Mr. Tennyson makes the copies himself.
It is the best thing that happens to me all day, and I almost miss it. In the thirty minutes of recess, while the great hall is empty and the fire is a heap of orange, I put the Roster into Priya’s hands and she takes it to the bailiff, who is eating a sandwich out of wax paper in the corridor. He looks at the forty-one lines for a long time. Then he puts the sandwich down.
“A true copy of an item in the inventory,” he says. “Certified. Two sets. One for the court, one for the party. I’ll sign each page and stamp it, and note the time, and I’ll write the chain on the first sheet.” He glances at Priya over his reading glasses. “It’s a thing nobody can say later was altered, miss. That’s what I’m for.”
*THANK YOU,* I write. *I’M NOT SURE YOU KNOW WHAT YOU’VE DONE.*
“I’ve done my job, madam,” says Mr. Tennyson, with the air of a man who has done it for twenty-six years and has been waiting for one day when it mattered. “It isn’t often a bailiff gets to be useful.”
It takes him eleven minutes. He sews the pages with a stapler and a strip of red tape. At line seventeen his pencil stops, and moves on. He has seen it. He does not say a word.
---
Priya finds me on the stairs outside the hall, with my back against the cold wall and my numb hand in my lap like something I’ve been asked to look after.
“Line seventeen,” she says.
*I KNOW.*
“We can’t sit on it. She’s the judge who appointed Livia. If we say nothing and it comes out later, every order she’s signed goes under a cloud. And if we say something now, the way we say it matters more than the thing itself.”
*A DISCLOSURE. NOT AN ACCUSATION.*
“To whom?”
I think about it. I think about a daughter at law school in nineteen ninety-four, whose mother’s rent was paid by a man she never met. I think about a woman who may have been given a kindness and never told what it cost. It’s possible. It is, in fact, the likeliest thing. It is the whole shape of the Roster.
*TO HER. IN WRITING. TODAY. WITH A COPY TO THE CHIEF JUDGE OF THE DISTRICT. A LETTER, NOT A MOTION. I’LL SAY: THIS NAME APPEARS, I HAVE NO REASON TO BELIEVE IT IS KNOWN TO YOU, I AM TELLING YOU BEFORE ANYONE ELSE DOES.*
Priya reads it twice over my shoulder, and I see her mouth twitch.
“That’s the most Witness thing I’ve ever heard,” she says.
*IT’S THE ONLY THING I’M GOOD AT.*
“It’s not,” says Priya. “But it’ll do.” She is already typing.
---
At twelve-forty the satellite phone buzzes in my pocket against the bruise of the Stone’s cold. It is Reyes, on the two-hour call, and Priya answers for me and says “Marmalade,” and listens, and her face changes.
“What?” says Cyrus.
“Nothing yet,” says Priya. “Teo’s people have walked the Alder’s lower bars for two days. They found a second shoe, and a lantern lid, and a strip of oilcloth. No Royce. Reyes says it’s three days to the seventh dawn.” She puts her hand over the mouthpiece. “Monday. Dawn. The Stone calls him gone, and the line goes to Livia, and nothing any of us does will change it.”
*THEN WE LEAVE TONIGHT,* I write. *NOT TOMORROW.*
“You can’t. You’re a month a Witness and a day from a hospital. Reyes says if your pulse drops under thirty you’ve an hour.”
*THEN WE LEAVE BY NINE,* I write, and underline it, and the underline goes through the paper.
---
Colin Strand finds me before the Council has reconvened. He does it very well. He comes round the corner of the corridor with his folder under his arm and a cup of coffee in each hand, and holds one out to me, and stops six feet off, as a man does with a nervous animal.
“Ms. Holt. I won’t ask you to drink it. I only think you’ve been standing a long time.”
I don’t take it. He sets it on the sill, politely, and keeps the other.
“I’ll be brief,” he says. “I’m not a villain. I have a client I can’t name, a duty to him, and a firm that has been in this valley for a hundred and four years. I’d like to propose a thing, and I’d like you to hear it as a lawyer and not a Witness.”
*SPEAK.*
“Holdings Two will return the principal of the Winterlight Fund by Monday noon. In full. Nine million, one hundred and forty thousand dollars, wire to any account of the trust you name. No admission of liability. No question as to the transfer’s origin.”
He sips his coffee. “In return, the Roster, the *original,* is returned to the estate. Unread. The copies are surrendered. And you’ll find, Ms. Holt, that the forty-one households who are living on Ashgrove’s kindness will go on living on it, and the question of whose pencil wrote what in a dead man’s margin will remain what it has been for thirty years.”
*A QUESTION.*
“Yes?”
*WHO TOLD YOUR FIRM ANSEL WAS DEAD?*
He doesn’t blink. It’s very well done. But the coffee cup in his hand tips by a degree, and a small dark wave of it climbs the inside of the rim and falls back.
