Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 53

Room Three

The Delegates’ Hall smelled like the inside of a cedar chest that had been left in the sun.

I knew it from the street. I knew it from the revolving door, where the smell reached out and took hold of me by the face, and I knew it by the time we reached the second landing, where it had stopped being a smell and become a climate. Warm, clean, woody. A good chest of drawers.

I stopped on the stairs.

“Cleo,” said Nita, a step above me.

“Give me a second.”

I had spent the afternoon telling a county that I would recognize that smell. I had said it to a panel with my hand on a Bible. I had held it out the way you hold a coin you think is gold, and now I stood in a stairwell with my nose full of it and understood that I had no idea whether it was gold or brass, because the whole building was made of it.

“Floor oil,” said the deputy, a tall young man named Garrity who had been told to keep close and was doing it with the anxious politeness of a large dog in a small kitchen. “The custodian oils the halls every night, and it soaks in for hours. They’ve done it since before I was born. My mother used to say you could find the Hall in the dark.”

“Every night.”

“Every night, ma’am. Cedar oil and a wet rag.”

Ames, ahead of us on the landing, turned and looked down at me with a face that gave nothing away and asked, in its stillness, the only question that mattered.

“I can’t use it,” I said. “Not up here. If you want me to stand at that door and tell you what the person behind it smells like, I’ll be lying if I say anything. It’s the floor. It’s the whole building.”

It cost something to say. I want to be clear about that. For a month I had been a woman with one useful thing, and I had been quietly proud of it, in the way you are proud of a scar you got in a good cause. I had just handed it back in front of a deputy, without being asked, because the alternative was to stand at a door and play a part.

“Thank you,” said Ames. “That’s worth more to me than the smell would have been.”

“Is it?”

“It’s a witness who knows where she stops.” Ames turned and went on up. “Come anyway. I’d like you to see the room.”

---

The third floor was long and narrow, with a worn runner down the middle of a hall painted the green of old school corridors. There were brass numerals on the doors. The lights were on a timer and had come on in sections, so we walked through a succession of small bright rooms of air with dark between them.

Rafferty, the custodian, met us at the head of the stairs with a ring of keys the size of a dinner plate. He was a stooped man of sixty with forearms like cable and an expression of deep reproach. He had, I gathered, been woken from the best part of his day.

“I told the lady the machine was going,” he said to Ames, as though it were an accusation. “Nobody told me what to do about it. I wouldn’t go in. It’s not my room.”

“Whose room is it?”

“It’s the old chair’s. Mr. Hargrove’s. They’ve kept it as a kind of a records closet since he took ill. It’s on the committee list.” He sniffed. “I do the floor out here. I don’t do in there. There’s a lady.”

“A lady,” said Ames.

“Mrs. Hargrove. She comes Mondays and Thursdays, does the filing, goes at six. Only she hasn’t gone. I looked.” He lowered his voice. “She’s still in there. And that machine’s been going since ten to, and I know what a machine sounds like when it’s doing a job, and that isn’t it. That’s a machine that’s been left on.”

I listened. Down the hall, past two dark doors, I could hear it: a thin electric hum, a rhythm like a refrigerator trying to remember a song. It was not the clatter of a fax receiving pages. It was something patient, and a little pleased with itself.

The brass numeral on the third door was a 3. Somebody had polished it until it had no edges.

Ames put out a hand to stop the deputy, and with the other hand knocked, three times, quite gently, the knock of a person who has come to deliver a casserole.

“Come in, dear,” said a voice. “It’s open. I thought you were Mr. Rafferty.”

---

Room 3 had been a closet once, and a clerk’s office after that, and for some years it had been a shrine.

There was a window with a sill full of African violets, and a desk with a green blotter, and a swivel chair with its leather cracked in the shape of a long-ago back. Along one wall stood a steel filing cabinet with its drawers labeled in a firm, upright, old-fashioned hand: COMMITTEE, MINUTES, CORRESPONDENCE A-L, CORRESPONDENCE M-Z.

