He does not wait for me to answer. I think that is the first thing I learn about Edwin Garrity: he asks a question the way other men set down a coat, and expects someone to take it.
I turn in the black oak chair. It takes some doing. My neck has been frozen at an angle for an hour, and the Stone’s splinter pulls at the cord like a fish on a line. By the time I have the whole of him in view he is already lowering himself into the seventh chair, one hand on a blackthorn cane and the other on the carved arm, and the arc of the table goes quiet around him.
He is gaunter than his voice. A man in his early sixties who looks a decade older, tall once, spare and upright still, in a brown tweed jacket that someone has pressed with great care. White hair cut short. A face weathered to the grain of a good plank, with pale eyes set deep under a heavy brow, and a mouth that looks as though it has been kept shut for a long time out of habit and has only just remembered what else it is for.
His left hand wears a glove. Black kid leather, thin, with the fingers a little stiff. The right is bare and brown and perfectly steady on the cane.
“Madam Witness,” he says again, more softly. “Forgive the cane. I’d have run the length of the hall if I could.”
*YOU’RE EDDIE,* I write, and tilt the pad toward him so the whole table can read it.
He reads it. He lets out a long breath through his nose, and for a moment the pale eyes shut.
“I’ve been called a good many things,” says Edwin Garrity, “but I’d forgotten that one. Nobody has said it to me since a man with a very bad temper said it on a stair in nineteen ninety-three. Yes. It was Eddie, in that house. It was Edwin everywhere else.” He opens his eyes. “I wore the number eleven on a whistle for eight years, on the Ridge and at the Falls. If you want to give me a title, that’s the only one I ever earned.”
---
The Marshal clears his throat like a man dragging a gate across gravel.
“Mr. Garrity,” he says. “You are the holder of the Rowe interest?”
“I am. By assignment of the late Elias Rowe’s estate, through his daughter, who was my wife.” He says it plainly, and does not look at anyone. “Nell died in two thousand eleven. She left me the chair and a great deal of silence about it. I have not sat in it for thirty-two years.”
“I have voted by written proxy, and I’m told the proxy was exercised well, for which I thank Mr. Strand.” He does not look at Strand either. “I’m told it was also exercised a few days ago for a petition that I did not read. For that, I’ll come to it.”
At the back of the hall, Colin Strand has gone very still. It is the stillness of a man holding a full glass on a moving train.
“The chair is yours to sit in,” says Mrs. Marsh, from Chair Four, slowly. She is a broad woman with reading glasses on a chain and an accountant’s patience. “I won’t pretend we expected you. In the books, you are *a bearer.* We have never had a face to match.”
“You’ve one now.”
“We have one that is on a letter in a Kodak box, signed with a wolf.” That is Dunstan, in Chair Five, with his fist-faced stare and his big hands flat on the stone. “I’d like to know, Mr. Garrity, before this Council does one more thing, what that wolf is doing on the Witness’s mail.”
The old man turns his head toward him, courteously, the way you turn it toward a dog you’ve decided not to mind.
“Councillor,” he says. “I’d like to tell you. I’d like to tell all of you, once, in the order it happened, and I’d like to do it at the proper hour. But I’ll make you an offer first. It is a rude one, and I know it. I’d rather make it to your faces than to your lawyers.”
---
Nobody tells him to go on. He goes on.
“Eight years of my life,” he says, “I was a Warden. Six of them for the Corwin Ridge Pack, under the old Alpha, and two for the Wardens at the Falls, on loan, as part of a sort of friendship that one Alpha extends to another. I was a boy of twenty-two when I first took the pin, and I was a damned good one. Nobody ever had to say my name to me twice.”
He turns his gloved hand over on his knee, and looks at it.
“In April of nineteen ninety, I was twenty-seven and I was owed a week. I was getting married. I’d told the old Alpha I’d be in Utah from the tenth to the sixteenth, and I’d told the old Alpha’s guest, Ansel Varnell, who was visiting, because Ansel made a point of asking the date and the name of the church. So I was in Utah, at a wedding, on the eleventh of April.”
He lifts his eyes to me.
“I was also on a bluff over the Alder River in Colorado. Both of those are true. That’s what a man learns, in my trade. How to be in the one place by the letter of the thing, and in another by the grace of it.”
Livia has gone the color of milk. I see her hand tighten on the manila envelope.
Cyrus has risen from the visitor’s bench without noticing. I can feel him at my shoulder, a warm wool smell and a kind of held breath. Priya has stopped typing. Her hands rest on the keys, and she is looking at the old man with the expression I have seen on her in the hallway of a courthouse, when the other side’s witness says the thing nobody planned for.
