Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 45

Four Pages

Maris did not drive to Rookvale. She did something Ames later called worse, and I called very much like her. She drove to the edge of Rookvale at one in the morning, parked three houses down from a gray bungalow with a covered car in the drive, and sat in her hatchback with the engine off and her coat over her knees until a quarter to six. Then she drove home, showered, and phoned the district at six-ten to say that she had not knocked.

“I want that written down,” she told me, when I came into the studio and found her at the cutting table, pinning a pattern to a length of gray wool with a face like a clenched fist. “I want it noted that I did not knock on that door.”

“It’s noted.”

“Her light came on at four. A kitchen light. A woman in a robe stood at the sink for a long time.” Maris pinned a dart. “I couldn’t tell if she knew I was there. She didn’t look out. She just stood. And then she turned the light off and I thought: if I go up that path, it becomes something I did. If I stay in the car, it’s something that happened to me.”

“That’s not how it works.”

“It’s how it works for me.” She looked up. “Inspector Bell says I’m to stay away until Sunday. A deputy will sit on the house. Lorraine will be asked, politely, whether she’ll speak to me. I’m told it’s a question of consent.”

“A good one.”

“A cruel one.” Her mouth shook, once, and set. “She taught me to thread a needle, Cleo. I’m the one who’s being asked for consent.”

I did not say anything. I took a pin from the cushion and handed her the next one, and we worked like that, in a silence that smelled of wool and steam, until Ames’s text came and told me to be at the district office at ten.

---

It was a low, square building at the edge of the county seat, with a flag, a bank of vending machines, and an interview corridor whose linoleum had been waxed so often that it had acquired a glow, like an old tooth. I had been there three times. I had never liked it, and the smell had not improved: burnt coffee, floor wax, the faint stale sweetness of nervous people who have been told to wait.

Ames met me in the lobby with a folder. “You’re not here for Mr. Skell,” Ames said. “You’re here to sign a statement about the sedan, which Nita will take down in a side room at ten fifteen. I’d like you to know that now, because you’ve an expression.”

“What expression?”

“The one a dog gets when it hears a car door.” Ames did not smile, but something around the eyes allowed it. “He’ll be in Room Two with counsel and Dr. Thale. The pages begin at half past ten. You’ll hear nothing of it and see less. Give your statement and go.”

“Understood.”

“You didn’t say yes.”

“I said understood.”

“I noticed,” said Ames, and went away down the waxed corridor.

---

I gave the statement. It took twenty minutes in a room the size of a closet with Nita typing and saying nothing, and I told it plainly: a car at the lane, no lights, nine minutes, cedar polish and wet wool, five characters of a plate, a cold night, a woman asleep in the next room. Nita read it back. I signed it.

The pen was a cheap blue ballpoint, and for the first time in my life I looked closely at how my own hand made a C.

“Can I ask what the pages are?” I said.

“Four pages of text, copied from a script Dr. Thale prepared,” said Nita. “Dictation of three paragraphs, the alphabet, a list of numbers, and a signature repeated twelve times. Ball-point. Supervised, timed, from a sheet put in front of the writer. It’s no different from what a bank would ask.”

“And he’s agreed.”

“He’s agreed to everything.” Nita capped the pen. “That is the part Inspector Bell dislikes.”

I thanked Nita and went out into the corridor to find the exit, and it was there that I made the mistake.

I do not say it was a large mistake. It was the size of a left turn. The side room let out onto the wrong end of the corridor, and the exit was down it, past Room Two, whose door had a narrow window of wired glass. I walked past it with my eyes on the floor. I heard, through the door, the scratch of a pen on paper: a quick, fluent, easy scratch, like a person writing a postcard on a sunny day.

Then the door of the room beside it opened, and a man came out with a paper cup of water, and it was Devon Skell.

---

He was smaller than I’d imagined. I had built him, over six weeks, out of a voice, a coat and a cuff, and what stood in front of me was a medium-sized man of fifty or so with a face of pleasant, unremarkable good looks, sandy hair going gray at the sides, and an oatmeal-colored cashmere coat folded over one arm. He was holding the cup in his left hand. He had very clean nails.

“Ms. Dace,” he said. “What a happy accident.”

I stopped. I did not step back. The nose took him in all at once, and it was cedar polish and clean wool and a faint warm sweetness like a boiled candy, and underneath it, nothing, a strange, smooth absence, like a wall that has been painted over many times.

“Mr. Skell,” I said. “Please talk to your counsel.”

“I’m on a break. We’re allowed one.” He sipped the water. He had a lovely voice, I’ll say that for him: an easy, rounded baritone that made every sentence a favor. “I’m writing four pages for your inspector. I’m told it’s an honor. I haven’t been asked to copy a paragraph since school.”

