Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 70

The Seventh Chair

I do not drink the tea. I would like that entered somewhere, in case there is ever a record of my judgment on the second-worst night of my life.

I stand at the shutter for what feels like a quarter of an hour with the cup steaming a foot from my face and the lemon turning slowly in its saucer, and I think: it’s hot. Whoever left it was here a minute ago, or less. The snow of the courtyard is a clean blue page and nothing has walked across it. The only thing moving in the whole yard is the thread of the waterfall, a long way off.

Then I take the pad from my pocket and write four words, and go and wake Cyrus Hale.

*CUP ON MY SILL. NOW.*

---

He is out of his room in nine seconds. It is the fastest I have ever seen him move. He has a quilt around his shoulders and one sock on and a flashlight in his hand that he forgets to turn on, and he stands at my window with Livia and Priya crowded behind him, and nobody says anything for a long time.

“Don’t touch it,” says Priya, who is holding her phone in both hands like a candle. “Photographs first. Then a jar.”

“A jar,” says Cyrus.

“A jar with a lid, from the kitchen. I want to hand it to Dr. Reyes with a chain of custody that would make a judge cry.” She starts taking pictures. “Is it a Ridge cup?”

Cyrus bends. He doesn’t lift it. He turns his head sideways and reads the foot of it by the light of her screen, and his shoulders go slowly down.

“It’s Augustus’s,” he says. “It’s the one he drank from on Thursdays. White, with the blue band. The Hall’s good china was made in a little pottery in Silver Fork for the old Alpha’s grandfather, and the foot is stamped with a wolf, *C.R. 1931.*” He straightens. “It’s hung on a brass hook in the Hall pantry since the day he died. Mrs. Bellamy won’t let anybody wash it. I have watched her dust it.”

“Then it’s not on the hook,” says Livia.

“I would stake my life that it’s not on the hook.”

I take out the satellite phone and put it into Priya’s hand. She calls Teo at the cairn. She says, “Is Mrs. Bellamy awake? Wake her. Ask her to go to the pantry. She’ll know what we mean.” It takes eleven minutes.

At the end of it, Teo’s voice comes thin out of the little speaker, flat and careful, saying that the hook is bare, that Mrs. Bellamy has gone very quiet, and that she says it was on the hook at noon yesterday, when she dusted it, and that she did not look again.

“Noon,” says Priya. “Yesterday. That’s two hours after we left.”

“That’s two hours after we left,” says Teo. “Somebody on the Ridge took it between noon and midnight, passed it to a car, and the car drove it to Utah.” A pause. “It’s fourteen hours. A hard drive, but it can be done.”

“Or it didn’t have to be driven by a Ridge man at all,” says Livia. “The Hall china isn’t the only set. My grandfather ordered a second service in nineteen eighty, for guests. It’s in the Falls pantry. It has the same wolf.” She presses her lips together. “But the cup on the sill has a chip on the handle. Look. At the join. It’s the cup. It’s *that* cup.”

Nobody asks who on the Ridge would hand it to a stranger. Nobody has to. We are all thinking about a call that was made from the Alder on Sunday night.

“And the footprints?” says Cyrus.

“The gallery.”

“The what?”

“There’s a flume gallery under the courtyard.” Livia pushes her hair off her forehead with a hand that isn’t entirely steady.

“From the old powerhouse at the base of the falls. It’s stone, about four feet wide, and it comes up under the kitchen. The children are forbidden it. I was in it when I was nine. It lets out in the wall of the east wing, at the foot of this window, under a hinged board. He’d need to kneel. He’d come up in the dark and put the cup on the sill and go down again.”

She swallows. “Nobody would see a track. The gallery floor is stone.”

It isn’t a comfort. It is an explanation, and a worse thing than a mystery. A mystery you can fear. An explanation you have to *deal with.*

*HE WANTED ME TO KNOW HE CAN REACH ME,* I write.

“And that he knows the house better than you do,” says Cyrus, grimly. “And that he has a very particular sense of humor.”

