Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 34

Stage Right

Jude

For the second time that day, Willa had said a sentence that took the floor out, and for the second time that day, nobody in her father’s kitchen moved.

“In the wing,” I said.

“Stage right. By the cable ramp.” She had not taken her hands off the table. “I went back for my sticks. I’d left the good pair in the bag, and I couldn’t sleep, and the dressing room smelled like a hundred pizzas. It must have been twenty past one. I don’t know. I went through the wing in the dark. There was a work light on, one blue bulb, and I saw the riser, and I saw you.”

“Wil.”

“You were sitting on it. With your head against my floor tom. And you were talking.” She finally looked at me. Her face was perfectly composed, and under the composure was something that I recognized, because I have worn it myself.

“I couldn’t hear you. There’s an air handler up there the size of a bus, and I’d been wearing the plugs all night, and even if I’d had them out, it was sixty feet. I saw your shoulders. I saw your mouth. I thought you were drunk. Or I thought you were saying goodbye to the tour. The last night. I thought, he’s allowed.”

“You didn’t come out.”

“I didn’t come out.” She said it like a woman reading her own sentence off a bill. “I thought, he’d hate to be seen. I thought, let him have it. I stood there for I don’t know how long, and then I turned around and went back, and there was a girl with keys, who asked me if I was okay.”

“Tasha,” said Paloma, from the counter, very softly.

“I said I was fine.”

“And she said ask twice,” said Rafe, who had the back of his hand against his mouth.

“She said her mom said to ask twice. I didn’t say anything. I said fine again, and she said okay, and after that I don’t remember it in order. I remember sitting somewhere until it got light.” Willa’s mouth twisted. “And then I woke up at dawn to a text.”

“I’m done,” I said. “Don’t call.”

“Yes.”

I had sat for three years in a room with a drawer, and in the drawer was the picture of a man alone in an empty arena. I had carried it as the single worst thing about that night, that nobody had been there.

That I had said the unsayable thing to a drum because there was nobody to say it to. And I looked across a hot dish at the woman I had loved for fourteen years and understood that I had been wrong about the size of the room.

“You were sixty feet away,” I said.

“Sixty. Give or take.”

“You could have walked.”

“So could you.” She didn’t say it unkindly. She said it with a hand held out, palm up, the way she would hand a man a wrench. “You could have walked sixty feet in either direction. You didn’t. I didn’t. We were both in the same building, doing the same thing, a thousand miles from asking.”

“Oh,” said Britta, quietly, behind her laptop. “That’s the whole book.”

“That’s the whole book,” said Willa. She put a piece of hot dish in her mouth and chewed. “For the record. I’d like to eat something before we make it worse.”

It took the room a minute to breathe again. Rafe turned back to the stove, wiped his eyes on a dish towel with a rooster on it, and ladled out five more plates that nobody had asked for. Paloma got down from the counter. Dot put her toothpick behind her ear and took off her coat.

And I took out my phone, because I’d been the only man in the kitchen who still had a call to make.

“I’d like to call Tasha Greer,” I said.

Willa looked up.

“I know. It’s your text. It’s your contact. But I think I’m the one she’d be afraid of, and I’d like to be the one who says she doesn’t have to be.” I took a breath. “Will you ask me first if I’m doing it wrong?”

“No,” said Willa. “I’ll just tell you.”

“That’s even better.”

She was a very small voice on a very bad connection. I called her from the sewing room with the door shut, on a bed too small for me, under a quilt of blue ducks, with Willa sitting beside me and Dot on the other line, silent, with a notepad. It rang four times.

“Hello?”

“Tasha,” I said. “This is Jude Harlan. I’d like to apologize for calling out of the blue, and I understand if you’d rather text. I wanted you to hear my voice first. Is this a bad time?”

There was a long, shaky silence on the line.

“Oh my God,” said Tasha Greer. “I’m in a stairwell.”

“Do you want to call me back from somewhere better?”

“No,” said Tasha. “No. It’s the only place I get any bars. I’m — sorry. Hi. I’m so sorry. I’ve been crying for an hour and my roommate thinks someone died.”

“Nobody died,” I said. “I’m told.”

She laughed. It was a nervous, wet, half-hiccuping laugh, and I knew from it exactly who she was. She was somebody who’d been brought up to say sorry to furniture. She was the girl on the tape.

“I don’t remember you,” I said. “I want to be honest about that. I listened to myself talk to you about an hour ago, and I don’t remember any of it. I don’t remember your voice. I don’t remember what I said. But I heard it, and I’d like to thank you. You asked if I was okay, and I said I was fine, and you didn’t believe me. That was the right instinct. And nobody told you so, I think, for three years.”

There was a sound at the other end like someone sitting down on a concrete step.

“Nobody did,” said Tasha Greer. “Nobody ever knew. I went home that night and I thought, I’m going to be fired. I thought I’d heard something I wasn’t supposed to. And the next morning the whole tour was on the news, and I thought, oh my God, that was him. And I thought, what do I do? And I didn’t do anything. I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be.”