“Within the hour, Ms. Holt,” he says gently. “A man called. I won’t say who. He is a client’s friend.” He sets the cup beside mine on the sill. “I’d like you to consider what I’ve said. I’ll be at the foot of the stair.”
---
Livia finds me last. She comes round the corner a few minutes after, quite alone, in the gray dress, and stands in front of me with her hands behind her back like a child at a recital.
“I’m going to say yes,” she says. “I thought you ought to know before they ask me.”
*I THOUGHT YOU WOULD.*
“I’m terrified. I want that clear.” She almost smiles.
“My grandfather put a man in the water, and my father held him there. And I have, God help me, the family name on a signet ring, and thirty-one people in this house who have served Ashgrove since they were children. If I say no, the next name is Dunstan, and he’d burn the Roster by morning. If I say yes, I’m the Chair of a house that is built on a drowning.” She looks at her hands. “I think I’d rather be the one to take it down.”
*YOU WILL HAVE ENEMIES BY DARK.*
“I’d say I’ve had them all my life,” says Livia. “They’ve simply been wearing my family’s coat.” She looks up. “Can I ask something? And you can say no.”
*YES.*
“After the swearing. Whatever happens. I’d like to come to the Stone, on Monday. At dawn. My father’s line is mine if he isn’t found.” Her voice thins. “I’d like to be there if it’s called.”
I write: *THE CHAIR DOES NOT LEAVE THE FALLS ON THE NIGHT OF HER SWEARING.*
“I know. It’s in the Rule. I read it this morning, on the stair.” She looks at the ceiling for a moment. “I’ve never in my life been so grateful for a clause I wanted to break.”
At one o’clock the Council reconvenes. The room has changed again. The sun has come round to the south windows, and a long bar of light lies across the pale stone table. Dunstan has taken off his coat. Strand stands against the back wall. Mrs. Marsh has brought a ledger and put it before her like a prayer book. Livia has not sat down.
“The question before the Council,” says the Marshal, in his hinge of a voice, “is the filling of Chair One. By the Founders’ Rule, it is filled within a day of vacancy, by the vote of the sitting Chairs, from among the blood of the line or those it has sworn.”
“Then it’s simple,” says Dunstan. “There’s one of the blood in this room who has stood at a Council before. I’ll put my own name.”
“You’re no Varnell,” says Mrs. Marsh.
“My grandmother was Ansel’s aunt. It’s a sworn line.”
“It’s a very thin one,” says the Marshal. “But it’s a line. Is there a second name?”
Edwin Garrity lifts his bare hand an inch from the cane. “Livia Varnell,” he says.
There is no sound. Then a sound, from the sixth chair, where the fourth Councillor has been sitting all day with his hands in his lap. He is a pale thin man named Arden, with a cough and a gold watch, who has not once spoken, and I realize with a start that he has been listening to every word.
“I’ll second that,” says Arden. And then, as Dunstan turns on him, mildly, “I was at the Alder at dusk on Sunday, Dunstan. I held a lantern. I watched a girl go into a flooded office with a rope round her waist to shut a sluice that her own father had opened. I can’t say I’ve seen another Varnell do it.”
---
It’s done by hands, in the old way. Not a secret ballot. Every Councillor stands, and puts a palm flat on the pale stone, and names the person.
Dunstan puts his hand down first, on the left, and says his own name in a voice that does not shake.
Mrs. Marsh says, “Livia Varnell.” She says it like a woman signing a check.
Arden says, “Livia Varnell.” Garrity says it too, from the seventh chair, quietly, with the glove and the bare hand both flat on the stone.
That makes three to one. Dunstan’s eyes go to the Marshal. The Marshal has not stood. He sits with his long dry hands folded in front of him, in the third chair, looking at nothing.
“Marshal,” says Dunstan. “Your voice.”
“I know what it is,” says Eamon Strick. He is looking at the table. “I’ve been Marshal of this Council for twenty-four years. I carried Ansel’s orders. I stood at the Alder on Sunday, and I did not go into the water.” A pause. “I’d like it entered that when the girl went in, I thought, there is a better Varnell than I knew.”
He stands. He puts his palm on the stone.
“Livia Varnell,” says the Marshal.
---
“Miss Varnell,” says Mrs. Marsh gently. “You’ve been named.”
Livia is looking at the floor. She has the manila envelope in her hand still, forgotten, and she turns it over, once, with a small dazed gesture, like a girl holding a program at a play whose title she’s lost.
“I haven’t said I’d take it.”
“You may refuse. The Rule allows it. The seat then goes to the next name. Councillor Dunstan.”
She lifts her head. She looks at Dunstan, and she does not look unkind. She looks at the five of them, at the empty crepe-hung chair, at the long bar of sun on the stone. Last, she looks at me.
I put the pencil on the pad. I do not know what to write. She is twenty-six. She buried her grandfather on a gravel bank on Sunday night and lost her father in a river, and she is looking at a woman who is a month a Witness and cannot speak, to be told what to do.
