Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 44

Bay Three

St. Procopius smelled the way a church smells at noon on a winter weekday: of wet wool, cold stone, and the thin, sweet ghost of a candle somebody had snuffed too fast.

We came in by the front door at eleven minutes past twelve. The plan had said one minute past noon; the plan had not met State Street. I was in a yellow dress with a borrowed gold band on my finger, and my husband was in a dark suit with a yellow handkerchief, and behind us a gentle, freckled giant was trying to hold the heavy door open without looking like a man guarding it.

Gus Fenn had come with us in the front seat of the SUV, in my father’s coat, and he’d given up trying to pray in the car after the third block.

Noon Mass was nearly over. There were perhaps thirty people in the pews, mostly old, mostly women, mostly in gray and navy, with the rapt, businesslike posture of those who attend every day and have never found it dull. The priest was at the altar, a small round man in a green chasuble, saying something about the intentions of the faithful. The organ was silent. A single votive rack flickered by the side altar.

“For the marriage of Santo and Margaret,” said the priest, into the quiet, “that they may be given peace.”

Thirty heads turned.

I could feel Santo flinch beside me. It’s an odd thing to hear your name offered to God by a stranger, as if it were an item on a shopping list. For a heartbeat I wanted to turn around and walk back out into the cold, and then I remembered why I’d planned this, down to the minute. A heron stands still and waits. I wanted to be seen.

So I walked up the side aisle in my yellow dress, past the Stations of the Cross, and sat in the third pew on the Gospel side, where Gus said the white envelope had been left twelve years ago. Santo sat beside me. Teddy stood at the back, a small wall by the font.

The congregation turned back around. Someone coughed. The priest finished the prayer, and the little bell was rung, and the whole room rose and sang something in Czech that I did not know and that moved me anyway.

I watched every back, every collar, every hand on every hymnal.

Nobody in that church wrote with the wrong hand. Nobody left early. Nobody looked at us twice, except an old woman in the second pew who stared at Santo with enormous, shining, unembarrassed pleasure and mouthed, in perfect clarity, “He’s so thin.”

---

When the Mass was done and the last of them had shuffled out into the cold, a woman with a broom was already working her way up the center aisle.

She was perhaps seventy-five, tiny, in a quilted housecoat and a blue kerchief, with a face like a walnut. She swept the way some people pray, fully, without hurry, in short firm strokes toward a little pile of grit and candle wax. She did not look up as we came near. She said, to the floor, in a flat, amused Chicago voice with Polish underneath it, “You are the bride. The one in the yellow.”

“I am. I’m Margo.”

“Anna Dabrowska.” She did not offer a hand; she held the broom. “I’ve done this floor since 1983. Gus is a good boy and a fool. You have him in a good coat. I like that.”

I looked at Gus. He had stopped dead in the aisle with his hands hanging.

“Ask the woman who sweeps,” I said.

“Who said that?”

“My baker. In a flour room. She didn’t say what to ask.”

Mrs. Dabrowska snorted. “Hanna Wozniak. We were girls in the same choir. She never says what she means, only what a person needs to hear.” She leaned on the broom. “I will tell you what I know, and you will not give me a lecture about telling. I know a great many things. Nobody asks. They ask Father. They ask the Lord. They don’t ask the old woman with the dust.”

“I’m asking.”

“Yes. Good.” She looked at Santo, and her face, to my surprise, softened. “You were a good little boy. You were afraid of the incense. You stood on the back of the pew, up there, every Sunday, with your friend, and the other one held your hand.”

Santo went still. “Which friend?”

“The tall one. The dark one, with the dimple.” She shrugged. “There were two. They came with your father, and then without. You were never apart.”

“Dom,” said Santo.

“No. No, no, the other.” She frowned, working it out. “A thin boy. Quiet. He used to come early and stand by the confession box and look at the saints. I don’t remember his name. It started with”

“Mrs. Dabrowska,” I said gently. “The man in the garage. The one who leaves packages.”

Her face closed like a purse.

“Ah,” she said. “That.”

“You know.”

“I know I saw a coat. Once in a while, on a Monday. A good coat, a dark one, coming in by the choir stairs, from the street door on Allport. A man. I don’t see him often. He comes when the church is empty, before six, or in the dark in Lent.” She resumed sweeping. “I do not ask. A man who comes in the dark to a church before six has his reasons. I light the candle and I leave him alone.”

“Did he have a limp?”

“No. Gus has the limp. This one walks very straight. Like a man who was taught.” She flicked a bit of wax with the toe of her shoe. “And he lights one candle. Always the same one.”

“Which?”

