “It’s thank you out loud.”

“Then this is Seventeen,” said Dot. She had put the toothpick back and was holding her phone against her chest like a hymnal. “Nobody answers a thing that went out while they were still hurt.” She looked at me sideways. “That’s mine. I’m not too proud to say I got it from you.”

We drove back to Duluth in two cars. Len took the truck. I rode with Dot, in the front seat of a green Subaru that smelled of cinnamon and wet wool, with the reel in its gray box on my lap and Jude in the back seat behind me, his head against the window, not talking. Birdie followed in the rental.

Dot drove with one hand and made calls with the other, which is illegal in Minnesota. She called Teddy. She called Corinne. She called, with tremendous dignity and no result, Preston Gault’s cell, which went to a voicemail that said in a warm, cracked, unfamiliar voice that he was not available and would call back, and I thought, he has already turned the phone off. He had told us he would. He had a key to return, and he was not a man who did two things at once.

Teddy picked up first. She was in a car, too, a rental with a bad muffler, and she was breathing hard.

“I’m on 35W,” said Teddy. “I’m driving up. I’ll be there by four. I’ve watched it nine times. I want to say, for the record, that the lawyer in me would like to address the thing in three paragraphs and the human being in me would like to put a brick through a screen.”

“Which one is winning?” said Dot.

“It’s a close race. Listen. They got it from somewhere. Reel fourteen has a chain of custody. It went from the truck to Brasswell’s archive in Burbank, which sent it to a storage vendor in Glendale, which has a log. Corinne’s got someone on it. Hold on.” She put somebody on the other line, and I heard Corinne’s voice, a long way off, saying, “Two, three,” very softly, and then, “Put it on the speaker, Teddy, I’ll say it to them.”

“Ms. Mercer?”

“I’m here.”

“I have bad news.” She said it plainly, without softening it, which I have come to think is a form of respect. “I had Brasswell’s business affairs pull the archive log in the last fifteen minutes. Truck B’s reels were all digitized, in a lot, at the vendor, in October, eleven weeks ago. All twenty-six of them. Including the ones marked unusable. Including reel fourteen.”

“Digitized,” I said. “Why?”

“Because Brasswell licensed the entire Philadelphia truck archive to a third party in September. For what the contract calls archival review in connection with a documentary production.” A pause, a count. “Mr. Gault’s business affairs department signed it. Mr. Gault did not. His signature is not on the license. He may not have known. I do not know yet. I want to be very careful about what I say about the man.”

“Who’s the licensee?” said Jude. It was the first time he’d spoken in the car, and his voice came from the back seat flat and slow.

“Fieldlight Pictures,” said Corinne. “A small outfit in Brooklyn. Producer of record is a woman named Naomi Pruitt. She is, I’m told, extremely good.”

“Good how?” said Dot.

“Good in that she’s won two awards for documentaries about musicians,” said Corinne, “and neither subject sued her. I looked. That’s rare.”

“So she has the whole thing,” I said. “All twenty-two minutes.”

“She has the files. I’m told she has had them for eleven weeks.” Another count, and this one was longer. “Which means that she’s heard the end. She knows what’s after ‘I’d do it again.’ She cut it anyway.”

Nobody spoke. We came over the last hill in a long rush of orange light onto a view that stopped my breath every time, the lake below us, dark gray and enormous, and the long black line of the ore docks, and above it a white sky like the inside of a shell.

“I’m so sorry,” said Corinne. She sounded as if it were costing her something to say it to the wrong people on a holiday. “I told you I’d give it away. I did. And I find that I’d given away a thing someone else already had.”

“It’s not your fault,” said Jude, from the back.

“It’s partly my company’s,” said Corinne. “It’s entirely my problem. I’d like to keep the two apart.” A breath. “I’ll find out who signed. And I’d like to propose that nobody respond publicly until I do. I have a very good lawyer, and she believes she can get the clip down by tonight.”

“Don’t,” I said.

There was a silence on the line.

“I beg your pardon?”

