THE MEETING WILL COME TO ORDER. THE MEETING HAS NOT BEEN CONSULTED.
The Union meets in a net loft with sixty folding chairs, a stove, and a gavel that is a brass weight from a ten-pound standard. I know because the chairman told me so, three times, before the meeting began.
"It's ten pounds, Ms. Marek," said Haskell Dray. He was seventy and shaped like a bell, with white mutton-chops, a waistcoat, and the expression of a man who has run the same meeting for thirty years and intends to die in the chair. "Ten pounds avoirdupois, certified. When I bring it down it is an act of the Union."
"I'll try not to provoke it."
"See that you don't."
There were twenty-eight skippers on the floor and about forty other people leaning on the walls, which is how I learned that Kettle Harbor treats a vote on the Day Book the way Tallow Cove treats a funeral. Everyone knew everyone. The women had brought knitting and the men had brought thermoses, labeled with numbers, which they passed along the rows in the manner of a church collection. Alvin sat at a table at the front with the ledger and a pencil sharpened at both ends. Juno Castellan sat at the end of the front row with her coat buttoned to the throat and her arms folded, and she had not looked at me once since we came in.
Tav had taken the chair beside me. He had put on the good jacket. Kenji, on my other side, had brought a notebook and was taking minutes in French.
"First item," said Dray, and brought the weight down. The whole loft jumped. "Reading of the previous minutes. Alvin."
"The previous minutes are long, Chairman."
"I know they are long. That is why we read them."
It took eleven minutes. I would like to tell you there was a point to it. There were two motions to dispense with the reading, both defeated on a point of order. There was a lengthy debate about whether a tide table was a document. A skipper in a yellow oilskin rose to ask, with immense dignity, whether the item "any other business" was still permitted after the item "new business." Another, at the back, had a motion concerning the price of rope, which was tabled, and untabled, and tabled again in the same breath. I kept my hands flat on my knees. I was learning that the reason the Union had lasted two hundred years was the same reason Alvin's pencil had two points.
"Item six," said Dray. "Request of a visitor. Ms. Castellan."
Castellan stood. She did not go to the front. She spoke from her chair, in her flat voice, the way you read a lab result to a doctor who has not asked for it.
"A woman named Corinne Marek has come from Saint Orrin with a letter in a hand that appears in the Day Book, and has requested that the Union open the register to her for the purpose of copying a page. I have tested her. She is exact to a tenth. She is a pharmacist by training. I believe she is a relation of the original apothecary." She sat. "I am obliged to say that I do not recommend it."
"Noted," said Dray. "Seconded?"
"Seconded," said a voice at the back, which was Alvin's, which was a point of order that was overruled.
"Discussion."
I have been to a good many meetings. I have sat at a hospital ethics board while a man in a bow tie argued that a patient's sodium was a matter of opinion. I have never in my life seen a room go silent as fast as that loft did when a woman in a green cardigan, very small, with a thermos on her knee, stood up and said:
"Why is she asking now?"
"I'll answer that," I said.
"I wasn't asking you, dear."
"Mrs. Fenn," said Dray. "The visitor may speak."
I stood. I had not planned a speech. I had planned a list. I held the list in my hand, and I looked at the faces, forty of them, weathered and polite, and thought of Hank on the Dawn's wheelhouse stool saying I don't need your number, I need your back on the winch.
"There is a Court," I said, "off Saint Orrin. It sits on the Spar Bar at the spring low. It's old. It is older than your Union. It has been put to a question, and the question is whether a person who has been Stacked is a person. My brother is one. The Court has ordered him to sit in a chair on the fifteenth day. The chair is wrong. It was written wrong by the man who wrote this book. If I can't correct it, my brother will sit in it forever."
"We don't hold with Stacks here," said a man in the yellow oilskin. There was a murmur. "We don't dose to the ceiling. We weigh. We're not Saint Orrin."
"No," I said. "You aren't. Mr. Dray, may I say what happens to the ones you don't see?"
"You may not," said Dray, "but I expect you will."
"Eleven boats from this harbor have sold a Stack to the Dray's Reach refinery in the last six years. I know because I have the Co-op's ledger. I'm not going to name them." I did not look at the yellow oilskin. "If the Court rules a Stack is a person, then every one of those sales is a sale of a person. Halvard Biologics, the company that bought the Perpetua bonds, intends to buy every Stack ever refined. They will own the claim. And they will come to this Union and ask what it knew."
There was no murmur this time. The loft had gone quite still, with a stillness I recognized from Winnie's galley the night Hank read out her own number.
"That's a threat," said the yellow oilskin.
"It's a dosage," I said. "I'm telling you what's in the cup."
It was Tav who spoke next. I had not expected it. He got up quietly and stood beside my chair with his hands at his sides, a big man in a jacket with the shoulders let out, and the loft turned and looked at him.
"I'm a nine," he said. "Was. I'm an eight now. I went into a Glaze on my first haul with her because I took an extra cup so I could earn my mother's rent. I'd have stacked on the next one. A woman with a thumb told me my own number, and I stopped." He looked at the weight on Dray's table. "I'd have gone to a refinery. I didn't know it. I'd have thought it was a funeral."
Nobody coughed.
"That's all," said Tav. "Sorry. I don't make speeches."
"Seconded," said Dray, who had apparently lost the thread, and then, hearing himself, brought the weight down, and everyone laughed.
They took a show of hands. It came to thirteen against and thirteen for, and two skippers who had gone out for the stove. Dray frowned at the weight as though it had cheated him. Alvin looked at the ledger. In the front row Castellan did not move.
"It's a tie," said Dray. "Under Rule Nine, in the matter of the Dispensary, the Keeper holds the casting key."
Castellan stood up.
I think I expected her to look at me. She did not. She looked at the stove, and at the dozen people in knitted caps who were not looking at her, and at a framed photograph of a woman on the wall, in an apron, with a pair of calipers, who looked exactly like her.
"I said I would not vote for it," she said.
"You did," said Dray.
"I did not say I would not read it." She turned. Her face was a plain brown fact, and her hands, at her sides, were doing something very small and careful with the cuff of her coat. "Alvin. Record the Keeper's vote in favor. I will open the Dispensary at nine tomorrow, and Ms. Marek may see the book, and no one else will."
She walked past me out of the loft. At the door she stopped, without turning round.
"I should tell you what it is I am letting you read," she said, in a voice I could barely hear. "I have read page one. Once."

