Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 39

Standing

The thing nobody tells you about emergency motions is that they are mostly typing.

I write the petition at Agnes Whitlow’s kitchen table at one in the morning, with a borrowed laptop propped on a stack of seed catalogues and a cup of nettle tea going cold at my elbow. Priya is on speaker from Silver Fork, reading me statutes from the Colorado Revised Statutes in a voice like a tour guide. Agnes sits in her rocking chair with a quilt over her knees and her eyes shut, apparently asleep, correcting my grammar every time I get a comma wrong.

“Beneficiary standing,” says Priya. “Section 15-5-1001. A beneficiary may request the court to enjoin a breach of trust.”

“Good. Quote it.”

“Is it a breach if the trustee just stops paying?”

“It is if the trust instrument says it can’t,” I say, “which I don’t know, because the instrument is the one document in this whole case I’ve never seen.” I type. “So we plead on information and belief. Upon information and belief, the trustee is retaliating against a beneficiary’s guardian for conduct unrelated to the trust.”

“You said that phrase in the truck.”

“It’s the phrase that opens doors.”

Agnes opens one eye. “A comma, child. After ‘beneficiary.’”

“Yes, Keeper.”

At ten past one the hospital pharmacy’s confirmation finally lands in my inbox, held up for hours by my bank’s fraud review, and I put my head on the table.

Forty-one thousand, eight hundred dollars. Thirty-one thousand from the account I called my house fund and ten thousand eight hundred from a credit card I’ve been cursing since law school. I’m now, as of one-ten a.m., the poorest I’ve been in nine years, and I’ve done it for a child I met once, in foxes pajamas, who asked me whether eleven hours was the right amount of time.

“Maren,” says Priya, softly. “Are you crying?”

“No.”

“Because it sounds like...”

“I’m hungry. Describe the next statute.”

---

Daniel Dace arrives at two, in scrubs, with the look of a man who has run four flights of stairs. He’s forty, tall, soft-spoken, with his father’s long face and none of his father’s armor. He reads the petition once, without a word, at the kitchen table. Then he takes the pen I hand him and signs it in three places as guardian.

“My father called,” he says. “He said you paid it.”

“It’s covered.”

“I’ll pay you back.”

“We’ll talk about it after the hearing.”

“No.” He lays down the pen. “We’ll talk about it now. I’m a pharmacy tech. I clear fifty-two thousand a year. I’ll pay you back, and it’ll take me longer than it should, and you’ll never once let me forget it, and that’s fine.” His mouth shakes. “She’s been sick for three years. I’ve never been able to do one thing for her but sit there.”

“Sitting there counts.”

“It doesn’t, though.” He picks up the pen again, as if to check it’s real. “What happens next?”

“At six, I file in Jefferson County. The duty judge sets an emergency hearing, probably nine. Whoever’s on the other side will be given notice by email, and if they’re smart, they’ll ask for a week to respond.” I swallow. “If they’re not, we win in a day.”

“And if they’re smart?”

“Then we find out what they’re hiding.”

He’s a quiet man, but at that he almost smiles.

---

At four, when Daniel has gone and the petition is printed and the laptop is warm as a loaf, Agnes stops rocking.

“Walter Holt,” she says, into the dark.

I look up. She hasn’t opened her eyes.

“You’ve been circling that name for three days,” she says. “Rosalind said it. Augustus’s tape didn’t, but his debt did. You’d rather argue the statutes. It’s easier.”

“It is easier.”

“Tell me about him.”

I don’t want to. I do it anyway, because it’s four in the morning, and the Keeper’s kitchen is the sort of place where things get said.

“He kept books for a feed supplier in Pinecrest,” I say. “He was a quiet man. He wore the same brown cardigan until it was a rumor. He did the crossword in pen and he whistled when he thought nobody was listening.” I smile, at the table, at nothing.

“He drove me to school every morning for eleven years and never once played the radio. He said a car was for thinking. When I got my first speeding ticket, he took it from me, read it, and said, ‘Well. You’ll want to contest the signage.’ I think that’s where it started.”

“The law.”

“Contesting the signage.” My throat tightens. “He had a stroke when I was nineteen, in the spring. It wasn’t long. Mom said it was kinder than the alternative.”

“And before that? Did he ever speak of a river?”

“A river?”

“A flood. A man he pulled out of the water.”

I frown. I search. There’s a pale rope of scar across the heel of his right hand, and a smell of wet canvas, and a camping trip when I was small. I asked about the scar and he said a creek had given it to him, before I was born, when a fellow got himself in trouble and he’d helped him out. My mother laughing. My father not laughing.