*NO,* I write. I look at the cup, at the lemon. *IT’S NOT A JOKE. IT’S AN INVITATION.*

---

I don’t sleep again.

At seven Dr. Reyes calls and I say “Chutney,” and she says “Pulse?” and Priya reads it off the little cuff, thirty-three, and Reyes says something under her breath that is not a word anyone should say to a patient.

She wants to know about the Stone. I tell her it has taken the feeling out of my right palm to the wrist. She says that’s the price, and I say I know, and she says do you? and I say, Mrs. Cobb is bringing toast.

“Eat the toast,” says Reyes. “I am being very restrained. I’d like that noticed.”

Priya has put the cup in a pickle jar. I watch her seal it with a piece of tape and write the time across it in marker, and sign her name, and pass it to Cyrus to sign under hers. He does it in a slow, careful, antique hand.

“A witness’s witness,” he says.

“I’m a paralegal,” says Priya. “It’s my entire personality.”

---

The bailiff is a tall, bored, polite man named Mr. Tennyson who arrives at eight in a county car with a case of camera equipment, a clipboard, and a thermos, and looks around the great hall of Ashgrove Falls as though it were a very ordinary room that he’d been told was haunted.

He is not alone. Colin Strand has come in behind him with the leather folder under his arm and a key on a silver ring, and has taken up a position by the study door with the pleasant, unreadable face of a man holding a hostage’s coat.

Two Ashgrove Wardens stand against the wall, in dark coats, with their hands folded. And at the end of the corridor, very straight in a gray dress, stands Livia, with Cyrus on one side and me on the other, and Priya two paces behind with a laptop and a lens.

“Special Administrator,” says Mr. Tennyson. “I’m going to ask you to break the seal on the record, if you please.”

Livia steps forward. The seal is a paper strip across the lock, signed and numbered, with the court’s stamp. She slides a thumbnail under it and lifts, and the paper comes away in one piece, as if it had never been stuck, and the bailiff photographs it, and Strand hands over his key without a flicker.

The door opens with a long soft sigh.

I have been in a great many studies, in a great many wills. I know the smell of the room where a man has spent his life: leather, pipe, damp paper, a flavor of decades. This one is all of those. But under them is another smell, quite distinct, and I stop on the threshold and put my hand on the doorframe.

Cherry tobacco.

Not strong. Hardly there. A sweetness in the cold air, faded and old, the way the smell of a pie is old in a house where nobody has baked in a year. I turn my head and find Priya looking at me. She’s smelled it too. She hasn’t Bram’s nose. She is only a woman who reads.

*SOMEONE’S BEEN IN HERE,* I write.

“Of course,” says Strand, from behind us. “The household has the run of the room. The housekeeper dusts.”

“Mrs. Cobb doesn’t smoke a pipe,” says Livia, without turning round.

---

It is a long, gray, pleasant room, with two windows facing the yard and a shelf of ledgers behind a desk the size of a door. There is a leather chair, scarred and shapeless. There is a green banker’s lamp. And under the window on the left, set low into the wall, is a long, shallow drawer of dark wood, with a brass pull in the shape of a fish.

“That’s it,” says Livia, in a voice I’ve never heard her use. “The Kodak box is in there. He called it his *drawer of other people’s mail.*”

Mr. Tennyson sets up his tripod. He photographs the room from four corners, and the drawer from two, and he writes the time down: eight-fourteen. He gestures at it with his pencil. “Open it, please. Ms. Varnell. And speak aloud what you see. I’ll be recording.”

Livia kneels. She has to use both hands on the pull. The drawer comes out slowly, with a long hollow rumble of wooden runners, and the whole room waits.

There is a box.

It’s a yellow cardboard Kodak carton, an old film-processing box, soft with age, the corners rubbed to felt. It sits in the exact middle of the drawer, on a bed of green baize, and nothing else is there. No dust. No second thing. The baize has been brushed.