On the wall behind the desk hung a framed photograph of a big white-haired man in a good suit, shaking hands with a smaller man who had his back to the camera. The man’s name was on the little brass plate at the frame’s base. Harlan Hargrove, Chair, 1998 to the year I was twenty-two.

And on a low table by the window, between a lamp with a tasseled shade and a basket of yarn, sat a gray fax machine with a blinking green light and a small white electric timer plugged in at the wall.

In the chair beside it, in a lilac cardigan, with a half-finished sock in her lap and a pair of needles in her hands, sat the smallest and most tranquil old woman I had ever seen.

“Constance Hargrove,” she said, to Ames, with the faint pleased air of one who has been waiting for a visitor and had hoped for a better hat. “You’ll forgive me not getting up. It’s my hip. Are you from the committee?”

“I’m from the county district’s inspector’s office, Mrs. Hargrove.”

“Oh, how nice. Harlan would have been interested. He liked the county.” She looked at me, and Nita, and the deputy, and Rafferty hovering in the door. “That’s a lot of people. Is there something the matter with the machine? I’ve been told not to touch it.”

“Who told you?”

“The young man.”

I did not breathe. I had been in a lot of rooms in a month, and I knew the exact shape of the pause that follows a sentence like that. Ames let it settle, and then sat, on a hard upright chair, so that their eyes were level. It was a thing I had seen Ames do with frightened witnesses and with horses.

“Tell me about the young man, Mrs. Hargrove.”

“Well, he’s not so very young,” said Constance Hargrove. “I suppose he’s fifty. But when you’re seventy-three, you know.” She resumed her knitting. “He came in, oh, five or six weeks ago. I remember because the violets had just come back into flower. He said he was from the committee on pensions, and that Harlan’s old correspondence line had been left connected, and that it would be a kindness to the Hall if I’d let it stay on until the paperwork was sorted.

He said there’d be letters. I wasn’t to open them. He said they were confidential, and that I’d been so good to the Hall for so long.”

“Did he give you his name?”

“He gave me a card. I put it in the blotter.” She nodded at the desk. “It said Mr. Smith. I thought, well, that’s a modest name. He had a lovely manner. He was left-handed, dear, I noticed that, he held the card out on the wrong side. And he gave me a hundred dollars.”

“A hundred dollars.”

“A week. For the trouble.” She said it with the faint embarrassment of a woman who has found money in a coat. “I didn’t want to take it. I said, I’m a volunteer. But he said it would only be for the electricity, and I do have the electricity bill, you know, since Harlan. And my sister’s been unwell.”

I looked at Nita. Nita’s face did not move, but a muscle at the corner of the jaw went tight.

“What did you do with the letters?” said Ames.

“Why, I put them in an envelope. In the tray on the desk, there. A big brown one, and I write on it. Chair’s Office. And Rafferty comes for it in the morning, don’t you, Mr. Rafferty, and takes it down to Pamela.”

“Who is Pamela?”

“Pamela Quint,” said Rafferty, from the doorway, very grimly. “Mr. Thorne’s assistant. Second floor. She sorts what comes up.”

“I never read them,” said Mrs. Hargrove, with quiet dignity. “I couldn’t if I wanted to. They come out upside down, you see, and the print is so small. I’ve tried. I tried twice with the magnifier. I tried one on its side, and it was something about money. And then I thought, Constance, this isn’t yours.”

It was a sentence I carried out of that room and have not been able to put down. Not yours. She had been given a thing to do and been told not to look, and she had obeyed, and she had also, I think, been very lonely, and glad of the company of a machine that hummed.

---

The page came out while we were looking at her.

I did not see the machine start. I felt it, as you feel the first drops on a roof: a slight shift in the pitch of the hum, a mechanical clearing of the throat. The green light stopped blinking and went steady. Something began to feed out of the slot, slowly, curling at the end like a tongue.

Nobody moved. Ames did not rise. I saw the deputy’s hand go to his belt out of habit and come away.

It was one sheet. Thermal paper, a little yellowed, the sort that fades if you look at it hard. Ames lifted it by the edges with two fingers, read the header, and held it out so Nita and I could see.