“There was a creek,” I say slowly. “I thought it was a fishing story.”

“It wasn’t a story.”

“Agnes, how do you know?”

“Because Augustus told me once, thirty years ago, after a very bad night and three bottles of plum brandy, that there was a man in Colorado he could never pay back.” Her eyes open, round and bright. “I thought he was boasting. A debt he couldn’t pay. I thought, here’s a man with too much money and too little shame. And I was wrong. He meant it as a plain fact.”

“A life debt.”

“The oldest kind we have.” She taps the cane. “It does not expire when the man who earned it dies, Maren. It passes.”

“To me.”

“To the line.”

“I never asked for it.”

“No one asks for the oldest things,” says the Keeper, “they just arrive. Like weather.”

I look at the printed petition on the table, the neat black signature line where Daniel Dace has written his name. I think of my father’s hands, long and clumsy and warm, always a little stained at the heel with ink, because he was left-handed and dragged the side of his palm through everything he wrote. I used to wipe it clean with the hem of my shirt.

“He never told me,” I say. “Fourteen years. He never said a word.”

“A man who saves a life isn’t always the first to speak of it. Sometimes it’s only the other man who can’t forget.”

I nod. There’s nothing else to do.

Then the printer finishes, with a soft electronic sigh, and I go to file.

---

The Jefferson County courthouse in Golden is a squat, sand-colored building with a flag out front and a metal detector at the door, and I’ve been in it nineteen times in my life. I have never once felt as if I was walking into a mine.

It’s twenty to nine. The snow has stopped. Cyrus walks beside me in a borrowed overcoat, silent and ashen, with his hands in his pockets, because Agnes decided, at five a.m., that “matters of human necessity” covers the Colorado judiciary, and Marguerite signed the grant in blue ink at five-fifteen, over Orrin’s furious, whispered, completely helpless objection. Teo is parked three blocks away, in a truck with the engine running and a pair of binoculars that he insists are for birdwatching.

The courtroom is small and beige. Judge Imelda Ferreira has a hearing-room voice like a closing drawer, a bun the color of steel wool, and a reputation, which I looked up at four in the morning, for dismissing any litigant who wastes her time and rewarding any who doesn’t.

I take the table on the left. Daniel sits beside me. I haven’t told him how scared I am; he can see it.

The table on the right is already occupied.

A man in a charcoal suit rises as I enter. He’s fifty, tanned, with a silver watch and the easy courtesy of a man who bills nine hundred an hour. I know the face. I last saw it across a long walnut table at Corwin Tower while he threatened me in a tone so pleasant it could have been an invitation to dinner.

“Ms. Holt,” says Marcus Brandt. “How nice to see you outside the boardroom.”

“Mr. Brandt. I wasn’t aware you represented the trustee.”

“I represent several of Ashgrove’s interests. It’s an honor.” He smiles. “You filed at six this morning, and I’m told I was served at six-oh-two. I was in the building by seven-thirty. It’s remarkable what a good alarm clock will do.”

“You must be a very light sleeper.”

“I’m an early riser.”

I sit. Under the table, my left hand is a fist, and I let it be one.

The petition is called. The judge reads from the bench, the way judges do when they want you to know they’ve read it first. She asks if the trustee has an appearance. Brandt rises and says the trustee has authority, and also, in passing, that he would like to raise one threshold matter.

“The petitioner’s counsel is Maren Holt,” he says. “Ms. Holt is not merely a member of the bar. She is the daughter of a beneficiary of this very trust, Rosalind Holt, whose name appears in the same distribution schedule. She has a direct financial interest. And she is, if the record is accurate, the executor of the late Augustus Corwin’s estate, a connection she did not disclose in the petition.”

It’s a clean, sharp little move, and I admire it, the way you admire a well-made knife an instant before it enters you.

“Ms. Holt,” says the judge.

“Your Honor.” I stand. “My appearance is limited. I’m acting as counsel for Daniel Dace, guardian of an eight-year-old beneficiary. I am not a party to this petition, and I seek no relief on my own account.

“My mother’s status is disclosed in paragraph nine of the verified petition, which I’d ask the Court to read.” I take a breath. “As for the estate, Mr. Brandt is correct. I’m its sole executor. The estate’s interest in the Fund is nil, and I’d welcome the Court’s inquiry into why Mr. Brandt thinks otherwise.”

“I think nothing of the sort,” Brandt says pleasantly. “I only think the Court should know who is drafting its emergency orders.”