“Saint Joseph. The side altar, the little one. He puts a dollar in the box and he lights one, and he says a prayer, and it is not a Christian prayer, I think. It is too short.” She jerked her chin toward the votive rack. “He left one this morning. It’s still going. Before six. I came in at five-thirty, it was already lit.”

We all turned.

On the little iron rack at the foot of Saint Joseph’s statue, among forty dark wicks, one small flame burned in a blue glass cup. It was perfectly steady. It had a faint, strange, honest glow, like a thing that has been kept alive on purpose.

I walked over and looked at it. The glass was cold. Under it, folded very small, tucked flat against the iron, was a piece of cream paper.

I did not open it. I’d learned that much. I took the little silk handkerchief from my sleeve, lifted the glass with it, and set it on the altar rail. Teddy, who had followed me up the aisle, bagged the folded paper in a sandwich bag from Hanna’s thermos basket, unread.

---

Bay three was behind the rectory, at the end of a gravel alley that smelled of snow and engine oil.

It was a garage door, old, green, with the paint peeling in long curls, and a padlock the size of a fist. Gus had the key on a hymnal ribbon. His hands shook so badly that Santo took it from him and opened the lock, quietly, as if there might be a sleeper inside.

“Wait,” I said.

“Margo.”

“Rule six.” I put my hand flat on his chest. “I’m asking. Before you go in. Please let Teddy go first.”

He looked at me with his dark eyes, and I watched him decide. He’d spent six years being the man who went in first. He’d spent five days learning to stand behind a tall, scared, apologetic man with enormous hands, and let that man do the thing he was best at.

“All right,” said Santo. “Teddy.”

“On it,” said Teddy, in a tone of such relief that I almost cried.

The door rolled up with a long scream of tracks.

It was a dim, dusty, ordinary garage. A workbench, a pegboard of tools, three stacked folding tables, a rusting wheelbarrow. A crate of hymnals. A smell of old paper. On the bench there was a wax-cloth parcel tied with butcher’s twine. And in the back, bound to a chair with a length of orange extension cord, with a rag in his mouth and a bruise coming up like a plum on his left cheekbone, there sat a man in a duffel coat.

“Ricci,” said Santo.

The man made a muffled, furious noise.

I’ll tell you what I felt, because it was not what I’d expected. I’d thought of him for five days as a face in a car and a name on a flip phone, a man who’d put a rifle on a dock and a boy behind it. He was fifty-something, with a broken-veined, ordinary, tired face, and his eyes above the gag were the eyes of a man who had been left in a cold room by someone who’d promised to come back and hadn’t.

Teddy cut the rag first. Then the cord.

“Don’t touch the wax,” Ricci rasped. He coughed. “Don’t touch the parcel. Dio. He said”

“Who said?”

“I don’t know his name. I never had it.” He rubbed his wrists. His voice was a wreck. “I’m a made man in a table that doesn’t want me, I’ve been in this for thirty years, and I’ve never had a name. A voice on the phone. He told me where the old man was. He told me when.

He gave me the boy and the rifle, and the boy was supposed to do it. The boy couldn’t.” He laughed, ugly. “The boy looked at him and put the thing down. Twenty-four years old. I should’ve known.”

“Who sent you here?”

“Nobody sent me. I got a call at eleven this morning. The voice said, go to bay three, the garage behind St. Procopius, the old Corvino’s boy will come at noon. You’ll have what you need. I came, and the door was open.” He gestured at his face. “And somebody hit me from behind. A single blow. I woke up like this at twenty to twelve.”

“A voice,” I said. “What did it sound like?”

“A man. Older. Careful. A voice you could mistake for a priest’s.” He rubbed his jaw. “Almost like he was reading.”

Santo stood looking down at him. The old Santo, I thought, the one who’d have had a name by now with a hand on a collar, was somewhere nearby. I could see him standing at his shoulder like a hungry dog.

“Teddy,” said Santo, without taking his eyes off Ricci. “Take him to the SUV. Sit him in the back. Give him Hanna’s thermos. Then call the sergeant Gia found last night and ask him to come and collect a man who is about to confess to attempted murder.”

“I can’t,” said Ricci, in sudden panic. “My table will”

“Your table sat in the third row of my wedding this morning,” said Santo, “holding a pie. I think you’ll find it quite lenient.”

---

I found the book while they were leading Ricci out.

It was under the wax-cloth parcel, a flat, black, cloth-bound ledger of the kind you buy in a stationer’s and keep for twenty years. Its spine was cracked, its corners were round with handling. I opened it on the bench, standing, with my sleeve around the pages.

It was a log.

A hand had ruled the columns, very carefully, in pencil. Date. Event. Place. Seat. Present or absent. And a final column, narrow, headed in a small neat italic: Observed.

