Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 61

A Signature Is a Habit

Dr. Imogen Thale arrived at Jessa’s lane at ten past nine in a mud-colored station wagon, carrying a hard black case on her knees like a woman bringing a cello to a funeral.

She was sixty-one, small and brisk, with iron hair cut straight at the jaw and a magnifier hung on a cord between the lapels of her tweed coat. She got out of the car, looked at the black mailbox, at the gravel, at the sky, and said to nobody in particular, “Is there a table? A flat one. Not metal. Metal is hell on lighting.”

Jessa produced a kitchen table. Within ten minutes it had been dragged out onto the farmhouse porch where the north light fell, covered with a sheet of brown paper, and fitted with a lamp on an orange extension cord that ran back through the window.

Ames stood at one end in her gray coat with her notebook shut. A deputy stood at the other with a camera. I stood in the yard, with my hands in my pockets, a witness who touched nothing, and watched a woman unwrap a cream-colored sheet with a pair of bamboo tongs.

Thale did not speak for a long time. She turned the page under the lamp, tilted it, laid the magnifier on it, moved it a quarter inch, tilted it again. Once she made a small, appreciative noise in the back of her throat, the noise a cook makes at a sauce that has been done well and should not have been.

“Ms. Dace,” she said, without looking up. “The younger. Would you come and sign a few things for me?”

“How many?”

“Thirty. On this pad. Quickly, as you’d sign a delivery slip. Then thirty slowly, as you would a contract. Then a dozen with your eyes shut, if you don’t mind.”

“That’s an odd sort of afternoon,” said Jessa.

“It’s a morning,” said Thale, “and I find it passes.”

---

It took forty minutes. Jessa signed her name seventy-two times on a pad of unlined paper in a dozen speeds and moods, while Thale watched her hand and not the page, and Ames watched Thale. When it was over, the examiner laid the forgery on one side of the table and a sheet of the real ones on the other, and stood between them with her arms folded.

“It’s very good,” she said.

“Is it a tracing?”

“At the start. The first three letters were traced, I’d say, with a light table, quite carefully. Then the writer let go. The rest of the name is freehand.” She tapped the air above the last flourish with a pencil. “That is a person who has looked at your signature a great many times, Ms. Dace, and has taken pleasure in it. You make a bird of the last stroke. That’s rare. And it’s lovely. Whoever wrote this has been rather charmed.”

“Where could they have seen it?” said Ames.

“Anywhere it’s posted.” Thale glanced at Jessa. “I should think you sign a good many certificates.”

“Every inspection,” said Jessa. Her voice was thin. “I sign them and the venue hangs them in the lobby, in a frame, next to the fire permit. They’ve to be displayed. It’s the law.”

“Where’s the nearest framed one?”

“At the Ridgetop Arena. I did the whole house last spring. It’s by the box office.”

“Ah,” said Thale. “Then I should think that’s the template. A woman who inspects the rafters of a public building has a public signature. It’s rather like a lighthouse.” She straightened. “It’s not Mr. Skell’s hand. I have his four pages and it’s not his. It’s not the slow, frightened hand that made the carbon, either. This is a confident, practiced person, fluent, who works from a model and likes the work. Quite a different animal.”

“A third hand,” I said, before I could stop myself.

Thale turned her magnifier on me, so that for a moment I saw my own face in a glass the size of a coin.

“You’re Ms. Dace the elder.”

“Yes.”

“May I see you sign something?”

---

I signed it on a clean sheet at the porch table with Jessa’s red carpenter’s pencil, then with a ballpoint, then with a felt pen. I signed it fast and slow. I signed it in the new way, which I’d not known was a new way until she put the pages side by side.

“You’ve changed,” said Thale.

“I’m sorry?”

“Since the injury. It’s the wrist.” She slid a copy of Exhibit Nine in front of me, a photostat of my twenty-two-year-old hand: the big loops, the dropped final E. Then she laid my morning’s work beside it. “You used to write fast and large, from the shoulder. Now you write small, and slowly, with the hand held very close to the paper. Look at the E. It doesn’t drop anymore. It’s a little closed knot.”

I looked. It was true. The burn on my right wrist had pulled at the tendon for a month, and I’d been signing every statement and consent form and hospital slip with the stiff careful squint of a woman threading a needle. I had not noticed. I’d have sworn my name looked as it always had.

“If someone shows me a Cleo Dace of this month’s date,” said Thale, “in the old big loop, I should be suspicious. A signature is a habit, Ms. Dace. It’s the most intimate habit you have, in some ways. It changes when your body does. People forget to forge the change.”

“He’s got Exhibit Nine.”

“He has a signature from six years ago. And nothing else, I’d say, unless he’s been to your bank.” Thale snapped the case shut. “I’d advise you, if I may, to sign something in front of a witness every day this week. It will be dull. But it makes a calendar.”

“That’s the cleverest thing anyone’s said all month,” said Jessa.

“It’s the dullest,” said Thale, “which is why it works.”

---

I kept the physio appointment at ten forty-five, because I’d promised myself I would.

