Pratt’s lawyer was a woman named Ingrid Voight, fifty, with cropped silver hair and a leather portfolio, and she met Ames in the parking lot of the district office at four o’clock with the air of a person who has walked into a burning building to retrieve a single umbrella.
I watched it from the car, with Nita beside me in the passenger seat and a thermos between us that neither of us touched. Voight did most of the talking. Ames stood with her hands in her coat pockets and let it go over her like weather. Twice she shook her head. Once she took out her notebook, wrote a line, and tore it out and handed it over, and I saw Voight read it and, for the first time in ten minutes, stop talking.
“What did she write?” I said.
“I couldn’t see,” said Nita. “I’d guess a number.”
When Ames came back to the car she bent to the window and spoke in her usual low flat voice.
“Mr. Pratt will deliver the box to the panel clerk at eight-thirty tomorrow, in a sealed carton, under his lawyer’s hand. He will be in the room at nine. He’d like immunity on the forgery counts and we’ve told him the panel doesn’t grant it and I don’t either. He says he’ll come anyway.” She straightened. “Ms. Voight says her client has not slept in three days and is, in her phrase, in a state of grace.”
“And tonight?” said Nita.
“Tonight he’s at home, with a deputy at the door and another at the back. And a lawyer on his sofa. He’s going nowhere.” Ames looked at me. “You’ll go home and eat something. You’ll sign your name on a piece of paper in front of someone, on Dr. Thale’s advice. And you will not, under any circumstances, go to the office of Mr. Alvin Pratt tonight and ask him what’s in the box.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were thinking about it.”
“For about four seconds.”
“Make it three,” said Ames, and went in.
---
Lorraine was to speak to Yvette at six.
It had been arranged by Maris, in the course of a long afternoon in a Harlan motel with the television on and the curtains drawn. It was to happen in the one place both women could stand: the empty box office of the Ridgetop Arena, with the grille down and the lights off but one.
Nobody else would be in the building but Odette Fairbanks, who had a key and a view on privacy, and who had said, drily, that she would be in the lobby doing her accounts and that if anyone cried she would pretend to have gone deaf.
I was not asked. I’d have gone anyway, out of the old snooping habit of a person who has learned to smell a thing in a room, but Maris called me at five and said, in her new careful voice, “Will you be in the lobby? Not in there. Just in the building. In case.”
“In case of what?”
“I don’t know. In case somebody’s knees go.”
So I sat in the lobby, on a red plush bench under a framed poster of a long-dead tenor, next to Odette, who was in fact doing her accounts, in pencil, on a green ledger sheet, with her glasses on a chain. She did not look at me. She said, after a time, in her thin dry voice, without lifting her pencil, “I’ve known them both for thirty years.”
“I know.”
“Yvette was twenty-six when she married into this building. Lorraine was the one who showed her where the bathrooms were.” A small tick of the pencil. “I’d like them both to have a decent evening, if it’s all the same to the Lord.”
“I’d like that too.”
“It’s no business of yours,” said Odette, “which is why I’m telling you. Someone ought to be.”
The door of the box office stood a hand’s breadth open, and I could hear nothing from it, which was worse than I’d feared.
To keep my hands from drumming on my knees I got up and walked the lobby. Jessa’s framed inspection certificate hung by the box office window, between the fire permit and a faded photograph of the Arena’s opening night, in a plain black frame with a brass hanger. The hanging wire on the back, when I leaned and looked behind it with the flashlight on my phone, was bright and new, and the screws had been turned by someone with a better screwdriver than the Arena owned.
I did not touch it. I put my face an inch from the glass, and breathed through my nose. Dust. Brass polish. Glass cleaner, years old. And along the bottom edge of the frame, where a thumbnail would pry the backing off, something thin and clean and bright, which was orange.
“Someone’s had this down,” I said, quietly, to Odette.
“I’d have said so if I’d known.” She still did not lift her pencil. “I do the lobby with a damp cloth every Friday. Last Friday the frame was crooked and I straightened it, and thought, the cleaners. I didn’t think, a forger. One doesn’t.”
“What time Friday?”
“Five. Before the board meeting.” Her pencil stopped at last. “There was a man at the box office window asking about a ticket for a show that had been cancelled for a year. I thought he was a Graymill tourist. He wore a county parka.”
I wrote it down on the back of my hand, because I had left my notebook at Maris’s, and I thought of Dr. Thale saying that it was all done at a light table, and that someone had taken a pleasure in it. The frame had been down for an afternoon, and put back with great care, and nobody in the building had noticed but the bird.
---
I will not set down all that was said. I was not in the room. I know the shape of it only as Maris told it to me that night, at one in the morning, over a pot of tea in the studio kitchen, with her feet up on a chair and her hair in a scarf.
