I did not tell Maris. Maris told me.
It happened on Saturday morning in Jessa’s kitchen, which had become, over a week, a sort of embassy for the Dace and Keene governments. Jessa stood at the stove frying eggs. I sat at the table with my notebook closed. Maris came in at nine with a thermos and a bag of bread, took one look at my face and put both items down on the counter.
“You know something,” she said.
“I know something I’m not allowed to say yet.”
“Is it about my mother?”
I had rehearsed lying to her for about four seconds in the van on Thursday, and found that I couldn’t build the sentence. Jessa’s spatula went still.
“I’m not allowed to say what it is,” I said. “I gave my word to a man, and the word is good until Monday. But I won’t tell you it isn’t about her. And I won’t tell you it’s proof of anything. It’s a piece of paper with two initials that might be hers and might be four thousand other people’s.”
Maris stood very still. She had her mother’s way of doing that, I noticed, a vertical stillness, as though her spine were a plumb line. Then something went out of her shoulders.
“Thank you,” she said.
“For what?”
“For not saying it’s nothing.” She pulled out a chair and sat. “I’ve been told it’s nothing by everyone my whole life. It’s always something.”
“I could be wrong.”
“You could.” She turned her cup in the saucer Jessa pushed toward her. “I’d like to ask her myself.”
“Ask her what?”
“I don’t know yet.” She laughed, shakily. “That’s the problem. I don’t know the question. I only know I’d rather be the one who asks than the one who’s told afterward by a man with a letter.”
Jessa put a plate of eggs in front of each of us and sat down. “Do you want us there?”
“No.” Maris said it kindly. “Not in the room. I want to do it in my studio, because it’s mine and nothing in it belongs to her. I’ll invite her for tea. I’ll ask what she remembers of the Towerfall arena and the fall of that year. I’m not going to show her any paper. I’m not going to lie. I’m going to ask a plain question.”
“And if she lies?”
“Then I’ll know what her lying sounds like when it isn’t about money.” She picked up her fork. “I’ve never been able to tell.”
“Could I be nearby?” I asked. “Not in the room. In the car, across the street, with the engine off.”
“Why?”
“Because if it goes badly, I’d like to be a person you can walk to. Not to rescue. To sit with.”
She considered it. I watched her think. It was a long, careful look, from a woman who had spent six months learning that every offer of help carried an invoice.
“Yes,” she said. “Across the street. You don’t come in unless I come out.”
“Closed loop,” I said.
“What’s closed loop?”
“It means I say it back. I stay in the car unless you come out.”
“Then I come out and you drive me to the diner and I order pie,” she said. “That’s my side.”
“That’s your side.”
“Good.” She ate a mouthful of egg and added, with complete calm, “I haven’t been this frightened since I forged my mother’s name on a permission slip.”
---
Yvette Keene arrived at Maris’s studio at two o’clock, in a long gray coat, in a black car, with a driver who did not get out.
I watched from a gray rental across Main Street, one of four cars on the block, a window rolled down two inches, the engine off, my notebook on the seat. The tailor’s old shop had a green door, a bay window with a dress form in it, and a hand-painted sign that said M. KEENE, COSTUME & ALTERATION. Behind the glass I could see Maris moving between a worktable and a kettle, her back very straight.
Yvette stood on the sidewalk for a moment looking at the sign. She was a handsome woman of fifty-six, silver at the temples, with her daughter’s cheekbones and none of her daughter’s hesitation. She touched the handle of the green door the way one touches a stranger’s furniture. Then she went in.
I waited.
It was extremely cold in the car. A woman walked a small brown dog past me and gave me a sidelong look. A truck delivered feed to the hardware store and reversed with a long, patient beeping. Fifteen minutes passed. Twenty. I did not use the radio. I did not use my phone.
I did not do what every muscle in my body wanted, which was to cross the street and open the green door and stand between a mother and a daughter. My right shoulder had stiffened in the cold, and I worked my fingers inside my glove to give the rest of me something to do.
At minute twelve, the old man who had twice called Maris “Miss Keene’s girl” came down the sidewalk with a newspaper under his arm. He saw the green door, then my car, then my face. With the instincts of a man who had lived in a small town for seventy years, he turned around and went home without a word. It was the first act of discretion the Reach had ever shown on my behalf, and I was grateful for it.
