Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 44

Allocution

Claims Manual, 1.6: An insured who tells the truth about his own act shall not be treated as having forfeited the right to be heard.

The sister was fine.

I learned it at 7:40 on Monday morning, standing in the corridor of the county courthouse with a paper cup of bad coffee, when Deputy Oyelaran came up the stairs two at a time and said, without preamble, “Corinne Teague is unharmed. A Pelham officer was at her door within the hour. She was making soup. She thought the call from her brother’s house was about her birthday.”

“And the voice on the telephone?”

“A burner, gone by the time anyone arrived. Mr. Teague is in a county safe house with a deputy who likes crossword puzzles. He is, I am told, ironing.”

“Good,” I said, and found that I was smiling, and was absurdly close to tears.

The courtroom was on the second floor, a plain paneled room with a flag and a county seal in dark wood behind the bench. It had forty seats. Every one was taken by ten. Graça sat in the front row in her best black coat, with her knitting bag on her knee and her hands perfectly still, a thing I had never seen. Beside her sat Cleo, then Billie, in a good wool jacket, with her cap in her lap. Then Lucky, Pip, who had been told to behave and was observing the discipline of a small judge, Dario, under escort. Renata Tillman and her mother Odette sat across the aisle, and Odette looked over once and gave me a small, grave nod, which I took, in my confusion, as a medal.

I sat in the second row, beside Boone, who was wearing a green suit and had unwrapped a lemon drop in a manner I can only call prayerful.

“Remember,” she said. “You are a spectator.”

“I have a pencil.”

“Hold it. Do not use it.”

At ten, the bailiff said, “All rise,” and we rose, and Judge Harlan Voight, seventy, gray, with a face like a weathered fence post and the slow, deliberate gestures of a man who had never once been hurried, took his seat. A side door opened. Two deputies brought in Teo.

He was in a county jumpsuit, orange, too short in the sleeves, with his hands in front of him in cuffs. He had lost twelve pounds. He was gray-skinned, hollow at the temple, unshaven. He looked, for a moment, like a stranger.

Then he turned his head. His eyes went along the front row, one face to the next, like a man counting names. They reached mine.

He did not smile. I did not either. He looked at me for a very long time, in front of the whole courtroom, as I had seen him look at a column of figures to see whether it balanced.

Then he turned and faced the bench.

The county attorney, Dana Okafor, a tall woman in a charcoal suit, with close-cropped hair and the calm, level voice of a person who has been told she is generous and distrusts it, rose and read the information. Arson in the second degree. A plea agreement, with cooperation. Dismissal of two counts. A sentencing hearing in sixty days. Her recommendation, subject to the court’s approval, of a term of not less than four years and not more than nine, with credit for time served.

“Mr. Amaral,” said the judge. “You understand what you are doing.”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“You understand you are giving up your right to trial.”

“Yes.”

“Are you pleading guilty because you are guilty, and for no other reason?”

“Yes, sir,” said Teo.

“Tell me what you did.”

The room was very quiet. Teo drew a breath. He had no paper. He stood with his cuffed hands before him and his head up, and his voice, when it came, was the voice I knew, slow, level, exact.

“On the thirty-first of August, Your Honor, at about two in the morning, I entered the Brannock Cannery by the loading door, with a key. I had checked three times that the building was empty. I poured a quart of kerosene on a wooden pallet in the corner of the packing floor. I lit it. I walked out. I did it to collect on an insurance policy, in order to pay claims that my family’s fund could not pay.” He paused. “I did not intend a total loss. A second fire, set by a person I will not name in this court because he has been dealt with under separate charge, made it one. That does not excuse me. I started the first.”

“You say it was for the fund.”

“I say that is why I did it, sir. I do not say it was a reason.” He looked down at his hands. “My father spent forty years saying that the Cover was a promise. I broke it, in order to keep it. That is a hard thing to say in a room like this. It is also a very common crime. The man who sets a fire to be paid, and tells himself it is for someone else.”

The judge said nothing.

“I would like to say one more thing,” said Teo. “If the court permits.”

“Go on.”

“People on my island have asked me, in three months, whether I was sorry. I told them yes. I want to tell the court that I was not telling the truth. I was ashamed. It is a different thing. Shame is the feeling of being seen. Sorry is the feeling of what you did to the person.” He raised his eyes, not to the judge, but past him, to the empty gallery wall, where there was a clock. “I have thought about it for ninety-five days. An old man, the night watchman, was in that yard, and I did not see him. He saw me. He told no one. If the second fire had come a little sooner, he would have died. I am sorry in the way you are sorry for a person.”

There was a very small sound behind me. I think it was Lucky. I did not turn around.

“That is all,” said Teo.

Judge Voight looked at him for a long time. Then he looked at Okafor, and at Boone, and at the papers on his bench.

“Mr. Amaral,” he said. “The plea is accepted. Sentencing is set for the fifth of February. I am going to do something unusual. The county has asked, with the concurrence of the state, that you be released pending sentence to the custody of your family at the Amaral residence, under electronic monitoring and the supervision of Deputy Oyelaran. You are not to leave the island. You will report weekly. Is that understood?”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“The state has agreed to lift the condition that bars your contact with Ms. Quigley, as a material witness, provided that all such contact be in the presence of a third party.” The judge looked, for the first time, over his half-moon glasses, directly at me. “I understand the third party is to be a woman who knits.”

Somebody laughed. It was Billie. She stifled it with her cap.

“I do not believe in cruelty as a procedural device,” said the judge. “This court is adjourned.”

The gavel fell.

I sat very still. I felt Boone’s hand close on my arm, once, hard, and let go. I watched two deputies unlock a pair of cuffs. Teo stood rubbing his wrists, looking at nothing, and then Graça was out of the front row and across the well of the court in four steps, a small, black, formidable figure, and took her son’s whole face in her two floury hands, and the room, I am afraid, lost its composure entirely.

I do not know how long it was before I looked at the back of the courtroom.

It was still full. The last row, by the doors, was a row of strangers, spectators, reporters, a woman with a sketchpad. And in the aisle seat, with a gray overcoat folded neatly over his knee, a silver-haired man in his sixties sat perfectly motionless with his hands in his lap. He had a long, gentle, intelligent face, the face of a good headmaster, and a white carnation in his buttonhole. He was looking at me. He had been looking at me, I suddenly understood, for some time.

He inclined his head, very slightly, like a man at a concert acknowledging the soloist.

I knew the face. I had seen it in a hundred company newsletters, over a hundred annual messages, under the words A Letter From Our Chairman.

Hale Mercer rose, and came slowly down the aisle toward me, smiling.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!