“A cardboard box,” says Livia, to the recorder. “Yellow. Approximately ten by seven inches. Unsealed.” She lifts the lid. “It contains envelopes. I count nine. Cream stock, number ten. Each addressed to *A.V.* in a single hand, in blue ink. Each bears a postmark. The first is dated fourteen April, nineteen ninety. The last is dated twelve October, nineteen ninety-three.” She takes a breath. “There is a tenth item.”

“Describe.”

“A larger envelope. Brown manila. It is under the nine, on the bottom, flat. It’s sealed with red wax.” She turns it over. Her voice goes very small. “The wax has a mark in it. A wolf’s head, in profile. The left ear is notched.”

I have stopped breathing. I don’t remember doing it. It’s an old, bad habit.

“It’s addressed,” says Livia. “On the front. In the same hand, blue ink.” She reads it out loud in a clear flat voice, as one reads a sentence that one is not quite able to accept. “*To the Witness of Corwin Ridge. To be opened by her, and by no other, at the Council. If there is no Witness, to be burned.*”

---

Nobody moves.

Strand moves first, and he is very smooth about it. “Special Administrator, with the greatest respect, that is not an item of inventory. It is a letter to a third party, which I take to be the property of the estate until the court rules otherwise.”

“It’s addressed to Ms. Holt,” says Livia.

“It is addressed to *the Witness of Corwin Ridge,* which, as you know, in nineteen ninety-three was a different person. Ms. Holt was not sworn into the office until a few weeks ago.”

“Then the court can tell us whether the office or the woman inherits its mail.” She sets the manila envelope on the desk, face up, under the lamp. “Mr. Tennyson, please photograph it. Both sides. And the wax. And the box.”

“I’ll be happy to,” says Mr. Tennyson, who is clearly enjoying himself more than he has in years.

“And Ms. Holt will not take it,” says Strand, still smoothly, “until Judge Ridley has been heard.”

I tap Priya’s arm. She reads the pad aloud. “Ms. Holt agrees. She’d like it recorded that she hasn’t touched it.”

“Recorded,” says Mr. Tennyson, and writes.

There is a flash of satisfaction in watching the wax photographed, with its notched wolf, and the careful blue ink of the address. The man who wrote it knew a bailiff would see it. He knew a court would. He has been drawing this wolf for thirty-six years and has never, I think, drawn it without an audience in mind.

“The nine,” says Livia. “I’m going to inventory the nine. I’m going to read the first lines of each into the record, and no more. Mr. Strand, if you wish to object, do it now.”

“I object to everything,” says Strand, “on a standing basis.”

“Fine.”

She lays them out on the desk in a row, in order of date, like a hand of cards.

---

*14 April, 1990.* “*A.V., It is done as far as the water goes. The Holt man spoiled the rest. The woman had a camera. G. has it and says he’ll hold his tongue for his master’s sake. I have seen his face since and I do not like it. He knew me. He looked up at the bluff and he knew me.*”

I write. My hand is trembling. *KNEW ME.*

“*Knew me.*” Livia lifts the next. “*2 August, 1990. A.V., The old Alpha has taken to calling me into the study. He speaks of his son as a stone he can’t lift. I’ve said nothing. I’ve poured the tea. It’s the one thing I do well.*”

Cyrus makes a sound. Livia keeps reading. She has gone very pale, but her voice does not waver.

“*11 December, 1990. A.V., Augustus has asked for my opinion of the Holt matter. He says there’s a Fund. I said I’d heard nothing. He looked at me a long time. He said, ‘You’d tell me, Eddie, if you had.’*”

I stop. The pad is on my knee. My pencil is on the paper and I haven’t moved it.

“Eddie,” says Priya, very quietly.

“A diminutive,” says Strand. “Of any number of names. Edward. Edgar. Edmund. I’d be careful, Miss Varnell, about building a case on a nickname in a letter of dubious provenance.”

“I’m not building a case, Mr. Strand. I’m inventorying.” Livia takes up the fourth.

---

By the ninth, the room has changed. It is the same room, the gray light, the lamp, the desk with its row of cream envelopes. But it has gone very small. Nobody stands near the window. Mr. Tennyson has put down his pencil.