“Then I turned twenty. And twenty-one. And I thought about it every time somebody said they were fine.” She laughed again, shakily. “My supervisor at the venue says I’m the only person on staff who asks a drunk guy if he’s okay twice. I get written up for it. I mean, nicely.”

“Do you know what that is?” said Willa, quietly, beside me.

“Who’s that?”

“Willa Mercer. Hi.”

A very long silence.

“Hi,” said Tasha, in a voice like a mouse in a jacket. “Hi, Ms. Mercer. Oh my God.”

“You can call me Willa. I think we’ve met. I think you asked me twice, and I said fine both times, and I’d like to say now that I wasn’t.” She paused. “I was very much not. And you were nineteen, and you saw that, and I’ve been trying for fifteen minutes to figure out what to say to you.”

“You don’t have to say anything,” said Tasha.

“Thank you,” said Willa. “That’s what I came up with. Thank you.”

“Oh,” said Tasha. “Oh, God. Okay.” She sniffled. “Can I say something? I don’t know if it’s stupid.”

“I think you should.”

“I don’t think it’s your fault. Either of you. The tape, I mean. Not the — I don’t mean the whole — I mean I think you’re both people, and you’re sad, and a woman with a camera got hold of it. I’m not a lawyer. I’m in an audio program. But I’ve been editing for a year and a half, and I know what a cut is. And I think the person who cut it knew it was a lie.”

“What makes you say that?” I said.

“Because of the room tone,” said Tasha.

We waited.

“When you cut a sentence out,” said Tasha, and her voice had steadied; it had changed key, a note lower, into the voice of somebody who knows a thing, “you hear it in the room tone. The hiss behind the words. The hall has its own sound, you know, that big hum. And when you splice two pieces, the hum jumps. A person in a trailer wouldn’t hear it, and a person on a phone wouldn’t. But if you listen on good headphones, at forty-one seconds, you can hear the hum change. It’s the sound of someone choosing.” She paused. “I’ve been listening to it for an hour on my headphones. I think it’s the best-made lie I ever heard.”

I looked at Willa. She looked at me.

“Tasha,” I said, “would you be willing to talk to a lawyer?”

“I don’t have a lawyer.”

“We have a very good one,” said Willa. “She wears a hockey jersey.”

“Oh my God,” said Tasha. “Okay. Yes. Is that okay? Is it okay to say yes?”

“It’s very okay,” I said.

“And Mr. Harlan?”

“Jude.”

“Jude.” She said it as though she were trying it for size. “Can I ask you something? Since you said ask.”

“Please.”

“Are you okay?” said Tasha Greer.

I opened my mouth and the standard answer was right there, and it was already out, halfway to the air, and for the first time in my life I stopped it with my teeth.

“Ask me again,” I said.

“Are you okay?”

“No,” I said. “Not really. Not today. Ask me tomorrow.”

“Okay,” said Tasha, softly, and I heard a stairwell door open on the other end and a lot of noise and a girl’s voice saying “Sorry, sorry,” and she was gone.

Willa was looking at me with her eyebrow, the one. Dot, on the other line, made a noise like a kettle.

“Is she,” said Dot, “in the market for a job?”

“Rule Eighteen,” said Willa.

“No,” said Dot. “That’s a plan.”

The call to Naomi Pruitt was my idea, which I want on the record, because it was not a good one, and I made it anyway.

Teddy had gotten to Hank’s by four and had her laptop open on the dining table, with a travel mug the size of a lamp, and had told us, in order: that she could send a cease-and-desist before dinner; that it would be ignored; that Fieldlight’s license from Brasswell was, from her reading, valid, and that she’d take a month to break it; that the one thing we had that Fieldlight did not was consent.

“A subject who won’t sit is a problem,” said Teddy. “A documentary about two people who’ve told the producer to go to hell is a film about a woman who got a tape and made a lie. She’d lose half her audience.” She looked at us over her glasses. “You could call her, though. I’d tell you not to. I’m saying it for the record.”

“I’d like to,” I said.

“Why?”

“Because I’m tired of finding out what people want from a screen.”

“She’ll record it,” said Teddy.

“I know.”

“She’ll use it.”

“I’d expect her to.” I looked at Willa, who was sitting across from me with her chin in her hand. “It’s not a trick if everyone knows the rules. Is it?”

“It’s a call,” said Willa. “I’ll listen. I won’t speak. You do the talking, and if you flinch, I’ll write it on a stick.”

“That’s very reassuring.”

“I want you to know I’ll be keeping score.”

Naomi Pruitt answered on the first ring.

I had expected someone brisk. I had braced for a voice like an elevator, a media voice with a smile in it and a lawyer behind it. What I got was a low, tired, intelligent contralto, slightly hoarse, with a Brooklyn in it and under the Brooklyn something older, Ohio maybe, and an open laptop clicking.

“Mr. Harlan,” she said. “I was hoping it would be you.”

“Ms. Pruitt.”

“Naomi. I’d like to say, before anything else, that I have been waiting since twelve thirty-one this afternoon for one of you to call, and I want to thank you for being faster than I expected.” A small click. “I’m recording this. I’d like to say so. I don’t do it any other way.”

“So am I,” said Teddy, from across the table, very softly, “for the record.”

