They tried Captain Marr by torchlight, in a coach yard, with a dozen chickens roosting in the rafters of the stable and a milk cart for a dock.
It was Sorrel’s idea of dignity. He had set a trestle table at the head of the yard, with a green cloth and a single candle, and a high-backed chair that someone had carried down from the landlord’s parlor. The Emperor’s bell-glass stood on the cloth at his right hand, in its silver ring, catching the torchlight like a coin. He had put the key round his neck again, on the outside of his coat. It lay against the black wool and shone.
Around the yard stood the Wing. Not all of it. Two hundred riders, perhaps, in a square, in silence, black and silver, with their faces turned to the front. Past the yard wall, in the dark of the paddock beyond, I could hear the forty unbelled dragons of the Fourth Flight shifting on their chains. They were humming. They had not stopped since the barn. It was a deep, patient, wordless sound, as of a very large animal dreaming of its mother.
I did not look in that direction. I had learned to hold the line of my gaze the way you hold a full cup.
“The Queen will sit,” said Sorrel, and they brought me a chair.
They brought it to the left of the table, between the dock and the glass, and my family took the benches behind me. Hadrian did not sit. He stood at my shoulder with his bandaged hands clasped before him and his chin up, in the old Captain’s attitude, and I knew from the way the nearest riders flinched that they remembered it.
At the other end of the yard, the red-wheeled wagon stood in a pool of dark with its grille toward us. I looked at it, once. Nothing moved behind the bars.
“Bring the prisoner,” said Sorrel.
---
They had not hurt her yet. I want to say that. They’d taken her silver braid and her gold bell and the little black enamel clasp she wore at her collar, and they had put her in the plain gray shirt of a ranker, but nobody had laid a hand on her. She walked between two guards with her wrists tied in front of her and her black-and-white hair pinned tight. Her face had a scoured look, like a field after burning.
“Odile Marr,” said Sorrel. “Captain of the Third Talon Wing. You are charged, before the officers present, under the Articles of the Wing and the authority of the Emperor, with the wilful destruction of forty bells of the Emperor’s issue, the unlawful release of forty dragons, and the concealment of the Queen’s person from lawful custody. Do you wish to answer?”
“I wish to be heard under Article Eleven,” said Marr.
“You’ve been told the Articles have been suspended.”
“Article Four has been revoked. I was shown the vellum. I read it. It was very thorough.” A thin pale gleam went across her face. “It revoked Article Four, Lieutenant. It didn’t touch Eleven.”
Sorrel looked at her for a moment. Then he looked at the glass, and I knew, from the little white ring that flowered on its face, that the Emperor was awake.
“Article Eleven,” said the voice from the glass, benignly, “gives an accused officer the right to be defended by one who is not of the Wing, and seconded by a rider of equal service, in the hearing of two flights. Does the Captain name a defender?”
“I do,” said Marr. “Brandt.”
Brandt had been standing in the shadow of the stable arch. She came forward into the light in her steel-gray coat with her hands behind her back, and the whole yard, I swear, took one small breath. It was the breath you take when a person you’d heard of and never believed in walks in through a door.
“Madam Brandt,” said the Emperor, with pleasure. “I’d hoped.”
“You are kind.” Her voice was dry as a bone. “I have two submissions before we begin.”
“Please.”
“First, that an accused is entitled to be seconded by a rider of equal service. The Captain is a Captain of the Wing. She has been under guard since this morning and has had no way to ask. I’d like the court to inquire whether any rider present is willing.” Brandt did not turn her head. “Second, that the court record, in the Emperor’s words, that no other defense will be heard.”
There was a small silence.
“I think,” said the Emperor, “the second submission is unnecessary.”
“I thought so, too. I’d like it recorded.”
“Lieutenant,” said the glass, with a trace of amusement, “record it.”
It was done in four lines. A young clerk wrote them down with a scratching pen. I watched Brandt’s face, which had not changed at all, and understood that she had just made the Emperor say aloud, in front of two hundred witnesses, that he would not hear another defense. It would be worth very little, tonight. In a year, in a court that wasn’t his, it might be worth a crown.
“Now,” said Brandt. “Is there a rider of equal service?”
Nobody moved.
I counted. It took thirty heartbeats, and the yard seemed to get colder with each of them. Sorrel waited, with his hand on the key and his smile in place. The torches popped. The forty dragons hummed on in the dark.
“Equal service,” said Sorrel, kindly, “would mean a Captain. There is, at present, one in the Wing. She is in the dock.”
“Equal service,” said a voice, “in the Article, means rank *or* years.”
A man had stepped out of the square.
He was perhaps fifty, broad and bald, with a scar through one eyebrow and the plain tunic of a Flight rider with no braid. I had seen him in the barn. He’d been the one at the far wall with both hands over his mouth. He had taken them away now. They hung at his sides, big and square and perfectly steady, and they were shaking all the way to the wrist.
“Orrin Pike, Fourth Flight,” he said. “Twenty-eight years’ service. Marr’s got fourteen. I’ll second.”
“Rider Pike,” said Sorrel, softly, “I would think very carefully.”