At the top, in the small gray capitals the machines make, it said:

KESTREL INN BUSINESS CTR - TAMSIN LAKE

And under that, handwritten, in a round, easy, clear hand, in what I recognized with a little cold drop in my stomach as the left-leaning slope I had seen in a visitor book and on a counsel’s cover sheet:

BOXES WILL NOT BE PRODUCED. HOLD UNTIL FRIDAY. THE NOTE WILL BE CALLED. D.

“Tamsin Lake,” I said. “That’s where the staffing agency was.”

“Mr. Pettibone’s town,” said Nita. “Forty minutes from here.”

“He sent that to the Chair,” I said. “Not to Ames. Not to the panel. To the person in this room.”

“To the machine in this room,” said Ames. “Which is a different thing, and a more useful thing, and which I’d like very much to be clear about before anyone says the name of a man downstairs.” Ames’s voice was very even. “Mrs. Hargrove. Did the young man ever tell you who the letters were for?”

“He said they were for the Chair.”

“Did he say which?”

She looked up from her sock with her faded blue eyes, genuinely puzzled. “Why, the Chair, dear,” she said. “There’s only one. Harlan was the Chair for more than twenty years. They never really stopped calling him it, even when it was Mr. Thorne holding the gavel. I always assumed it was a courtesy.”

Nita closed both eyes briefly.

“He said ‘the Chair wants it quiet,’” said Mrs. Hargrove, apparently as a point of interest. “Mr. Smith. When he gave me the hundred. I thought how nice, that they still think of Harlan.”

I did not look at Ames. I could feel what was happening in the room, the slow clicking of a lock in three places at once. Leona had heard the phrase and thought it was furniture. Ellis had heard it and thought of Thorne. And a lonely old woman with a sock had heard it and thought, kindly, of a husband in a wheelchair, three miles away, who could no longer say his own name.

It was a title that anybody could wear. That was what was so clever about it. It was a coat with no label, and a man could put it on in a kitchen and let each listener see whatever coat they feared.

---

They took the machine apart on the spot, with a form, and a camera, and a great deal of care. Ames photographed the timer settings, which showed that the unit powered itself on at five-fifty every weekday and off at six-fifteen, and which somebody had set, with a small screwdriver, in the last month.

Nita read the memory log aloud and wrote it down: thirty-one incoming pages in six weeks, every one from a different number, every one a hotel or a copy shop or a library, in four counties.

“No outgoing,” said Nita.

“It’s a drop box,” said Ames. “Whoever uses it sends to it. It never speaks. Someone collects.”

“Pamela Quint,” said the deputy.

“Or whoever empties Ms. Quint’s tray, or whoever tells her what goes in it.” Ames put the sheet into a paper sleeve. “I’d like Rafferty’s envelope. The one that came up this morning.”

Rafferty brought it from the foot of the stairs, where he had apparently set it for the night, a big brown envelope with CHAIR’S OFFICE written on the front in a clear upright old woman’s hand. It was unsealed. Inside were the day’s three sheets: a page of Courier clippings, a copy of the Finch motion with a line in green highlighter, and a two-line note that said, in the same left-leaning hand, CLEO DACE SAYS SHE SMELLED IT. HOW LONG ON THE MOUTH.

“On the mouth,” said Nita, in a very flat voice.

“Means the nose,” said Ames. “Or the mouth. It’s a way of saying how soon. How long until she says it aloud.” Ames glanced at me. “He was keeping a clock on you, Ms. Dace. That’s a note from this morning.”

“From this morning,” I said. “Before I’d said anything. Before the hearing.”

“Yes.”

“Then he knew about the cedar polish at St. Brigid’s,” I said, “and the smell at the lane. Before I did.”

“Or he guessed that it was the thing you’d reach for.” Ames put the note in its own sleeve, a different one. “There’s a tendency to credit people like Mr. Skell with magic. It’s a mistake. A man like that has read your file. He has never needed to know what you’d say, only what you’d be likely to be proud of.”

It was an accurate remark, and it went in somewhere under the ribs. I had been proud of the smell. I stood by the violets with my hand on my own sore shoulder and thought of Cleo Dace on a witness stand, tasting peppermint, proud of a dog’s trick, and of a man somewhere forty minutes away with a pencil and a left hand who had known she would be.

