Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 28

Thirteen of Fourteen

I kept my promise to Lyle Rowe for exactly as long as it took to ask him to release me from it.

I called from Jessa’s back stairwell at seven o’clock, with the radiator ticking behind the door and my sister’s soup going cold on the table inside. He picked up on the second ring, sounding like a man who had been sitting beside the phone pretending he hadn’t been.

“I’m calling to break my word,” I said. “Politely.”

“Go on.”

“My sister is in the next room. I told her I’d tell her something on Saturday. You said Monday.”

“I said Monday for the panel, not for family.” A long exhale. “Tell her what you saw. Not the photographs. Those are mine to hand over, and I’d like them handed over once, in the right room. But the fact of it, yes. She has more right to it than the panel does.”

“Thank you.”

“Miss Dace.” The old welder’s voice went dry. “Is she angry at you?”

“She was. We’ve been working on it.”

“Good. Anger that gets worked on is a tool. Anger that gets stored is a fire hazard.” He hung up before I could answer, which I was beginning to understand was his way of saying goodbye.

Jessa heard all of it standing at her own table. I did not dress it up. I told her about the carbon record from the twelfth of September, the line that said replace within thirty days, the load figure sitting at sixty percent, and the received line initialed in a different pen.

I told her there were two letters on it and that they might be anyone’s. I told her that Yvette Keene had said she once initialed a sheet in her first week and passed it to Beck without reading it.

My sister listened with her good hand flat on the table and her bad one tucked against her ribs, the way she held it when she was concentrating.

“Thirty days,” she said.

“Yes.”

“Three weeks before the fall. So there were nine days left.”

“Yes.”

“Somebody could have walked into that loft and swapped two plates in an afternoon.” She said it without heat, as a fact she was setting on the table beside the bread. “I’ve been thinking for six years that it was a freak thing. A bad day. A bolt that sheared the way bolts sometimes shear.”

“It may still have been a bad day. The sheet doesn’t say the anchor failed. It says it needed replacing.”

“Don’t.” She looked up. “Don’t do the careful thing. Not tonight. Let me be angry for ten minutes and then you can bring the careful back.”

So I sat and let her. She was angry in a way I hadn’t seen since the hospital, quiet and complete and without a single raised word. She was angry at a loft, at a carbon copy, at a woman with silver at her temples she had never met. When she was done, she got up, ladled soup into two bowls and put one in front of me.

“Eat,” she said. “You look like a stray.”

“I’m a wolf.”

“A stray wolf. Eat.”

I ate. It was very good soup. Neither of us mentioned that her hand shook slightly on the ladle.

---

Ellis arrived at twenty to eleven.

I heard the truck before I saw it, which is one of the few uses a wolf’s hearing has in daily life. The engine had a low, tired note that I’d have known in a crowd of engines. I went down the back stairs in my socks and met him in the alley behind the hardware store, where the snow had stopped and the sky had gone the black-silver of a gun barrel.

He had a document box under one arm. His coat was open, his hair was flattened on one side from the headrest, and he had the pinched, gray look of a man who had driven four hours in the dark rehearsing something.

“You didn’t have to drive tonight,” I said.

“I couldn’t think of a reason not to.”

“Sleep. Eat. Ordinary things.”

“I’m not good at ordinary when I’m like this.” He held up the box with a sort of embarrassed pride. “I brought the whole thing. The report, the invoice, the cover letter, the envelope it came in. I didn’t touch anything but the appendix. I wore gloves. I’m told that’s what you do.”

“You wore gloves.”

“They were gardening gloves.”

I laughed. It came out of me before I could stop it and it hurt my shoulder, and I put my good hand on the brick wall and laughed until my eyes ran. He stood there holding eleven thousand dollars’ worth of paper, looking at me with real offense, and then his mouth gave way at one corner.

“It’s not that funny.”

“It’s extremely funny. You’ve been practicing chain of custody in the greenhouse.”

“I wanted to do it correctly.”

“I know.” I wiped my face. “That’s what makes it funny.”

Upstairs, Jessa had cleared the table. She gave Ellis a look that was almost a handshake and a bowl of soup, in that order. He ate standing for three bites before she pointed a spoon at a chair, and he sat. The chair rocked. He stopped with the spoon in the air, looked down at the leg, looked at her.

“It’s been doing that since March,” Jessa said.

“I could fix it.”

“You could.”

“Do you want me to?”

She considered it, and I watched my sister decide something about him. “After the soup,” she said. “And I’ll hold the flashlight. I don’t need a man in my kitchen with a toolbox as an act of charity. I’d like to see how you do it.”

He fixed the chair in nine minutes with a pocketknife, a folded square of cardboard and a drop of glue from a tube in his coat pocket. Jessa held the flashlight and asked three questions about glue. At the end she sat in it and rocked once, experimentally, and said nothing for a moment.

“That’s all right,” she said, which from her was a parade.

Then we opened the box.

---

Appendix F was thirteen pages of dull, official paper under a cover sheet, and it took us until midnight to learn anything from it, because dull official paper is designed that way.

