Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 38

Butterscotch

Orrin Dace lives at the bottom of a dirt lane on the east side of the Ridge, in a house so plain that it looks like a drawing of a house.

One story. Gray siding. A porch with two chairs, one of them with a blanket folded over the arm. A woodpile stacked to the eaves in dead straight rows, and a truck in the drive that has more rust than paint. There’s a light in the kitchen window, yellow and small. Smoke goes straight up out of the chimney into the dark, because tonight there’s no wind at all.

“Last time I was here,” Teo says, killing the engine, “I was seventeen and I’d dropped a cord of firewood on his dog.”

“Is the dog alive?”

“The dog was fine. The dog was a hero. He bit me.” He stares at the porch. “Maren. If this goes wrong, I’m the one who knocks. You stay behind me.”

“If this goes wrong, you’re the one who gets bitten.”

“I’m aware. I’d just like to go on record that I’m doing this for love.”

“Of whom?”

“Of the pack. Mostly. And your mom’s casserole, which I haven’t had yet but have heard great things about.”

I laugh, which I badly need. Then we get out into the cold.

Teo knocks. Three raps, polite, with the flat of his knuckles.

Footsteps. A latch. The door opens six inches on a chain, and a sliver of Orrin Dace looks out at us: one gray eye, a bar of white mustache, the shoulder of a cardigan so old that the elbow has been darned in a different color.

“Teodoro,” says Orrin.

“Elder.”

“I’d say it’s late, but I know that’s no use.” The eye moves to me. It doesn’t soften, but it doesn’t harden either. “Ms. Holt. I had a call from the Keeper an hour ago, telling me you’d be coming. She didn’t say why.”

“Mr. Dace. I’d like to talk to you. Not as a Witness. Not as a lawyer, either.” I take a breath. “I’d like to sit at your table for ten minutes and ask a question, and I’ll go if you say go.”

“It’s a question about the dead man’s pad.”

I don’t blink.

“Agnes told you.”

“Agnes told no one anything. Agnes would never. I’m seventy years old, Ms. Holt. I can smell graphite from forty feet.” The chain rattles. The door swings wide. “Wipe your boots.”

---

The kitchen is clean in the way of a man who has lived alone for a long time and refuses to be seen doing it badly.

A table with an oilcloth. Two chairs. A kettle on a back burner, which he moves. A refrigerator whose door is papered with drawings in crayon: a purple dog, a house with a smiling sun, a family of stick figures labeled, in a stiff, careful, eight-year-old hand, GRANDPA, ME, DADDY, and, with a heart over her head, MOMMY IN HEAVEN.

I look at the drawings a half second too long.

Orrin sets down a mug in front of me without being asked. It smells of chamomile and something more medicinal. He puts one in front of Teo too. Then he sits, heavily, with the black cane across his knees, and looks at me over the rim of his own cup.

“Ask,” he says.

“The Winterlight Fund pays six thousand four hundred dollars a month to an O. Dace in Jefferson County.”

“Yes.”

He says it so quickly that I’m halfway through my next sentence before I realize he’s answered the first.

“It does,” Orrin says again. “To me. Not for me.” He sets down his mug. “It’s paid by wire on the first of every month, to a hospital in Denver. The Children’s. It’s been paid for twenty-six months.”

“Children’s.”

“My granddaughter.” He nods at the refrigerator. “Wren. Eight years old. Hers is a rare thing in the blood, an aplastic something, and when it flares, the treatment costs more than this house. My son’s wife died of it. Her side of the family. A human line.” The word is flat, like a stone laid on a table.

“We thought it would skip Wren. It didn’t. My son took a third job. We sold the cabin. And then a man from Salt Lake City sat where you’re sitting, in this very chair, and told me that a certain private fund would cover Wren’s treatment in full. For as long as it was needed. No conditions.”

“No conditions,” I say.

“None. That was what he said.” His mouth moves, bitterly, under the mustache. “I’m a man who’s lived seventy years and sat on a Court for forty. I know what ‘no conditions’ costs. I took it anyway.”

“Who was the man?”

“He gave me no name. He wore a good coat.” Orrin’s eyes are cold. “Camel.”

Teo makes a tiny noise, like a cut thread.

“Royce Varnell came to you, two years ago,” I say.

“Royce Varnell came to my door, and he told me that Ashgrove’s generosity to a grieving Elder was no business of the Moon Court. He said the Fund was founded by an anonymous friend of the pack who valued discretion. I believed him.” He folds his big spotted hands. “It was only after Augustus died, and the rumors started, that I understood whose money it was. Not the Fund’s. Augustus’s.”

“You knew?”

