THIS MEDICATION MAY CAUSE DROWSINESS. SO, IN MY EXPERIENCE, CAN DINNER WITH THE ENEMY.
“Not tonight,” said Ione Calder. “Tomorrow. Tonight, Corinne, you will go and eat with Pryor. He is going to ask you for something. Listen to what he doesn’t say.”
I would have refused. I was a sack of wet sand with a pulse, and I had been sick in a steel basin, and I wanted my own bed in Winnie’s spare bunk and a thermos and eight hours. But Tav was already helping me up, and Quarles, who had taken fifty-one signatures and a very great number of marks, looked at me over her form and said, “I’ll stay on the ladder.” So I went.
The ship’s galley was a long white room, with a stove the size of a bathtub and a table that could have seated twenty. Hale had laid it for two. A cloth, a lamp, a saltcellar. I looked at the saltcellar and said, “Take that away, please,” and Pell, pale and quick, whisked it out of sight as though it had made a remark.
Tav took the chair by the door. He did not say anything. He stretched his legs out across the frame so nobody could close it and looked at the ceiling with great interest.
Hale did not eat. There was a boiled egg in front of him, and a slice of dry toast, and a glass of the clear thing I would not touch. Pell brought me chowder, in a white bowl, hot, and I ate all of it, in the exact way that you eat a thing you cannot taste, with concentration and a faint sense of insult. It was good chowder. I know this from the texture.
“I should like to begin,” said Hale, “by saying that I do not expect you to like me.”
“That’s fortunate.”
“I have been told by a number of reasonable people that I am a villain. It is a thing I have considered at length, and I do not believe it is correct, and I do not think the correction would matter to you.” He cracked the egg, neatly, and did not eat it. “Today a man of eighty-eight said a poor thing to a very old child at the bottom of the sea, and it believed him. You saw the arithmetic. Seven tenths of a fathom every ten minutes. By tomorrow he would have been a statue.”
“Yes.”
“Now think how many people are alive, on this coast, who will say a poor thing about themselves this week.” He folded his hands. “The island is full of them. There are men who owe the Co-op their boats. There are women who buried a husband under the Program. There are children, Ms. Marek, who have been told by a grown-up that they are a bother. Some of them will be asked by a salt cellar at three in the morning, in a voice they love, how much they are worth. Some will say, I do not know. Some will say, nothing. I should like to know how many are standing in their kitchens tomorrow, white to the neck.”
“Then tell them stories.”
“It is a splendid remedy. It will work for as long as there is somebody to tell the story, every ninety seconds, every hour, for the rest of everyone’s lives.” He said it without scorn. “It is a nurse at a bed. You cannot nurse a sea.”
I put down my spoon. “So what’s yours?”
He said it as though it were a very small thing. “An answer.”
Tav shifted in his chair.
“A good one. A high one. Given on behalf of everyone, by someone whom the thing below has reason to believe.” His voice grew a little warmer. “I have been preparing for forty years. I have spent a great deal of money, and a great many people have given me what they had. If the question is asked in the name of the whole of mankind, I propose to answer it in the same name, plainly and with authority. A person is worth the highest thing a person has ever carried. Sixty. Perhaps more. If it believes that, Ms. Marek, then no one on this coast will ever again be weighed at nothing.”
I was silent for about the length of a breath.
“That,” I said, “is a terrible dose.”
“I beg your pardon?”
“It’s a standard dose for a population, and you’ve set it at the maximum anyone has ever survived.” My voice was thick, and I could feel the old, bone-dry pharmacist’s fury coming up through the exhaustion like a clean pipe. “I spent twelve years at a hospital counter, Mr. Hale. I know what you do when you set a standard at the top of the range. You kill the small ones. A greenhorn has a ceiling of three. If you tell the sea that a person weighs sixty, you have told it a greenhorn is a fifty-seven fathom debt. It will not weigh him at sixty. It will weigh him at three, and it will wonder where the rest is.”
Hale was quite still.
“You assume,” he said, slowly, “that the sea would collect.”
“I assume it’s a scale. A scale doesn’t forgive a shortfall. It just reads it.” I took a breath. “You’re not wrong that someone has to answer. You’re wrong that the answer is a number.”
I thought he might argue. He did not. He looked at his egg, and then at his hands, which were folded on the cloth, and for a moment he looked exactly his age, which I would put at sixty-eight, and not a day under.
“Danny said something very like that,” he said.
It went through me like cold water. Tav’s chair legs scraped.
“Mr. Hale—”
“I have a letter.” He reached inside the camel coat, which hung on the back of his chair, and he drew out an envelope, soft and gray at the corners, with the foxing of paper that has been carried in a pocket for years. “It came six years ago, in March. Your people have a photograph of the first page. They do not have the last.”
“You told us the original was lost.”
“I told Ms. Brandt’s receiver that it was not in the office.” A very faint smile. “That was perfectly true.”
He did not hand it to me. He read it aloud, in his smooth bank voice, which went steadily more careful as he went, and I sat there holding a spoon.
“‘Dear Mr. Hale. I think you and I want the same thing, and we’re going about it all wrong. I’ve been under the Seam eleven times, which I’m told is not allowed, and I think I know what it is, and I think it can be asked. If you stop the Program, I’ll show you the way down. If you don’t, I’ll go on my own.’” He turned the page. “There is more. It is a good deal of it about crab. ‘P.S. If anything happens to me it won’t be your fault, but it will be your doing. I’m telling you so you’ll know the difference. Don’t go to my sister. She’ll hate you for exactly as long as it takes, and then she’ll know what to do.’”
He folded it. It was a very careful fold.
“I replied that I could not stop the Program. That it was not mine to stop.” His eyes were quite dry. “It was not a lie. It was an evasion. I should like you to know I am capable of telling the difference.”
I could not feel my hands. I thought of Hank, on the Dawn, six years ago, saying hire my sister. I thought of Danny in a galley with his guitar. And a small, cold voice that was not Danny said somewhere under the table, from the salt in the planks, patiently, how much is a person, and Hale’s hand twitched on the cloth.
“Why are you telling me this?”
“Because I am about to ask you for something,” said Hale. “And I should like you to think better of me than you would otherwise.”
“What?”
He tucked the letter back in his coat. His face had changed. It had gone, for a second, old and young at the same time, the face of a boy who has been caught.
“I do not know,” he said, “how to put it in a way that will not sound like a threat. So I will say only that I will tell you tomorrow, in the afternoon, when you have slept. It concerns the covered tank.” He rose. “And one thing more, Ms. Marek. It concerns your brother. He did not only write to me. He came to see me, on the mainland, the week before he died. He sat in my office for two hours. I have never told anyone what he asked for.”