I write on the pad, with my left hand, in letters like a child’s. *HOW LONG DID YOU KNOW I WAS COMING?*
Priya reads it aloud, in a clear careful voice, so that no one at the table has to lean.
“Since the sixth of December, in the evening,” says Garrity. “A man at the Moab post office telephoned a woman who telephoned me. A Witness had been named on the Ridge, a woman, a clerk. A Holt.”
The corner of his mouth moves. “I took a liberty with the name. I thought, a Holt. A Holt put his hands on the Alpha’s shoulders and pulled him out of the water, and a Holt has come to hear what I have to say. I didn’t think I was a man who believed in that sort of thing. I find I am.”
*WALTER WAS MY FATHER,* I write.
“I know.” He says it very gently. “I knew him for eleven days. I’d have liked to have known him longer. He was the one who put his coat over Augustus after. I stood on the bluff, and I watched him do it.”
The Stone’s splinter flares at my collarbone, a cold that is nearly a sound. I put my palm flat over it. Under the cloth it is as numb as a stone in a stream.
“You gave the signal,” I say.
It is a whisper. It costs me. The words come out of my throat like thread out of a cut sleeve, and the table leans, as one body, to hear them.
“Ah,” says Edwin Garrity. “Frame thirty-six.”
---
I have a very short list of things I did not expect to see in a Council chamber, and a man crying is not on it. He does it neatly, without a sound, with the tears running into the creases of his face as into old riverbeds. He doesn’t wipe them. His bare hand stays on the cane.
“Yes,” he says. “I gave it. I had an open palm, at my ear. It meant *now.* We used it on the Ridge to start a hunt, or end one. I gave it because Ansel Varnell had said at breakfast that I’d know when.”
He wets his lips. “And I did. Augustus Corwin looked up at the bluff, and I knew he saw me, and I raised my hand, and Royce Varnell, who was twenty and had a face like a boy at a school play, put both of his own hands on a man’s shoulders and pushed.”
His voice is perfectly even. That is the worst of it.
“I was supposed to have been at a wedding. So I went. I married a good woman in a stone church in Moab on the fourteenth of April, and I wrote a letter that afternoon, and I put it in the post. And I have been married to that afternoon for thirty-six years.”
Nobody speaks. The only sound is the waterfall, and the clock over the door, and my own pulse, which I can hear in my ears as if the room were the inside of a drum.
“I would like,” says Edwin Garrity, “to be tried for it. I’d like it done properly, before the Stone, with the Witness. But I’m told a man like me has a use first. So I’m here to trade.”
---
He sits straighter. The cane stops trembling.
“Here is what I hold. I hold the chair, and with it the seventh vote of this Council. I hold what Ansel Varnell left in the study for the Witness, which is a list. I have not read it. I don’t have to. I know what is on it, because I watched it being kept.”
He rests his bare hand over the glove. “It is the Roster of what Ashgrove calls its friends. Forty-one humans, in Utah and in Colorado. People who saw something, or were in a position to, and were looked after for it.”
“*Bought,*” says Priya, quite clearly, from the bench.
“Bought,” says Garrity, and does not argue. “In the same way Augustus bought his life. A monthly sum. A medical bill. A school fee. A job that came out of the sky. I’ve an idea that Ansel took the notion from the Winter Fund and copied it for the opposite purpose: to keep a window shut, not to open one.”
He looks at me. “The Witness’s late father began a Fund to pay a debt. Ansel made one to pay for a silence. I think there’s a certain honesty in that.”
He lets us take it in.
“My offer is this. I’ll give the Roster to the Witness, openly, here, today, with the Council and the bailiff and the lens in the girl’s lap all looking on. I’ll give her my evidence on the drowning, in my own voice, on the record. And I’ll go with her to the Stone on the Ridge and name myself on line forty-four, and stand it.”
He looks down the arc of the table to the empty chair at its far end. Chair One, in its crepe.
“In return I ask two things. The first is very small. The second is not.”
---
“Small first,” says the Marshal, and his voice is barely a voice.
“The small one is a question. It’s the question I put at the foot of my last letter. It isn’t for the Council. It’s for the Witness alone, and I’ll ask it when she’s ready, and not before. She’ll understand it when she has read what Ansel sealed.”
I feel the table turn toward me. Dunstan’s eyes, Mrs. Marsh’s, the Marshal’s. They are looking at a woman who has not eaten, whose hand is dead to the wrist, who is a month a Witness and a lifetime a clerk of other people’s wills.
