Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 31

Fourteen Names

A lie has a shelf life, and mine started going off before the coffee was cold.

By Sunday night I had told it eleven times without opening my mouth. I told it by saying “fine” when Santo asked how I’d slept. I told it by laughing at Gia’s joke about the courthouse metal detector, a half second after everyone else. I told it by not touching my planner, which for me is like not touching my own elbow.

The letter lay behind the pressed white rose. I could feel it through the leather every time I sat down.

Here is what I know about secrets, professionally. I have kept a bride’s pregnancy from her grandmother for eleven weeks. I once got a groom’s first wife and second wife into the same church without either of them seeing the other’s dress. A good secret isn’t a wall. It’s a schedule. You decide who is where, and when, and what they’re looking at, and you never leave an empty minute for someone to wander into.

So I did what I do. I made a list.

I did it at the shop, at nine on Monday morning, with the door locked and the lights off and a single desk lamp on my mother’s blotter. I took a fresh yellow legal pad and I wrote, across the top, in block capitals: THE THIRTY-EIGHT MINUTES.

Then I closed my eyes and rebuilt the engagement party.

I’ve done it a hundred times for other people. You start with the room. The Larkspur’s second-floor ballroom, with the dreadful chandelier and the carpet like a casino rug. Then the clock. Doors at seven. Cocktails. Toasts at nine. And then the part that wasn’t on my cue sheet at all, because I had no idea it was coming: Santo, at twelve minutes past nine, with his phone in his hand and a look on his face I’d mistaken for a headache, saying quietly in my ear, “I’ll be back in ten.”

He was gone for thirty-eight.

In those thirty-eight minutes, a man named Gerald Pruitt died in a stairwell two floors down, and the whole case against my fiancé was built out of them. Hale had planned it to the minute. Hale had known the minute.

I wrote that on the pad. Then I wrote under it the question that had been sitting in my chest since Sunday noon.

Who knew Santo would leave?

Nobody did. That was the thing. I’d been standing beside him and I hadn’t known. A phone call had pulled him out of the room, and a phone call is a private thing. But if Enzo was right, somebody had told Hale where Santo would be walking alone and when. Which meant either somebody had made the call happen, or somebody had known it would come.

Nico, said a small, sensible voice in my head. Nico had made that call. Nico had flipped, and testified, and was sitting in a cell in exchange for four years. It wasn’t Nico. Nico had been the hand. I wanted the arm.

I tapped my pen against my teeth, and began, as I always do when I’m lost, to write down every person who had a copy of my paperwork.

My cue sheets go to people. That’s what they’re for. A run of show is useless in a drawer. For the engagement party, I’d sent a master schedule four days ahead to everybody who needed to be somewhere at some moment: the caterer, the florist, the DJ, the hotel’s banquet captain. And I’d sent a second one, shorter, tidier, with only the family timings on it, to Santo’s side. Nonna. Gia. Teddy. Leo. A paper copy to the head of security, who turned out to be a man I’d never learned to like, and a digital copy to the one other person I couldn’t remember.

I wrote them out in a column. Fourteen names.

I read it back and felt faintly sick. It looked exactly like a seating chart. Which is the cruelest thing I know about a seating chart: it tells you who was in the room, and it tells you nothing about who was lying in it.

I crossed out the florist. I crossed out the DJ, who was sixty-three and had cried at my mother’s funeral. I crossed out the banquet captain, because I’d trained her myself. Then I sat looking at what was left, and what was left was the family.

Nonna. Gia. Leo Brandt. Teddy. Santo himself, ha. Nico, who’d already confessed. The security chief, whose name was Rocco and who now ran a gym in Cicero, and whom I resolved to find. And five names I didn’t yet understand, the people on Santo’s side who’d had my first cut of the schedule in their email.

There’s no easy way to say this part. Enzo had written that he could not name the person on paper. I hadn’t wanted to read between the lines. But I’m a person who notices, and I noticed that two of the names on my list were people I would have trusted with my life, and a third was a man who’d just said “I mean it, anywhere” with ears the color of a stop sign.

I put my pen down.

“Pani Margosia?”

I jumped a foot. Mrs. Wozniak stood at the shop’s side door in her flour-dusted apron with a loaf in her hands, the way other women might carry a baby, and a look on her face that told me she’d been standing there for some time.

“You said you were locking up,” I said.

“I have a key. I have had a key since 1994.” She set the bread on the desk and looked, with great and deliberate interest, at the ceiling. “I did not read your paper. I am seventy-one. I cannot see so far.”

“Mrs. Wozniak.”

“Mm.”

“The boy with the bicycle. Did he say anything else?”

“He said it was hand-delivered. He had a green scarf.” She considered. “He was very young. He was frightened of the dog.”

“You don’t have a dog.”

“The boy didn’t know.” She rubbed flour from her knuckles. “I made a promise over rye, Margosia. To your mother. A long time ago. She said: if a day comes when I can’t say a thing, and Hanna’s face tells you she knows it, then let the face be. Don’t ask what she knows. Just let her bring you bread.”

I looked at the loaf. It was still warm.

“I think I’m in trouble,” I said, very quietly.

