Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 54

Ten Cartons

They counted paper until after midnight, and I learned that a person can be afraid and bored at the same time, in about equal measure, for hours.

Room 4 had been the old clerk’s office. It was twice the size of Room 3 and smelled of dust and warm radiator and, over everything, of the cedar oil that came up through the floorboards like damp. Somebody had pushed two long tables together under the window and covered them with brown paper. On the paper, in two rows of five, stood the cartons.

They looked like what they were. Dolores Pike’s uncle’s estate had sold them by the box, and the boxes had the soft, tired corners of things that had been in a damp shed for a very long time. Each one carried a lot number in grease pencil. Each one had been taped shut, and then, I noticed, the tape had been cut, and then taped shut again with a different roll.

“Different tape,” I said.

“Yes,” said Ames, who had already seen it. “Photograph it, Garrity. Every carton, every seam, with a ruler in the frame.”

The deputy photographed. Nita, at the end of the table, put on a pair of white cotton gloves and began a log in a ruled book with a steady, unhurried hand. Ames stood at the head of the tables with a clipboard. Edmund Thorne sat in the clerk’s old swivel chair by the radiator with his coffee, his umbrella across his knees and his long legs crossed, like a man at a recital he had paid for.

And I sat on a hard chair by the door with my good hand under my thigh.

That was Ames’s condition. I was a family witness, the district was entitled to one, and if I touched a single sheet of paper I would be sent downstairs to sit with the custodian. I had promised. I was holding the promise under my thigh.

Ellis was downstairs.

He had not been asked up. Ames had been courteous about it and absolutely firm: a delegate named in the refund could not be in the room while the Hall’s records were opened, because the first thing Mr. Pratt would say was that he had touched them.

Ellis had said he understood, in the voice of a man who is in the middle of something that hurts and has decided to be reasonable about it. Then he had gone down to the lobby and sat on a bench beneath a portrait of Harlan Hargrove, with his hands between his knees, and I had left him there.

---

The first three cartons were the Hall.

I do not know what I had expected. A treasure, I suppose. A drawer full of letters. What came out of the cartons was the sediment of an institution: minute books with marbled covers, bundles of session certificates tied up in string, ledgers of dues, a program from a banquet nine years back with somebody’s thumbprint in the soup.

Ferris had notarized the Hall’s closed sessions for thirty years, and his niece had sold the lot, along with his spare staplers, to the highest bidder at eight on a Tuesday morning.

“It’s all ours,” said Thorne, from the radiator. He said it with a little sigh. “I’d never have thought to ask Walter Ferris where the sessions went. He was a very private man. You’ll find, I think, that he kept a copy of every certificate he stamped.”

“We’re finding that,” said Ames.

Thorne did not go on. He drank his coffee.

Carton four held a bundle of old election returns and a bag of rubber bands. Carton five held a tin of buttons. Carton six was the first one that made the room change.

Ames lifted out a thick folder, pale green, with a metal fastener, and a typed label on the tab that read INDEMNITY - MEMBER VENUES - RIDER 9, and set it on the paper. The folder was twelve pages thick. Nita photographed the cover and laid a gloved finger on the first line.

“Will you read it aloud?” said Ames.

“I’d rather you didn’t,” said Thorne, mildly. “Not because of what it says. Because it will take a quarter of an hour, and I believe I can say it in a sentence.”

“Say it.”

“The Hall, as a mutual body, carries a fund. A venue that’s a member can claim on that fund if one of its people is injured through a failure the venue could not have known about. If the venue did know, or ought to have known, the fund pays nothing, and the venue’s owner is liable in their own right.” He paused. “That’s Rider 9. Harlan drafted it. I was vice chair at the time. I initialed what I was handed.”

I listened to him, and I heard something under the courtesy that I had not heard before. It was not guilt. It was relief. It was the sound a man makes when the thing he has been dreading is being said by somebody else, in an unhurried room, to people with clipboards.

---

I will try to say it plainly, as Nita said it later in the car, with a pencil and the back of a parking stub.

Six years ago a rope failed at the Towerfall and a woman who was my sister fell forty feet. If the people who ran the Ridgetop Arena had not known about a bad anchor plate, the Hall’s fund paid for Jessa’s surgeries, and for the rest of what she would need, and the Arena’s owner owed nothing beyond her premium.