The first entry was March 2002. First Communion, St. Procopius. Santo C. Seat: front left. The Observed column read: Frightened of the incense. Holds a friend’s hand.

I made a small sound. Santo, who had just come back in, crossed the garage in two strides and looked over my shoulder, and I felt him stop breathing.

Every page was like it. Every christening, every confirmation, every Christmas Eve for twenty-four years. Gia’s baptism. A funeral in 2009, with a brief, bleak line: Father not present. Santo at graveside, with an aunt. Dry. A school play in 2004. A wedding in 2008, someone’s, with a line in the Observed column that I could read only in fragments: Brother cheerful. Sister silent. S. dances once, with the bride’s mother.

“He was watching,” said Santo, in a wasted voice. “He was there. At all of it.”

“He was in the room. Or he had someone in the room.” I turned a page. The pencil smudged under my sleeve, and I saw it, the dull gray heel of a hand dragged left to right across the freshly written line: the smear of a man who writes with the left and touches the page with the side of his palm. “Look at that. He’s left-handed. Gus was right.”

“He was never anywhere I can remember.”

“He was always standing at the back. Or in a pew. Or at the edge of a photograph.” I flipped to the end. “Santo, look at the dates. They stop when your father went. Look: June 2020. Then nothing. Then a page in November this year, in different ink. And then”

I stopped.

There were three entries on the last leaf. The first was dated December 29. Wedding rehearsal. Bakery. S. kisses her in the doorway. Observed: She laughs first. Then Dec. 30, 5 a.m.: Dock. Heard shot. Not mine.

The third was in fresh, dark, wet-looking ink, with the smudge still shiny along its margin. Today’s date. No time. Under Event, it said: Marriage. Court. Under Seat, it said: Third row (S.S.). Under Present or absent, it said, in careful, tidy, upright pencil, Present.

And in the Observed column, one line.

He does not look at his best man. Good.

I read it three times. It was written, if the ink was any guide, in the last hour. It had been written by someone who had been in the courthouse. Someone who had sat in that room, with the roses and the cream silk and the forty cards in my handwriting, and had watched my husband look at me.

“Margo,” said Santo, very quietly.

“Yes.”

“I didn’t look at Dom.”

“No. I told you not to.”

“Because of the card. Because of five fifteen.” His voice was dry, taut, and very controlled. “He’s put a note in a book that says I didn’t look at him. He’s saying I did the right thing. He’s saying he approves.”

“He’s saying he was there,” I said. “And he wants us to know it.”

I turned the page back. There was a fourth line. I hadn’t seen it, because it was written lower, in different pencil, right at the margin, in a hand that pressed harder, as though the writer had been angry, or in a hurry.

It had no date and no column. It said:

Tonight. River Forest. Everyone at one table. The Underwood. Let them eat.

The ledger lay open on the bench in the dust, in the cold, in that dim green garage that smelled of paper and ice. Outside I could hear Teddy’s voice in the alley, low and kind, talking to a man he had rescued, and a long way off the St. Procopius bell, striking the quarter.

I had been married for forty minutes. I had a borrowed ring that was too big, a dress with a wet hem, and a husband who was reading a line of someone else’s pencil over my shoulder with an expression like a man looking at a map of his own house.

“There’s a dinner,” I said.

“Nonna’s. For my father. For everyone.” Santo’s voice was almost soundless. “She’s been cooking since Tuesday. She told Hanna. She told the whole bakery. She said, the whole family, at one table, with Enzo at the head. For the first time in six years.”

“And the Underwood is in the flour room.”

“Yes.”

“And the whole family will be in the dining room, eating, with the flour room empty, for two hours.”

“Yes.”

“Santo.” I closed the ledger, gently, over the dull gray smear. “He’s telling us. He’s giving us the time, and the place, and the typewriter. Why would he give us that?”

“Because he’s not afraid we’ll stop him.”

“Or because”

“Or because he wants us to try.” He took the book from me. He did it carefully, like a man taking a baby from a nurse. “Margo. I’m going to ask you something, and I want you to answer it the way you answered in the judge’s room.”

“Ask.”

“Do we cancel the dinner?”

I looked at the bench. At the parcel. At the little blue flame of the Saint Joseph candle in my handkerchief on the church’s altar rail, a hundred feet away, that someone had left burning before dawn. At the gentle sweeper and the shaking sacristan and the man in the duffel coat in the back of the car.

Nonna had been cooking since Tuesday. She had not seen her son in six years. And I had planned sixty weddings, and in every one of them I had learned that you can ruin a thing by guarding it too well, and that you can only really win a room by deciding to be in it.

“No,” I said. “We don’t cancel. We cook.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!