We don’t run. Not at first. There’s nowhere to run to.
The lip of the Falls is a flat of granite with the whole roaring cold abyss on one side and a black stair on the other, and up the stair come a dozen Wardens in dark coats, shoulder to shoulder, in a line as neat as a row of fence posts. Behind us there’s only the white drop, and the long smoke of the spray, and a rail made of old iron.
“Livia,” says Garrity.
“I know,” she says. “I know. Give me a minute.”
I have my left hand on Cyrus’s sleeve and my numb right hand shoved into my pocket, and the Stone’s splinter has begun to hum against my collarbone in a high thin note I can feel in my teeth. Pulse thirty-one. I count it, because it’s a thing to do. Priya is clutching the dry bag with the laptop as if it were a baby.
“There’s a hatch,” says Livia, in her clear, shaking voice. “Beside the old sluice gate. Behind the railing, at the foot of the rock. It was the head of the flume, before they built the powerhouse. It’s iron. It sticks. It has a wheel.”
“Where does it go?” says Priya.
“Down. Under the courtyard. Under the house. It comes out at the powerhouse at the foot of the Falls, a quarter mile of stone, four feet wide. It’s dry in winter.” She swallows. “It’s *dark.* There’s no light in it. I was nine.”
“Then we’ve an hour’s walk,” says Cyrus, dryly, “in the dark, in a ditch.”
“If anyone has a better idea.”
---
Nobody has. It is Mr. Tennyson, in the end, who changes things, and he does it by doing nothing except what he has done all day.
He’s standing at the back of the granite flat in his county coat with a clipboard under his arm and the leather case of his camera in his other hand, and as the Wardens reach the head of the stair he walks, without hurry, directly toward them. He’s a tall bored man of fifty-odd and he looks like exactly what he is.
“Gentlemen,” says Mr. Tennyson, pleasantly. “I’m a bailiff of the Third District Court, in the execution of an order. I’m carrying the court’s certified copy of an inventory, in this case. I’d be obliged if you’d stand aside. I’m going down to my car.”
The leading Warden stops. He is a thick young man with a flat face, and he has plainly been told to hold the gate against a woman in a gray dress and a woman with a pad. He hasn’t been told about a bailiff.
“Sir,” he begins.
“Thank you,” says Mr. Tennyson, and walks through the line like a man crossing a street, and down the stair, and out of sight. At the back of the line, a Warden steps aside. Then another. Nobody stops him. They’re a house of wolves, and they’ve all been brought up to respect a man with a piece of paper.
It’s the opening of a door, about the width of a hand. I don’t wait for it to close.
*GO,* I write, and I hold up the pad above my head, and Livia is already running.
---
The hatch is where she said. It is a round black iron lid, set low in the foot of the rock beside a rusted wheel, behind a drift of snow and a skein of old frozen vine. Cyrus hauls the vine away with both hands. Livia seizes the wheel. It doesn’t turn.
“It’s frozen,” she says. “It’s *frozen.*”
“Move,” says Cyrus Hale, and in the voice of a very large and very old man who has been a gentle accountant for fifty years, he says, “Livia, my dear, I’ve been a Hale since before this house had a roof.”
He doesn’t change. He doesn’t need to. He puts his shoulder against the iron wheel, and sets his boots against the granite, and the cords stand out in his neck like cables, and the wheel gives, an inch, a groan, a long scream of rust.
“Now,” says Priya, who has her phone in her teeth for a flashlight.
The lid swings up. A black mouth. A breath of air that smells of old stone, and iron, and cold years, and under it a faint sweet cherry that I know, because Edwin Garrity has just reached my side and is looking down into the dark with the face of a man looking at his own front door.
“I’ve been down here,” he says. “In ninety-two. We used to bring the courier up the flume on the night of a Chair, to keep the Falls from knowing which road he’d taken.” He lowers himself, with a hiss, onto the first iron rung. “It’s two hundred and eleven steps, if I remember. There’s a turn at ninety. Mind the turn.”
---
It takes us nineteen minutes to go a quarter mile.
The flume is a long stone throat. The floor is a shallow channel, worn smooth, with a ridge on each side to walk on, and over it a vaulted roof built by men who knew how to build for water.
The sound of the Falls follows us, a long dull thunder in the stone. Our breath goes up in smoke. Priya’s phone casts a narrow wavering beam, and in it I see the walls, black and furred with white salt, and the drops of ice hanging from the roof like the teeth of something.
Cyrus goes first, with the bag. Priya second. Livia third. Then me, with my left hand on the wall, because the right will not do what it’s told and I can’t feel the stone. Garrity is last. He doesn’t speak. I can hear his cane on the floor behind me, a slow tap, a pause, a tap, and between them his breathing, hard and shallow and careful, as though each breath were a thing he had been lent.