“*12 October, 1993. A.V., It’s settled. Gus takes the seat at midnight. He has paid me what he promised, and given me the one thing I asked for, and I’ll leave the Ridge by the road in the morning. I am to have a pension in perpetuity and my life.*” Livia’s voice drops.

“*I asked him for one thing more and he said he would think. I do not expect an answer. He’s never made me one. But if he ever does, tell me, and tell me whether he says it with his mouth or with his hands. It matters to me. I have taken forty thousand dollars of your family’s money and I mean to give back every cent, the day I’m let.*” She stops. “There’s no name. It’s signed with the wolf.”

She lays it down. In the silence the waterfall can be heard, the long white sound, three hundred feet away, like a held note.

“He’s *promised* to give it back,” says Cyrus, softly. “Forty thousand dollars. Thirty-three years later.”

“A man who still thinks he has a line to pay,” says Livia, to nobody. “And a question he wants put to him.”

*WHAT QUESTION?* I write.

“I don’t know.” She looks at the manila envelope. “I think it’s in there.”

---

At eleven-forty, in the great hall of the Falls, I take my place at the left hand of a chair that does not have a man in it.

My seat is the one Ansel told Mrs. Cobb to give me. It is a high chair of black oak, carried down from his study and set at the left of the empty seventh, with a carved wolf on the back and a cushion worn thin as silk. There are seven chairs in an arc around a table of pale stone. Four are filled. Two wear black crepe, and the seventh stands empty.

I’ve been introduced to the four in a rush, in the doorway, by a very old woman in a velvet cap who hadn’t been told whether to shake my hand or bow to it: a gaunt Marshal named Eamon Strick, a Mrs. Odette Marsh who runs the Falls’ accounts, a Councillor Dunstan with a face like a fist, and a fourth whose name has already gone.

They all look at me with the same expression, composed of courtesy and calculation, like men at an auction who have seen the lot before.

Livia stands at the foot of the table, in the gray dress, with the manila envelope held against her chest and a copy of Judge Ridley’s order folded in her hand. She has declined a chair. Cyrus has taken the visitor’s bench, with Priya at his side and the laptop open on her knee. I can feel the Stone’s splinter on my collarbone, so cold it has stopped being cold and become a kind of burning.

My pulse is thirty-two. I count it against the old clock over the door.

The Marshal rises. He is a long dry man in his sixties with a face the color of paper and a voice like a hinge. “The Council of Ashgrove Falls is in session,” he says. “I call the roll.”

He calls it. Chair One, the Chair, vacant by the death of Ansel Varnell, and a murmur goes round the walls. Chair Two, vacant by the disappearance of Royce Varnell. Chair Three, present. Four, present. Five. Six. And I hear them answer, one by one, in tight steady voices, and I hear Strand at the back of the hall, standing with his folder, say nothing at all.

“Chair Seven,” says the Marshal. “The Rowe chair. By written proxy of the holder, represented by Mr. Colin Strand of Pellam and Rowe.” He pauses. His eyes go to the paper in his hand. They stop. They read it again.

“I have a note,” says the Marshal. “Delivered by hand at eleven this morning. It amends the proxy. It says that the holder of the Rowe interest will, for the first time in thirty-two years, exercise the seat in person.” He looks up. “It says the holder is at the door.”

I do not turn. I’m the one person in the room who has been told not to.

On the stone behind me, very slowly, I hear a cane begin to tap.

It comes up the long hall from the doors. It is unhurried. It is old, and it is steady, and it is perfectly in time with a thing I know. It is the cadence of a hymn. I don’t have to look to count the notes.

I can feel the Stone burning at my throat, and the cherry sweetness comes up the aisle on the warm air like a hand laid on the back of my neck, and the tapping stops, six feet behind my chair.

The double doors, which I have not heard open, swing quietly shut.

“Madam Witness,” says a low, pleasant voice that I have never in my life heard before, and have been listening for since Monday. “I’m so glad you came. I see you’ve kept my chair its left hand. May I? It’s been a very long walk.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!