“I’ll take it under advisement,” says Judge Ferreira, with a look that makes both of us sit. “Ms. Holt, I’m going to allow the limited appearance. But if I see you pressing your own mother’s interest through this child’s, I’ll strike you, and I’ll refer you. Do we understand each other?”

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Then tell me why I should stop a trustee from managing its trust.”

---

I tell her.

I do it in six minutes, the way I’d been taught: plain, sequenced, dull. A girl with aplastic anemia. An appointment at seven this morning, nearly cancelled by a call the evening before. A guardian father in tears at a pharmacy counter.

A wire that arrived from a private account, not the trustee, because the trustee had withheld its own distribution without notice. A pattern, or the beginnings of one, in which three beneficiaries in three counties had, within the past nineteen days, been contacted by Ashgrove’s office with the same phrase: “under review.”

The last part is Priya’s. She called them at four in the morning, and then again at six. She doesn’t sleep, I’ve decided. She runs on spreadsheets and spite.

Brandt answers in two.

“The Court may be surprised to learn that the trustee has no objection to a continuation of the distribution,” he says. “On the contrary. It never intended to suspend it. A clerical error occurred in the payment queue. It has been corrected. Ms. Holt’s client has already been paid, by the Fund, this morning.” He lifts a hand. “Nothing to enjoin.”

“Paid by the Fund?” I say. “That’s not what the pharmacist told me.”

“Ms. Holt.”

“The wire was mine. It was drawn from my personal account at eight-fifty last night. I have the confirmation. I’d offer it as Exhibit B.”

“Miss Holt,” says the judge. “Mr. Brandt. Sit.”

I hand up a single sheet. She reads it. She looks at Brandt, a long dry look over her reading glasses.

“Mr. Brandt,” she says, “your client has told the petitioner’s guardian that a payment was pending. Your client’s records show a payment was queued, and then recalled at two-twelve in the morning by a user with administrative access. Is that what you call a clerical error?”

“It is a possible reading.”

“It is also a reading I can’t accept on this record.” She straightens a paper. “I am issuing a temporary restraining order, effective immediately. The trustee is enjoined from reducing, suspending, delaying or conditioning any distribution to any beneficiary of the Winterlight Fund until further order. The trustee will produce, to this Court, for in camera review, the complete trust instrument and any amendment, with settlor identification, by nine o’clock Friday morning.”

“Your Honor, the instrument is confidential...”

“That’s why I said in camera.”

“The settlor has the right...”

“Mr. Brandt,” says the judge, “I’m aware of the settlor’s rights. If the settlor wishes to be heard, he or she may come and be heard on Friday.” She closes the folder. “Next matter.”

I let myself breathe. It’s a long breath, and it hurts.

Beside me, Daniel is crying silently, with one hand over his mouth. I put my hand on his shoulder. We stand. We gather our papers. I hold the door for Cyrus, who is staring at the bench with something like reverence.

“That,” he says faintly, “was the most terrifying and beautiful thing I have ever seen.”

“It’s a TRO,” I say. “It’s temporary.”

“It’s a leash,” says Cyrus. “You said it yourself.”

I’m smiling. I’m actually smiling, for the first time in a day and a half, when a hand touches my sleeve.

“Ms. Holt.” Marcus Brandt, in the aisle, soft-footed. “A professional courtesy. You’ve been so generous with the Court’s time that I think I owe you the same. Friday is a long way off.”

“It’s two days.”

“It’s an eternity, if one has a document to read.” He draws a folded paper from his breast pocket. It’s cream stock, heavy, with a gold embossed seal at the top. “I wouldn’t have thought to bring this today. But the judge has been so insistent on the settlor’s rights that I feel I ought to put my clients on the record.”

He holds it out.

I don’t want to take it. I take it.

It’s one page. A notarized instrument, dated the day before yesterday. At the top, in heavy type: NOTICE OF REVOCATION OF THE WINTERLIGHT CHARITABLE TRUST. Beneath it, the language I know too well, formal and fluent, the voice of a lawyer who has drafted a thousand of them.

The settlor reserves the power to revoke, it says, under Article Nine.

The settlor hereby exercises it.

All assets revert.

At the bottom, over the printed line where, for two years, the settlor’s name has been a long white absence in every copy of the Fund I’ve ever seen, there’s a signature in blue ink. A rounded, upright hand, with a little curl on the tail of the J, and a heavy underline, like a man pressing his thumb into the page.

Walter J. Holt.

My father’s signature.

My father, who died fourteen years ago, in a hospital bed, with my hand in his.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!