“Then you should go back.”

“Three minutes.” He lowered the cup. “I’d like to say I’m sorry about the Larkin Street booking. And the others. It must be hard to be a person whose name is in every paper. I know what that’s like. I was in one for a week, once, six years ago, over a trifle.”

“I don’t want to talk to you.”

“Of course you don’t. Nobody does until they have to.” He said it kindly. “I’ll be quick, because I’m a man of limited time, and I’ve been asked for four pages.” He tilted his head. “I’d like to give you a piece of advice. For free. As someone who has watched the Keene family for a very long time.”

“Mr. Skell.”

“Ask Mrs. Keene who kept the plate.”

The corridor was quiet. The scratch of the pen in Room Two had stopped.

“I beg your pardon?”

“The engraver’s plate. The monogram. It’s been in a drawer six years. Everyone knows where it is. Everyone knows who put it there.” His voice dropped to the gentle register of a physician delivering a diagnosis to a friend. “I would ask her, if I were you, what she paid for the privilege of leaving it there. And what she paid, afterwards, to a person who never sent her a bill. She won’t tell you.

“She’ll say ‘I don’t make a fuss.’” He gave the last phrase the exact cadence, the flat, level, gently weary downward slide that I had heard Yvette use on the recording. It was perfect. It was not just good. It was Yvette’s mouth, in a man’s throat, and my skin tightened up my arms.

“You do it very well,” I said.

“I do nothing well,” said Devon Skell, with a smile. “I just notice things. A habit of the trade.” He drank the rest of his water, and set the cup on a window ledge, and for a moment the hand lying beside it on the ledge was entirely still, left, relaxed, with a slight dragging curve of the little finger, and I saw how the side of it rested on the wood. A thumbprint, a smear, the way a hand lays itself along a line.

“It’s been a pleasure,” he said, and turned, and opened the door of Room Two, and went in.

I stood in the waxed corridor with my heart going. I heard Ames’s voice come through the wired glass, low, flat and furious, saying the words “a break is not a conversation,” and a soft pleasant laugh answering.

Then the other door opened, and Nita was there, looking at me, with no particular expression, which on Nita is the loudest face there is.

---

Ames saw me in the lobby, twelve minutes later, in a plastic chair beside a vending machine, with a cup of the district’s coffee going cold between my knees.

I stood. “He walked out of the room with a cup. I didn’t go to him. I was walking to the exit. He said four sentences and then he went back in. I’ll tell you every word.”

“I know you will.” Ames sat down beside me, a thing Ames did rarely, and put the folder on a knee. “The sentences are on the recorder. There is a recorder in the corridor. There’s one in every corridor of this building, Ms. Dace. I’d have been remiss if I’d let a man with a booking quarrel walk the hallway in the hours before his interview without one.”

“Then you knew.”

“I didn’t know he would speak to you. I knew he would try.” Ames was silent a moment. “Mr. Skell’s counsel is about to withdraw his offer. I am going to let counsel do it, and say nothing. The trade is gone. Mr. Skell will have a stranger to blame for it, which is a relief to a man in his position.”

“Because of me.”

“Because of a corridor. And a decision to put a witness in it.” Ames’s tone was grave. “I can’t have you in the interview building again before the hearing. Not in the building, Ms. Dace. Not in a side room. I’ll find someone else to take the rest of your statements. It isn’t a punishment. If it were, I’d say so.”

“It feels like one.”

“It would. It would to me.” Ames took a breath. “He said, ask who kept the plate. I’d like to know whether you heard anything beneath it.”

“Beneath what?”

“Your nose.”

I said nothing for several seconds. It was a long way to say something so strange. “There wasn’t anything. Cedar polish. Wool. A boiled candy. No fear, no sweat, no change when he said her name. Nothing came up off him at all.” I looked at my hands. “It’s like standing next to a clean glass. I’ve never met anyone who didn’t smell afraid at least once in the middle of a conversation. Even Beck.”

“A man who has practiced,” said Ames.

“Or a man who isn’t afraid, because he knows what he’s got in his pocket.”

“Or that.” Ames stood. “Dr. Thale will see you at the door. She’d like a word. I’d like you to hear it from her, and not from me, and I’d like you to go to your sister’s afterward and do nothing.”

---

Dr. Imogen Thale was the same short, brisk woman in tweed, with the magnifier on its cord and the habit of closing her sentences like drawers. She met me in the vestibule, among the umbrella stands, and shook my hand with a dry cool grip.

“I’m told I may tell you the preliminary,” she said. “In the broadest terms. Inspector Bell says you’ve a right to hear what concerns your sister’s case, and I find I agree.”

“Thank you.”