Ellis laid it out on the table in order, with a clean sheet between each section. Contracts. A lease. A staffing sheet printed in a typeface that had gone out of fashion a decade ago. The loft maintenance agreement, ending, as he had read it to me, with a line that said See Inspection Record, F-7. Then F-8, as if the world had never paused.

“Look at the cover,” I said.

“I’ve looked at the cover.”

“Look at it as someone who didn’t buy it.”

He turned it over. At the top was a rubber stamp in faded blue ink, a round seal with a state emblem and the words Records Office, Public Copy Set 2, Certified Complete. Under it, in a box, a hand had written, 14 pp.

“Certified complete,” Ellis said slowly. “Fourteen pages. Somebody counted.”

“Somebody wrote fourteen. Whether they counted or just read the contents sheet, I can’t tell from a stamp.” I tapped it. “This went into a public set that anyone could request. Either F-7 was in the set when the stamp went down, or it was already missing and the clerk certified a number off the index.”

“And on the day I bought it, it wasn’t there.”

“So the page was pulled before the stamp, or between the stamp and your check.”

“Either way,” Ellis repeated. He had gone very still, with the look he got when a piece of a problem clicked into place. “That’s a long window. Years.”

“Yes. Who held this copy during the years?”

He turned to the invoice. It was a single sheet, folded in thirds, on cheap cream letterhead that said SUTTER DOCUMENT SERVICES, Archival and Records Recovery. He had paid eleven thousand dollars in two installments. In the corner of the sheet, in a small block of type I’d have skimmed past, was a line that said Source: consigned lot, Cinderhall House Office (B. Arlen, authorized).

He read it twice. Then he read it aloud, and his voice shook on the second line.

“Beck consigned it,” he said. “Beck Arlen sold this set to a document broker.”

“After pulling F-7.”

“If he pulled it.”

“Ellis.”

“I know. I know it doesn’t prove that.” He put the sheet down with great care. “But he was the one who had the paper in his hands, and he was the one who decided it was worth selling, and then I came along with eleven thousand dollars and bought it, and I thought I was being thorough.”

“You were being thorough. You bought a record.”

“I bought a record someone had edited.” He pressed the heels of both hands against his eyes. “And I didn’t read it. Cleo, I told the delegates I’ve been trying to repair this family’s reputation for a year, and I paid a man to hand me the exact mess I was trying to understand, and I didn’t read the appendices because they were boring.”

“Everyone does that.”

“I’m not everyone. I have a staff and a degree and a position that supposedly depends on reading things.”

Jessa, from the stove, said without turning, “You’re also thirty-two and you haven’t slept.”

He lowered his hands and looked at her. She was drying a pot.

“I’m saying you can be an idiot and a decent person in the same hour,” she said. “It’s one of the things I’ve learned this month.”

---

It was nearly one in the morning when he said what I had been waiting for him to say.

“I want to go see Sutter.”

I had known it was coming. I had watched it assemble itself on his face for an hour, a straight, bright line from the page to the man who had sold it. I had even recognized the shape of it, because I’d carried the same line around for six years, and I’d ended up with a torn shoulder and a reputation.

“Monday,” he said. “First thing. His office is in the capital, near the courthouse. I’d just ask him where he got it. Politely. I’d bring the receipt and I’d ask who authorized the consignment and whether he kept a copy of F-7. A man like that keeps everything.”

“Ellis.”

“I’d be very calm.”

“Do you remember the thing I did at the assembly?” I asked. “On the stage, in the first week, before the hearing. When I decided I would simply handle the problem and nobody had asked me?”

His mouth tightened. “I remember.”

“Everyone you meet is going to tell you what a good idea it is to go yourself. You have standing. You are a customer with a grievance. You have a name people return calls to.” I leaned forward. “That’s exactly the problem. If you walk into his office, a man who sold you thirteen pages of fourteen is going to say whatever lets him keep selling pages, and then he’s going to know you’re looking. And he’s going to know before Nita does.”

“He’ll know soon anyway.”

“Not if she asks first. With a request that says preserve everything, and a name on the letterhead he can’t shrug off.” I held his eyes. “You can’t help by arriving as yourself. You can only help by getting out of the way.”

“That’s very hard to hear.”

“I know. I’m the person who says it worst.” I looked at Jessa. “Tell him.”

“I’m busy with a pot.”

“Jessa.”

She put the pot down. “Ellis,” she said. “The thing you’re good at is walking into a room and making everyone feel like the room was waiting for you. It’s why people vote for you. It’s also why Sutter will sell you a story. Let someone walk in who nobody’s afraid of.”

“Nita,” Ellis said.

“Nita folds laundry in that voice and takes statements like a surgeon,” I said. “Nobody has ever lied to Nita successfully.”

He sat for a long time. The radiator knocked. Somewhere under the floor, in the hardware store, something small scurried across the boards and I tracked it automatically with my left ear.

“Then what do I do?”