It is a strange thing to sit in a cubicle in a clinic on the second floor of a medical building above a pharmacy, in a paper gown, with an ice pack on your shoulder, while somewhere in the same county a man with a left hand is ironing out your life.

A plump bored young woman took my blood pressure. A poster on the wall explained the rotator cuff in four colors. Dr. Reyes, who had examined me three times and spoke to me as to a capable colleague, ran me through a set of movements that made me sweat.

“Better,” she said. “Don’t make that face. It’s better. You can take a ground-crew shift if it’s under thirty pounds and nothing above your shoulder. No ropes, no overhead. No driving more than an hour at a stretch.”

“I drove forty minutes last night.”

“Did you stop?”

“No.”

“Then don’t do it again.” She wrote on a pad. “And the wrist’s good. The scar will fade, though not all the way. It’ll pull in cold. Moisturize. Don’t sign anything you can’t read.”

I laughed. She looked up, puzzled.

“It’s a private joke,” I said. “I’ve been told it three times today.”

“By whom?”

“By everybody who loves me, I think,” I said, and put on my coat with my left arm first, the careful way, and felt, for no good reason, much better than I had in days.

---

Ellis rang at noon, as he’d promised. He did not say hello. He said, “I’m in the truck. I’m outside the Hargroves’. Will you come in with me?”

“Ames said she’d be there at one.”

“I’d like to be early. I want to see him before there’s a stenographer.” His voice shook slightly and he steadied it. “I’d like you in the hall. I don’t need you in the room.”

“I’m on my way.”

I was there in twenty-five minutes. He was sitting in the truck with the engine off and both hands on the wheel, in his good gray coat, with a cherry-and-ash walking stick on the seat beside him. He had made it, he told me later, between three and five that morning. He had sat down to a chair leg and a cane had come out of his hands before he understood what he was making.

Constance let us in. She had put on a navy dress and a brooch, and combed her hair. She looked at Ellis for a long moment, and then, without a word, took his face between her two thin dry hands and kissed him on the forehead, and let go.

“He’s had a good night,” she said. “He’s been asking for you since five. He can’t say it, but I know the look.”

“Mrs. Hargrove, I—”

“Go up, dear. It’s easier if you don’t talk.”

He went up with the cane in his hand. I stood in the hall at the foot of the stairs, under the fringed lamp, beside the table with the bowl of keys, and heard a door open, and a pause, and the creak of a chair.

I did not listen. I looked at the wallpaper. It was a pattern of small green ferns. Somewhere upstairs a man’s voice, Ellis’s, said a quiet sentence I could not catch, and then there was a long silence, and then the sound of two men breathing in a room.

It went on for nineteen minutes by the hall clock.

---

When Ellis came down, his face had been washed in something. His hands were empty of the cane, which he had left propped at the head of the bed, and he had a thick, soft, dark-green cloth ledger under his arm, the kind that clerks used to buy at stationers’ by the dozen.

Constance had come out of the kitchen with a tray, and she stopped at the sight of the book. “That’s from the study,” she said. “He’s had it in the safe under the desk for six years. I thought it was his father’s.”

“It’s the Contingency Reserve,” said Ellis. “He kept the vouchers himself, apart from the Hall’s books. Every January. Every four thousand dollars. Every one with Pratt’s initials and a note in Harlan’s hand.”

He set it on the hall table, carefully, as a man sets down a sleeping child. “He wrote the amounts in himself, with his left hand, on the first of the month. He kept doing it after the stroke. He said,” and here his voice failed, and came back, “he said he’d like it known that he knew what he was paying for.”

“What did he say to you?” I asked.

“Not much. He took the cane in his good hand and held it across his knees. He said Ellis. He’s got that, you see, and Quiet, and two more.” Ellis looked at the stairs. “He said, Footnote. I think he meant, I picked you for the footnotes. I read them. It was the only reason he gave me a seat.”

“He chose well.”

“He chose me because I’d be quiet,” said Ellis, “and I’d like to know which of us was wrong.” He drew a breath. “I told him I forgave him for nothing, because it wasn’t mine to give. I told him I’d like to say I was angry, and I was too tired. And I said that I’d carry the book to Ames, and that I’d be there if he needed anyone to hold the pencil.”

“That’s more than I managed,” said Constance, softly.

“It’s all I had.”

There was a pause. In it, the front door opened, and Ames came in with a stenographer behind her, a gaunt gray woman with a machine in a bag, and Garrity bringing up the rear with two cups of coffee in a cardboard tray. Ames looked at the ledger on the hall table and at Ellis and at the cane.

“I’d like you to leave it where it is,” she said. “And I’d like a photograph of that book before anyone moves it.”

“It’s all yours,” said Ellis.

“It’s Mrs. Hargrove’s,” said Ames. “It’s her house.”

“Take it,” said Constance. “Please. I’d be so glad to be rid of it.” She put the tray on the table with a small rattle. “But there’s something I must tell you, Detective, before you go up. I thought I’d keep it till he was well, and then I thought, I won’t be able to bear another night, and then I thought I’d tell Cleo.” She turned to me, with her chin up. “I think I’m the plaintiff.”