“Yes,” said Mrs. Wozniak. “Eat. You will need to be strong.”

I ate. We didn’t speak of it again. But when I left, she put a paper bag in my hands, and at the bottom of the bag, under the rolls, was a small steel thermos with a chipped red lid, and I understood that she knew exactly how long a drive it was, and in which direction.

---

Santo proposed on Monday over a plate of eggs.

“Margo Kaminski,” he said, in the voice of a man reading from a legal document. “Will you marry me, in front of a witness, a judge, and Gia, who has promised to behave.”

“Gia has promised nothing.”

“She’s promised not to throw anything.” He cut his toast on the diagonal. “I counted that as a win.”

“Yes,” I said.

“Thank you. You always say it so quickly. I’m beginning to get a complex.”

“I’ve been saying yes to you for five minutes at a time since April. I’m very efficient.”

He laughed, and it was the old laugh, the real one, the one I would have paid dearly to hear. And something in me, small and sour and honest, said: you’re about to take that from him.

I’d been standing at the kitchen counter in his apartment on the forty-first floor, in an oversized sweater, watching him eat eggs, and I’d have given a great deal not to be the person with the letter in her planner. He’d already lost so much. He’d lost six years to a grave. A father is a thing a man gets to have exactly once, and Santo had held a casket corner for his. And now here I was, planning to walk into the dark to find that father without him.

I knew why Enzo had asked. I even agreed with the logic. If I told Santo, Santo would go with ten men and a map. The road would watch him go. Whoever had sold the cabin once would sell Bayfield in an hour.

But I also knew what I would do if the lie were turned around. If Santo had handed me a cocktail-napkin rule and then broken it on the second page.

“What’s on your mind?” he said, not looking up.

“Nothing.”

“Margo.”

“I’m just.” I turned and pulled the lid off the coffee. “Wedding brain. The cake is two tiers and the stand is rated for one and a half. Priya is on it.”

“I like when you say that. ‘Priya is on it.’ It sounds like a prayer.”

I made the smile. It came out all right, and he took it, and he went on cutting his toast, and I stood with my back to the window, forty-one floors above the lake, and was the worst fiancée in the state of Illinois.

---

Tuesday, the best man arrived.

I’d heard about Dom Ferrante for a month, in the way you hear about the weather in another country. Dominic Ferrante, thirty-two. Santo’s oldest friend, from the St. Procopius days, when they were nine and ten and shared a locker and a hatred of one particular nun. He’d moved to Phoenix after college, and run a couple of the family’s perfectly legal car dealerships out there, and had somehow missed every funeral, trial, and shooting of the last ten years by one flight each time.

“He called from the airport the night they arrested me,” Santo had said, once. “He wanted to fly in. I told him no. I didn’t want him anywhere near it.”

“And now?”

“Now I want him standing next to me.” He’d looked at his hands. “He’s the one who’d say if I was being an idiot.”

So I was ready to like him, and I did. It took about forty seconds.

He came up the shop stairs at ten on Tuesday morning with a suit bag over his shoulder and a box of cannoli in the other hand, a lean, loose-jointed man with sun-creased eyes and a dimple, wearing the sort of watch a person buys after he has stopped worrying about watches. He put the cannoli down and shook my hand with both of his and said, “You’re the one who got Sam to ask for things. I’ve been trying to get that man to ask for a glass of water since fourth grade.”

“He asks for lots of things now.”

“I heard. I heard he asks every morning.” The dimple deepened. “I told my wife, I said, I’ve got to see that. She said, don’t bring a camera. I brought a camera.”

“Don’t you dare.”

“It’s in the car. I’m weak.” He turned his head, took in the shop: the ribbon wall, the swatch books, the dreadful gold chairs. His eyes lingered a second on my mother’s desk, with its yellow folder squared to the edge. “This is Helen’s. Isn’t it. Santo told me about her. I’m sorry I never met her.”

I’m used to condolences. I’ve had four hundred. They tend to arrive like parcels, handed over and quickly put down. His didn’t. He just stood there, hands in his pockets, in a small stillness, letting it be.

“She’d have fed you,” I said. “Immediately. Without asking.”

“Then she’d have been the first person in Chicago to get it right.” He grinned. “Where’s the man himself?”

“Downstairs, being fitted for a suit he refuses to admit is too long in the sleeve.”

“Ah.” Dom nodded gravely. “The tragedy of the Corvino wrist.”

He was good company. He was easy and funny, and had the knack of being a stranger and an old friend within one conversation. By noon he had charmed Priya (she went a pale pink and said, “I’m furniture, don’t mind me,” and he said, “Please never be furniture,” which delighted her for several hours), made Mrs. Wozniak laugh, and discovered that Nonna’s gnocchi was the single dish in North America he would cross a state line for.

At lunch he told us about Phoenix. At two he took Santo out for a walk and came back with his tie off and Santo looking ten years younger.

“I’ve missed this idiot,” Dom said, to me, sotto voce, on the steps, with a hand on Santo’s shoulder. “I won’t say I’m not still angry at him. But I’ve missed him.”

“Angry about what?”