At the sixtieth step, my pulse drops.
I know at once. It’s a thing I know now, as you know the first step of a staircase in the dark. It is as if someone has put a cold finger on the base of my skull. The edges of the beam go gray. I put my hand flat on the wall and I stand there.
*PRIYA,* I write, and can’t see it. I don’t know if she does.
“Maren?”
*THIRTY,* I write. *THIRTY. I’M NOT. I’M FINE.*
“You are *not* fine,” says Priya, and there’s a hand on my arm, and then there are two, and a smell of wool and cardamom and tea, and Cyrus has turned round and is looking at me in the thin white light with his round kind old face gone as hard as a rock.
“Miss Holt,” he says. “Put your arm over my shoulder. I shall not ask again.”
---
The turn at ninety is a bend to the left, where the flume divides. One arm runs on down towards the powerhouse. The other runs flat and narrow to the right, under the great house, and comes out behind a hinged board at the foot of a window I know.
Livia stops at the fork.
“The sill,” she says. “The cup. That’s the other branch. It goes to the east wing.” She says it with a funny, flat clarity, as one reads out a sum. “I could go up. I could be in the Hall in four minutes. I’d come out in my own front room, and Dunstan would find me there in the morning, and the Rule would be kept. I’d be Chair, and under his hand, and the Roster in his pocket.”
“Livia,” says Garrity.
“Or I could go on.” She doesn’t look at him. “I could leave the house on the night of my swearing, against the Rule. And he’d stand at the gate with a dozen Wardens in the morning and say that I abandoned the Chair. And he’d be right.”
I stand in the dark with Cyrus’s arm around me and the cold coming up through my boots, and I look at a woman twenty-six years old who has never in her life broken a rule she didn’t have to.
*YOU SAID YOU’D BE THERE,* I write, and she reads it by the glow of the phone. *WHEN IT’S CALLED.*
“I did say that.”
*I WON’T ASK YOU TO. THE RULE IS THE RULE. I’M ONLY SAYING WHAT YOU SAID.*
She looks at the right-hand branch for a long, long time. Then she turns her back on it, and goes on down the left.
“It’s a clause I wanted to break,” says Livia Varnell, a little unsteadily, over her shoulder. “I told you. I’d just forgotten how far it was to the bottom.”
---
The powerhouse is a stone building the size of a church, with its roof half gone and its windows blown out, built into the foot of the Falls where the water used to turn a wheel. The wheel is still there, a great rotted ring of oak and iron, dripping black in the dusk. The whole place roars. There’s ice in the pit. There’s a drift of snow on the floor where the roof has come in, and a smell of wet rust.
Priya lights a flare from the dry bag. She has been carrying it, God knows why, since Sunday. It goes up in a hissing red star and the whole shell of the room leaps into being: the broken turbines, the stairs, the black gaping door at the far end, and beyond it the white-and-gray dusk of a service road under the cliff.
“There’s a road,” says Livia. “It runs out to the county highway. It’s six miles.”
“Can you reach the cairn?” says Priya. “Is the satellite phone dry?”
It is. It’s the only dry thing in the world. Cyrus puts the phone in my hand, because I have forgotten how, and I turn it on and watch the little screen swim up out of the dark. Priya takes it back, gently, and dials. It rings twice.
“Teo,” says a voice, small and clear and furious with relief. “*Where are you?*”
---
They take two hours and six minutes to come. I know, because I counted most of them.
I sit on a ruined turbine housing with a quilt that Cyrus has dug from the bag and my left hand holding the right one, and I listen to the Falls. There’s a sound in it like the Stone’s, a deep low note under the roar. And I wonder, with the sort of idiot calm that comes at pulse thirty, whether the people who built the house knew that the river and the Stone were the same thing in two different coats.
Garrity sits beside me. Near the end, he speaks.
“Miss Holt.”
*YES.*
“I’d like to say something and I haven’t the right words for it. So I’ll say it badly.” He turns the pipe in his fingers. “I heard what you wrote. I have been hearing it all afternoon. *I’ll think about it, Eddie.* All these years I thought it was the end of the sentence. And I never once thought that it might be *the start.*”
*IT WAS AN ANSWER,* I write. *IT TOOK HIM THIRTY-THREE YEARS.*
“It was.” He’s quiet. “I wonder if he’d be glad of the company.”
I don’t ask what he means. I think I know.
---
The dogs are nearer than I like. At seven twenty, there’s a clatter on the service road above the powerhouse, boots on frozen gravel, and a swing of lantern light across the broken wall. Two Wardens have come down the cliff path to the road, with a dog straining between them. They stop at the black doorway, and one of them lifts a lamp and calls into the dark, in a voice that has been taught to be polite, “Chair Varnell? Ma’am? Councillor Dunstan asks that you come back.”
