Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 35

Reel Fifteen

Willa

We went out onto my father’s back porch, because there are things you cannot say in a kitchen with a rooster dish towel in it, and because Teddy had looked at my face and said, very gently, “I’ll watch the stove.”

It was twenty past five and the sky over the hill had gone the color of a bruised plum. Eleven degrees. No wind. The snow lay blue in the yard and the old lilac by the fence stood in it like a drawing of a lilac, and from the garage, thin and tinny, came the sound of Rafe’s radio playing a polka, which meant that Rafe was hiding.

Jude sat on the top step in his coat. I sat next to him. We did not touch. He had his hands between his knees, and he was looking at the yard with the careful face of a man waiting to be told a diagnosis.

“I’m going to tell you,” I said. “And I need you not to fix it.”

“Okay.”

“I mean it. I know you. You’ll want to put a hand on my shoulder and make a joke about a drum, and I’ll let you, and we’ll both feel better, and it won’t be true. I’d like to say the whole thing and then have you sit there.”

“I can sit.”

“You can’t,” I said. “But try.”

I took out my aids, then. I don’t know why. I think I wanted to say it in the same quiet he’d said his to the drum. The porch went soft. The radio in the garage dropped to a murmur, a smudge of accordion, and I heard my own voice from the inside, deeper than it is outside, with the thin wire of the whine behind it. I felt him look at me. I did not look back.

“After the girl left,” I said, “I didn’t go to the dressing room. I said I did. I told myself I did. For three years I’ve had a picture of a long hallway and a couch, and I know now it’s something I built, because I didn’t want the other one.”

“What’s the other one?”

“I went out on the stage.”

He did not say anything.

“You’d gone,” I said. “You went out the back, to the hotel. I heard the dock door. I stood in the wing for a long time after, and then I walked out into the dark. It was about one-thirty. Nobody there. The work lights were off except for the one blue one, and it threw just enough that I could see my kit.”

I shut my eyes. “You’d left the towel on the snare. And there was a — I could see the mark. On the head of the floor tom. A smudge, where your forehead had been. A little oily circle, about the size of a coin.”

“Oh, Wil.”

“I sat down at the kit. I took the towel off. I didn’t play it. I never touch a drum when it’s quiet unless I’ve got a reason. I put my hands in my lap and I looked at the smudge.” I opened my eyes. “And I started to talk.”

I heard him stop breathing.

“I’d been planning it for three weeks, Jude. I had a thing I was going to say. I had it in the shower and in the van and in the middle of the second chorus of ‘Lighthouse Hours,’ when I’d lose count and you’d look back at me and I’d think, I’m going to tell him. I’m going to tell him tomorrow. And I’d get to the end of the show and I’d think, not tonight. He’s tired. We have the bus in the morning.” I laughed. It came out thin. “It was an excellent system. It lasted three weeks.”

“What did you say?”

“I said it to the floor tom. Same as you.”

I could hear that he wanted to speak, and was biting down on it. I loved him, I think, more in that second than I had in the whole of the tour.

“It’s not long,” I said. “I know it by heart. It turns out I’ve known it by heart for three years, only I told myself I’d forgotten.” I folded my hands. “Here’s the first line. ‘Jude. I’m going to tell you something, and I need you not to fix it.’”

He made a sound.

“I know,” I said. “I said it in the kitchen forty minutes ago. It’s the same line. I’d forgotten I had a line. It was in the bottom of me the whole time.”

“Go on.”

“‘I’ve lost forty-two decibels in my left ear. I’ve known for three weeks. I read the letter on a bus in Ohio, and then I read it forty times. I haven’t told anybody, and I’m so scared I can’t feel my feet.’”

My voice shook, once, and I held it still. I do not think I’d ever said those words in order aloud to anyone, and it turned out they were not hard to say. They had just been very heavy to carry. “‘I told you once that I’d rather be dead than be somebody’s patient, and I meant it. I hate that I meant it. Because it means I can’t ask you. I’ve been trying for three weeks to say the word and I can’t get my mouth around it.’”

“What word?”

“Help,” I said.

Jude put his hand over his eyes.

“‘I’m going to say it at breakfast,’” I said. “That’s what I said to the drum. ‘I’m going to say it at breakfast. In the hotel, with the little eggs. And he’s going to say, what’s wrong, and I’m going to hand him the letter. And I’m not going to say I’m fine.’” I took a breath. “I said that part four times. ‘I’m not going to say I’m fine.’ I wanted to hear it in the room. I wanted the hall to hear I’d said it.”

“Willa.”

“And I said the rest. I said, ‘And if he says stop, I’ll stop. I’ll sell the kit. I’ll go home and work at my father’s store.’” I stopped. I could barely get the next one out. “‘And if he says keep going, I’ll keep going for as long as I can, and I’ll let him stand on my right. Either way, I just want somebody to say it with me.’”