“I have, sir. I thought about it in the barn.” Pike’s jaw worked. “I’ve ridden a dragon for twenty-eight years. I never once heard her say a word. And then the Captain cut the bell off, and she said, *Orrin, I’ve missed you.*” He stopped. He cleared his throat. “That’s all. I’d like to be told it was a crime.”
Sorrel did not answer. He turned his eyes, instead, with great delicacy, toward the glass.
“Record it,” said the Emperor.
---
I will not give the whole of the trial. It lasted two hours and a quarter, and it was one of the strangest and most terrible things I’ve ever sat through, because it was done so well.
Brandt argued like a woman laying a table. She never raised her voice. She took each charge in turn, as a carpenter takes a joint, and she showed the court the grain of it. The bells were issued to the Wing, not owned by it, she said: but the Articles said an issued article might be returned by the officer who judged it unsafe. The forty dragons had not been released.
They had been unbelled, and released was a word that implied they had gone somewhere. The Queen’s person had not been concealed. The Queen had been present, and had at no time been invisible.
“You are being clever,” said Sorrel, mildly, at the third charge.
“I am being exact. It’s less amusing, but it lasts.”
Twice the glass chuckled. Twice the white ring went pale and I realized he’d let go of the key, and the Emperor’s voice had come back a beat late, in a tone of such warm uncomplicated pleasure that I could have wept. He liked her. That was the horror of it. He liked her, and he would not stop.
“The prisoner is charged with destroying the Emperor’s property,” said Sorrel, at last, with the air of a man bringing up the heavy artillery. “It is not denied that she cut the bells. She has been asked why. She has declined to say.”
“She has declined to *incriminate herself,*” said Brandt. “It’s not the same.”
“Then let her answer in her own voice. Captain Marr.” The Lieutenant half-turned in his chair. “Why did you cut them?”
I watched Marr.
I’d seen her ride a dragon through fire and hold a door against a mob. I had seen her at the barn, kneeling in white dust with a bell in her hand and a face like a drowned girl. I had never seen her look the way she did then. She stood up very straight and raised her bound hands. And she did what she had told me, at the barn, that she’d always been afraid of doing.
She told the truth.
“Because every bell has a tooth in it,” said Marr.
The yard went still.
“Because the teeth are numbered. I looked, in the barn, with a lantern. This one.” She nodded, and her guard, who was a boy of twenty, looked as if he would sooner have been shot. He reached into the breast of her shirt, as she indicated, and drew out a small white thing on a scrap of cloth, and laid it, with a trembling hand, on the green table. A tooth.
A sliver of iron no longer than a barleycorn, notched and gray, the one tooth that had not yet gone to dust. “Hold it to the candle. The side, there. You can read it.”
Sorrel did not touch it.
“Read it,” said Marr, “and you will find a date. Every tooth has a date. It is the night that dragon was bound. This one is from the night of the first frost, three winters back. I have the roll in my head. I’ve heard it chimed on a hundred parade grounds, and I never once thought what it was a roll *of.*
“The Emperor’s ring has three hundred and five teeth. I counted them at a levee. I told the Queen that. I did not tell her what I’d seen on the other side.”
“Captain,” said the glass, very softly.
“There’s a notch.” Marr’s voice did not rise. It grew quieter and clearer, like water finding its level. “After the last tooth. A little groove, cut ready. It’s a hair wider than the others, and it has no date. I took it for a flaw in the casting. I think it is a place. I think there are three hundred and five dragons in his Wing, and the three hundred and sixth tooth is not for a dragon.”
Nobody spoke.
I had not moved. I could not have said whether I was breathing. I had my hand flat on my knee and the cracked bell in my palm gave a single great, slow thud, like a door opening a long way off.
“That’s what I cut them for,” said Marr. “I’d like it recorded. A man has made a roll of everything he’s tied to his hand, and left a blank at the end, for one more.”
“Strike that,” said Sorrel.
“It’s the defense.”
“*Strike it.*”
“The Emperor,” said Brandt, gently, “has already said no other defense will be heard. It’s in the record. He may not now say this one’s inadmissible.”
The glass said nothing at all.
It said nothing for a very long time. The ring on its face went white, then gray, then, for the first time since I’d met him, entirely dark. Not turned off. It was something else. It was listening so hard that it had stopped being a glass.
Then the white came back, and the voice said, as if nothing had been said at all, “Rider Pike. You seconded the prisoner. Would you speak?”
“I’d as soon not, sir.”
“Nevertheless.”
“She’s right,” said Pike. He said it in the plain, flat, headlong way of a man stepping off a bridge. “I’ve a notch like that on my own bell. I’d seen it. I took it for a flaw.”
---
It was the sentence that broke me.
The Emperor gave it himself, through the glass, in a voice so regretful that for a moment even I believed it. The Articles, he said, were a net with a very large mesh. The prisoner had been heard. She had been well defended. He admired her courage. But the Articles named the penalty for damage to issued bells, and there was no way round it, and he was exceedingly sorry. Ten strokes.
Publicly, at once, before the Flights, to be a lesson. And as an act of grace, because he’d taken such pleasure in the Queen’s company at supper, the sentence could be remitted entirely.
