Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 40

Left-Handed

“He’s dead,” I say.

It comes out in the voice of a woman reading her own name off a list. Brandt tilts his head, as though I’ve given him a pleasant piece of local news.

“So I understand. A pity. The notary was, I believe, less informed.” He nods at the page in my hand. “Article Nine. The settlor retains the power to revoke at any time, on written notice to the trustee. All property reverts to the settlor or the settlor’s estate.

“I’m told that a probate petition was filed this morning, at eight-fifteen, in your late father’s name. Naming his surviving daughter as the sole heir at law.” He smiles. “Congratulations, Ms. Holt. If this is valid, the Winterlight corpus is yours. I’d estimate nine million. I do hope you’ll be kind to the trustee.”

The corridor is very quiet. Cyrus has stopped breathing beside me.

I see it then, the whole shape of it, the way you see the second half of a chess problem after the first move has already cost you a piece.

If the revocation stands, the Fund dies. The payments stop, by law, all forty-odd of them, my mother’s included. The Fund’s money lands in my account, and every wolf on the Ridge, every judge in Golden, every reporter who ever reads about it will see the Witness of the Moon Court become a very rich woman at the moment her own court hearing begins.

A conflict of interest so large you could park a truck in it. If I take it, I’m bought. If I refuse it, the Fund’s beneficiaries lose their only lifeline, and Royce Varnell stands in the middle of the wreckage and says, quite reasonably, that he only followed the settlor’s wishes.

It’s a very beautiful trap. I can almost smell the man who built it.

“I don’t want it,” I say.

“Excuse me?”

“I’m disclaiming.” I pull a legal pad out of my bag. I tear off a sheet and write on it, standing, on the flat of my briefcase, in my fastest, ugliest hand. I disclaim any interest, in whole, now and forever, in any property of the Winterlight Fund or any revocation of it, whether as heir, executor, devisee or otherwise. I sign. I date. I write the time. “Cyrus. Witness it.”

“Maren, this is...”

“Sign.”

He signs. He writes his full name, Cyrus Alden Hale, with a trembling flourish. I give the sheet to the clerk at the end of the hall, who looks bewildered, and to Brandt, who looks, for the first time in our acquaintance, annoyed.

“You’ve just thrown away nine million dollars,” he says.

“I’ve thrown away nothing. I never had it.” I fold the revocation into my bag. “And I’ll be asking the Court on Friday to examine this document very closely, Mr. Brandt. Particularly the signature. Because my father was left-handed.”

“Is that relevant?”

“You’d be surprised.”

---

It’s a lie. Or it isn’t a lie, exactly. It’s the thing a lawyer says in a corridor when she has nothing, and her only choice is to sound as if she has.

My father was left-handed. I’ve told Agnes so. But the signature on the page is a clear, upright, rounded hand, and I haven’t the faintest idea what that proves. A man can change his hand. A forger can change it for him.

I sit in the truck, in the parking structure, with the revocation open on my knee and Teo in the driver’s seat, and I stare at the J until it stops being a letter.

“It’s him,” I say, finally. “It looks like him. It’s got the weight, and the tail.”

“Is it?”

“It’s what I’d have guessed. It’s the signature on his letters. I’d know it...” I stop. “No. I wouldn’t. He signed everything left-handed. It slanted backward. Like it was leaning away from a wind.” I put my finger on the page. “This leans forward. This is a right-hander’s J.”

“So someone copied it badly.”

“Someone copied it very well, off a sample that was upright.” I pull out my phone. “There’s one place he wrote right-handed. There must be. Priya?”

She answers on the first ring.

“Don’t say anything,” she says. “I’m in the clinic. They’re giving your mom a hot-water bottle and she’s singing again. I wrote down the notes. It’s the same eight. Is it bad? You sound like it’s bad.”

“I need you to put the phone to my mom’s ear.”

A rustle. A cough. The distant flutter of a hum, small and bright, like a tune coming out of a music box.

“Mom,” I say. “It’s Maren.”

“Oh, hello, darling.” Her voice is perfectly clear. It’s the clear voice, the one that comes and goes like a radio signal, and I hold my breath. “Is it time for the cake?”

“Soon. Mom, can I ask you about Dad?”

“Walter?” A smile in the words. “He’s at the creek.”

“I know. Mom, did he ever write with his right hand?”