“Don’t get it taken down,” I said. “Not yet. If you take it down, it becomes a story about a thing that was hidden. The ‘what are they hiding?’ story. It’s better than a tape of a man crying. I’ve read the comments. It already says they’re suing.” I held the reel against my stomach. “I want to answer it. I don’t want to answer it today. But I want the right to.”

“You’d leave it up?” said Teddy.

“For now. I want to see who’s saying what.” I breathed. “It’s a lot easier to find someone who’s lying when they have a microphone.”

“That’s very cold, Willa,” said Teddy, with deep admiration.

“It’s a hardware thing,” I said. “You leave the rust on until you’ve found where the water comes in.”

We got to Hank’s at ten past three. The street was white and glittering, and the sun was a brass coin in the south, and the porch had been shoveled. Rafe’s truck was in the drive with its engine ticking. So was Paloma’s rented Kia, and a gray sedan that I did not know, and in the front yard, on a plastic folding chair, in a full-length down coat and a Packers hat, sat my father with a thermos on his knee, as if he were waiting for a parade.

“Heard it on the radio,” said Hank, as I got out. “The classic rock station played the clip on the hour. Guy said, ‘Quite a story.’ I shut it off.” He stood up. “The boys are inside. Eat something.”

“Dad.”

“Eat,” said Hank, and took my face in both of his rough hands and kissed my forehead, which he does not do. “And then you can be as mad as you want. I’ve got a good garage.”

The kitchen smelled of hot dish. Rafe was at my father’s stove in his wedding-suit shirt and an apron that said KISS THE COOK (MY WIFE SAYS YOU’D BETTER NOT), with June asleep in a car seat at his feet, and his face was gray with sleep.

Britta sat at the table with a laptop open, all five feet two of her, in a gray sweater, with her jaw set. Paloma was on the counter with her boots up on a chair, scrolling, her face lit from below by the screen.

“Oh, for sure,” said Rafe, when he saw me. He put down the spoon. His eyes were wet. “That’s different. That’s really different. Willa —”

“I know,” I said.

“I told you the whole time —”

“I know, Rafe.”

“She cut the end,” said Paloma, flatly, without looking up. “Did you hear it? You can hear it. There’s a splice at forty-one seconds. It’s a hard cut on a breath. Whoever did it’s a pro.”

“It’s Naomi Pruitt,” said Dot, coming in behind me with her coat still on. “Fieldlight Pictures. Brooklyn.”

“Oh, I know her work,” said Britta, to my surprise. She didn’t look up from the laptop. “She did a thing on a woman who built a cello. Seventy minutes. I cried in a parking lot. She’s —” She stopped. “She’s very good, Willa. I want to say that. I want to be fair. She’s the person you’d hand a tape to if you wanted somebody to understand it.”

“Then why’d she cut the end?” said Rafe.

“Because,” said Britta slowly, “it’s a trailer.”

Everyone looked at her.

“A forty-one second clip with a hook and a cut on the line. It’s an ad. It was always going to be the front of something.” She turned the laptop around. On the screen, under the video, there was a second link, and a date, and white letters on black. “Look. It says ‘Nothing Left to Say. Premiere: March.’ It’s not a leak. It’s a launch.”

“March,” said Jude.

He had come in behind me and stood in the doorway in his coat, still pale, still snow in his hair, and he looked at the screen as if he’d never seen a month.

“That’s three months,” said Paloma. “We were going to be in the drill hall in April. We were going to make a quiet record in April.”

“So,” said Dot, “someone wants the story out before the record.”

“Someone wants the story to be the record,” I said.

I sat down at the table. It’s a thing I do when something’s going to be long. I put the gray box on the oak, in front of the salt shaker, and Rafe set a plate of hot dish in front of me without being asked and a fork on the napkin, and I ate, for the record, four bites, because I’d said I would.

Then I looked up.

“Okay,” I said. “Here’s what I want to do.”

I told them, in the order I’d tell a customer, with the cheapest option first.

I want to meet her, I said. Naomi Pruitt. In person. I want to hear what she thinks she’s making, and what she thinks she knows, and whether she’s ever heard what comes after “I’d do it again.” I want to ask her. First. Before she gets to ask me.