Lorraine had come in first, in her brown coat, and sat down on a stool by the ticket window. She’d taken her bare hands out of her pockets and set them on the counter. Yvette had come three minutes later, in a black wool dress and no jewelry, pale as paper, and had stood in the doorway and said nothing at all.
“I thought she’d scream,” Maris told me. “Mama doesn’t scream. She goes very quiet and very formal. But she didn’t do that either. She just looked. She said, Lorraine, you’re thinner. And Lorraine said, yes, I’ve not been eating.”
“Who spoke first?”
“Lorraine. She said, Yvette, I took a hundred and thirty-two thousand dollars from you that you gave to me for my keep and I never needed it. I took it because I was too ashamed to say no. And Mama said, I know what the checks were. I wrote them.” Maris shook her head. “They’ve been doing that for years, you see. Writing and cashing and not saying. It was a kind of marriage.”
“And the plate?”
“She told Mama about the plate. All of it. The two thousand, the gala, what Mr. Hargrove said. And Mama said, I knew you’d done something. I didn’t know what. I knew the morning I came in and your desk was clear. I knew you’d been crying at your typewriter for a month and I never asked, because if I asked I’d have to know.”
“That’s honest.”
“It’s the most honest thing I’ve ever heard her say. She said, I let you go because I was afraid of what I’d learn, and I paid you every month so I wouldn’t have to see your face.” Maris’s voice broke. “And then Lorraine said, I know. And they sat there. A long time. And then Mama said, would you come to dinner on Sunday?”
I put down my cup.
“She didn’t forgive her,” said Maris. “I want to be clear. She didn’t say it. She said, would you come to dinner. And Lorraine said, I’d like that, and she said, I’ll bring a pie. And that was all.”
“It’s a lot.”
“It’s a pie,” said Maris, and began to laugh again, helplessly, with her face in her hands, and I got up and put the kettle on, and did not once forget to turn it off.
---
I took Dr. Thale’s advice at ten past seven, in the front office of the district, at a counter with a brass bell on it, under the eye of a night clerk named Penny who chewed cinnamon gum and asked no questions.
Nita stood witness. I signed a blank sheet, wrote the date and time beneath it, and Nita signed under mine and added a line in her small square hand: Signed in my presence, right hand, left wrist braced. Penny stamped it with a stamp that said RECEIVED, and put it in a folder marked D, and said, “Is that all? You’d be surprised what people want stamped.”
“What do they want stamped?”
“Dog licenses, mostly,” said Penny. “A fellow came in last week and wanted his lunch receipt stamped, in case it was evidence.”
“Was it?”
“It was a very good sandwich,” said Penny, “but no.”
I looked at the paper in the folder. The E at the end of my name was a small tight knot, closed like a fist. It looked like a stranger’s. It looked, I thought, like the signature of someone who’d been through something and meant to be careful, and I felt a sudden fond, absurd loyalty toward it, as toward a dog that has learned to come when called.
“It’s a good signature,” said Nita, who had been watching my face.
“It’s not mine.”
“It’s the one you have.” Nita closed the folder. “That’s not the same thing as no good.”
Jessa had rung while I was signing. I called her back from the steps. She was in her shop, I could hear the heater, and she said she had taken the framed inspection certificate out of her own files and signed a new one for the Arena lobby, in a different pen, with a different stroke, and put the old one in an evidence bag. “I’ve changed the bird,” she said. “He can have the old one.”
“You’re going to alter your own signature?”
“I’m going to make it harder to love,” said Jessa. “Somebody should.”
Ellis’s workshop was on the north edge of Ridgetop Reach in a converted creamery, a long low building with a tin roof and a loading dock, and I got there at half past seven, with a bag of takeout from the diner on Fenn Street and a bruise coming up on my left hip where I’d walked into a pillar.
He had lit the woodstove. The big room smelled of cherry and linseed oil and cold, and a pale quantity of shavings lay in drifts along the benches. On the long table in the middle sat the half-finished chair, an armchair with a low slung back, its arms not yet fitted, looking like a good idea that had not decided what it wanted to be.
He was sitting at the end of the bench with the walking stick across his knees, doing nothing.
“I brought soup,” I said.
“Thank you.”
“And a grilled cheese. It’s the only thing the diner does that I trust.”
“I’d like both.” He did not move. “Cleo, may I tell you something before I eat?”
“Yes.”
“I’ve decided about the title.”
I put the bag down on the bench. I did not look at him. I took out the cups and the lids and the soup, and set them in a row, and opened the sandwich, and gave it to him on a paper napkin, and said, as evenly as I could manage, “Go ahead.”