At thirty-five minutes, the dress form in the window moved.
It was only a shift in the light. Someone had walked behind it. I watched a pair of shadows resolve into a pair of women, standing apart, their faces turned away from me. One was talking. The other had her arms folded across her chest. The talking one lifted both hands, palms up, a gesture like a woman explaining why the soup had gone wrong.
Then the shorter shadow put out a hand. Palm flat. Stop.
The door opened.
Yvette came out first. She stood on the step for a second, buttoning her coat. Her face, at that distance, gave away nothing, but her hands were not steady and she did not look at the street. She walked to the black car and the driver got out in a hurry and opened the door and she said something short, and the car pulled away from the curb.
I waited exactly the length of time I’d promised.
The green door opened again. Maris stood in the frame with her apron still on, pins in the collar. She looked down the street, found my car and walked across the road.
She got in the passenger side. She shut the door. She sat for a moment with both hands in her lap.
“Pie,” she said.
“Pie.”
“I’d like a very large piece.”
I drove.
---
The diner was on the highway, with a chrome counter, red vinyl booths and a waitress named Doris who called us both “hon” and brought pie without being asked. Maris did not touch hers for a long time.
“She was calm,” she said finally. “You’d have been proud of her. She sat on the stool by my worktable and drank tea like it was a negotiation and said she was glad to see I’d found a space. Then I asked.”
“What did you ask?”
“I said, ‘Mother, were you at the Cinderhall Arena the week before the Towerfall accident?’” Maris picked up her fork and put it down. “I said I’d seen the old stock records. I’d found the date on a share purchase. I said I wasn’t accusing her of anything. I only wanted to know where she’d been.”
“And?”
“She didn’t pause. She said, ‘Of course I was. It was my first week as a shareholder.’” Maris looked at the pie. “She said she’d taken a walk-through with the facilities man and the house manager, a tour of the building before her first board meeting. She said she’d been in a good coat and a great hurry.”
I held very still.
“She said the facilities man had a man from the state with him, up on a ladder in the loft, and the facilities man had handed her a sheet. Just handed it. She said, ‘Sign for the venue,’ and she was a first-week shareholder who didn’t know what a loft was, so she’d initialed it and moved on.”
Maris pushed a crumb of crust around. “I asked what the sheet said. She said she hadn’t read it. She said she’d never read it. She’d carried it to the box office and put it in a basket on the manager’s desk.”
“Did she say whose desk?”
“She said Beck’s.” Maris’s mouth tightened. “Beck Arlen wasn’t a stage manager then. He was the assistant house manager. He ran the paperwork.”
The diner’s coffee machine gurgled. At the counter a trucker laughed at something on his phone.
“I asked her whether she’d known the sheet was an inspection,” Maris said. “She said, ‘I know now. I didn’t know then.’ I asked her what she knew now. She said, ‘That it was in the file when the accident happened and not in the file when the inquiry asked for it.’ And then she said, very quietly, ‘I have spent six years not asking why.’”
“Do you believe her?”
“I don’t know.” She said it with a dreadful honesty. “That’s the strangest part, Cleo. I’ve spent my whole life certain she was lying, and I looked at her today and I could see it either way.
“She might have been a woman who signed a sheet she didn’t read and then buried the fact because it was convenient. Or she might have been telling me exactly what happened, and the burial was done by somebody else.” She looked up. “I’ve never been able to tell, because I was always so busy being angry.”
“You don’t have to decide today.”
“No. I just have to decide whether to write it down.” She breathed. “I’m going to tell Ames’s office on Monday, after your Mr. Rowe goes. I’ll say my mother told me she initialed a sheet and passed it to Beck Arlen. I’ll say that’s all I know. If they want her, they can find her. I won’t be the one who delivers her.”
“That sounds right.”
“It sounds terrible. It’s right.” She took a bite of pie at last, and chewed, and looked across the table at me. “Is the sheet she described the thing you can’t tell me about?”
I had known the question was coming since the car, and I had picked my answer at the diner door.
“I can’t say. I gave my word until Monday. What I can say is that I won’t hear her version and nod to make you feel better. I’ll hold it the way you do, as one account.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“No. It’s the most I’ve got that isn’t a lie.”