“I guessed.” He says it simply. “A man like Augustus Corwin doesn’t have friends who give money to a grandchild he’d never met. But he had a conscience, and it was a very large and very troublesome one, and he’d been repaying a debt his whole life to someone. I thought it was me. I thought it was my forty years.” A crack in the stern voice. “I thought he was grateful.”

“And Varnell?”

“Varnell is the trustee.” He picks up his cup, sets it down. “Ashgrove Fiduciary Services administers the Fund. Augustus set it up. A year after Esparza, I think, through his lawyer. Gerhard. He couldn’t have known the lawyer was his own brother’s creature, and I couldn’t have known that the man who signed the checks would call me, the week after the Alpha’s funeral, and say, very politely, that the Fund would be reviewing its distributions.”

I put my hands around the mug. They’re cold.

“He threatened Wren.”

“He didn’t threaten,” says Orrin. “Royce Varnell has never threatened anyone. He said, ‘I’d hate for the generosity to lapse.’ He said it three times.” He looks at me. “Then he asked me, as a favor, to look closely at the Witness. At her conflicts. At her standing under the Law. And whether a Witness who had been bound to an Alpha might be said to have forfeited the neutrality the office requires.”

“So you moved the hearing.”

“I moved it because the people who held my granddaughter’s treatment in their hands asked me to.” His voice doesn’t waver. “I did it with my eyes open. I did not tell myself it was the Law. I told myself it was Wren. And then, this morning, the Keeper stood up in the snow and said, Sit down, Orrin, and I sat, and God help me, I was almost glad.”

Silence.

“I didn’t open the cells,” he says. “Before you ask. I’ve never held a Court key at night in my life. I would not free a man who killed my Alpha for any amount of money. If you think I did that, you may arrest me tonight.”

“I don’t think you did.”

“Why not?”

“Because you’d have been smarter about it.” I try a half smile. “And because if you were guilty, you wouldn’t have told me about Wren.”

Orrin looks at me for a very long time.

“You’re very like him,” he says at last.

“Who?”

“Augustus. The same kind of mouth.” His own twitches. “It’s no compliment.”

---

I ask him the rest, because I have to.

Who delivered the first payment. Who is his contact at Ashgrove Fiduciary. Whether he’s ever seen the trust documents, or the signature on the foundation page. He answers each question curtly. A woman named Delphine calls from Salt Lake on the first of the month, to confirm that the hospital has received it. He has the number written on the inside of a kitchen cupboard. He’s never seen the settlor’s name. Gerhard Vail would have kept the original, in a trust file nobody was permitted to open.

“One more thing first. The study. You said the Wardens inspected it on the second day, with you present. Who held the door?”

He thinks. It costs him; I watch him go back through the days.

“Pruitt. Cadmus Pruitt, the captain. He carried the lamp, because the power was off in that wing. He stood at the desk while I looked through the shelves.” His brow lowers. “He stood very close to the desk. I thought it was nerves. A man stands close to the dead man’s things when he served him thirty years.”

“Did he know about the pad?”

“Everyone knew about the pad. Augustus was proud of it.” He grunts. “The pad is how Pruitt got his captaincy. Augustus handed him the first slip himself, the night the north fence came down, and said that a Warden who could not be trusted with a slip could not be trusted with a gate.”

“Pruitt swore he saw me cross the footbridge at six-fifty, the morning Celeste was poisoned. That was a lie.”

“I know. I was there when he swore it.” Orrin’s eyes go dark. “I’ve asked myself why I believed him. I think because the lie was convenient, and I was tired. It’s an odd thing about age. You don’t stop being a fool. You only get better at being a fool in good order.”

“Where is Pruitt now?”

“On the roster for the north gate.” He frowns. “No. That’s wrong. He was relieved at dawn. He said he was sick. His wife told the kitchen he’d gone to the clinic in Silver Fork.”

Teo has gone still beside me.

“Silver Fork,” he says. “That’s where Priya is. And Rosalind.”

“It’s a town of nine hundred people,” I say, as steadily as I can. “It has one clinic and one diner and Okafor’s station. He’s not going to walk into the station.”

“No,” says Teo. “But he doesn’t have to. Not if he’s meeting someone.”

I take out my phone and send Priya a text, three words, no punctuation. Lock the door. She replies with a single thumbs up, and a second later, a cat emoji, which I choose to find reassuring.

“Orrin,” I say. “I have to ask you something, and I want you to hear it as a question and not an accusation.”

“Go on.”

“When the Court votes tomorrow, on whether the Witness stays. How will you vote?”

His silence is its own answer, and he knows it. His jaw works.

“I don’t know,” he says at last.

“They’ll cut Wren off.”