“Oh. Ah.” A flicker, nothing, a hitch. “That he didn’t let me help. That he shut the door on me and sat in the dark for six years.” He shrugged, and the dimple came back. “Typical Corvino. Everybody’s got to be a martyr.”

I laughed. I put it away. I put it all away: the flicker, the hitch, the way he had said sat in the dark, as though he knew the dark and its furniture. I’m telling you now because I’m telling you everything. But at the time it went on the pile with all the other things a person notices and chooses not to carry.

Fourteen names on a legal pad, and a fifteenth walking up my stairs with a box of cannoli. I hadn’t written him down. He hadn’t been in Chicago.

I made a note to ask, anyway.

---

At six that evening, Santo and I sat on the floor of the shop with the checklist spread out between us, going down the last list for the wedding. Priya sat nearby, in a chair, with a laptop and the expression of a person determined to be an inanimate object.

Forty-one guests. Seats. The cake. The flowers, one hundred and twenty roses, coming in at five on Friday morning from a grower in Michigan. The two empty chairs at the front, which Santo had not mentioned once and which I had noticed him looking at, on the diagram, three separate times.

“Who’s driving you Thursday?” he said, without looking up.

I’d been waiting for it. I had my answer ready for two days and it sat on my tongue like a stone.

“Thursday?”

“The final walk-through. With Dunphy, at the courthouse. You put it on the sheet.” He tapped item sixty-two. “Seven a.m., ‘Margo, courthouse, rehearse the two-step with the judge.’ You said it’s the only time he’s free.”

I had, in fact, put it on the sheet. I’d put it on the sheet because I’d needed a hole in Thursday at dawn, and a plausible shape to put in it. It was the first time in my career I’d written a false line in a cue sheet.

“Right,” I said. “Yes. It’s very boring. I’ll take Priya’s car.”

“Teddy will drive you.”

“Santo.”

“I’m not ordering. I’m asking.” He looked up. His eyes were very dark, and kind, and tired. “Humor me, Margo. Eleven days ago somebody wanted me in a cell for life. I want a man with a gun and good ears between you and the world until Friday. Then I’ll never mention it again.”

I could have said no. I could have said, Teddy won’t fit in the ceremony anyway. I could have turned it into a joke, the way I turn everything into a joke.

Instead I looked at him, and what I felt was a rising, helpless tenderness, and under it, a cold click, like a lock turning in a house I’d thought was mine.

“All right,” I said. “Teddy can drive.”

“Thank you.” He reached over the checklist and tucked a strand of hair behind my ear, beside the pen. “Dom says I’m a controlling lunatic.”

“Dom is correct.”

“Dom’s always correct. It’s his worst quality.”

On the other side of the shop, Priya, from behind her laptop, said very softly, without moving her face, “Margo, the florist is calling. It’s urgent.” Her eyes met mine over the screen. “I’ll take it in the back.”

I stood up. I followed her into the stock room, between the shelves of tulle and the box of dead pens, and she shut the door and turned on me, small, brave and furious, with her hands on her hips.

“You’ve lied to him twice today.”

“I haven’t.”

“You said ‘nothing’ with your whole face.” She held up one finger. “I’m a ladder. I’m furniture. I don’t ask. But I have loved you since a Tuesday in sophomore year, and I know what your face looks like when you’ve stopped sleeping, and I know what your pen does when you’re scared.” She took a breath. “It’s been going tap-tap-tap against your teeth for two days.”

“Pri.”

“Tell me one thing.” Her voice cracked. “Are you in danger?”

I thought about it honestly. I owed her that.

“I don’t know,” I said. “I think I’m in the most danger I’ve ever been. And I think, for the first time, I know exactly what I’m going to do.”

She looked at me for a long, long moment. Then she nodded, once, the way she does when I give her a seating chart with eight conflicts and a prayer.

“What do you need?”

“A car that isn’t Santo’s. A tank of gas. And on Thursday morning, at six, Teddy needs to be somewhere that isn’t outside my door.”

“Where does he need to be?”

“I don’t know yet.” I pulled the pen from behind my ear, and found, with some surprise, that I was gripping it so hard my knuckles had gone white. “But I’ve got until Wednesday night to build it. And I’ve never failed to build one.”

Priya let out a long breath. She went to the shelf, took down a roll of white tulle, and held it against her chest like a shield.

“I’m furniture,” she said fiercely. “I’m the best furniture you’ve ever had.”

I hugged her. Over her shoulder, through the half-open door, I could see the front of the shop: the desk, the lamp, the yellow folder, and Santo standing at the window with his hands in his pockets, looking out at the snow, a tall man with a scar through his eyebrow, waiting for me.

He turned his head. He smiled.

And behind him, on the glass of the shop window, I saw a reflection I hadn’t noticed before: the street, the parked cars, a gray sedan with Wisconsin plates idling at the curb across from the bakery, its engine running, its windshield dark.

It had been there, I realized, when Dom arrived.

I didn’t know whose it was. I didn’t know how long it had been there. I only knew that I’d just spent two days building a lie so careful it could hold a man’s whole heart without spilling, and that someone was already standing outside it, waiting to see whether it would crack.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!