ALL RISE. THE HYMN BOARD WILL NOW BE USED AS EXHIBIT A. WE APOLOGIZE TO THE CHOIR.
Magistrate Adaeze Okonkwo came across on the Wednesday ferry in a green raincoat, carrying her own robe in a dry-cleaning bag, and said to the crowd on the wharf, “I apologize in advance. I have never held a hearing in a church. I intend to enjoy it.”
She was small, brisk, about sixty, with cropped gray hair and the kind of dark observant eyes that make a person re-check their pockets. She nodded at me as though we had met. I realized later that she had read every page of Renata’s report, twice, on the ferry.
The church hall held eight hundred and filled with nine. The bake sale banner had been taken down and, in its place, over the altar rail, someone had hung a sheet of butcher paper that read ORDER IN THE COURT, which was Dolores’s idea of formality. The magistrate sat behind the pulpit, under the organ pipes. Her gavel was a wooden spoon from the church kitchen, and she tapped it once on the lectern, and eight hundred people fell silent so fast I heard the radiators tick.
“This is the matter of the Saint Orrin Provisioning Cooperative, in receivership,” said Okonkwo. “I have three questions. Who owns what is in those tanks? Who may touch it? And what, if anything, is it?” She looked down at the two tables. “Ms. Brandt. You first. Be brief. I have a ferry at five.”
Brandt was brief. She stood with her glasses in one hand and a single sheet of paper in the other, and went through it in eleven minutes with the economy of a woman packing for an emergency. The Release, clause 9(c). The wires from the Calder Street Memorial Fund. The Program’s forty-thousand-dollar purchase prices. Dacey’s ledger, seventeen years of pink slips, each signed P.H. The slip from the Lone Gull’s wheelhouse. “It said, and I quote, ‘Next time it will be the pharmacist.’ The signatory, Your Honor, is in this room.”
Hale rose.
He did it gracefully, with a smile, hand on his lapel. “Your Honor, I deny nothing and regret nothing. I sign documents for a living. I did not write that line.” He had a quiet, resonant voice that carried to the back of the nave. “My client’s interest is simple. We are a lender. We hold the refinery and its contents as collateral. Those contents are not, as Ms. Brandt would have it, human remains. They are refined mineral salt, produced by a licensed facility under a lawful contract, in tanks that belong to my client. Whatever sentiment may be attached to them, they are a commodity.”
“Mr. Hale,” said Okonkwo, “I read Ms. Ibe’s laboratory report this morning. It identifies four named human individuals in the sample.”
“A trace contamination, Your Honor. We are all, in some measure, the sum of our ancestors.”
“That’s very elegant,” said Okonkwo. “Sit down.”
She called me at ten past two.
I had never been a witness. I had stood at many counters, but never in a pulpit. I swore on a hymnal and sat in the choir chair beside the lectern, with my hands in my lap, trying to look like a person with a license.
Brandt took me through it. What I did for a living. What the gift was. How I had come to read a cup, and what the number meant. She had me explain, in plain words, the difference between a ceiling and a load. She had me describe Tank Seven, and the riser, and the water going sweet at the turn of the tide. I did not mention the jar or Bet. A court can carry exactly as much as you can prove.
Hale stood to cross.
He asked first about the license. He did it gently, with sorrow, like a doctor with bad news. “Ms. Marek, you hold no current license to practice pharmacy in this or any state?”
“It’s suspended.”
“Suspended, because you removed a sealed hospital sample of a deceased person from a laboratory refrigerator, in the dark.”
“Yes.”
“A sample of your own brother. Without authority.”
“Yes.”
“So you have already once, Ms. Marek, in a state of understandable grief, decided what the law ought to say.” He turned to the nave. “I mean nothing unkind by it. I only wonder whether a person who takes remains on her own authority is the right person to tell this court what they are.”
It was the best question anyone had asked me all week.
“No,” I said. “I’m not the right person. That’s why I brought a method.”
“A method.”
“A blind test, Your Honor. If the court will allow. I can read any cup of the stuff. The court can check me, with an instrument or with a second person. I would rather be tested than believed.”
Hale’s eyebrow went up by a sixteenth of an inch. Okonkwo looked at him. She looked at me. She tapped the spoon on the lectern, slowly.
“Mr. Hale,” she said. “I once watched a woman in my mother’s church identify a liar by the sound of his cup on a saucer. I am inclined to allow lay expertise. Do you object?”
“I would be delighted,” said Hale, “to see it.”
So we did it in a church. Brandt and Doc Ferris, behind a screen made of two coat racks and a tablecloth, prepared six paper cups from six jugs, each diluted by Doc’s old balance scale to a fathom count that only the two of them knew. They sealed the figures in an envelope for the magistrate and carried the cups out on a tray under a napkin, like communion.
I tasted them one at a time, in front of nine hundred people.
One point two. Four point one. Zero point eight, which was a cup of plain tap water with a pinch of salt, and a decoy. Seven point nine. Two point six. And the sixth was dark, heavy, wrong in a way I knew from the Founders’ Night urns, and I held it on my tongue, and said, “Eleven point six. It’s a cut with a trace of the Seven lot in it.”
The magistrate opened the envelope. She read it, and then she read it again, and then she held it up.
“One point two,” said Okonkwo. “Four point one. Point eight. Seven point nine. Two point six. Eleven point six.” She set the card on the lectern with the flat of her hand. “Ms. Brandt, would you say that is a probability?”
“I would say it is a certainty, Your Honor.”
“So would I,” said Okonkwo. She put on her robe, finally, over her raincoat, and it was a size too large. “I rule as follows. The seal on the tanks stands. Nothing is to be removed, refined, sold or moved. The Trust may inspect its collateral, as a lender may, on Thursday at nine, but in the presence of Inspector Quarles, Mr. Whitlock for the county, and Ms. Marek, who may speak freely. Any sample is taken in joint custody. If any party interferes with any other party in the course of that inspection, I will hold that party in contempt, and I will do it in a church.” She tapped the spoon. “Mr. Hale, I expect you will want your expert.”
“I have one, Your Honor. He arrives this afternoon.”
“Of course he does.”
“In fact,” said Hale, with his gentle smile, “I believe he has arrived.”
There was a movement at the back of the nave.
A man was standing in the double doors. He was tall and spare, in a gray suit that fit him like a thought, with a gray beard cut square, and a leather case in one hand. He had been standing there, I realized, for some time. He walked down the aisle without hurry, through the silent rows, nodding to no one, and when he reached the tray on the front table, with the six paper cups, he picked up the last, the dark one, and lifted it to the light.
“Dr. Casimir Vane,” said Hale. “The Trust’s assayer.”
Vane dipped one long finger into the cup and touched it to his tongue. He did it with no more emotion than a man tasting a soup. His eyes closed. They opened.
“Eleven point six,” said Casimir Vane, to the magistrate. “A cut with a trace of the Seven lot. Quite clean.” He turned and looked at me with gray eyes and a quiet interest that went through me like a scalpel. “How do you do, Ms. Marek? I believe we’re colleagues.”