“And the large,” says Garrity, and now he turns, very slowly, to the foot of the table, to the girl in the gray dress with an envelope against her chest. “The large is for Miss Varnell.”
Livia’s lips part. No sound.
“This Council has a vacant Chair,” says Edwin Garrity. “The first. For the first time since the founding, there’s no Varnell in it who can sit. I ask the Council to fill it today, by vote, in the usual way. And I will give my seventh vote, and my proxy, and the sworn word of every thing I have told you, to one name.”
He doesn’t say it. He doesn’t have to. Every head has already turned.
“You,” says Dunstan, in a voice like a stone dropped into a well. “You’d put a *girl* of twenty-six, a lawyer, with a drowned father and a dead grandfather, in the seat of Ashgrove Falls.”
“I’d put the one person in the room who ran into the water,” says Garrity, “and shut the sluice.”
---
Strand moves at last. He comes forward down the aisle, folder under his arm, smooth as oil. “Mr. Garrity, with every respect. You are tired. You have been through a great deal of strain, and a man in your position, with his conscience in this state, may be vulnerable to the suggestion of a young person with a motive.”
“Mr. Strand, I am sixty-three, not six.”
“The firm would advise you to take a recess. To consult counsel. Your own counsel.”
“My own counsel,” says Garrity, with great gentleness, “is the firm. Whom, Colin, I have been paying since nineteen ninety-four to tell me that nothing in the world would ever come of this. I believe that I am now asking you to stop.”
Strand’s mouth shuts. I watch it do so. It shuts like a purse.
“The Sunday direction,” says Livia, suddenly. It is the first thing she has said. “The petition that voided the declaration. It was signed with the wolf, in a left hand. It was *yours.*”
“It was a signature I gave in a letter in October,” says Garrity. “It was a standing instruction, in the event of Ansel’s death, to take whatever steps the firm thought wise to protect the estate and the Falls. I put my wolf to it the way a man signs the bottom of a blank check. I didn’t read what it became. That was my fault, and I’ve said so. I will not say that I knew.”
He looks at Strand. “I’ll say the firm knew within the hour that Ansel was dead. I’d like to know who told them.”
The room breathes out. Livia’s eyes go to Strand, and stay there.
“That,” says Garrity quietly, “is a matter for another afternoon.”
---
It is eleven minutes to noon. I have counted. I am thirty-two beats a minute, and I think I may be somewhat out of my mind.
The Marshal puts his palms flat on the stone. “The Council will hear the Witness,” he says. “It is her letter. By the form of the seal, by the writing on it, it is for her alone to open, at a Council, with her seal upon the wax. We are in Council. I ask the Special Administrator to hand her the envelope.”
Livia crosses the floor. It takes her ten steps. She puts the manila envelope in my right hand, which cannot feel it, and closes my fingers around it with both of hers.
“You don’t have to,” she says, under her breath. “Whatever it is.”
*YES I DO,* I write.
“I know,” says Livia. “I’m sorry.”
I take the paper-knife from the table. My left hand does the cutting. It is the hand that has always been the clumsier one, and it works at the red wax with a slowness that makes Strand shift his feet. The notched wolf’s head cracks across its brow. A flake of wax falls on the stone, small and dark as a drop of blood.
Inside is a single folded sheet of cream paper, and under it, a stapled sheaf, typed.
I unfold the single sheet. A line in blue ink, in the careful left hand.
*Madam Witness, I have not the right to ask you for anything. I am therefore asking for everything. E.G.*
And clipped behind it, on the first typed page, in capitals, under a heading that someone has thought about for thirty years, are the words *THE QUIET ROSTER,* and a column of forty-one names, each with a figure, and each with a date.
I run my eye down them, because that’s the one habit I have never lost. A clerk’s eye. Pauline Tuttle, Canyon Rim Credit Union, from ninety-three. A county clerk in Moab. A Gunnison deputy. A pharmacist in Montrose. And at line seventeen, between a hospital billing office and a church secretary, I stop.
*RIDLEY, Ada. $1,800/qtr. Mother’s care, Mesa Verde Manor. 1994. Daughter at law school. See T.*
Tamsin Ridley, Third District Court. The judge who made Livia the Special Administrator. The judge whose order, at that moment, is folded in Livia’s pocket, holding up the whole of the afternoon.
I look up. Garrity is watching me. He has seen my face, and he knows exactly which line I’ve reached.
“Yes,” he says softly. “I thought you’d stop there.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!