“Is that Ms. Brandt? I’ve read your work. It’s a pleasure.” No hesitation at all. “Hello, Teddy.”

“Hello,” said Teddy, with a cold, careful respect. “I’m here to observe.”

“I’d expect nothing less. Mr. Harlan, I know you’re angry.”

“I’m not sure I am,” I said, and found it was true. “I think I’m trying to find out whether you’re lying to me.”

There was a pause. Then, to my surprise, Naomi Pruitt laughed. It was a good laugh, low and short, and I think it was real.

“That’s the first fair question I’ve been asked all year. I’ll try to answer it as plainly as I can.” A breath. “I’m not lying to you. I did cut the clip. I cut it to forty-one seconds, and I cut it at the line, and I did it on purpose, and I’d like to tell you why. May I?”

“Please.”

“Because it’s a trailer. I’m not going to pretend otherwise. I’ve made seven films, and you can’t get a person to sit down for ninety minutes with a story they think they already know. You have to give them the version they know, and you have to cut it so it hurts. And then the film is the part after the cut.” Another click. “The film is what happens at forty-two seconds, Mr. Harlan. And it’s the best thing I’ve ever heard.”

“You’ve heard the end,” said Willa.

She had said she wouldn’t speak, and her voice came out of her so softly that I almost did not realize who was talking. Naomi Pruitt stopped.

“Ms. Mercer.”

“I’m here.”

“Yes,” said Naomi. Her voice had changed. It was lower and slower, and the click of the laptop had stopped. “I’ve heard the end. I’ve heard ‘no, I wouldn’t.’ I’ve listened to it fourteen times. I listened to it in a car outside my mother’s house on Thanksgiving, with the engine running, and I didn’t go in for forty minutes.”

Nobody in the room spoke.

“I’d like to ask you something,” said Willa, “if I may.”

“Please.”

“What do you want?”

“From you?”

“From the film.”

I heard a long breath at the other end, and then a sound I didn’t expect, a chair being pushed back, and a woman standing up and walking to a window.

“I want,” said Naomi Pruitt slowly, “to make the first documentary about a breakup in which both people were right to be afraid and both were wrong to stay quiet. I want to show two people who loved each other badly and then loved each other well. And I want, at the end, for nobody in the audience to say, ‘Which one was the villain?’” She stopped. “I’ve been trying to make that film for fourteen months. I don’t have the third act.”

“What’s the third act?” I said.

“I don’t know,” said Naomi. “I think you’re about to tell me.”

I looked at Willa. She had her fist against her mouth.

“The thing is,” said Naomi, “I didn’t call you first, because I didn’t think you’d pick up. I thought you’d hand me to a lawyer. And I thought, if I put out forty seconds that made you angry enough to call me yourselves, you’d get on the phone, and I could ask you for the third act in person.”

A beat. “That’s a manipulative thing to do, and I know it. I’m not going to ask you to forgive it. I’m going to tell you that I’ve been right about people in the past, and it’s the only reason I’m any good.”

“You made me the villain to get me to ring you,” I said.

“I made the villain you made, Mr. Harlan. I just left out the part where you stopped being one.” Her voice broke slightly, on one syllable. “I’ll put it back. It’s the only reason I made the film.”

“You said that,” said Willa, “to Tasha Greer.”

“Yes.”

“You told her what he said. Word for word. You had it from reel fifteen.”

“I did.”

“Then you know what I did in the wing,” said Willa.

There was a very long silence on the line.

“Yes,” said Naomi, finally, very gently. “I do.”

“All of it?”

“All twenty minutes.”

I turned to look at Willa. She had gone as pale as paper. She was sitting very straight, with both hands flat on the table and her eyes on the telephone, and she looked, I thought, like a woman in a doorway who has heard her name called and doesn’t yet know who’s got the knife.

“Naomi,” I said. “What’s on reel fifteen?”

“I’m not going to tell you,” said Naomi Pruitt. “It’s hers. It’s the only thing in either reel I haven’t played for anyone but myself. I’ve kept it out of the trailer, and out of the cut, and out of every conversation I’ve had with Brasswell. I think, Mr. Harlan, that it’s the best thing I’ve ever heard on tape. And I think she doesn’t know it exists.”

“I know it exists,” said Willa, hoarsely. “I just found out. An hour ago.”

“Then I’d like to ask her something,” said Naomi. “If she’ll let me.”

“Ask,” said Willa.

“Do you remember what you said, after the girl left?”

Willa closed her eyes.

I watched her do it. I watched her go very far away, in a kitchen in West Duluth with a woodstove ticking, a rooster dish towel over the back of a chair, and snow-light on the windows, down a corridor to a blue-lit wing in Philadelphia, to a drum kit with a towel over its snare, and I watched her find something in the dark and hold it.

“Yes,” said Willa. “I remember.”

“So do I,” said Naomi. “I’ll let you tell him.”

The line clicked. And Willa opened her eyes, and looked at me, and it was the first time since a Friday in Philadelphia that I’d seen her look at me without a single wall between us, no humor, no count, no shield, and I realized I was terrified of whatever she was about to say.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!