“Only the once.” She laughs, a small, delighted, schoolgirl’s laugh. “Our wedding. He’d broken his left wrist on the ladder that week, hanging the paper lanterns. The whole church was waiting. I said, Walter, you’ll have to sign with the other one. And he did. Slow as a snail. He drew the J like a little fishing hook.” She hums. “The county kept it. The paper. I have my copy in the blue box, under my bed.”

“The marriage license.”

“With the pearl barrette. We put them in together.”

I close my eyes. The pearl barrette is in my coat pocket, small and cold. I’d been carrying it since the lodge. I feel it now like a coin.

“Mom, thank you.”

“Is it a good thing?”

“It’s a very good thing.”

“I’m so glad,” says my mother, and hums the eight notes again, and I recognize them at last. Not a movie. A hymn. The one my father whistled when he thought no one could hear him. *Shall We Gather at the River.*

I put my forehead against the cold dashboard.

---

The Jefferson County Clerk and Recorder keeps marriage licenses in a vault that is nothing like a vault, being a back room with a rolling shelf and a clerk named Delbert who eats sunflower seeds out of a Dixie cup. I don’t need the original. I only need the image, and Priya, with the cheerful violence of a woman who has just learned that public records laws exist, has it on my phone in eleven minutes.

I lay the two documents side by side on the hood of the truck. The revocation, and the license from thirty-five years ago. Walter James Holt. Rosalind Anne Pryor. The signature in brown ink, a little shaky, with a J like a fishing hook.

I take Priya’s tracing paper, a sheet of clear acetate from a presentation she printed for no reason. I lay it over the license. I trace the J.

Then I turn the acetate and lay it on the revocation.

It fits.

Not nearly. Not almost. It fits down to the hair, every curve of the hook, every swell of the underline, the exact angle at which the pen skipped on the upstroke of the W. I slide it a quarter inch to the left, then right, and it falls in again like a key.

“No two signatures are identical,” I say, in a thin, odd, almost cheerful voice. “Not even by the same hand in the same minute. A forger who traces gets identical. A forger who studies gets close.” I hold up the acetate. “This is a copy. Someone took the one right-handed signature my father ever made and put it on a revocation he never saw.”

“A public record,” says Teo.

“Public to anyone who’d look.” I turn the revocation over. At the bottom, in the lower margin, stamped in blue, is the notary’s seal. “Which brings us to the one person who swore my dead father stood in front of her.”

I read the stamp aloud.

PEARL A. WHITAKER. NOTARY PUBLIC. STATE OF COLORADO. COMMISSION EXPIRES...

“Whitaker,” says Cyrus. His voice cracks. “Pearl Whitaker. The chair of the board. At the vote on the north valley.”

“She called the roll,” I say. “She told me, very kindly, that my easement was an interesting document. She smiled at me for an hour.”

“She’s a human,” Cyrus says.

“She’s a notary. A notary swears she looked at a man’s face and his license and saw him sign. It’s a sworn lie. It’s a felony.” I fold the page carefully. “And she’s the one person in the whole case who had no reason to be near that study. Unless somebody asked her to.”

“Then who asked her?” says Teo.

“The question isn’t who asked. It’s who had the pad.” I count it out on my fingers, the way I did on the mountain, my hand shaking only a little. “A key slip is written on the Alpha’s pad. A revocation needs a right-handed sample from a public vault and a notary willing to swear.

“Those are two different crimes, and two different skill sets, and one very patient mind to join them.” I look up. “Pruitt didn’t build this. Pruitt was a tool. Somebody gave him a page, and somebody gave the page to a notary. There’s a chain.”

“With Varnell at the top.”

“Maybe. Or maybe Varnell is the front on a door somebody else is standing behind.” I shake my head. “A man in a camel coat doesn’t need a notary. He has a dozen. He sent Pearl Whitaker because she had something else.”

“What?”

“Access,” I say. “To the dead man’s papers. To his board, his lawyers, his calendar. Whoever chairs a board knows where the chairman keeps his pad.” I shut my eyes. “And she smiled at me for an hour, and I thought she was just being polite.”

Cyrus leans forward between the seats. “Maren. Look at the date.”

I look. Under the signature, in the notary’s neat blue hand, is the day she swore my father stood in front of her. Monday. The day before yesterday.