If the owner had known, the fund owed nothing, and it was the owner who had to pay. There were, I understood, a great many millions in the difference. The Hall would very much have preferred the second.

And the person who owned the Arena, in the week the accident was investigated, was Yvette Keene. She had walked the building on the twelfth. She had signed the cover sheet on the thirteenth. The transfer had been recorded on the nineteenth, a day she did not own anything yet.

“ownership notified, nine-thirteen,” I said. I had not meant to say it aloud. “Beck wrote that on the pink sheet. A note on the thirteenth that Yvette had been told.”

“Which was a lie,” said Nita. “Beck said so.”

“It was a lie that makes Yvette the owner who knew.” I looked at the pale green folder. “She didn’t own the building. Not until the nineteenth. Whoever wanted her to be the owner who knew only had to say she’d been told on the thirteenth, and let the transfer date catch up with the story.”

It was Nita who put a finger on the next piece. In the margin of Rider 9’s last page, in pencil, in a small elegant upright script, were seven words: RECOMMEND “OWNERSHIP NOTIFIED” LANGUAGE PER COUNSEL. And beneath them, two initials, a little looped, a little worn.

E.T.

Thorne looked at them as though they were a photograph of his own younger face.

“That’s mine,” he said.

“It’s dated?” said Ames.

“It is not. I never dated margin notes. It was a habit.” He set his cup on the sill. “I didn’t write the language, Inspector. Counsel for the Hall suggested it, in a memo, in the week after, as a model clause for the incident report, so that if the owner had been informed, the file would say so.

It was meant for the next time. It was meant as a drafting suggestion. I initialed it as I initialed everything. Hargrove would be able to tell you what became of it, if he could tell anybody anything.”

“And did you ever see it used?”

“I did not,” said Thorne, quite gently, and I could not smell a lie, because I could not smell anything, but I could see his hand, and the hand did not move. “And I should be grateful if the district would consider why the person who bought these cartons and brought them to you in a tidy row may be the one man in the county with no interest in hiding a note that has his initials.”

It was very well put. It sat in the room like a good chair, and I had the first small cold thought of that evening: the people who offered me a comfortable place to sit had always asked for something before I got up.

---

Carton two, which Ames had left for last because of its weight, held the paper.

It was in the original wrap. A thick ream, I thought at first, and then I saw that it was only a half ream, a block of heavy cream letterhead with a deckled edge, bound in brown Marlowe Engraving paper and tied with twine. At the head of each sheet there was a raised Y and K in a looped monogram that had been out of use for six years.

I did not need to touch it to know. I could feel the raised ridge from the door.

Nita counted. Ames counted. The deputy counted, because it was a form. I counted in my head, which was not allowed, and which I did anyway, and which came out the same.

“Thirty-one,” said Ames. “Each pencilled in the lower right corner. Consecutive?”

“No,” said Nita. “One through eleven. Thirteen through thirty-six, with a gap at twenty-two. Then forty-five through fifty.” A pause. “So not forty-four, not thirty-seven, not twelve.”

“Three known,” said Ames, “and sixteen unknown. Nineteen sheets gone out of fifty.”

“Nineteen,” I said.

Nobody asked why I had said it. Lorraine Vance had traced a pair of initials on that many sheets of paper on a Monday six years ago, as a joke. I had not set the two numbers beside each other until I heard myself say it, and when I did the room seemed to warm by a degree.

“It could be coincidence,” said Nita.

“It could,” said Ames. “It won’t be.” And then, with great care, “The sheets Lorraine Vance traced on were practice paper. She told Ms. Keene’s daughter so, and she told the district, and I believe her. These are the letterhead itself. Someone took nineteen from the top of the block before it left the engraver’s box.” Ames turned a page of the clipboard. “We know where three went. The other sixteen have been used for something.”

“Used how?”

“I’d give a good deal to know,” said Ames.

---

It was about half past eleven that Thorne asked if I would walk with him.

I looked at Ames. Ames, who had been counting sheets with a deliberate monotone, glanced up at Thorne and then at me, and made a very small movement with one hand, which meant: you may; Nita will be near; take nothing, give nothing. Nita put down the pen without being asked.