Garrity gets up. It takes him a while. He puts his cane against the turbine housing, and he walks to the door without it, a tall gaunt man in a pressed tweed jacket, with his hat in his hand, into the lantern light.
“Boys,” he says.
The lamp stops. It stops quite still. The older of the two, a grizzled man with a gray mustache and the hard slow face of someone who has done the same job for thirty years, takes one step back, and then another.
“Mr. Garrity,” he says. “I heard you’d come back. They said it was a rumor.”
“It wasn’t.” Garrity pulls the black glove off his left hand, one finger at a time, and holds the hand up in the lamplight, flat, open, at the level of his ear. It’s a ruin.
The palm is a white lace of old scar, silver-burned, with the two last fingers drawn into the hand like the claws of a dead bird. “I’ve a thing to ask of you, Warden. I wore the pin at this house two years, in ninety-two and ninety-three. I’d like you to remember what it looked like when I put up my hand.”
The old Warden stares at the palm. His mouth works. The younger man, behind him, is looking from one to the other, quite lost.
“Hold,” says Edwin Garrity, gently. “Hold the road, and the dog. Let a Chair of Ashgrove go where she’s called. And in the morning tell Dunstan that you stood at the powerhouse door and saw nothing but an old man in a doorway.”
The old Warden swallows. And, very slowly, he lowers the lantern to his knee.
“Eleven,” he says, in a rough voice. “You were Eleven.”
“I was,” says Garrity.
---
The headlights come round the cliff at seven forty-one. They are a pair of cold white eyes in the dusk, jolting over the frozen ruts, and behind them another pair, and behind them a third. I can hear the engines in the stone. I can hear, over them, the faint shrill high flat note of a whistle on the Falls above us, and a very long way off, dogs.
The first truck stops at the powerhouse door. A door bangs. And a man gets out of it and stands there with the headlights on his back, with a coat over one shoulder and an arm in a sling made from a torn blanket.
He doesn’t call out. He doesn’t move. He stands there, six feet from the door, with his head up, as a wolf stands on a ridge in the half-light, smelling the wind.
I’ve told myself for six days that I’d say something dignified. That I would be a Witness, and not a woman. I find I am not able. I stand up from the turbine, and the room tilts, and the quilt falls off my shoulders, and I take two steps and a third.
Knox crosses the last of the distance in about a second and a half. He doesn’t say anything at all. He puts his good arm round me, and his face in my hair, and for a long moment I stand there with my cold numb hand against his chest and listen to his heart go very hard and fast, like something running.
“You’re freezing,” he says, finally, into my hair. “You’re *freezing.* You stupid, stubborn, magnificent, terrible woman.”
*I KNOW,* I write, against his shirt. I don’t know how. Then I give it up, and put the pad down, and say it in a thread of a whisper that costs me more than anything I have paid all week.
“I know.”
---
He carries me to the truck. I don’t argue. Teo has the door open and the heater roaring, and there’s a blanket, and a thermos, and Dr. Reyes’s voice coming small and fierce out of the satellite phone saying *thirty-one, thirty-one, I want her flat.* Priya and Cyrus are loading the dry bag. Livia stands in the doorway of the powerhouse, in her gray dress, looking at the Falls.
“Come,” says Knox, and holds out his good hand.
“I can’t,” says Livia. “The Rule.” Her voice cracks. “It’s a very old Rule.”
“It’s a very old house,” says Garrity, behind her. He’s leaning on the cane. “I should know. I’ve tried to leave it three times.” He looks at her, kindly. “The Rule is a promise, Miss Varnell. A promise you made on a stone. I’d say it is the sort of promise that keeps better with the person you made it to. And you’ll find, I think, that you only made it to the one.”
Livia looks at him. Then she looks at me, and I look at her.
She takes Knox’s hand.
---
The phone rings at 2:07 a.m., on the long dark road across the plateau. I am lying flat across the back seat of the second truck with my head on Priya’s coat and my feet in Cyrus’s lap, and I have not slept, and I do not remember how long it has been since I could feel anything below the elbow.
Teo answers. He listens. His voice goes quite still.
“Say that again,” he says. “Say it all.”
He listens a long while. When he lowers the phone his face is white in the dashboard light, and Knox, driving, takes his eyes off the road for one moment.
“That was Deputy Okafor,” says Teo. “A rancher on the lower Alder, below the second bar, found a man in his root cellar this evening at six. Half-drowned, half-frozen. Silver in the lungs. Wouldn’t give his name.” He swallows. “Okafor drove down and looked at him. Says he’s alive.”
Nobody speaks.
“The man asked for the Witness,” says Teo. “And when Okafor told him the girl had been sworn to the first Chair of the Falls, he laughed. He laughed until he coughed blood. And he said, quite clearly, *tell her I’ll take the other year.*”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!