Maris turned her fork over in her fingers. “Then keep it,” she said. “I’d rather live in the part of the world where someone says she can’t tell me than the part where everyone says it’s nothing.” She took another bite. “Doris was right about the pie. Don’t tell her.” “She said one more thing, at the door.”
“What?”
“She said, ‘Ask Ellis what he paid for.’”
I put down my coffee.
“I didn’t understand,” Maris said. “I thought she was being her usual self, throwing a rock at the man who left me. But she wasn’t smiling. She sounded frightened.”
---
I called Ellis from the diner’s parking lot at four o’clock, with the engine running and Maris inside, arguing amiably with Doris about whether peach counts as a vegetable.
“I’m sorry to ask this,” I said. “When you bought the Towerfall inquiry report, who did you buy it from?”
A pause. “A document broker. A man named Sutter, in the capital. He had a catalog. It was supposed to be the complete report with all appendices. I paid for the complete one.”
“Did you get the complete one?”
“I think so. I only read the summary.” His breath caught. “I told them that on Tuesday. I told the delegates, in closed session, that I never read the appendices.”
“Would you read them now?”
“Now?”
“Tonight. All of them. And tell me what’s in Appendix F.”
“What’s Appendix F?”
“I don’t know.” I rubbed my eyes. “It’s what Yvette told Maris to ask you about. ‘Ask Ellis what he paid for.’ It might be nothing. It might be her last throw. But you sent the panel a scan, and the paper is the only copy you can put your hands on.”
He was quiet for a long time. “The paper is in my office safe. At the hall.”
“Then go to your office.”
“I’m in the hall’s parking lot. I came straight from a meeting.” His voice had changed. It had gone low and steady and very careful. “Give me an hour. I’ll call you.”
I sat in the car and watched snow begin, thin and dry, a few grains at a time. Through the diner’s window, I saw Maris laughing at something, her head tilted, the pie finished, and I thought, with a small, odd ache, that it was the first time in a month I had seen her do it with her whole face.
My phone buzzed. Nita.
Beck Arlen’s counsel has contacted the district office. Beck would like to speak to Ames about the Towerfall paperwork. He says he’s ready. Call me.
I read it twice. I did not call. I put the phone down on my knee and waited for the other one.
---
Ellis called back at five fifty.
He did not say hello. He said, “I’ve got it.”
“What’s in F?”
“It’s a stack.” Paper rustled. “Appendix F, ‘Venue Documentation.’ It’s numbered F-1 through F-14. It’s got contracts, a lease, the house manager’s staffing sheet. There’s a cover page that says it’s the ‘complete documentation provided by the venue to the inquiry.’” His voice was strained. “I’m looking at the page numbers.”
“And?”
“F-1, F-2, F-3, F-4, F-5, F-6.” A pause. “F-8.”
I closed my eyes.
“There’s no F-7,” he said. “It goes from six to eight. The page numbers are printed in the footer by the same press, in the same type. It’s not a typo. Somebody pulled a page and renumbered nothing.”
“What’s on F-6?”
“The contract for loft maintenance. The last item is, ‘See Inspection Record, F-7.’” He read it slowly, flat as a legal brief. “And F-8 is the next contract. The footer reads, ‘Page 8 of 14.’”
“The report says fourteen pages.”
“It says fourteen. I count thirteen.” He drew a long breath. “Cleo, I paid for this. I paid a document broker eleven thousand dollars for a complete report, and he sold me thirteen pages of a fourteen-page appendix. And I didn’t know, because I didn’t read it.”
“You couldn’t have known.”
“I could have read it.” His voice cracked on the last word, and then recovered. “That’s the point. I could have read it the day it arrived.”
I let the silence sit. Outside the car, the snow thickened. A man in a feed-store cap went by, head down, with a sack on his shoulder. The diner’s neon sign flickered pink, then blue.
“Ellis.”
“Yes.”
“There’s a man named Lyle Rowe who’s going to the state panel on Monday with a carbon copy of an inspection record from September twelfth.” I opened my eyes. “I think I know what page seven is.”
He did not answer for a long while. When he did, his voice was very quiet.
“Then somebody’s been holding it for six years,” he said. “And I paid them to keep holding it.”