I write: *IT’S YOURS TO DECIDE.* I turn the pad. She reads it. Then she does something I don’t expect. She laughs, a short, cracked sound with no joy in it, and shakes her head.
“That’s what Walter would have said,” she says, “and he was a bookkeeper.”
---
“I’ll take it,” says Livia Varnell. “On terms.”
The Marshal inclines his head. “State them.”
“One.” She holds up a finger, and the old signet ring on her thumb catches the light. “The books of the Falls are open to the Witness of Corwin Ridge, all of them, from nineteen ninety. Mrs. Marsh has offered the discretionary ledgers. I’d like it to be the whole of the treasury. The deeds, the minutes, the proxies, the Winter Fund.”
“That’s the whole of the house,” says Dunstan.
“It is. Two.” A second finger. “The principal of the Winterlight Fund, nine million, one hundred and forty thousand dollars, which was moved twenty months ago to a company in Salt Lake City by a firm that was acting on an instruction nobody has explained. I’d like the Council to ask the firm to account for it, in writing, by Monday noon.”
At the back of the room, Colin Strand shifts his weight from one foot to the other.
“And three.” She lowers her hand. “That the Chair of Ashgrove Falls take no part in the vote on the Rowe interest, or on the petition of Pellam and Rowe, until the Witness has had it in evidence. Because if I’m to sit in the first chair,” she says, quite steadily, “I’d like it to be known that I sit in it *with my eyes open.*”
No one says anything. Then Mrs. Marsh, in a very small voice, begins to clap. She stops at once, ashamed. But Arden has taken it up, a thin dry patter of palms, and Garrity’s bare hand strikes his knee, and it spreads, and the Marshal, with a face like the day the dam broke, nods once.
“The terms are accepted,” he says. “The Chair is filled. The swearing will be at the Falls at dusk, as in the Rule.”
---
It happens at four-forty, with the light going orange on the snow.
The Falls are a tall white rope thrown down a cliff of black stone. The path to the lip runs along a ledge cut in the rock a century ago, with an iron rail and a wet black stair. At the top there’s a flat of old granite no bigger than a kitchen floor, and the whole of the cold wet roaring is there, in your teeth and in the roots of your hair, and the spray rises out of the abyss in a smoke.
I’m there because the Rule says the Witness stands for a Chair. Cyrus holds my elbow. Priya has the laptop in a dry bag against her chest. Mrs. Marsh and the Marshal and Arden and Garrity are ranked on the granite behind me, with Mr. Tennyson at the back writing everything down, and across the gulf of noise, at the far edge, stands a woman in a gray dress with her hair coming down, and a stone in her hand.
It’s a small gray stone from the Alder. She picked it up on the gravel bar on Sunday night. She didn’t tell me why.
The Marshal says the words. I can’t hear most of them. I see Livia’s mouth move, repeating, and I see her lift the stone, and I see her put it into the river, into the edge of the white throat where the water goes over, so that it goes with the rest.
That’s the whole of the oath. A person gives the river a thing from the water of a thing she has done. I understand it, suddenly, in my bones. She has put the river’s own stone back.
The Marshal turns to the Council. His mouth shapes, *Chair One.* And in the roar of the Falls, with the cold in my teeth, I see Dunstan walk three steps back from the edge and put two fingers in his mouth.
---
The whistle goes up under the noise of the water like a knife through a sheet. It is a Warden’s whistle, high and flat. And from the gate, from the path, from behind the stair, I see them come: eight, ten, a dozen men in dark coats, with the green-lamp badge of the Falls Wardens on their collars, running quietly along the ledge with their hands out of sight.
“Councillor Dunstan,” says the Marshal, loud, over the water.
“The Master of the Wardens,” shouts Dunstan, “has judged that the swearing is *void!*”
“On what ground?”
“That the oath was given at the lip in the presence of a *stranger,* a human, not of the Compact, who has no right at the Falls on the night of a Chair!” He’s pointing, across the granite, at me. His face in the spray is purple. “By the Rule, the Chair is sworn before the Council alone. The Witness of Corwin Ridge has no standing at the Falls. And the Wardens will hold the gate until it’s put right!”
“She stands under safe conduct,” says Livia. She has not moved. Her hair is plastered across her face and her voice is quite clear. “From the Compact. From the cairn at the Green River. A thing you’d have to answer for to the whole West.”
“*Safe conduct,*” Dunstan roars, “to the Council! Not from it! When the Council rises, so does the paper, and the stranger goes where we choose! And I choose that she go nowhere with a *copy of our books!*”
I look at Cyrus. I look at Priya, with the dry bag against her chest. Behind her, in the dusk, the Wardens are coming up the stair in a body, quite unhurried, in a closing line.
The Marshal says one word. It is not loud, and I read it on his lips. It is not a word I would have expected from the long dry man with the hinge of a voice.
“*Run.*”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!