---

“Here is the question I would like answered,” said Ames, an hour later, in the hall.

It was past seven. The corridor lights had been on for long enough to be tired. Nita had taken Mrs. Hargrove down to a car, with a cup of tea in her hands and her knitting in her bag, and a promise of a policewoman to sit with her.

She had not understood any of it, and had thanked everyone twice, and had asked Ames if she was in some kind of trouble, and Ames had said, “No, Mrs. Hargrove,” in a voice that I will not forget.

“Who in this building would have known to come and set a timer in a closet for a woman who volunteers on Mondays and Thursdays? Who would have had a key?”

“Anyone on the committee,” said Rafferty.

“Anyone with a delegate’s master. Which is how many?”

“Fourteen, ma’am. Fifteen. Sixteen, if you count the spare in the safe.”

“Sixteen,” said Ames. “And the chair’s office, and the chair, and the custodian, and Mr. Hargrove’s family.” The tired cold look came back. “I would like, and I say this to nobody in particular, for a person to be standing outside this door when I turn around.”

“Somebody is,” said Nita, very softly.

Nita had come back along the hall, silent on the runner, and had stopped about ten feet from us. I looked past Nita’s shoulder.

He was at the head of the stairs, a tall man in a charcoal overcoat, bareheaded, with silver hair that had been brushed back from a high forehead and a long, courteous, intelligent face. He was sixty-four years old, as I knew from the Hall’s own program, and he stood as though he were still a great deal younger. In one hand he carried a black umbrella, furled, and in the other a manila folder.

He had a smell, which I could detect even through the floor oil, because it was his own and it was a small, dry, stubborn one: wool and pencil shavings and, under that, a faint trace of pipe tobacco, the kind of smell that has been on a man for forty years and does not care who minds. It was not cedar polish. It was not Devon’s nothing. It was only Edmund Thorne.

“Inspector Ames,” said the Chair of the Delegates’ Hall. His voice was beautiful, a dry quiet baritone with something old in it, like a stage that has been walked on for a long time. “Ms. Dace. Nita Dreyer. I understand you’ve been in Room 3.”

“Mr. Thorne,” said Ames, with no pronouns and no preamble.

“Pamela telephoned. The custodian told her.” He glanced down the hall at Rafferty, who went the color of putty. “You have a warrant, I imagine. You didn’t need one. You could have asked me for the key.”

“I’d prefer to ask you something else.”

“Of course.” He bowed slightly. “And I should like to answer, though I’m afraid I’m going to begin by interrupting you. May I?”

I watched Ames’s face, and saw nothing in it at all, which was the most professional thing I had ever seen a person do with a face.

“You may,” said Ames.

“I’ve spent the last two hours,” said Thorne, “in the Hargrove Memorial Records Room. Not that one. The next one.” He lifted the folder a half inch. “Room 4. It was the old clerk’s office. I’m told by my assistant that you will be calling at nine tomorrow morning for ten cartons of paper, and I’d like to save the panel a trip, and the sheriff a very tedious morning. They’re in there. Ten. Sealed. Every one of them.”

I felt the hall tilt a degree, as though the floor oil had made the whole third story slide.

“You have the cartons,” said Ames.

“I bought them,” said Edmund Thorne. “At four o’clock this afternoon, from Mr. Devon Skell, in the car park of a motel, for four thousand dollars of the Hall’s own funds, in cash. He seemed in a hurry.” He looked at the three of us in turn, mild and grave and unsurprised, a man delivering the weather.

“I thought it better that the Hall’s records not walk about the county. They’re the Hall’s records. A good many of them have our seal. I did not think anyone would mind.”

“Mr. Thorne,” said Ames, very quietly. “You bought evidence from a man the panel has ordered to produce it.”

“I did,” said Thorne. “And I’ve come to give it to you. Shall we begin? I believe I’ll want a pot of coffee.”

He smiled, a little wryly, the smile of a good man caught in a bad hour, and I tasted peppermint, and I had never in my life wanted so much to be wrong about a person I could not smell.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!