It was very quiet on the porch. The radio had stopped. A branch ticked in the lilac. Down the hill, a long way off, a car’s headlights went across the snow, a slow pale oblong, and swung away.

“I did it twice,” I said. “I did the whole thing twice, all the way through. Then I sat there and I thought, he’s going to be so relieved.” I turned and looked at him. “I thought you’d be relieved. That I was finally going to let you in.”

He had taken his hand away. His face was wet. He was not hiding it. He looked at me with his mouth slightly open, like a man standing in the road looking at a truck that had already gone by.

“I got in the elevator at five,” said Jude, hoarsely.

“I know.”

“I called Rafe from the hallway. I texted you. I had the phone in my hand and I wrote it forty times and deleted it thirty-nine, and the one I sent was —”

“‘I’m done. Don’t call.’”

“I wrote it so you’d hate me.”

“I know.”

“And you’d been going to ask me for help.”

“Yes.”

“At breakfast. With the little eggs.”

“I’d put the letter in my back pocket,” I said. “I’d put on the good flannel. I’d even looked up how to say it in sign language, because I thought it might be easier if I didn’t have to use my mouth.”

He made a sound that was not a word. It was an animal sound, low and short, the sound of someone hit under the ribs. He bent forward over his own knees and put his forehead against his hands, and I let him, the way I’d said I would, because he was not fixing it. He was sitting there. He was doing the thing I’d asked.

I did not touch him. It was the hardest thing I did that day.

“I’m not telling you so you’ll feel worse,” I said, when he’d been quiet for a minute. “I need you to hear that part. I’m not telling you it was your fault. We were both wrong, and we were wrong at the same time, in the same building, about the same thing, in two languages that sounded exactly alike. I thought I’d drag you down. You thought you’d drag me down. We each walked off a cliff so the other one wouldn’t have to carry us.”

“It’s the worst plan I’ve ever heard,” said Jude, into his hands.

“It’s the only one we had.”

“It’s the same plan.”

“It’s the same plan,” I said. “We came up with it independently. That’s what happens when you spend eight years in a van.”

He laughed, and it turned halfway into something else, and he sat up. His face was a ruin, and there was snow on his shoulders, and he looked at me as if I were the first sunrise he’d ever seen.

“I’d like to touch you,” said Jude. “May I?”

“Yes.”

He took my hand. He took it in both of his, the hand with the callus on the middle finger, and held it against his chest, flat, over his heart, and I felt the whole thing going under the wool, fast and plain.

“I didn’t have to leave,” said Jude, softly.

“No.”

“I could have stayed. I could have asked. I could have walked sixty feet.”

“You didn’t know. I didn’t ask.” I made myself say it. “If I’d come out of the wing, I’d have found you. You’d have told me. We’d have been in a bad place for about a week and we’d be married now.”

He closed his eyes. “Don’t.”

“I’m not saying it to hurt you. I’m saying it because I’m done pretending it didn’t happen.” I breathed. “Three years. A lot of songs. Eleven of them were the best you ever wrote. I wouldn’t trade a note, and I’d trade every one of them for a bad week.”

“So would I,” said Jude. “For the record.”

I laughed. I could not help it. “That’s my line.”

“I know. I took it.”

“It looks good on you.”

We sat for a while with our hands together, not speaking, and the stars came out. They come out early in January in Duluth, a hard dry glitter over the lake, and the cold took the sweat off my forehead, and from the garage the polka came back on, a little louder, as if Rafe had decided to give us the music for a minute.

“Naomi has it,” said Jude at last, in a voice scraped clean.

“Yes.”

“She’s had it for eleven weeks. She listened to you say that, fourteen times.”

“I know.”

“In a car. Outside her mother’s house.” He looked at the yard. “Willa, that’s the most private thing you’ve ever said.”

“It is.”

“And a woman in Brooklyn has it on a hard drive.”

“It’s the best thing she’s ever heard, she says.” I felt my mouth shape something. It was not a smile. “I’d like to be furious about it. I tried, a minute ago, at the table. I’d like to hold on to the clean feeling. And I can’t find it. I keep thinking about a woman crying in a car.”

“She cut me,” said Jude, “to get us on the phone.”

“She did.”

“It was a rotten thing to do.”

“It was a very good edit.” I looked at the lilac. “And she’s the only person who’s ever listened to either of us all the way to the end. Including us.”

He said nothing. I heard him think about it. He thinks with his whole face, which is a flaw in a man who lies.

“What do you want to do?” he said.

“Ask me properly.”

“Wil. What do you want to do about reel fifteen?”

“I want it back,” I said. “I want it where it belongs, and it belongs to me. It’s the only thing I’ve ever said in my life where I was telling the truth and nobody was there to hear it. And somebody was.” I put my aids in.