“What if she says no?” said Rafe.

“Then I’ll know.”

“What if she says yes and it’s a trick?”

“Then I’ll still know.” I looked at Jude. “We’ll go together. And I want all of it in the room. The whole reel, the whole twenty-two minutes. I want her to hear it with me, in a room, with the lights on, and see her face.”

“You’d play her the end,” said Jude slowly.

“She’s got the end. I’d like to hear her say what it was.” I picked up the fork. “And I’d like the thing I always want from a stranger. I’d like to know what she wants.”

“You want to ask her what she wants,” said Paloma.

“It’s the only question I’ve got,” I said. “I don’t know a better one.”

Nobody spoke. The stove ticked. Somewhere behind us a floorboard creaked, and I understood that my father had been standing in the doorway the whole time with his hat in his hands.

“That’s a good plan,” said Hank. “You measured it.”

“I’ve been taught,” I said.

My phone buzzed on the table.

I almost didn’t look. I’d had thirty-one texts in the last hour, from people I hadn’t talked to in a decade and a man who wanted to sell me a boat, and my face was hot, and I wanted to eat my hot dish in peace. But the number on the screen had a 215 area code, which is Philadelphia, and I turned it over.

It was a long text. It was a very long text, for a person who looked, from her style, as if she’d typed it with her thumbs in a stairwell, and I read it twice, once fast and once slow.

Ms. Mercer, this is Tasha Greer. You don’t know me. I’m the girl who locked the dock. I heard the clip this morning and I about threw up on a bus. I didn’t send it. I swear to God. I never told anybody, and I’m 22 now, and I’m in an audio program at a community college, and this is the first time I ever heard that tape since the night I stood in the dark. I didn’t know it was recorded. Nobody told me the mics were on.

I need to tell you something and I don’t know how. A woman named Naomi has been calling me for two weeks. Not the first time. She called once a week since December. She wanted me to say what I saw that night, and she was nice about it. She said she was making a film about you two and she wanted it to be fair. She said I was the only living witness.

I said no. She said that’s fine.

Then last Tuesday she called and told me what Mr. Harlan said to me at the end. Word for word. She said, “You’re the only person he ever told to ask twice.” She said it like a line from a movie.

I think I’m in it, Ms. Mercer. I think she’s put me in it, and I don’t know how. I don’t know who to call. I’m so sorry. I don’t know if you want to hear from me.

I looked up. Everyone in the kitchen was looking at me, and I turned the phone around and slid it across the table to Jude, and Jude read it, and I watched his lips move, and I watched the color come back into his face, all in a rush, as if someone had opened a window in a very small room.

“‘Ask twice,’” said Jude, slowly.

“Yes.”

“I said ‘ask again.’ On the tape. I said, ‘ask again.’” He looked up at me, and his eyes were very wide. “I never said twice.”

“I know,” I said.

“So where did Naomi Pruitt get ‘twice’?”

“Dot,” I said slowly. “How many reels did Truck B have?”

“Twenty-six,” said Dot. She had her glasses on and her phone up, scrolling Teddy’s forwarded index from the vendor, and I saw her stop. “Reel fifteen starts at one-twenty-nine a.m. Twenty minutes. Stage-right wing mic, which nobody ever asked the truck to roll. Same log note. ‘Empty hall. Do not use.’”

“I left the stage at one-twenty-nine,” said Jude. “I went to the hotel. I walked.”

“I know you did,” I said.

I was looking at my hands. They were flat on the oak on either side of the plate, and they were very steady, and for the first time in three years a thing I had not let myself remember walked all the way out of the dark and stood in my father’s kitchen with the light on it.

A girl with a ring of keys on her belt. A wing full of coiled cable, and a dim blue work light. A towel over my own snare, which I had gone back to retrieve. A voice, very young and very kind: “Are you okay, ma’am?”

“I’m fine,” I had said.

“My mom says you’re supposed to ask twice.”

“Willa?” said Jude.

“I was in the building,” I said. “Jude. I was in the wing. I was there for the end of it.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!