---

We sat in the dining room, a long polished chamber with a sideboard and six chairs and a bowl of wax fruit, and the stenographer set up at one end of the table with the quick small sounds of a woman assembling a loom.

“I’d like to hear it from the beginning,” said Ames.

“Alvin Pratt came to this house on the sixth of September,” said Constance. “He’s been our lawyer since 1991. He brought a folder and a bottle of sherry, which I thought odd, and a stack of documents he said were for my husband’s estate. They were routine, he said. They were so that if Harlan died first, I wouldn’t be troubled with probate. I’d sign in the margins and he’d have them witnessed by his secretary.”

“And you did.”

“I signed eleven pages in the margins. I did not read them. I never have. Harlan always did.” Her voice was steady and very dry. “On Monday morning my niece came with a newspaper, and said, Aunt Connie, here’s your name in the Courier. It said that a trust, of which I am sole trustee, had filed a motion in the county court to freeze the accounts of the Ridgetop Arena.”

“The Keene Arena Preservation Trust,” I said.

“A very pretty name. I’ve never heard of it.” She folded her hands. “Detective, I am seventy-three years old. I have a stroke patient upstairs, two cats and a house. I did not file a lawsuit against Yvette Keene’s livelihood. I’d have cut off my hand first. I have known her since she was thirty. She brought us a casserole when Harlan fell ill.”

“The trust has a mailing address,” said Ames, evenly. “A post-office box. Maplewick.”

“I’ve never been to Maplewick in my life.”

“And you’ve a joint account at Cinderhall Savings with a monthly deposit of a hundred dollars from a Mr. Smith.”

“That’s the fax machine,” said Constance, with a faint, wild, humorless smile. “He said it was for the old committee line. I was to leave the machine plugged in. I thought it was a charity to the Hall.” She shut her eyes. “I’d like to withdraw the lawsuit. I’d like to know how it’s done. I’d like to ring Alvin and tell him he’s dismissed.”

“I’d rather you didn’t,” said Ames, “just yet. May I ask why?”

“Because he’s been very kind to us,” said Constance, and a single tear rolled down the side of her nose, and she let it fall. “And because I think he’s frightened.”

---

She rang the office at ten past two, in the front hall, on the old black telephone beside the bowl of keys, with Ames on the extension in the study and the stenographer’s little machine turned to the receiver.

It rang eight times. Then a voice answered, and it was not the receptionist’s.

“Hargrove residence?” said a man, in a thin, hoarse, careful baritone, a voice I had listened to for three days at the bench of the panel, light and unhurried, and never once heard cracked. “Connie. Is it you?”

“Alvin. Where are you?”

“I’m at the office. I’ve sent everyone home.” A rustle, a small cough. “I rather thought you’d ring. I’d like to say something. I’ve very little time.”

“Alvin, I’ve learned what I signed—”

“I know you have. I’m so sorry. I should never have done it that way. I thought it a small matter, a technicality. I thought Harlan would never—” He stopped. “No. That’s no good. Mr. Skell dismissed me by fax on Tuesday, you know, at seven in the morning, which I think was the kindest thing he has ever done me. It meant I had nobody left to be loyal to. Is there someone there? Is it Ames?”

“I’m here, Mr. Pratt,” said Ames, from the study, in her flat clear voice.

“Ah.” A pause so long I thought the line had gone. “Then I’ll say it to you. I should like to surrender. Not to the district. To the panel. At nine tomorrow, in front of Ms. Tolliver, with my own lawyer. I’d like to bring a box.” The voice dropped. “I’d like to bring the fifteen.”

“The fifteen sheets.”

“Fifteen letters, fifteen drafts, fifteen unsigned. He gave them to me in March for safekeeping. I don’t think he knew I’d read them.”

He drew a shaking breath. “I should like it understood that I did not forge anything. I told the panel on Tuesday that I had no knowledge of the Trust’s filing. That was true of the filing. It was not true of the margins, and I’d like that corrected in my own voice. I did a great deal that was shabby and one thing that was fatal, but I never held the pen. And I should like to speak to Ms. Dace.”

I was standing in the hall. I had not moved. My own name came down the line like a hand on my collar.

“Which Ms. Dace?” said Ames.

“The elder. The one who smells.” A cracked dry sound that was not quite a laugh. “I beg your pardon. I’m told it’s a gift. I should like her to be there when I open the box, because I’m afraid, Detective, that there’s a good deal in it that is addressed to her. And I’d rather she weren’t alone.”

“Why?”

“Because the man who wrote it,” said Alvin Pratt, “has been writing to her for six years. And I think she ought to hear it read aloud.”

The line closed, quite gently, with a click. I stood in the cold hall of a stranger’s house, under a fringed lamp, with my hand flat against a wallpaper of green ferns, and heard Constance Hargrove begin, very softly, to laugh and cry at the same time.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!