“Monday,” I say slowly. “Dana at Aspen Willow left me a voicemail Monday evening. ‘A gentleman and a lady from your family’s trust came this evening with discharge paperwork.’ A gentleman and a lady.” I pull up Priya’s copy of the sign-in sheet and enlarge it with two fingers. R. Varnell, in a confident slant. And under it, a second line, a looping scrawl I read right past the first time because I was looking for the name that mattered. It starts with a W.

“The lodge wasn’t a hideout,” I say. “It was a set.”

“A set for what?” says Teo.

“For one signature. He took my mother out of a locked ward on Monday night so she could sit across a table from a man in a brown coat and say yes. The notary was in the room. The paper was in the room. All that kindness, the lemon cake, the fire, the view of the mountain, was staging for a woman who would swear to anything if you made her feel loved.”

“And you?” says Cyrus.

“I was the second prize.” My mouth is dry. “Varnell wanted me overnight, under his roof, so the story could be that the Witness slept in his lodge and her mother was in his care. But the revocation was already in a drawer. Brandt has been carrying it for forty-eight hours. He didn’t produce it to answer my petition. He produced it to answer my winning.”

Teo’s hands tighten on the wheel. “So what do we do?”

“We photograph every page,” I say. “The stamp, the date, the sign-in sheet, the license, the acetate, in one sequence, with Cyrus watching and signing as he goes. Priya drafts the subpoena for Aspen Willow’s visitor log and the admin’s discharge file before anyone there gets a phone call telling them to lose it. And I stop thinking of this as a document, and start thinking of it as a night.”

“A night,” Cyrus says.

“Monday night. Everyone who touched my mother on Monday night is a witness to something.”

I check my bank balance while I wait for my breath to come back. I shouldn’t. It’s like pressing a bruise.

Two hundred and twelve dollars. That’s what I have. That’s what a nine-million-dollar disclaimer leaves behind, and a night of statutes, and a one-hundred-and-eighty-six-thousand-dollar education that has finally, for once, paid for itself.

“You could’ve kept it a day,” Cyrus says quietly, from the back seat. “You could have taken the money, held it, and given it back after the Friday hearing. It wouldn’t have been dishonest.”

“It would have been a story.”

“A story?”

“The kind that gets told about you afterward, by people who weren’t there. ‘She took the money, but she meant to give it back.’ It’s very easy to believe that about yourself.” I rub my face. “Orrin took money for Wren. I don’t judge him for it. But he’s spent two years being told that was what it cost. I wasn’t going to find out what my price was in a parking garage.”

“I wouldn’t have thought less of you.”

“I would have.”

He’s quiet. Then he says, with a note of wonder, in his thin, stubborn, bespectacled voice, “My mother always said that a person is whatever they do when no one will ever know.”

“Smart woman.”

“She’d have liked you.” He sniffs. “She’d have thought you were far too loud.”

My phone buzzes once against my knee, a different sort of buzz, short and dry. A text from a number I don’t know, with no greeting at all.

*Seven o’clock. Infusion started. She is asleep with the dog. D. says thank you. I say it as well, which costs me. The butterscotch is not a bribe. -- O.D.*

I read it twice. I show it to Teo, who reads it and says, thickly, that he’s allergic to something in the truck.

And under my ribs, the cord gives a small, warm, answering tug, as though at the end of a long mountain road a man with his palm on a black stone had read the text over my shoulder.

My phone buzzes.

It’s a number I don’t know. A Silver Fork exchange. I answer.

“Counselor.” A woman’s voice, low, flat, unmistakably tired. “It’s Lena Okafor. I’m sorry to call you in the middle of your morning.”

“Deputy. Is everyone all right?”

“Your mother and your friend are fine. They’ve eaten two grilled cheeses.” A pause. “I pulled over a truck on Route 9 about twenty minutes ago for a broken taillight. Corwin Ridge plates. Driver says his name is Cadmus Pruitt.”

I sit up.

“He’s in my back seat,” she says. “He’s very polite. He’s also, I think, very frightened. He asked me whether you were a lawyer, and I said yes, and he said he’d like to speak to one before anyone else.” Her voice drops. “He says he opened the iron door.”

“Did he say why?”

“He says he had a slip. A page from the Alpha’s pad. He says it was handed to him, Monday night, by a woman he’d never expected to see on the Ridge. A human woman, in a good wool coat. He says she asked him very kindly to do something for the late Alpha’s memory.”

I close my eyes. I already know.

“Did he give a name?”

“He said she told him to call her Mrs. W,” says Okafor. “And that she wore a notary’s pin on her lapel.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!