“On what condition?” I said.
“On a very small one.” The voice turned to me with great gentleness. “Your Majesty may have noticed the Fourth Flight is restless. They are very large, and they have been confined with no bells, and they are, I’m afraid, humming. It’s a thing the unbelled do. It will go on until they are sung down. If you would go to the paddock now, and sing them quiet, I should be perfectly content to consider the Captain’s offense purged.”
I understood it all at once.
It was beautiful. It was so tidy. If I sang, I’d give the Anvil another mouthful, a long sweet one, tasted through forty open throats at once. If I did not, the woman who had told me the truth would be flogged in front of her own riders. He was not asking me to sing for them. He was asking me to *choose,* and he’d laid the table so that either choice was a price.
I said, “No.”
“Seren,” said Marr, very low. “Don’t. It’s all right.”
“It isn’t.”
“It’s ten strokes. I’ve taken worse in the training yard, and from my father.” She smiled at me, a tiny, ruined, fierce smile. “I’d be ashamed to be the reason. Don’t sing.”
“I’d rather,” said the Emperor, with a sigh, “that you decided yourself.”
“I have,” I said. “I won’t sing for him. Not tonight.”
“Then it’ll be done.”
It was done quickly. I will not describe it. It was not savage, as such things go, and it was not meant to be. It was meant to be seen. They put her to the post at the end of the yard, her shirt left on, and a sergeant of the Wing laid on ten strokes of a plain leather strap, with a long even pause between each, in the silence, and Orrin Pike counted them out loud in a voice like a man reading a prayer.
I did not look away. I’d made myself that promise, on the road, long before this. If a thing is done because of my choice, I will see it done.
At the first stroke, the humming in the paddock faltered.
At the second, it stopped.
I felt it before I understood it. A flutter, in the little cracked bell, as if a bird had hit a window. Another. Another. The Anvil had heard. The Anvil, who lay far under a palace and could not stop himself from feeding on me, was hearing a woman struck, through forty dragon-throats, and he flinched. I could feel him flinch. At each stroke, my pulse leapt like a boy shying from a blow, a hundred and sixty-three, a hundred and sixty-six, a hundred and seventy.
*Stop,* said the Anvil. It was the tiniest thread of a voice, scarcely there at all. *Stop. Please. Make them stop.*
I could not.
On the tenth they cut her loose. Marr did not fall. She stood with her back to the post for a long moment, and then Brandt was there, with an arm under hers and a blanket round her, and Orrin Pike on the other side, and the three of them stood together in the torchlight with their heads down, not moving, like the figures on a tomb.
I got to my feet. My knees were not entirely mine. Hadrian caught my elbow. For the first time that night I looked at the glass, and it looked back, with its small pale silver ring.
“I am so sorry,” said the Emperor. “I do want you to know it gave me no pleasure.”
“I know,” I said. “That’s the thing about you.”
---
They carried Marr upstairs on a door.
It took six of us to get her up the narrow stair of the Three Candles, my mother going first with a lamp, and when we had laid her on the bed in the room at the end of the passage, my mother pushed the rest of us out and closed the door and said, “I was a Keeper for twelve years. I’ve seen worse and set it right. Go and wash your face, child, and *sit down.*”
I stood in the passage. I could not remember how. Hadrian came out of the dark of the landing and stood beside me, and he did not take my hand, which was a mercy, because I’d have broken. We stood there, side by side, with the lamplight shaking on the boards, and the building creaking with the dreams of a hundred sleeping soldiers, and I thought: I made that choice. It was the right one.
And she is lying on a bed with her back in ribbons, and the Anvil is weeping far under the ground, and I would do it again.
That is the whole of what I know about being a Queen. You do it again.
Down the passage, a door opened. Light spilled out of it. Sorrel came into the corridor, still in his coat, with his hair a little rumpled, and a lantern in one hand and the key in the other. He’d come to see to the guards. He was walking briskly, humming to himself, with the soft contented air of a man who’s had a long, demanding, successful day.
Tally lifted her head from the crook of my arm.
It was such a small movement that I almost did not feel it. Then she said, in a voice so thin that I had to bend to hear, “Seren. Do you hear it?”
“Hear what?”
“The key.”
We both looked at Sorrel. He had stopped in the middle of the passage, ten paces off, with his lantern lifted. I do not think he knew he’d stopped. He had put his left hand to his chest, and he was holding the key between thumb and finger, tilted to the light, turning it as one turns a watch that has ceased to tick.
“It hums,” said Tally. “It’s hummed since Warrow. It’s the loudest thing in the key, it’s *her,* I can hear her breath in it. A long one, a short one. A long one. It’s the only way I know she’s there.” A pause. “It’s stopped.”
Sorrel put the key to his ear.
I watched his face, in the swinging light. It was a handsome, civil, unremarkable face, and it had worn the same smile since the morning we met. I saw the smile stay where it was, as a painted thing stays, while everything underneath it went out like a lamp. His lips parted. He shook the key once, very gently, as one shakes a sleeper.
“No,” said Lieutenant Sorrel, quite softly, to nobody. “No. Not tonight. Not *yet.*”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!