The last house on my wall had one line and one resident, and no asker we sent could get him to pick up.
It was on the board as 1104 and nothing else. Loy’s ledger gave it a name: Ninth Street Bridge, East Approach. Strand had gone to the city records for me in her own way, which is to say she remembered it. A tollbooth. Brick, six feet by six, with a stove and a window. The bridge had stopped charging in 1970 and the booth had been knocked down for a turning lane.
It was Sunday, the twenty-second. Two hundred and nine squares stood in the right-hand columns, one of them in Vosk’s fourth. Ines was at thirteen and on my couch, grading quizzes, with my mother, Dot Hadley and Irv coming by in shifts she had stopped arguing with.
And one pink square.
“Lyle Garrity,” said Orrin.
He was at the trainee board in Dispatch, where he had been every night for four weeks. I had not asked how he knew. He told me anyway, with his eyes on the cords.
“Night collector. He had the booth from fifty-one. There was a storm in February of sixty-six and the day man could not get in until noon. Mr. Garrity had been gone since about four.” He set a plug down, exactly. “He telephoned the Exchange every night at three for the time. It was against regulations. One was not to tie up a line for the time. I was new on the board in sixty-five, and I gave it to him.”
“For how long?”
“Five months. We did not converse. He would say, ‘Booth,’ and I would say, ‘Three and two minutes, Mr. Garrity,’ and he would say, ‘Much obliged.’” Orrin’s hands were folded now. “After the storm the line went on ringing at three. For some years. I took it for a fault. I ought to have known a man by his habits.”
Miss Crane’s people had tried the booth six times. The lamp was lit. Nobody answered.
“He isn’t declining,” I said. “Tolliver declined. This is something else.”
“He does not know the ring, Miss Park. A man alone in a booth for sixty years learns not to answer what he does not know.” Orrin hesitated. “There is one he would know. I should have to place it myself. I should have to do the asking.”
I had seen that coming for a day and a half.
I had let him ring bells. I had let him sit at a board. I had not, in four weeks, let him put the question to a single soul, and he had not asked to. We both knew why. The last time Edmund Orrin said “May I?” to a lonely person on a line, a nurse died of it.
“I’m going to be on the circuit,” I said. “The whole time. If you help him, if you lean on him one ounce, I pull the cord.”
“I should expect it.”
“And it’s the form. Those words. You don’t get to improve them.”
“I have improved enough things,” said Orrin.
It was nine at night. He said three would be better, but we did not have another three. He took a cord and held it a moment over a jack at the bottom corner of the board, a jack with no label, only a number stamped in the brass.
He did not ring long-short. He rang one short ring, and stopped, and waited, the way you tap once on a window.
The line opened at once.
“Booth,” said a man. An old, slow, careful voice, with a stove ticking behind it.
“Good evening, Mr. Garrity,” said Orrin. His own voice had gone very quiet. “It is nine and four minutes. I regret that I am six hours early.”
“Exchange,” said Lyle Garrity. “That’s never you.”
“It is, sir.”
“You quit answering. Seventy-four.”
“I died, Mr. Garrity. On a Sunday night. I ought to have sent word.”
“Huh.” The stove ticked. “Well. Me too, I guess. I’d wondered.”
I had my hand on the cord. I did not pull it. Orrin sat with his back straight and his eyes shut.
“Mr. Garrity, I am not calling with the time. I have been asked to put a question to you. It is not my question. It belongs to a young woman who is listening, and she will stop me if I get it wrong.” He drew a breath he did not need. “What would you like? You may say stay, or go, or that you do not know. You may answer later, and you may answer differently tomorrow.”
He stopped. He did not add one word. I watched him not add it. His folded hands had gone white at the knuckles.
“That’s the whole thing?” said Garrity.
“That is the whole of it.”
“Nobody wants the booth?”
“Nobody wants anything, sir. That is rather the point.”
The old man took his time. Mrs. Ferro had told two hundred operators that the hard part was shutting your mouth. Orrin shut his. A full minute went by on the Dispatch clock, and then another, and the man who had built a party line and a pager service and an app to keep from ever sitting through a silence sat through it.
“Stay,” said Garrity. “I’ll stay. Somebody ought to be in the booth. People come over that bridge at night and it’s a comfort to them, a light, even if they don’t know why.” A creak, a chair. “I’d take the time at three, though. If it’s being offered.”
“It can be arranged,” I said, on my key. “I’m Lena. I’ll see somebody rings you.”
“Much obliged, miss.”
Orrin reached for the cord.
“Hold on, Exchange,” said Garrity. “I’m not done. You asked me. I had a job thirty years where everybody handed me a dime and nobody said a word. It’s manners to ask back.” The slow voice was not unkind. “What about you? What would you like?”
I saw it go into him. I do not have a better way to put it. He had asked that question, in one form or another, of six thousand people. He had built machinery around other people’s answers. In fifty-one years no one had turned it round.
He opened his mouth to answer smoothly. I know he did, because I know the face. Then he did not.
“I had always known,” said Edmund Orrin. “That is the difficulty, Mr. Garrity. I knew precisely what I wanted, for half a century, and I was very patient and very courteous about it, and it was the ruin of a number of people. One of them is on this line.” His voice had lost its starch. It was the voice of a man of thirty-six. “I find, now that I am asked, that I do not know. I do not know what I would like. I am not certain I am a safe person to want things.”
“Well,” said Garrity comfortably. “Then that’s your answer, I guess. Lady said it’s one of the three.”
“It is.”
“They ask you again, then. Next year.”
“So I understand.”
“I’ll ring you,” said the tollman. “At three. Turnabout. Much obliged, Exchange.” And he hung up, gently.
Orrin took his hands off the board and put them in his lap.
“I heard that,” I said.
“Yes, Miss Park.”
“I’m writing it down. Orrin, E. Does not know. To be asked again.” I found the pencil. My hand was not steady and I did not pretend it was. “That isn’t my answer to you. I want that clear. I still don’t have one.”
“I had not supposed it was.”
“But it’s on the record that somebody asked.”
He bowed his head. I wrote the line.
Two hundred and ten. I carried the sheets to Vosk myself, at ten forty, and he read every one, and turned the last one over to look at the back, and signed. The stays stood. They would stand on Tuesday and next year. No house on my wall could be closed for want of asking.
It did not touch the eighteen hundred and forty. I knew that when I laid them down.
I was in the car with Odell, going up, when my own phone rang in my pocket with Miss Budd’s bright double bell.
“Toll,” she said. She did not sound pleased as a cat. She sounded like a girl reading bad news off a card. “Miss Park, I am to read you the amount and the hour. And I want to say, miss, that I may not volunteer anything. Not a thing. I may only answer what I am asked.” She paused, and I heard paper, as of a book being opened and laid flat. “I do hope you are still a person who asks.”