“They’ll cut Wren off,” he agrees, “on the first. Which is in nine days. I’ve been counting.”

“Then I have a proposal.”

“I thought you might.”

“The Fund’s beneficiaries have rights. Every one of them. Under Colorado trust law, a beneficiary has standing to demand an accounting from a trustee, and to enjoin a trustee who is administering a trust in bad faith. Wren is a beneficiary of record. Her guardian is her father.

“If he signs a petition, I can file it tomorrow morning in Jefferson County district court, with an emergency motion to freeze any change to distributions.” I lean forward. “It won’t make Royce Varnell stop being who he is. But it makes him a defendant. A court order is a different kind of leash.”

“And in return?”

“I don’t want your vote.” I say it before I’ve fully thought it through. “If you vote for me because I’m saving your granddaughter, you’ll hate me by spring, and you’ll be right. I want you to vote the way the Law tells you. Whatever you read in it.”

He stares.

“That’s either the most honest thing anyone’s said in my kitchen in twenty years,” Orrin says, “or the cleverest.”

“I’m a lawyer. It’s often both.”

Teo coughs into his sleeve, a sound suspiciously like a laugh.

Orrin’s hand moves toward the refrigerator, toward the stick figure with the heart above her head, and stops. He pulls it back. He looks, for the first time since I’ve known him, his age.

“My son’s on shift until midnight,” he says. “At the hospital. He works nights in the pharmacy. I’ll have him call you in the morning.”

“That’s too late,” says a thin, small voice.

We all turn.

A girl is standing in the kitchen doorway. She’s eight, with a bob of fine brown hair and a hospital bracelet on one wrist and pajamas printed with cartoon foxes. She’s holding a stuffed dog under one arm. Her cheeks are the color of paper.

“Wren,” says Orrin. His voice goes hoarse. “Sweetheart. You should be in bed.”

“The lady on the phone called,” she says. “The nice one. She said I shouldn’t worry.” She looks at the three of us with immense, serious eyes. “She said my appointment tomorrow was fine. And then she called back again, after dinner, and said it wasn’t.”

Orrin goes very still.

“What did she say?”

“She said there was a problem with the payment.” Wren hugs the dog. “She said it was probably nothing. She said the medicine might have to wait.”

The clock on the wall ticks.

“When is the appointment?” I ask, gently.

“Seven,” says Wren. “In the morning.” She frowns, as if the arithmetic worries her. “That’s in eleven hours, isn’t it?”

Orrin Dace puts his face in his hands.

Teo is already on his feet. I hear his chair scrape. I see him go to the child and kneel, and say something I can’t hear, something low and warm that makes her giggle weakly. But I’m looking at the old man across the oilcloth, and the dark steps of a long cold plan I’m only beginning to see.

Royce Varnell didn’t need to wait for the vote. He didn’t even need to wait for the first of the month.

He just needed us to see how fast he could do it.

---

We don’t stay.

Orrin walks us to the porch and stands there under the yellow light with his cane planted and his granddaughter’s hand in his, her small face turned up to the stars. He doesn’t say thank you. He says, “Whatever you do, do it by seven,” and goes inside.

In the truck, with the heater roaring and the dark pressing at the windshield, I do what I should have done two minutes ago and call the number on the hospital’s website. A recording tells me the billing office is closed. A second recording tells me to press three for the pharmacy.

A pharmacist named Gordon, with a voice like warm toast, listens to my explanation, tells me three times that he cannot discuss a patient, and then, in a lower tone, says that if a payment were to arrive before six a.m. in a certain amount, it would clear whatever hold had been placed.

“What amount?” I ask.

He tells me.

It’s forty-one thousand, eight hundred dollars. A quarter’s worth of treatment, paid in advance, because the Fund’s wire is what usually covers it.

I stare at the dashboard.

“Maren,” says Teo.

“I have it.”

“You don’t.”

“I have a savings account I’ve been calling my house fund since I was twenty-six.” I’m already opening the banking app, with a thumb that doesn’t feel like mine. “It has thirty-one thousand. There’s a credit line against my firm bonus, which I’m not getting, so that’s moot. There’s a card with a limit of twelve.”

“That’s your whole...”

“I know what it is.”

“It’s your student loan payment. It’s your mother’s...”

“My mother’s room is paid by a man who’s dead.” I swallow. “I’ll sort it out. A child gets her medicine at seven o’clock tomorrow. That’s not a negotiation.”

Teo says nothing. He puts the truck in gear. Then, very quietly, as the lane unspools in the headlights, he says, “If you’re going to be reckless, you could at least let me chip in.”

“How much have you got?”

“Four hundred dollars and a jar of change.”

“Keep the jar,” I say, and hit Send.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!