“Give her everything. Tonight, or tomorrow morning. The report, the invoice, the envelope, your bank record. Hand it over with a note that says exactly what you did and didn’t read.” I paused. “And the thing you told the delegates on Tuesday, behind closed doors. Say it again in open session.”

“Open session?”

“Tomorrow morning, before Lyle goes to the panel. Thirteen pages, a stamp that says fourteen, and Beck’s name on a consignment line. Not on a date you pick.”

He looked up sharply. “That breaks my deal with Finch. He agreed to hold the renewal vote a month if I disclosed the purchase quietly, in closed session, with the minutes sealed. He said it would look better as a procedural item.”

“It would look better. It’d also be a little less true.”

“Finch will say I’ve made him look like a fool.”

“Finch will say a lot of things.” I shrugged, carefully, with my left shoulder. “You get to decide what kind of person you’d rather be on a Monday morning. The one who protected a compromise or the one who handed over the page.”

“You’re making it sound simple.”

“It’s not simple. It costs you the vote. Maybe the title.”

“Probably the title.” He said it slowly, tasting it. He sat back and looked at the new chair leg, at the cardboard shim peeking from under it, at my sister’s spotless oven, and something in his face went loose and young. “Fine. Then I’d like to do it badly and honestly rather than well and sneakily.”

“That’s the best sentence you’ve ever said.”

“It’s a low bar.”

“It’s not a bar at all. It’s a floor.” I smiled at him. “You just stepped on it.”

---

Nita came on Sunday at ten, in boots and a quilted coat, with a canvas bag and a chain-of-custody form in triplicate. Nita looked at the table, at Ellis, at the cardboard shim on the chair leg and at me.

“This is the most useful kitchen I’ve been in all year,” Nita said.

Nita went through everything in ninety minutes. Each page of the appendix was photographed twice, with a ruler beside it, and the cover and the invoice went into separate bags. Ellis was asked the same six questions three different ways, and I noted that his answers did not change by a single word. When he got to the part about the delegates, a hand went up.

“Don’t tell me. Tell them.” Nita gave him a long look over the top of the glasses. “You understand that anything you say publicly becomes part of the record of what you disclosed and when.”

“I understand.”

“Then say it in the plainest words you’ve got. No adjectives.”

“I haven’t got many left.”

“Keep it that way.”

At the door Nita lingered, one hand on the knob, and the laundry-folding voice went flat.

“I called Sutter’s office this morning,” Nita said. “A courtesy call, before I send the preservation letter. A recorded message answered. The business has been closed since Wednesday. The website’s down, the phone is forwarded to a storage number and the landlord says the lease was terminated by email.”

Ellis went white.

“Wednesday,” I said.

“The day after Ellis’s delegates’ meeting.” Nita buttoned her coat. “Which is when a certain amount of the town would have learned that he had bought a certain report.”

“I disclosed it as a procedural item,” Ellis said. “In a closed session.”

“There’s no such thing as a closed session in a building with forty people who gossip.” Nita gave him a look that was not unkind. “I’ll find the landlord’s records and the storage number. It may be nothing. Brokers fold. But I’d like to remember that this man’s whole business was selling paper, and he stopped within a day of a customer saying out loud that his paper was wrong.”

Nita was gone before either of us found anything to say. The door shut. Down in the street, an engine started, a small slow cough in the cold.

Ellis sat down in the repaired chair. It didn’t rock.

“Then I’m it,” he said at last.

“What?”

“The only evidence that Sutter’s catalog ever existed. His records are gone. His customers are gone. I’m a man holding one invoice in gardening gloves.” He gave a short, helpless laugh. “I’m the exhibit.”

“You’re a witness,” I said. “That’s better. Exhibits don’t get to say what they saw.”

“What did I see?”

“Thirteen pages, a stamp that said fourteen and a name on a consignment line.” I sat in the chair beside his, close enough that our shoulders touched, left to left. “Which is enough to make a man pack up his office in a day, if he’s the right kind of nervous.”

His hand found mine under the table. It was warm and had a faint callus from the glue and the pocketknife. We sat like that for a minute in my sister’s kitchen, with the report cooling in its plastic bags, and neither of us said what we were both thinking.

It was Jessa who said it, from the doorway, in her coat, car keys already in her good hand.

“I’m driving to the capital in the morning,” she said. “Not to see Sutter. To see the state records office, which is open to the public on Monday, and which keeps a log of everyone who ever requested Set 2.”

I stood up so fast the chair legs shrieked. “Jessa, you can’t just walk in and ask.”

“I can ask for a public record. It’s the one thing in this whole mess that’s actually public.” She jingled the keys. “I’ve done it before. When I was nineteen, the spring after my accident, I requested every document I could find about it. They gave me a form. It’s a very boring form. It’s why I know the building.”

“You never told me that.”

“You never asked how I spent my Mondays.” She gave me a small, crooked smile. “Closed loop, Cleo. You can come, or you can stay and be a very useful chair.”

I looked at Ellis. He lifted both hands in surrender.

“I’m out of the way,” he said. “As directed.”

I went to find a pen and a second pair of socks.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!