“I’m going to keep it through the hearing.” He took the sandwich. “Not for the vote. Not for Finch. Not because I want it.”
He turned the stick over in his hands. “I’ve been trying all week to find out what I’d say if I resigned, and every sentence turned out to be about me. About how I’d look. Whether I’d seem clean. A man who’s read the Hall’s ledgers for ten years has a duty to go into that room and answer to them in person. I don’t think I’m allowed to leave before I’ve been asked what I know.”
“That’s not a bad reason.”
“It’s the only one that doesn’t flatter me.”
I sat down on the bench beside him. It was a long bench, and I sat a respectful foot away, with the cheap soup between us, and we ate for a while without talking. The stove ticked. A truck went by on the road outside with a long sweep of headlights across the high window.
“I was so afraid you’d decide for me,” said Ellis at last.
“I know.”
“And I was afraid you wouldn’t.”
“I know that too.” I tipped the cup against my lip. “It’s a hard kind of fear. Being the person who doesn’t.”
“It’s the hardest thing anyone’s done for me.” He turned his head. In the dim light his face was drawn and hollow-eyed and very young, a face that had been a long time awake. “I’ve a favor to ask. It’s not a large one.”
“Ask.”
“Tomorrow, at nine. When Pratt opens the box. Would you sit where I can see you? I’d not need you to do anything. Just where I can see the back of your head.”
“That’s all?”
“It’s enough,” said Ellis. “It’s a very fine head.”
I leaned my shoulder against his, carefully, the left, the good one. After a moment he put the stick down and rested his cheek on my hair, and we sat in the creamery in the smell of cherrywood and bad soup, and for twenty minutes, and for the first time in a week, no one called anyone.
---
The phone rang at ten forty-one.
I knew it was bad by the ring. A phone has a sound for good news, a kind of clean bright bell, and a different one for the other kind, a bare rattle. I was in Maris’s hatchback outside the creamery, with the engine running and my hand on the gearshift, and the screen said AMES.
“Where are you?” she said.
“Leaving Ellis’s. I’m driving to Maris’s.”
“Pull over.”
I pulled over. I put the car in park on the shoulder of the Fenn road with the heater roaring and the dark fields flat on either side.
“A courier delivered a sealed envelope to the home of the panel clerk, Mr. Basil Orrin, at twenty past nine tonight,” said Ames. She spoke in her very flattest voice, the one she’d used to describe the camera footage. “The courier was a teenage boy on a bicycle who said a man had paid him ten dollars in a parking lot. Mr. Orrin opened it at ten past ten. He called me at ten thirty.”
“What’s in it?”
“A sheet of cream paper. Pencil number one. A typed statement in the first person, over the signature of Cleo Anne Dace, with a notarial seal dated today.”
I did not breathe.
“The notary is Ferris,” said Ames. “The seal is the one that was stolen from his estate. It says you appeared before him at three-fifteen this afternoon and swore that you cut the primary anchor line of your sister’s rig, knowing the secondary was weakened, because you believed it would end the act before a payment dispute.”
“At three-fifteen I was at the Hargroves’,” I said. “In the hall. With Ellis. With Constance. With the stenographer. With you.”
“I’m aware.”
“Is the signature mine?”
A short pause. “That’s what I rang to ask. I’ve a photograph on my phone. I’ll send it. It’s quite large and it has a loop. It drops, at the end, like a man stepping off a curb.”
“The old hand.”
“Dr. Thale will say so in the morning. She’s asleep. I’d rather not wake her for a thing I’m already sure of.” Ames paused again. “There’s another thing, Cleo. It’s not only the clerk.”
“What else?”
“Orrin’s wife has a nephew at the Courier. She sat down at the kitchen table after he read it out, and she was so shaken she told him before she’d thought. He’s the night editor. He’s already got a headline.”
I put my forehead against the cold wheel. On the dashboard my phone buzzed, once, twice, and again, a small insect noise, the sound of a county waking.
I picked it up. The first alert was from the Harlan Courier. It was brief. It said, in the plain black type of a small-town paper that had made up its mind in a hurry:
TOWERFALL RIGGER SIGNS CONFESSION. SISTER CUT LINE ON PURPOSE, DOCUMENT SAYS. HEARING TO RESUME THURSDAY.
Beneath it was a photograph of a cream sheet with a monogram and a signature in a big, looping, confident hand whose last letter fell away like a dropped stitch. It was my name. It was the name I had signed at twenty-two in a hospital waiting room, under a typed line I never read.
Ellis had asked me to sit where he could see the back of my head. I wondered now how many people would be looking at it by nine.