We went out into the green corridor, where the lights had gone to sleep in sections and only a long lit stripe remained at the far end. Thorne walked slowly, with his umbrella tapping once on the runner at every second step. Nita stayed by the door of Room 4, twenty feet off, with a ledger under one arm and the stillness of a post.

He stopped at a tall window that looked down on a dark square and a bench with a man on it.

“He’s still there,” said Thorne.

“He told me he would be.”

“He was always loyal. It’s a trouble for a delegate, loyalty. It makes him easy to lead and hard to rescue.” He rested both hands on the umbrella’s curved handle. “I’m going to say something to you, Ms. Dace, and I would like you to hear that I’m saying it with respect.”

“All right.”

“The panel will find, tomorrow or the day after, that there was a failure of paper in the Hall. It will find that the Hall’s records were handled badly for a number of years and that I was a part of that. I accept it.

I’m prepared to say so under oath. It’s a failure of administration, of a kind that happens to any large body with a lot of drawers.” He spoke without hurry. “What I would prefer to avoid is that the panel go further. It would be a very great pity if a report were written that confused a failure of administration with a conspiracy, and the Hall, which has paid the medical bills of four hundred members’ families over thirty years, were broken on that confusion.”

“I haven’t written the report.”

“No. But your statement has weight. You’re a young woman who has been very honest in public, and it has made you valuable.” He turned his long face toward me, courteous, pained, and quite gentle. “If you were able to say, in an amended page, that you had seen nothing to suggest that anyone on the Hall’s side had acted knowingly, I believe I could do a great deal.

I believe the censure against Ellis could be rescinded at the next session. I believe he would be restored to the bench. I might be able to say it was a mistaken motion. These things can be arranged, between decent people, without any fuss.”

I should like to say that I did not feel it. I felt it very distinctly. It went through me like warm water, a thing so reasonable and so comfortable and so exactly the size of my deepest wish that for the space of two breaths I could see Ellis in his seat again with his hands on the desk, and a bench of people who had called him a fool bowing to him in a hall.

I tasted peppermint. I was not holding one.

“Mr. Thorne,” I said. “Are you offering me something for my statement?”

“I’m offering to be of use.”

“That’s not what I asked.”

“I never offer anything for a statement,” said Edmund Thorne, with a small, kind, mournful smile. “It would be improper. I merely observe that the same people who care about the truth also care about what becomes of other people, and I think you’re one of them.”

Twenty feet away, Nita’s head had turned a quarter inch.

“Then I’ll answer the observation,” I said. “I’ll tell you what I told the panel. I’m a witness who’s trying to be reliable. I won’t say I saw nothing about the Hall, because I’ve seen a drawer and a note and a closet with a fax machine and a very kind old woman who was paid a hundred dollars a week to look the other way.

That’s what I’ve seen. I’ll say it again in the morning. And I’m going to go downstairs and tell Ellis exactly what you just said to me, in the order you said it, and then I’m going to tell Inspector Ames, because Nita’s already heard it.”

“Of course,” said Thorne, instantly, without the least change of expression. “He ought to know. I’d have expected nothing less of you.” He inclined his head, an old courtly nod. “I hope you’ll tell him I said it with affection.”

He turned and went back along the corridor, tapping, and the door of Room 4 closed behind him with its small quiet click, and I stood at the window and found that my good hand was shaking.

“I heard it all,” said Nita, at my shoulder.

“I know. Is it a crime?”

“It’s not a crime. It’s very close to the edge of one, and he’s too careful to step over it.” A pause. “It’s also the first thing he’s done tonight that he didn’t have to.”

“Why did he do it?”

“Because he thought you’d take it, and in a way I think he’d have been sorry,” said Nita, “and because he thought you wouldn’t, and he wanted to see how you said no.”

---

Ellis was on the bench.

The lobby was dark except for one lamp over the portrait. It was after midnight, and the revolving door had been locked, and Rafferty’s mop bucket stood by the stairs with a gray rag over its rim. The air smelled of cedar and of a man who had been sitting still for four hours.

He looked up when I came down the last flight. He did not stand. He moved over on the bench, a few inches, the way you make room for someone in a pew.

I told him.