“You’ve seen the carbons. The two tracings.” I nodded. “I said at the time that the hand was left-handed, and I said the fit was good but not exact. I said it of the signature on the temp’s pay slip, as well. I’d like to retract, in part, a thing I said, or rather, refine it.” She lifted the magnifier off her chest and let it drop. “The man writes beautifully. I want to be plain about that.

“He writes an entirely natural, fast, fluent left-handed script, with a very particular drag along the side of the hand. I’ve seen it before in people who learned to write in a school that punished them for it. They adopt a slanted overwriting posture and smear the line.”

“The visitor’s book.”

“The smear in the visitor’s book is that hand. I’d put it at a good deal better than a fit. It’s a pressure pattern, a slope, an entry stroke on the S. It’s him, or it is someone trained exactly as he was trained, which, in a county this size, comes to the same thing.” She paused. “That’s the first finding.”

“And the second?”

“The second is that the tracing on the carbons is not his.”

I stared at her.

“Not his hand. A left hand, certainly. But a slow one. The K on the carbon was drawn, not written. It was drawn by someone looking at the model and going stroke by stroke, with a pressure that rises at every turn, as a person does when she is afraid of making an error. Mr. Skell does nothing slowly. His four pages were done in nineteen minutes, and the nineteenth was the signature, which he did with a flourish.”

She tucked the magnifier into her pocket. “I’m not saying the man didn’t visit the building. I’m saying that if he stood in a room with a carbon on a desk, he was not the one who traced the initials. There were two left-handed people in the room that week, or in the chain of the room. I’ve found one of them. I haven’t found the other.”

“A woman,” I said.

“I said ‘she.’ I’m sorry. A habit of mine; I think of the careful, slow hand as a woman’s. I’ve no scientific basis for it.” She gave a small dry smile. “You’ll tell Inspector Bell that I said so, and the inspector will say that it isn’t evidence.”

I thought of a hook at the top of an L.

“Dr. Thale,” I said. “If somebody wanted to know whose hand it was, would they need a model of her writing?”

“They’d need a good deal more than a model.” She looked at me, unblinking. “They’d need a sample of an exact written hand, taken without any pressure to disguise it, and a good while. A few pages. The longer, the better. But a hand like that, a woman who traced a famous signature with fear, will not write naturally when told she’s being compared. She’ll disguise. I’d hope the inspector has a source.”

“A card,” I said. “A Christmas card.”

She raised her eyebrows. “That would do,” said Dr. Thale. “That would do very nicely.”

---

I did not go to Jessa’s. I did not do nothing. I walked out of the building into a wind that smelled of snow, and saw Devon Skell’s counsel in the car park, a heavy fair-haired woman in a gray wool coat, hunched over the hood of a car with a folder open and a coffee cup on her knee, writing on a form.

I could not help it. I will say that it was not the nose; it was just the angle. The sun had come out for a moment behind the clouds, and it lay low across the folder, so that the cover sheet printed on the top, a list headed WITNESSES FOR THE DEFENSE, showed through from the back. Seven names.

The first two were the Pettibones, which made no sense, and then a gap, and then a long black bar of ink, a redaction, a single heavy stripe, over a name that went two words long.

The sun shifted. Where the black bar met the edge of the paper, the back of the sheet showed through in a different light, and the pen had pressed hard enough to leave a ghost, the kind an engraver or a notary or a child could read by tilting the page.

The first word under the bar began with a capital L. And the surname, short, five letters, began with an M and had an r and an s in it, and I did not need to count them twice.

“Ms. Dace,” said the counsel, not looking up. “I’ve got a very good eye for a person reading over my shoulder.”

“I’m sorry.”

“You’re not.” She closed the folder, quite gently, and tucked it under her arm. “But it was a clever thing to do. I’d have done it at your age.” She sighed. “It’s a pity. He’d have liked to give you the name himself. He rather prefers to give names.”

I did not answer. I walked to my truck with my arm in its sling, and I got in, and sat. I did not start it for a long time. I took out my phone and typed to Ames in a single hand with one trembling thumb:

L. M-A-R-S-H. On his witness list. Under black ink. He is going to put Lee in the room on Monday.

The reply came before I had put the phone on my knee. It said only: Come to the truck-stop on Route Nine. Nita will meet you. Say nothing to anyone else.

I started the engine. I thought: I have been told to go home and do nothing. I thought: it is not yet noon on Saturday.

I thought, finally, with the wipers beginning to move, and the first dry snow ticking against the glass, that a man who tells you the name of the one who kept the plate, and gives you the weight of a name in his mouth, and writes four beautiful pages in nineteen minutes, is not afraid of what you will find in Rookvale. He wants you to go.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!