The world came back, the garage radio, the tick of the lilac, the long soft drone of a plane very high up. “I don’t want to hide it. I think I’d like to hear it. I’ve been trying to remember it all afternoon and I can’t get past the second line.”

“You’d listen to it with her?”

“I’d listen to it with you,” I said. “And I’d like her to be somewhere in the building. In a different room. With the door open.”

“Then ask her.”

“I’m going to.”

I called Naomi Pruitt from my father’s back porch at five-forty, with Jude beside me and the kitchen window glowing yellow behind us, and Teddy’s silhouette at the glass, holding a spoon like a gavel.

She picked up on the second ring.

“Ms. Mercer.”

“Naomi. May I ask you for some things?”

“Please.”

“I’d like them in order.” I looked at the stars. “One. The forty-one seconds comes down. Not because I’m asking you to hide it. Because it’s a lie, and you know it’s a lie, and you’ve been listening to the truth in your car for eleven weeks. You put it up as a hook. I’m asking you to take it down as a favor.”

There was a pause. I heard a clock tick somewhere.

“Yes,” said Naomi.

“Two. Reel fifteen doesn’t go in your film, or any trailer, or any rough cut, or any room that has more than three people in it, without my written consent. Each time. For each use. I don’t want a license. I want a clause that I can say no to every day of my life.” I breathed. “It’s called the Ask Clause. We invented it last month with a man in a camel coat.”

“I know about it,” said Naomi. “I’ve read the terms. They’re better than most contracts I’ve signed.” Another pause. “Yes.”

“Three. I want to hear it. With Jude. In a room you pick, in Brooklyn, on a day you say. I’d like Tasha Greer there if she’d like to be, because she’s in the tape and she has a right to it. I’d like it to be a place where nobody’s rolling cameras. And I’d like you in the building. Not in the room.”

“I’d like that too,” said Naomi, quietly. “I’d like to be somewhere I can’t see your face.”

“And four.”

“Yes?”

“I’d like to ask you what you want,” I said. “Again. When it’s over. After you’ve watched me hear it. I don’t think you know yet. I think you thought you knew, and you’ve been wrong a few times this afternoon, and I’d like you to answer me honestly.”

Naomi Pruitt did not speak for what felt like a long time. A siren went by, very faint, a long way off, a real Brooklyn siren in a real Brooklyn evening, and I thought of a woman at a window.

“Ms. Mercer,” she said at last, “I haven’t been asked that by a subject in twenty years of making films.”

“It’s catching,” I said.

“Saturday,” said Naomi. “I have a screening room above a bakery in Red Hook. It has a door that closes and a door that doesn’t. Eleven in the morning. I’ll make coffee, and I’ll leave.”

“Thank you.”

“Don’t,” said Naomi. “Please. I don’t deserve it yet.” She hung up.

I put the phone in my pocket. It was dark now, all the way. The porch light had come on over our heads, a yellow bulb in a wire cage, full of moths that were not there in January, and in its light I could see our breath going up, his and mine, in two long slow plumes that met and braided and went away.

“Saturday,” said Jude.

“Saturday.”

“I’ll book the flights.”

“We’ll book the flights,” I said. “Ask me what kind of seat.”

He opened his mouth. And then my phone buzzed again in my pocket, a long low buzz against my hip, and I took it out, expecting Teddy, expecting Tasha, expecting a man who wanted to sell me a boat.

The number had a 310 area code. Los Angeles. I knew it. I had called it, in the last month, once, with a lawyer, in a drill hall full of folding chairs.

It was a text. It was a very short text, from a man who had never in his life written a short one.

Ms. Mercer. I must tell you something before you hear it from anyone else, and I would rather you heard it badly from me than well from them. I did know about the Fieldlight license. I told business affairs to sign it, in September. It was my idea. I did not read the tape. I thought it would be a kindness.

I am in a gray sedan at the foot of your father’s hill. I will not come to the door unless you ask.

I read it twice. I held it out to Jude, who read it with his lips, and I saw his jaw go hard.

“He said he’d stopped arranging the room,” said Jude.

“He did.”

“He said it on New Year’s Eve. In front of eleven people. With his hat in his hands.”

“He did,” I said. I looked down the long white hill at the road, where, a long way off, under the last streetlight, a pair of parking lights glowed small and amber against the snow.

“Willa,” said Jude. “Do you want me to go down there?”

“No,” I said. I put my hand on the porch rail. It was cold enough to hurt. “I want you to stay right here, and ask me what I want.”

“What do you want?”

I looked at the little amber lights for a long time, and I counted, one, two, three, four, and I didn’t have to, and then I did anyway.

“I want to go get my father’s coat,” I said. “And ask him in.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!