I told him all of it, in the order it had happened, with Thorne’s words as near as I could set them down. The restored seat. The motion that could be called a mistake. The amended page. I did not soften it and I did not improve it.

It was the hardest sentence I have ever said, and I said it with my hand flat on my knee, to a man who had been given everything that I had been trying to give him for a month, and who was being offered it back as the price of my silence.

Ellis was quiet for a long time.

“He taught me how to sand,” he said at last.

“What?”

“My first week. I had a drawer I was sanding on a bench in the basement, and he came down in his shirtsleeves to look, because he’d heard I made furniture. He took the block out of my hand and he said, ‘With the grain, Ellis.

Everything is with the grain. You’ll get there faster if you don’t fight the wood.’” He rubbed his face with both hands. “I’ve thought of that for three years every time I picked up a block. I’d have told you it was the best advice I ever got.”

“It’s still good advice.”

“It is.” He laughed, a short, wretched sound. “That’s the worst of it. He could be right and still be doing this. I don’t know what to do with a man who is right about the wood.”

After a while he put his shoulder against mine, the left one, the whole long warm side of him, and we sat there under the portrait of a man who could no longer say his own name.

“I’m glad you told me before you decided anything,” said Ellis, to the floor.

“There was nothing to decide.”

“Cleo.” He turned his head. “It’s the thing I’d have wanted to decide for myself, and you gave it back to me. That’s all I meant.”

It was the kindest thing anyone had said to me in two days. I did not trust my voice. I nodded.

---

The deputy came down for us at ten to one.

“Inspector wants you upstairs, sir,” said Garrity, to Ellis, with an expression of the deepest unease. “Just for a minute. The last box is open. It’s not about the records. It’s about, uh. Well. It’s about you.”

We went up together, the two of us, through the dark intervals of the hall. Ellis walked slowly, with his hand not quite touching my sleeve. At the door of Room 4, Ames met us with a single sheet of paper in one hand and a small brown evidence envelope in the other, the kind that is sealed with a strip of red tape.

“Carton ten,” said Ames. “It was lighter than the rest. It had a false bottom, a sheet of cardboard that someone had cut to fit and taped at the corners. Under it was this.”

Ames did not say anything else. The envelope’s flap had been lifted, and Ames tipped it, and let what was in it slide out onto the brown paper with a small flat clink.

It was a key ring. A plain steel ring, quite old, with three keys on it, a small brass one, a flat gray one, and a heavy dull one with a hex head. On the ring hung a tag of yellowed cardboard on a loop of string, the kind you write on with a pen in a shop. The writing was in blue ink. It said, in capitals, HALL MASTER, 3RD FL, E. VOSS.

Ellis looked at it for a long time. His face did not change, but his breathing did, and I heard it go shallow and then settle.

“That’s mine,” he said. “That’s the key they gave me my first month. I lost it. I mean I thought I had. I told the clerk. I went in the second year and told Pamela Quint I’d lost my master and she gave me a replacement and a form.” He swallowed. “I’d have said it fell out of my coat on the train.”

“You didn’t lose it,” said Ames.

“I don’t know that I didn’t.”

“It was taken from you or it was taken from somewhere you left it. In either case it came out of a carton Mr. Skell sold to Mr. Thorne, under a false bottom, three years after it went missing, and I’d like to know which of those things was meant to be the point.” Ames’s cold clear look moved from the key to the deputy. “Garrity. The door of Room 3.”

I understood, and so did Ellis, and neither of us said a word.

Garrity took the ring in a gloved hand and went along the corridor with his big careful tread. We followed at a distance, the way you follow a man carrying a lamp. The brass numeral on the third door gleamed in the half dark. He fitted the heavy key with the hex head, and it went in smoothly, without a catch, as a key goes into a lock that has been opened a thousand times.

It turned.

The door of Room 3 swung inward on the dark, and the violets on the sill, and the gray machine with its small steady green light, and a smell of wool and warm plastic and, very faintly, from the far end of the room, a thing I had not smelled in that building at all, because it was not cedar, and not pencil, and not a man’s coat.

It was fresh and sharp and quite out of place, like a pin in a cushion. It was the smell of an orange that had just been peeled.

Someone had been in that room since six o’clock.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!